Podcasts > The School of Greatness > Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

By Lewis Howes

In this episode of The School of Greatness, Jim Doty examines the science behind manifestation and its connection to the nervous system. He explains how stress affects our ability to manifest by triggering fight-or-flight responses, while relaxation techniques can enhance creativity and openness. The discussion covers how childhood experiences shape our beliefs and influence our manifestation patterns.

Doty outlines practical techniques for conscious manifestation, including visualization and intention-setting, which activate the brain's salience network to identify aligned opportunities. He shares insights about moving beyond material pursuits, drawing from his personal experience of giving away $30 million in stock. The episode explores how serving others and practicing gratitude can lead to more effective manifestation outcomes.

Listen to the original

Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 26, 2025 episode of the The School of Greatness

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

1-Page Summary

The Neuroscience and Psychology of Manifestation

Jim Doty explores the intricate relationship between manifestation, the nervous system, and mental states. He explains that while manifestation happens naturally, intentional techniques can enhance its effectiveness. According to Doty, embedding intentions into the subconscious mind helps it actively seek opportunities for fulfillment.

The Role of the Nervous System

Doty emphasizes how the nervous system significantly impacts manifestation abilities. He describes how chronic stress activates the sympathetic "fight-or-flight" response, which limits creativity and executive function. Conversely, activating the parasympathetic "rest-and-digest" system through practices like breathing exercises promotes openness and creativity. The heart's energetic field, Doty notes, can influence surroundings within several feet, affecting those nearby through vibrational energy.

Childhood Programming and Beliefs

Drawing from personal experience, Doty discusses how early life experiences shape beliefs and identity. He and Lewis Howes explore how negative childhood messages can create insecurity and block potential. While changing these ingrained beliefs is challenging, Doty suggests it's possible through awareness and choosing love over fear. He emphasizes the importance of understanding childhood attachments, as they often lead to seeking external validation rather than following genuine purpose.

Practices for Conscious Manifestation

Doty outlines several techniques for effective manifestation. He describes how embedding intentions activates the brain's salience network, which then seeks opportunities aligned with these intentions. The process becomes more effective, he explains, through visualization, reading, writing, and speaking one's intentions. Doty and Howes discuss the importance of accessing flow states through meditation and breathing exercises, while remaining detached from specific outcomes.

Service, Gratitude, and Letting Go

Through various examples, Doty illustrates how shifting from self-centered goals to serving others can transform both individuals and communities. He shares his personal experience of giving away $30 million in stock, demonstrating how releasing attachment to material possessions can lead to greater freedom. Doty emphasizes the importance of gratitude in recognizing abundance and maintaining an optimistic outlook, noting that true fulfillment comes from benefiting others rather than pursuing selfish gains.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The effectiveness of manifestation techniques is not scientifically proven, and the concept often lacks empirical support.
  • The idea that embedding intentions into the subconscious can actively influence reality is a claim that requires more rigorous scientific validation.
  • While the nervous system does impact our mental states, the direct correlation between nervous system states and manifestation abilities is not clearly established in scientific literature.
  • The concept of the heart's energetic field influencing surroundings through vibrational energy is not supported by conventional scientific understanding.
  • The role of early life experiences in shaping beliefs and identity is well-established, but the extent to which this influences manifestation potential is not empirically proven.
  • The notion that changing ingrained beliefs is as simple as choosing love over fear may oversimplify complex psychological processes.
  • The activation of the brain's salience network is a real neurological process, but its connection to the effectiveness of manifestation practices is speculative.
  • Techniques such as visualization and meditation may have benefits for relaxation and focus, but their direct impact on manifestation outcomes is not conclusively demonstrated.
  • The idea of accessing flow states to enhance manifestation could be conflating general well-being and productivity with the ability to manifest specific outcomes.
  • The concept of shifting focus from self-centered goals to serving others is a valuable ethical perspective, but its impact on transformation is subjective and varies from person to person.
  • The notion that releasing attachment to material possessions leads to greater freedom is a philosophical viewpoint that may not resonate with or be applicable to everyone.
  • While gratitude is generally seen as a positive practice, its role in recognizing abundance and maintaining optimism may not have the same effect for all individuals.
  • The assertion that true fulfillment comes from benefiting others rather than pursuing selfish gains is a moral stance that may not align with all worldviews or definitions of fulfillment.

