In this episode of The School of Greatness, Alia Crum and Lewis Howes examine how core beliefs shape physical health, behavior, and emotional experience. Crum presents research demonstrating that beliefs don't just influence perception—they directly affect physiology, from metabolism and hormone levels to weight loss and blood pressure. Her studies reveal that what people believe about stress, food, and exercise can produce measurable biological changes, even when external circumstances remain constant.
The conversation covers practical strategies for shifting beliefs, including reframing stress as an enhancing force rather than a harmful one and embracing a mindset of "enoughness" in health, productivity, and self-worth. Crum distinguishes core beliefs from passing thoughts and introduces techniques for deliberately reshaping these foundational assumptions. Throughout the episode, she and Howes explore how subtle shifts in belief systems can transform attention, motivation, and physiological responses to create tangible changes in daily life.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Alia Crum and Lewis Howes explore how subtle shifts in core beliefs can fundamentally transform our experience of the world through attention, biology, behavior, and emotion.
Beliefs act as filters determining what we notice and remember in our environment. Crum explains that our brain processes sensory information through the lens of existing beliefs, prioritizing confirming information while dismissing contradictions. Beyond perception, beliefs directly affect physiology. The brain, connected to all bodily systems, uses beliefs to compute where to allocate energy—whether to digestion, threat response, or immune function. A striking example from Crum's Harvard thesis involved hotel housekeepers who, after simply being told their work met exercise recommendations, lost weight, lowered blood pressure, and reported greater job satisfaction—without changing their behavior.
Beliefs also shape motivation and behavior in goal pursuit. Viewing stress as enhancing leads people to seek support and positive feedback, while seeing it as harmful triggers shutdown or overreaction. Howes shares how reframing adversity as growth opportunity allowed him to move forward productively after sports injuries. Finally, beliefs influence emotions by shaping how we interpret experiences—when stress is reframed as a signal we care rather than a threat, the emotional tone shifts from fear to engagement.
Crum explains that stress is unavoidable because it's linked to what we care about most. Eliminating stress would mean abandoning meaningful pursuits, potentially leading to depression, which she describes as a lack of care or purpose. The body's stress response isn't designed to harm but to mobilize energy and sharpen focus for meeting challenges.
Research shows that people who believe stress enhances them perform better and exhibit more adaptive physiological responses, maintaining moderate cortisol and higher DHEA levels. Howes recounts how reframing adversity as opportunity turned stress into a catalyst for his own growth.
Crum describes a three-step practice: acknowledge stress, welcome it as a sign something important is at stake, and use the energy it provides to pursue meaningful goals. This intervention reframes stress as an ally rather than eliminating it entirely.
Crum's research reveals that beliefs influence biology directly, not just through behavior change. The placebo effect harnesses the body's natural healing abilities activated by a mindset of readiness, shaped by social context and environmental cues. In one study, people given inert cream for a histamine rash healed more quickly when told it would help, while those told it might worsen symptoms improved more slowly—demonstrating the body's direct response to belief.
The qualities of healthcare providers dramatically affect belief-based interventions. When providers showed both warmth (personal engagement) and competence (visible expertise), their recommendations produced stronger physiological effects. If providers appeared disengaged or less competent, the placebo effect disappeared regardless of what they said.
Crum's milkshake study further demonstrates mind-body links. Participants consumed identical milkshakes but were told they were either "diet" or "indulgent." The hunger hormone ghrelin dropped much more steeply when people believed they'd consumed an indulgent shake, showing that belief about food affects biological responses as much as the food itself.
Finally, Crum notes that trusted social figures—parents, coaches, mentors who show both care and understanding—shape our beliefs and biology more powerfully than distant experts.
Howes and Crum discuss how belief in "enoughness"—sufficiency in actions, achievements, and self-worth—shapes motivation, health, and satisfaction. Cultural messages fostering a sense of lack undermine well-being, while embracing enoughness produces tangible benefits.
Crum emphasizes that believing "I am enough" is critical for mental health. Well-intentioned messaging to "do more" often demotivates people, leaving them feeling defeated. This belief of "not enough" is powerful enough to affect metabolism—when people adopt a restrictive eating mindset, the brain registers scarcity, triggering increased hunger hormones and slowed metabolism. Conversely, eating with a mindset of sufficiency creates positive metabolic changes.
