This article is an excerpt from the Shortform book guide to "Hold Me Tight" by Sue Johnson. Shortform has the world's best summaries and analyses of books you should be reading.
Like this article? Sign up for a free trial here.
Do you feel heard in your relationship? Do most conversations devolve into fights? Are you almost ready to give up?
When you’re in a struggling romantic relationship, you may feel like it’s impossible to fix. But clinical psychologist Sue Johnson says you don’t need to give up yet. In Hold Me Tight, she offers a roadmap for healing your relationship so you and your partner can communicate healthily, resolve conflicts, and grow close once again.
Continue reading for an overview of Hold Me Tight, including actionable advice for repairing your relationship.
Hold Me Tight Book Overview
In Hold Me Tight, Johnson explains that the root of most relationship conflict is emotional disconnection: when partners don’t feel safe sharing their emotions with each other. She argues that talking about this disconnection—and the reasons you don’t feel safe being vulnerable—is the key to addressing your issues, reconnecting with your partner, and building a more emotionally healthy relationship.
In this guide, we’ll examine Johnson’s approach to healing relationships in three parts:
- Part 1: The Key to a Healthy Relationship outlines Johnson’s theory that healthy relationships rely on emotional safety.
- Part 2: Addressing Negative Communication Patterns covers how to identify and change communication patterns that get in the way of emotional safety.
- Part 3: Reconnecting With Your Partner discusses how to recover from the past challenges of your relationship and grow close to your partner again.
In our commentary, we’ll touch on alternative couples therapy methodologies and offer supplemental advice for having difficult conversations with loved ones.
Part 1: The Key to a Healthy Relationship
Johnson begins by explaining the core of her couples therapy method, known as Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT). The key to a successful relationship is emotional security. In other words, in order for your relationship to thrive, you have to feel comfortable and safe communicating your emotions with one another. On the other hand, Johnson argues that a lack of emotional security is the primary cause of serious conflicts in relationships.
Part 1 of our guide will explain the main components of emotional security, why relationships need it, and why a lack of emotional security leads to conflict.
Elements of Emotional Security
According to Johnson, there are three main standards a relationship must meet for partners to feel emotionally secure: openness, caring, and engagement.
Standard #1: Openness
Johnson explains that a healthy relationship requires both partners to be open with one another about their thoughts and feelings. This creates emotional security: We naturally feel safer around people when we feel like we understand them and they understand us. Johnson explains that openness has to go both ways—in addition to openly expressing your feelings, you must be open to receiving the feelings of your partner. This also requires each of you to be willing to work through your emotions, since you can’t be open toward them if you’re avoiding or denying them.
Standard #2: Demonstrations of Care
Johnson’s second standard of emotional security is that both partners have to show that they care about each other’s feelings. Sharing your emotions with a partner who doesn’t seem to care will just make you feel ignored or neglected. Demonstrating care can be as simple as noticing that your partner is anxious and gently rubbing their back—showing you see their anxiety and want to offer them comfort.
Standard #3: Emotional Engagement
The third standard Johnson provides is that partners must regularly and eagerly give each other special attention and affection. These moments remind your partner that you’re there for them and committed to your relationship. Emotional distance and the absence of engagement can inspire partners to feel doubt, anxiety, and resentment.
How a Lack of Emotional Security Leads to Conflict
When partners don’t meet these three healthy relationship standards, Johnson says they’ll experience a lack of emotional security—the primary cause of most serious relationship conflicts. She explains how this plays out: When people feel emotionally unsafe or isolated from their partner, they get scared and upset. Then, because they don’t feel safe sharing those feelings, they respond with irrational and unproductive defense mechanisms (which we’ll discuss in Part 2) that then lead to conflict. They also create a hostile environment where both partners feel even less safe opening up, starting a negative feedback loop.
Part 2: Resolving Relationship Conflicts
Johnson explains that the first step of repairing your emotional connection with your partner is stopping the feedback loop of conflict: Feeling unsafe leads to conflict, which leads to feeling even less safe, which leads to more conflict, and so on. This feedback loop is fueled by negative communication patterns—defensive and unproductive ways of talking to one another that create tension and exacerbate emotional distance.
While every couple has moments of bad communication, Johnson says that negative communication is the norm in relationships lacking emotional safety—and escaping this norm is the first part of repairing your relationship as a whole. In this section, we’ll explore Johnson’s three steps for addressing negative communication patterns:
- Identify when and how you and your partner communicate negatively.
- Identify the vulnerabilities that cause you to communicate negatively.
- Resolve a conflict with your partner in a healthier way.
Step #1: Identify Negative Communication Patterns
Johnson states that first, you and your partner must articulate what your conflicts tend to look like and identify the harmful communication patterns you use. Having an awareness of your harmful tendencies, she says, will make it easier to spot them in the future and shut down the pattern early.
Johnson details three negative communication patterns partners commonly identify with:
1) Confront and Retreat
The first negative pattern involves one partner confronting another who then withdraws or shuts down. It plays out in the following way:
- Partner A communicates their emotions in a way that seems aggressive to Partner B.