Actionables

  • You can create a personalized intention-infused playlist to subconsciously reinforce your goals while you go about your day. Make a playlist of songs that lyrically or emotionally resonate with the intentions you want to set. For example, if you're aiming to manifest more courage in your life, choose songs that evoke feelings of bravery and empowerment. Listen to this playlist during your commute, workouts, or while doing chores to subtly embed these intentions into your subconscious.
  • Develop a habit of 'opportunity journaling' to actively recognize and pursue chances that align with your intentions. Keep a small notebook with you and whenever you notice an opportunity that could lead to the fulfillment of your intentions, jot it down. This could be as simple as overhearing a conversation about a job opening in a field you're interested in or seeing a flyer for a community class that aligns with your goals. Reviewing this journal regularly will train your brain to be more alert to these opportunities.
  • Engage in 'gratitude mapping' to shift your focus from material possessions to the value of experiences and relationships. Draw a simple map with yourself at the center and branches leading out to the people, experiences, and opportunities you're grateful for. Instead of listing material possessions, focus on moments where you felt connected to others or learned something new. Update this map weekly to visually reinforce the abundance in your life that isn't tied to material wealth.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

The Neuroscience and Psychology of Manifestation

Jim Doty delves into the nuanced processes that contribute to the act of manifesting, unveiling the roles of the nervous system, energy vibrations, and the power of the mind.

Conscious and Subconscious Mind in Manifestation

Doty explains that while we all manifest daily, often the process is inefficient. However, intentional techniques can significantly enhance the ability to manifest desires.

Intentions Are Embedded Through Conscious Focus, With the Subconscious Seeking Fulfillment Opportunities

He highlights the importance of embedding intentions into the subconscious, as it will then seek opportunities for fulfillment. Doty recalls a visualization technique learned at age 12, where he listed his desires, orienting them towards material possessions and status – a practice that framed his intentions into a tangible form.

Regulating the Nervous System for Effective Manifestation

Doty touches on the critical role of self-compassion in transitioning from fear and a critical mindset to one of compassion. This transition is not merely psychological but physiological, affecting one's ability to transcend limiting beliefs and treat themselves with kindness.

Sympathetic "Fight-Or-flight" Limits Creativity; Parasympathetic "Rest-And-digest" Enables Mindfulness and Abundance

A chaotic environment stimulates the sympathetic nervous system, keeping a person in a constant state of fight, flight, or fear. This state reduces accessibility to executive control in the brain, affecting memory, creativity, and thoughtfulness. Doty and Howes touch on how symptoms of fight or flight during childhood create barriers to manifesting desires.

Doty details how chronic stress triggers the sympathetic nervous system, elevating stress hormones like cortisol, dampening immune response, and fostering chronic disease states. Conversely, fear engages this same system's negative aspects, while love and compassion activate the parasympathetic nervous system, promoting generosity, thoughtfulness, and kindness.

Further, Doty mentions a morning breathing exercise he perfor ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Neuroscience and Psychology of Manifestation

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The effectiveness of manifestation techniques is not scientifically proven, and the idea that we can influence reality with our thoughts lacks empirical evidence.
  • The concept of the subconscious mind seeking opportunities for fulfillment is a psychological theory that may not have a direct causal relationship with real-world outcomes.
  • Visualization techniques may help with goal setting and motivation, but there is no clear evidence that they have the power to manifest desires in the material world.
  • While self-compassion can improve mental health, its physiological effects are complex and not solely responsible for the ability to manifest desires.
  • The sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems indeed regulate different states of arousal, but their direct impact on creativity and manifestation is not well-established.
  • Chronic stress has well-documented negative health effects, but its relationship with manifestation abilities is speculative.
  • The idea that love and compassion activate the parasympathetic nervous system is an oversimplification of complex neurobiological processes.
  • Morning breathing exercises may promote relaxation, but their effect on openness and creativity varies among individuals and is not a guaranteed method for enhancing manifestation.
  • The heart's energetic field, as described, is a concept from alternative medicine and lacks ...