Core beliefs about self-worth and capability drive willingness to pursue goals. Crum recommends looking at past experiences of growth through overcoming stress as evidence of innate capability. The belief in enoughness also extends to time and productivity. Rather than ruminating on scarcity, adopting a belief in time abundance allows people to make moments more meaningful without altering external circumstances, reducing stress and enhancing presence with loved ones.
Crum emphasizes the importance of understanding and intentionally engaging with beliefs to shape reality. She distinguishes thoughts (passing mental events) from core beliefs (foundational assumptions that serve as mental filters). Core beliefs like "I am incapable" or "the world is dangerous" cannot be conclusively proven or disproven because they're simple evaluations of complex realities. Their significance lies in their impact and usefulness rather than truth or falsity.
Crum presents a three-step "say-see-live" practice for shifting core beliefs. First, state the new belief aloud or in writing, which immediately shifts energy and emotions. Second, intentionally look for evidence confirming the new belief—the brain naturally filters experiences to align with core beliefs. Third, live the belief by embodying it in daily actions, creating a feedback loop that makes the new belief more deeply integrated.
Even small shifts in core beliefs yield substantial effects on perception, motivation, physiology, and behavior. Moving from scarcity to abundance or from "I am incapable" to "I am capable" changes both what one notices and how one responds to challenges. Crum concludes that lasting change comes not from controlling passing thoughts but from intentionally shifting the deep programming of core beliefs.
1-Page Summary
Beliefs play a crucial role in shaping our perception, physiology, motivation, behavior, and emotions. Alia Crum and Lewis Howes discuss how subtle shifts in core beliefs can cascade through our awareness and biology to fundamentally change our experience of the world.
Beliefs act as filters for what we notice and attend to in our surroundings. Alia Crum explains that our brain’s attention processes sensory information through the lens of our core beliefs, determining, often unconsciously, what details stand out to us. As a result, we prioritize information that confirms what we already believe and tend to overlook or dismiss evidence that contradicts our established views. This selective attention means beliefs literally shape what we see and remember in our environment.
The brain is intimately connected to all bodily systems and constantly monitors both internal states and external environments. Its computations, heavily influenced by belief, direct where to allocate energy—whether to emphasize digestion and metabolism, prepare for threat, or activate the immune system. Crum notes that even subtle changes in belief can shift what the body prioritizes, altering physiological responses to the very same stimuli.
A striking example is provided in Crum’s Harvard senior thesis, conducted with Dr. Ellen Langer, involving 84 hotel housekeepers. Despite their physically demanding work, most believed they received little exercise. The researchers informed one group that their jobs met or exceeded the Surgeon General’s exercise recommendations and listed possible health benefits, even placing signs in break rooms with this message. After four weeks, these housekeepers lost about two pounds on average, experienced a 10-point drop in systolic blood pressure, reported greater job satisfaction, and had an improved body image, compared to a control group. This study shows how a shift in belief alone, without a change in behavior, can produce significant and measurable physiological benefits, improving both health markers and subjective well-being.
Beliefs also direct how we react to challenges and pursue goals. Seeing stress as harmful can lead people to overreact—“freaking out” behaviorally and physiologically—or to shut down and disengage. By contrast, perceiving stress as enhancing makes individuals more likely to notice and seek out positive feedback and social support during difficult times. People with this mindset move toward engagement rather than avoidance, increasing their access to resources that boost performance and well-being.
Lewis Howes shares from his own ...
How Beliefs Shape Reality: Attention, Physiology, Behavior, Emotions
Alia Crum explains that stress is inextricably linked to the things people care most deeply about. She suggests that if someone is not personally invested in a situation, such as Johnny failing school, it will not cause stress—unless Johnny is their son, or they care about students like Johnny as a teacher would. Stress is a natural byproduct of pursuing meaningful goals; eliminating stress would require abandoning those pursuits. Crum warns that attempts to reduce or avoid stress often disconnect people from what matters, leading to depression, which she describes as a lack of care, purpose, or energy. She asserts that experiences of personal growth and learning are always connected to stress, making it a necessary part of purposeful living.