- Partner B retreats emotionally out of fear of conflict and aggression.
- Partner A interprets this retreat as emotional unavailability. This triggers anxiety and fear of isolation, causing them to communicate even more aggressively.
- A’s increased aggression makes B feel more under attack and withdraw further, continuing the pattern.
This pattern causes a breakdown in communication because neither partner feels like they’re able to share their emotions.
Johnson recommends that you and your partner identify a moment when you got stuck in a similar pattern. But, she urges, don’t get caught up in the specific details of your dispute. Instead, take a step back and consider the ways your conflicts fit the “confront and retreat” pattern overall. Identify who usually confronts and who usually retreats, then try to empathize with the emotions that lead to both reactions—wanting connection and feeling attacked.
2) The Blame Game
The second communication pattern Johnson says you may identify in your relationship is “the blame game”: Partners enter a cycle of blaming and accusing each other of various perceived offenses. Johnson explains that people use blame as a way to regain control when they feel hurt and vulnerable. When Partner A blames B for an issue, Partner B feels vulnerable. To regain control, partner B criticizes A, making them feel vulnerable—and restarting the cycle.
This blame game leads to a breakdown in communication—if you feel that anything you say could expose you to a counter-attack, it will feel impossible to share your emotions and feel safe with one another. To stop this cycle, recognize that no one has to be the “bad guy”—the real problem is the pattern itself. Reflect on a time when you got into a fight with your partner and focused more on “winning” (or being in control) than on working through the issue. Acknowledge how that made you view your partner as an adversary.
3) Full Disconnection
According to Johnson, the final pattern occurs when both partners in a relationship completely shut down emotionally. They feel that the love is gone and there’s nothing left to fight for, so they each retreat into a state of emotional numbness and shut off all communication. This makes both partners feel unloveable, further contributing to the feelings of hopelessness that led them to disconnect in the first place.
To unpack your roles in this pattern, speak to your partner about the things they do that make you feel like you need to pull away—and let them talk about the things you do that make them feel the same. Then, acknowledge what this distance has taken from your relationship and recommit to making it work.
Step #2: Share Your Vulnerabilities
After you and your partner identify your negative communication patterns and how you fit into them, Johnson advises that you each talk about the emotional vulnerabilities that tend to set these patterns off. Vulnerabilities usually stem from past experiences in important relationships where one of your emotional needs was neglected or dismissed, making you feel sensitive about it in the present. When something your partner does hits on one of these areas of sensitivity or insecurity, you may strongly and automatically react with anger or withdrawal.
For example, Maggie felt ignored by her parents as a child and developed a vulnerability around feeling unheard. So when she feels like her husband Joe isn’t listening to her, she’s likely to get particularly upset and start a fight with him.
Find Your Vulnerabilities
Johnson provides a series of steps you can take to pinpoint your vulnerabilities:
1) Think back on a moment when something small your partner did prompted a sudden, strong negative reaction in you. For example, Maggie got angry and yelled at Joe when he forgot to take out the trash.
2) Note what you thought was going on in that moment, or what you thought your partner was doing. In this situation, Maggie thought Joe was ignoring her on purpose because he didn’t care about her or what she wanted.
3) Using your response to step two, see if you can identify the vulnerability your partner triggered with their behavior. For instance, Maggie’s vulnerability around feeling ignored was triggered by Joe forgetting to do something she asked.
4) Once you have an idea of the vulnerability your partner touched on, think back to your past for a potential source of this vulnerability. Is there someone in your life who regularly made you feel that way? In Maggie’s case, her parents regularly made her feel ignored.
Express Your Vulnerabilities
Once you and your partner have each discovered your vulnerabilities, Johnson suggests you tell each other about them. This is often a difficult process, as it involves sharing some deeply personal feelings. But Johnson emphasizes its benefits, pointing to three in particular:
- Sharing vulnerabilities with your partner can lift a huge weight off your shoulders—emotional distance is a much larger source of stress than dealing with negative emotions together.
- You and your partner will have a better idea of what sets each other off and how to avoid those triggers.
- You’ll be able to approach relationship conflicts from their source—emotional vulnerabilities—instead of making assumptions about each other’s behaviors and getting trapped in a negative communication pattern.
Step #3: Resolve a Conflict Together
Once you have a clearer picture of the negative communication patterns you and your partner fall into and the vulnerabilities that often trigger them, Johnson suggests talking about a recurring conflict in your relationship—something that you’ve argued about multiple times.
This discussion requires you to use the tools you’ve developed so far: You’ll share your feelings and recognize your role in these recurring issues rather than placing all the blame on your partner. By using this new approach—working together to resolve the problems—you and your partner can start to rebuild your emotional safety and improve your connection.
Johnson’s Conflict Resolution Process
Johnson outlines a four-part process for getting to the root of your conflict, recognizing how you both contribute to it, and coming to a resolution.
1) Each partner acknowledges the role they played in the conflict. For example, Tyler recognizes that he started nitpicking Frank about how he was washing dishes. Frank acknowledges that he got defensive and, by telling Tyler to calm down, he brushed Tyler’s concerns aside.