Actionables

  • You can create a personalized intention-setting alarm to prompt focused intention setting throughout the day. Set multiple alarms on your phone with labels that remind you to pause and concentrate on a specific intention for a minute or two. For example, an alarm labeled "Abundance Mindset" at 10 AM could remind you to focus on opportunities for growth and prosperity.
  • Develop a habit of "compassion meditation" to transition from stress to a state of calm. Dedicate a few minutes each day to meditate on feelings of love and kindness, starting with yourself and then extending these feelings to others. This practice can be as simple as sitting quietly, breathing deeply, and repeating affirmations of self-love and compassion for others.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

Childhood Programming, Beliefs, and Identity

Jim Doty and Lewis Howes delve into the complexities of how childhood experiences shape our beliefs, identity, and adult behavior, discussing the challenge and importance of overcoming limiting beliefs and understanding our attachments.

Early Life Experiences Shape Beliefs and Identity

Negative Messages and Childhood Beliefs Create Insecurity and Block Potential

Jim Doty shares deeply personal accounts of his own childhood, growing up in poverty with an alcoholic father and a distressed mother, illustrating how these pressing circumstances molded his beliefs and personality. Doty and Howes both talk about the imprint that early life experiences leave on people, often resulting in a negative internal monologue that can seriously restrict one's self-belief and potential. He explains that negative messages become a familiar energy for those who have endured abuse from a loved one during their formative years, even if that energy is associated with pain.

Lewis Howes shares his own insecurities from his youth, feelings that were backed by beliefs and evidence he gathered during those early years. Negative self-talk, they suggest, can strip individuals of their agency and create a sense of powerlessness that also spills over into their relationships with others.

The Challenge Of Overcoming Long-Held Limiting Beliefs

Unlearning Harmful Thought Patterns Is Difficult but Possible With Effort and Self-Compassion

Doty and Howes discuss the profound difficulty of amending belief systems that are reinforced by years of personal history. They compare it to addictions, like those to alcohol or drugs, which can be a method of numbing the anguish of original childhood traumas. However, Doty also illustrates the possibility of change, sharing how a negative message became a driving force for a woman's success, despite the heavy toll it imposed on her self-worth.

Howes and Doty contemplate the pervasive issue of individuals accepting criticism or perceived limits from others as immutable truths, thus hindering their ability to reach goals. Doty recognizes that changing ingrained beliefs is not easy but insists that with awareness and the right approach—choosing love over fear, for instance—one can overcome these negative patterns and invoke positive change.

Lewis Howes raises the question of whether profound pain is necessary for people to alter their belief systems. Jim Doty emphasizes the need to identify the falsehoods in the narrative perpetuated by the inner critic and reclaim one's agency. He suggests that fostering compassion ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Childhood Programming, Beliefs, and Identity

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While childhood experiences are influential, they are not the sole determinants of adult behavior; genetics and experiences throughout adolescence and adulthood also play significant roles.
  • Some individuals may find strength and resilience in response to negative childhood experiences, which can lead to positive outcomes and personal growth.
  • The concept of a negative internal monologue may not universally apply; some individuals may develop positive self-talk or coping mechanisms that mitigate the impact of early negative messages.
  • The comparison of limiting beliefs to addictions might oversimplify the complex nature of belief systems and the multifaceted process of addiction recovery.
  • The idea that negative messages can become driving forces for success might not acknowledge the full spectrum of how these messages can detrimentally affect mental health and well-being for some individuals.
  • The suggestion that profound pain is necessary for altering belief systems could be challenged by the notion that incremental learning and positive experiences can also lead to significant changes in beliefs.
  • The emphasis on self-reflection and understanding childhood attachments might not consider the potential benefits of other therapeutic approaches that focus on present circumstances and future-oriented strategies.
  • The focus on individual agency in overcoming limiting beliefs ...

Actionables

  • Create a 'belief timeline' to visually map out how past experiences have shaped your current beliefs. Start by drawing a line on a piece of paper, marking your age at intervals. At each interval, write down a significant event and the belief it fostered. For example, if at age seven you were told you were bad at math, you might have developed the belief that you're inherently bad at all numbers-related tasks. This visual representation can help you identify patterns and the origins of your beliefs.
  • Develop a 'counter-script' practice to challenge your negative internal monologue. Whenever you catch yourself engaging in negative self-talk, write down the critical thought and then write a positive counter-statement. For instance, if you think "I always mess things up," you could write a counter-script that says "I've succeeded in many tasks, and it's okay to make mistakes sometimes." Over time, this practice can help rewire your thought patterns to be more positive and self-compassionate.
  • Engage in 'role-reversal' exercises to build empathy and alter ingrained beliefs. Choose a belief that you r ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

Practices and Techniques for Conscious Manifestation

Jim Doty and Lewis Howes discuss the power of setting intentions and accessing altered states of consciousness to harness the brain's ability to manifest desires and achieve goals.