Crum emphasizes that the body’s stress response is not designed to harm, but to support survival and achievement. The stress response mobilizes energy, sharpens focus, and prepares the body and mind to meet challenges or complete important tasks. While chronic stress can certainly be harmful, especially when one is in a constant state of alert, Crum frames acute stress as supportive, helping people rise to the occasion and tackle problems directly. Stress, she insists, is a signal that someone is engaged in something important, rather than simply a threat.
Alia Crum and Lewis Howes discuss the power of mindset in determining the effects of stress. Crum cites research showing that people who believe stress can enhance them perform better under pressure and exhibit more adaptive physiological responses. Those with a stress-enhancing mindset maintain moderate cortisol levels—enough for alertness but not so much as to impair focus—and have higher levels of DHEA, a hormone related to growth and resilience. Shifting attention from stress’s harmful effects to its potential benefits leads to improved focus, increased help-seeking, and more positive feedback from others. Howes recounts his own experience, describing how reframing adversity as opportunity empowered him and turned stres ...
Stress Mindset: Viewing Stress As Normal and Enhancing
Scientific research led by Alia Crum reveals that beliefs influence our biology directly, not just by changing behavior. Carefully designed studies show that simply altering belief, while keeping behaviors constant, can change healing, hormone levels, and metabolism. These effects are often shaped by social context, authority, and our perceptions of those delivering information or care.
Traditionally, the placebo effect occurs when an inert treatment, like a sugar pill, leads to improvement simply because the recipient believes it will help. Crum explains that the power of placebo is not just mysterious mind-over-matter. Instead, it harnesses three elements: the body's natural healing abilities, the mindset of readiness or safety that activates those abilities, and the rich social context in which treatments are given. Ritual, branding, and cues from the environment all prime the mind to expect healing.
A study explored these effects by giving people a cream for a histamine-induced rash. Some were told the cream would help (placebo), others that it might worsen the rash (nocebo). Those in the placebo group healed more quickly, while the nocebo group improved more slowly—but their rash did not worsen. The key was not the cream itself but the belief about its effect, confirming the body's direct response to mindset.
Research further shows that the qualities of the person delivering care can dramatically enhance—or nullify—the effect of belief-based interventions. In an experiment, the same healthcare provider altered her demeanor and visible credentials to create perceptions of high or low warmth (personal engagement, friendliness) and competence (apparent expertise). When both warmth and competence were high—eye contact, first names, a badge reading “fellow at the Stanford Allergy Center," nature pictures in the room—the impact of her statements about treatment was noticeably stronger, and measurable placebo effects emerged. If the provider appeared disengaged or less competent (minimal eye contact, badge reading "student doctor," procedural errors), her recommendations lost their physiological power, regardless of what she said. This suggests our minds rapidly judge whether someone is on our side and capable of helping, and only then do our bodies fully respond to their advice.
Crum’s milkshake study further demonstrates mind-body links. Participants consumed the same milkshake on two occasions but were told it was either a “diet” shake or an “indulgent” treat. The body’s hunger hormone, ...
Direct Effects of Beliefs: Studies on Placebo, Exercise Perception, and Diet Metabolism
Lewis Howes and Alia Crum discuss how the belief in “enoughness”—the sense of sufficiency in one’s actions, achievements, time, and self-worth—directly shapes motivation, health, and overall satisfaction. They explore how cultural messages that foster a sense of lack undermine motivation and well-being, while embracing “enoughness” produces tangible psychological and physiological benefits.
Crum emphasizes that believing “I am doing enough” or “I am enough” is critical for mental health and motivation. When people are relentlessly communicated to that they must have more—money, success, followers, beauty—to be worthy or loved, it often becomes their internal belief system. This deficit messaging leads them to constantly feel they are not doing enough or are falling short, even if their efforts are significant. Howes notes that people can choose a mindset that either empowers or disempowers them, highlighting the shift toward believing in sufficiency and abundance as a path to deeper meaning and peace.