2) Once you’ve discussed the behavior on both sides, explain how you felt during the conflict. For instance, Tyler says he felt underappreciated because he’d expressed before why washing dishes a certain way is important to him—so by ignoring his advice, Frank made it seem like he didn’t care about what matters to Tyler. Frank shares that he also felt underappreciated because he was trying to help, and it seemed like it wasn’t good enough for Tyler.
3) Acknowledge how your actions affected your partner emotionally. In our example, Tyler admits that approaching Frank with a critical, irritated tone when he was doing a chore might make him feel defensive and underappreciated. In turn, Frank acknowledges that by brushing off Tyler’s concerns, he sent the message that he doesn’t care how Tyler feels about it.
4) Once you’ve finished talking through the conflict, reflect on how it feels to work together with your partner on these issues. Find some way to reconnect and restate your commitment to them—even if it’s something as simple as showing appreciation for the conversation you’ve just had. For example, Tyler and Frank agree to do their best to be considerate of each other’s preferences when doing chores. And, because each person knows their partner is trying their best, they’ll refrain from criticizing tasks done the “wrong” way.
If you recognize that you’re returning to a negative communication pattern during this process, pause the conversation instead of getting caught up in the back-and-forth.
Part 3: Reconnecting With Your Partner
In addition to stopping the ongoing damage to your emotional security, learning to avoid and resolve conflicts equips you and your partner to have deeper, more vulnerable conversations about your relationship. Johnson explains that in these conversations, you’ll be able to heal the damage you’ve done in the past and grow close to one another again.
In Part 3, we’ll cover two methods Johnson provides for healing your relationship: sharing your fears and needs, and working through your emotional wounds.
Method #1: Share Your Fears and Needs
Johnson explains that to repair your bond with your partner, you must practice sharing and accepting each other’s deepest fears and needs. Opening up to this degree is a vulnerable experience, so when you practice doing so in a positive way, you start to rebuild the trust necessary to feel safe in your bond. It also helps you become more in tune with each other’s feelings moving forward and to be emotionally available. During this conversation, give each other’s feelings space and address them with empathy and curiosity instead of doubt or judgment.
Share Your Fears
Tell your partner your deepest fears about your relationship. Johnson says this helps you and your partner understand the true emotions fueling your conflicts, behaviors, and struggles. To access your deepest relationship fears, Johnson recommends that you start by talking about how you felt during one of the lowest points of your relationship. Then, discuss the “worst case scenario” you had in mind during that low point—something you worried your partner would do that you desperately wanted to avoid. For example, suppose you were dealing with health issues during a period of nonstop fighting with your partner. Perhaps you felt afraid that if you got a serious diagnosis, your partner would leave you.
Next, consider the feelings behind that worst-case scenario. Why was it so scary to you? Those feelings are some of your deep fears. For example, you might find that you’re afraid to be alone, or that in leaving you, your partner would prove your fear that they don’t truly love you.
Share Your Needs
Next, directly state what you need from your partner to feel emotionally safe right now. What could they do to help you feel more secure in your relationship? For example, you might ask your partner to sit down with you and plan out how you’ll handle things if you receive the scary diagnosis you’re worried about. This will help reassure you that they’ll be there for you, even when things get hard. Johnson explains that being clear about your needs—and what would meet those needs—gives your partner insight into how to best support you and the most effective ways to work through your conflicts.
Method #2: Work Through a Past Wound
Johnson states that certain events in a relationship—particularly moments that cause feelings of abandonment—can become wounds that profoundly change how you view your partner and relationship. These wounds are often the root cause of many relationship struggles, so addressing them is crucial for reconnecting with your partner. Wounds can come from big, obvious actions like infidelity, but they can also come from something so small that the partner who did it is unaware of its impact. For example, maybe they skipped out on an event with their partner, not realizing how deeply important it was and that their apparent lack of support felt devastating.
To start healing, the wounded partner must be vulnerable and honest about their pain. Describe what caused your hurt feelings and how it affected your view of your partner. In return, the partner who caused the wound acknowledges their role and sincerely apologizes. Johnson emphasizes that the apology must be sincere: Showing true remorse for the hurt you’ve caused indicates that you care about your partner’s feelings and you want to repair the rift. Finally, discuss what the wounded partner needs to feel emotionally safe and secure again, and how the other partner can meet that need.
Exercise: Make a Plan for Your Relationship
Using Johnson’s method, think about how you can address problems in your relationship.
- Do you and your partner use any of the negative communication patterns Johnson describes? What does this look like in your relationship?
- What are some of your vulnerabilities that contribute to this negative communication?
- What are some of your strongest fears about your partner or your relationship?
- Can you identify any needs that aren’t currently being met in your relationship? Describe them.
———End of Preview———
Like what you just read? Read the rest of the world's best book summary and analysis of Sue Johnson's "Hold Me Tight" at Shortform.
Here's what you'll find in our full Hold Me Tight summary:
- Why so many relationships fail due to poor communication
- A series of conversations to have with your significant other to reconnect
- The three main standards a relationship must meet for partners to feel secure