Visualization, Intentions, and the "Filing Clerk"

The discussion includes various techniques and concepts that are crucial for embedding intentions and activating the brain's salience network.

Embedding Intentions Activates Brain's Salience Network to Seek Opportunities

Doty explains that embedding intentions in our subconscious can alert us to opportunities and occurrences that align with our goals. He likens this to a "bloodhound" that searches for ways to manifest those intentions. By embedding an intention, it becomes salient like one's own identity, triggering the brain's attention network to actively seek out related opportunities.

Lewis Howes emphasizes the importance of the energy and presence we bring to our actions aligning with our intentions. Doty confirms this by illustrating the effectiveness of visualization, reading, writing, and speaking one's intentions. This multidisciplinary engagement strengthens the neural wiring associated with the intention and maximizes manifestation potential.

Accessing Flow States, the Placebo Effect, and Hypnosis

Techniques Like Meditation, Breathing, and Self-Hypnosis Induce Flow and Activate the Brain's Capacity For Self-Healing and Manifestation

Doty and Howes talk about how individuals can tap into their inner power and access flow states, which are akin to hypnosis and the placebo effect. Doty notes that the placebo effect can facilitate positive outcomes even without belief in the placebo, suggesting a form of inner "magic" at play.

The conversation acknowledges the importance of practices such as meditation and breathing exercises in achieving a state conducive to productivity and well-being. These relaxation techniques help induce flow states and change the type of energy one feels and emits, thus affecting how others react to them. Lewis Howes discusses attaining a flow state for harmonious abundance creation rather than an exhaustive grind.

Releasing Expectations and Being Open to "Magic"

Detaching From Outcomes and Embracing Unexpected Manifestations Invites Synchronicity and Serendipity

Doty emphasizes the importance of not having attachment to any single outcome as it can cause suffering when life brings us unexpected results. He explains that focusing on the journey and those ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Practices and Techniques for Conscious Manifestation

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The belief in the brain's salience network actively seeking opportunities may be overstated, as there is limited empirical evidence to support the idea that intentions can directly influence external events.
  • The concept of the brain's attention network manifesting goals could be criticized for lacking a clear causal mechanism and for not accounting for external factors beyond individual control.
  • While engaging multiple modalities may strengthen neural wiring, it is not guaranteed to maximize manifestation potential, as success often depends on a complex interplay of factors, including luck and timing.
  • The idea that aligning energy and presence with intentions enhances manifestation effectiveness could be seen as overly simplistic and not universally applicable across different individuals and situations.
  • Practices like meditation and self-hypnosis may not induce flow states for everyone, and their effectiveness can vary widely based on individual differences and preferences.
  • The comparison of flow states to hypnosis and the placebo effect may be misleading, as these are distinct psychological phenomena with different underlying processes.
  • The notion that relaxation techniques can change the energy one emits and influence others' reactions might be challenged as being too vague and not scientifically grounded.
  • The concept of detaching from specific outcomes to reduce suffering could be criticized for potentially leading to a lack of goal-directed behavior and reduced motivation.
  • The idea of dispositional optimism attracting positive outcomes may be overly optimistic itself, as positive thinking does not always lead to positive results.
  • Maintaining optimism despite delays or changes i ...

Actionables

  • You can create a daily intention-setting ritual by choosing a quiet moment each morning to write down your intention for the day, then visualize it coming to fruition. This practice can help embed your intentions into your subconscious by making it a regular part of your routine, similar to brushing your teeth. For example, if your intention is to be more patient, you might visualize yourself handling a stressful situation calmly.
  • Develop a 'flow playlist' with music or sounds that help you enter a relaxed state, and listen to it during activities that align with your intentions. This can help induce a flow state that supports your manifestation efforts. For instance, if you're working on a creative project, choose music that energizes and inspires you, and notice how it influences your work and mindset.
  • Engage in a weekly 'optimism reflection' where you write ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why You Keep Manifesting the Wrong Things (And How to Fix It)

Service, Gratitude, and Letting Go

Jim Doty’s poignant stories and insights reveal the transformative power of compassion, service, gratitude, and detachment from material possessions.