Crum explains that the well-intentioned messaging telling people to “do more” or “try harder”—such as exercising more or achieving more—often leads to demotivation. Studies show that this approach “flops,” making people feel defeated and overburdened. The result is people feeling they are not enough, further draining motivation, especially when already stretched thin with responsibilities. Rather than spurring action, it leaves them with a sense of inadequacy.
Crum illustrates that the belief of “not enough” is powerful enough to affect metabolism and weight, not just motivation. When people adopt a restrictive eating mindset—believing they aren’t eating enough, even if eating healthy—the brain registers scarcity. This triggers physiological responses such as increased hunger hormones (ghrelin), slowed metabolism, and increased fat storage, all designed to prepare the body for possible deprivation.
Conversely, eating with a mindset of “enoughness” or indulgence, where individuals feel satisfied and believe they are getting enough, creates positive changes in the body. Crum shares that she noticed personally how being highly restrictive in her eating negated her efforts, whereas approaching food with enjoyment and sufficiency—choosing what feels like enough whether a burger or a salad—had better metabolic outcomes. The sensation and belief of sufficiency, even when eating nutritious foods, improves metabolism and supports healthy weight management.
Crum notes that core beliefs about self-worth and capability drive a person’s willingness to set and strive for goals. Not believing one is enough causes motivation to drop, while believing in one’s inherent self-worth and capability fosters engagement and persistence. Even when external voices have sown doubt, Crum recommends looking at past experiences of growth through overcoming stress as evidence of innate capability. She identifies beliefs like “what I am doing is enough,” “I have purpose and meaning,” and “I am capable” as crucial to lasting motivation and meaningful progress. These beliefs are accessible at any time by recognizing past growth and achievements, reinforc ...
"Enoughness" in Health, Motivation, Weight, and Self-Worth
Alia Crum emphasizes that the mind profoundly shapes both personal reality and the realities of others, making it essential to understand and intentionally engage with our beliefs. Learning to distinguish and shift beliefs can lead to fundamental changes in life experience.
Crum distinguishes thoughts, beliefs, and core beliefs. A thought is anything that flows through the mind—a passing mental event. A belief is an assumption or proposition, a statement one holds to be true. A core belief, however, is a foundational assumption about the essence of something—such as oneself, the world, or abstract concepts like stress or capability. Core beliefs serve as mental filters that influence perception, attention, emotions, and actions. For example, a core belief might be “people are dangerous,” “I am incapable,” or “my body will fail me.”
Because core beliefs are simple and highly evaluative, they cannot be conclusively proven or disproven. Unlike factual beliefs (“there are 50 states in America”), beliefs such as “the world is dangerous” or “my body is capable” are built around oversimplified appraisals of complex realities, making evidence available for both sides. Crum notes that because of this, core beliefs are not inherently right or wrong or true or false. Their significance lies instead in their impact and usefulness, depending on a person’s goals.
Core beliefs are expressed using simple, often single-word descriptors. These adjectives—such as “abundant,” “capable,” or “enhancing”—capture a broad, evaluative stance on the essence of a subject. For example, someone might hold the belief “stress is enhancing,” “my body is capable,” or “the world is abundant.” The identity-defining nature of these core beliefs determines how one internalizes challenges. If a person faces difficulty and believes “I am incapable,” the challenge becomes an identity limitation. In contrast, believing “I can't do this right now” frames the difficulty as temporary and specific.
Crum presents a three-step process—say, see, live—for shifting core beliefs. The first step is to state the new belief, either out loud, in writing, or in another expressed form. This forced articulation clarifies the belief, sharpens its specificity, and often immediately shifts energy, emotions, and body language. Affirmations such as “I am capable,” “I am worthy,” or “I have enough time” change one’s emotional tenor and embodied presence the moment they are spoken or written down.
Once the belief is stated, the next step is to intentionally look for evidence that confirms the new belief. Because the brain has evolved to filter countless sensory experiences through existent beliefs, shifting a core belief naturally aligns attention to find corroborating information. For example, after declaring “I have abundant time,” Crum describes experiencing moments in her ...
Belief-Shifting Techniques and Distinguishing Core Beliefs From Thoughts
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