Transformative Power of Compassion and Service to Others

Jim Doty shares compelling narratives illustrating how compassion and serving others can profoundly change individuals and communities.

Shifting From Self-Centered Goals To Elevating Others Impacts Physiology and Mindset

One such story involves a CEO whose transformation, following negative feedback and therapy, led to the incorporation of compassion into his workplace culture. After adopting a meditation practice influenced by a Buddhist monk, he fostered an environment of thoughtfulness and kindness, leading to high retention, productivity, and shareholder value.

Doty, a proponent of values such as integrity and kindness, which all embody love, also tells how a single lecture of his inspired a spiritual director at a large homeless shelter to not give up her role. He demonstrates that individual actions guided by compassion can impact physiology and mindset, with actions like holding the door for others or being kind activating the parasympathetic nervous system. Such actions have a range of health benefits and stimulate the brain's reward centers.

Furthermore, Doty describes how changing one's outlook to serve others rather than fulfill self-centered goals can profoundly alter how one perceives the world. He shares personal reflections on his own business success, recognizing that true fulfillment comes from purpose and benefiting others—eudaimonic happiness—instead of selfish gains.

Practicing Gratitude to Shift Perspective and Increase Abundance

Doty discusses the positive effects of gratitude, highlighting research on gratitude journals. Reflecting on things to be thankful for helps individuals gain perspective and recognize their relative abundance, which is significant given that half the world's population lives on less than $2.50 a day. He illustrates perspective's importance through patients with severe injuries and emphasizes the discrepancy in global fortune.

Acknowledging Abundance Counters Scarcity Mindset and Opens Prosperity

The implication is that transitioning from a scarcity mindset to one of service and compassion can open pathways to manifesting needs over wants. An optimistic view and engaging the parasympathetic nervous system can help someone see the world through a more abundant lens, enhancing purpose, meaning, and longevity. This optimistic viewpoint is seen as vital to shifting perspective and acknowledging the abundance in one's life.

Releasing Attachment To Outcomes and Material Possessions

Doty speaks to the heart of letting go, the detachment from material possessions, and the release of focusing only on outcomes. He recounts his decisi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Service, Gratitude, and Letting Go

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While compassion and service can lead to positive changes, they are not the only factors that can transform individuals and communities; other elements such as education, economic opportunities, and policy changes also play significant roles.
  • The impact of shifting focus from self-centered goals to elevating others may vary depending on individual circumstances and may not always lead to the positive outcomes suggested.
  • Incorporating compassion into workplace culture is beneficial, but it must be balanced with other business practices to ensure long-term viability and competitiveness.
  • Meditation and mindfulness practices are helpful for many, but they may not resonate with or be practical for everyone due to cultural, personal, or situational differences.
  • The physiological benefits of compassionate actions are well-documented, but attributing health benefits solely to these actions without considering other lifestyle factors could be an oversimplification.
  • The concept of eudaimonic happiness is compelling, but what constitutes true fulfillment can be subjective and differ greatly among individuals.
  • Gratitude practices are beneficial, but they may not be a panacea for all individuals, especially those facing severe adversity or mental health challenges.
  • The idea of abundance versus scarcity mindset is valuable, but it may not fully account for systemic issues that limit individuals' opportunities regardless of their mindset.
  • An optimistic outlook is generally positive, but it is important to acknowledge and address real challenges and not dismiss negative experiences or emotions.
  • Letting go of material possessions can be liberating for some, but for others, financial security and material resources are necessary for well-being and cannot be easily dismissed.
  • The notion of manifesting from a place of wholeness may not align with everyone's beliefs or experiences, and the concept of manifesting needs over wants could be seen as oversimplified o ...

Actionables

  • You can create a "compassion jar" where you write down daily acts of kindness you've performed or witnessed and review them at the end of the week to reflect on the positive impact these actions have on your life and others. This could be as simple as complimenting someone, helping a neighbor with groceries, or sending a thoughtful message to a friend. The act of writing and reviewing helps reinforce the behavior and its benefits.
  • Start a "gratitude chain" with friends or family where each person texts one thing they're grateful for to the group every day. This not only cultivates a habit of gratitude for you but also encourages a supportive community that focuses on abundance rather than scarcity. It can be as simple as being thankful for a sunny day, a delicious meal, or a helpful coworker.
  • Implement a "detachment day" once a month where ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA