In this episode of the Shawn Ryan Show, filmmaker-turned-investigator Payne Lindsey discusses his journey creating "Up and Vanished," a true crime podcast that evolved from a documentary concept into a real-time investigative tool. Lindsey shares how he built community engagement around cold cases, navigated complex relationships with law enforcement, and faced dangerous encounters with suspects while investigating disappearances across the country. He also addresses systemic failures in cases involving missing and murdered Indigenous women and the growth of his podcast studio, Tenderfoot TV.
The conversation expands beyond true crime to explore unexplained phenomena, including UFO investigations, ghost encounters, and the intersection of spiritual and paranormal experiences. Ryan shares his own spiritual transformation, describing how a trip to Sedona and a series of seemingly supernatural events led him away from New Age spirituality toward faith. Together, Lindsey and Ryan examine how openness to experiences beyond rational explanation can shape personal worldviews and investigative work.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Payne Lindsey begins as a broke freelance filmmaker with no investigative background, inspired by shows like "Unsolved Mysteries" and "The Jinx." He chooses the Tara Grinstead case—Georgia's top unsolved crime from 2005—as his focus, initially planning a documentary but settling on a podcast as a proof of concept. Lindsey leverages his storytelling skills and approachable demeanor to build rapport with sources, conduct interviews, and eventually become part of the unfolding investigation.
Lindsey releases "Up and Vanished" before completing his investigation, transforming it into a raw, real-time investigative tool. This approach invites listeners to contribute tips and information, with community engagement intensifying through cliffhanger endings that spur immediate feedback. Using social media ads targeting Ocilla, Georgia, Lindsey quickly expands his audience, and local news outlets pick up on the podcast's growing influence. At times, law enforcement investigates sites within hours of Lindsey's visits, underscoring the podcast's impact on the investigation's pace and direction.
Lindsey's relationship with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation is marked by tension and hostility. The GBI subpoenas user data from his online forums and imposes a gag order, prioritizing narrative control over cooperation. In contrast, Lindsey forms a productive relationship with the Colorado Bureau of Investigation during the Crystal Rising case, where officials recognize the value of outside help on cold cases and maintain constructive communication.
In February 2017, Ryan Duke is arrested and confesses under the influence of drugs to killing Tara Grinstead. Lindsey and many listeners doubt the confession's veracity and suspect Bo Dukes, who confesses only to burning the body but faces minimal charges. Years later, a jury finds Ryan Duke not guilty, validating suspicions that the GBI pursued the wrong suspect. Meanwhile, Bo Dukes exploits his notoriety on message boards, posting graphic crime details and enjoying attention from the podcast's community.
Investigating disappearances places Lindsey in perilous situations. He confronts "Catfish John" in Colorado, whose erratic behavior turns aggressive. While investigating Ashley Loring Heavy Runner's disappearance in Montana, Lindsey faces Sam, who emerges with a large revolver, but Lindsey calmly builds rapport to de-escalate the situation. He also confronts "Paul," who threatens him with dogs and violent behavior. In each case, Lindsey employs calmness and intentional self-presentation to extract information or escape harm.
To investigate Florence Ochpieluk's disappearance in Nome, Alaska, Lindsey creates a fake Facebook account to lure "Oregon John" to a bar for questioning. He later reveals his identity and convinces John to take a polygraph examination in Portland. John fails twice and admits he hasn't been fully truthful with authorities about Florence's disappearance.
Lindsey investigates missing and murdered Indigenous women, noting that Native women are murdered at ten times the national rate with almost no media coverage. Jurisdictional confusion among FBI, tribal, and state law enforcement creates bureaucratic bottlenecks that allow cases to go uninvestigated. Lindsey presents evidence of potential corruption or negligence to the FBI, highlighting the need for accountability and federal intervention.
Building on "Up and Vanished's" success, Lindsey co-founds Tenderfoot TV in 2016, which grows into one of the largest independent podcast studios with over 30 shows, 600 episodes, and 400 million downloads. "Up and Vanished" alone amasses around 800 million downloads, establishing Lindsey as a key figure in investigative journalism focused on cold cases.
Payne Lindsey and Shawn Ryan discuss how UFO research gained legitimacy after major media outlets exposed secret government programs. Lindsey recalls The New York Times and Politico revealing a classified U.S. government UFO program in 2017, reasoning that the government wouldn't pursue such research without credible evidence. Growing numbers of credible witnesses, including military pilots, report craft defying known physics, with many risking their careers to come forward. Lindsey highlights the 1975 Travis Walton case in Arizona, where Walton disappeared for five days after approaching a hovering craft, with investigators documenting burn marks and radiation at the site.
Lindsey recounts living in a 1767 Marblehead, Massachusetts house where he repeatedly heard footsteps running up three flights of stairs, witnessed a friend's encounter with a shadow figure, and experienced a sink that inexplicably turned on weekly. Ryan shares experiences in a Civil War-era cabin where he and crew members heard deliberate roof bangs and cowboy boot footsteps with no source found, with video showing static interference aligned with the sounds.
Lindsey explores connections between UFO and ghostly phenomena, speculating both could involve dimensions outside human perception. He notes UFO reports often describe objects appearing and vanishing instantaneously rather than flying away conventionally. Lindsey and Ryan discuss religious artwork depicting seraphim angels as disc-like beings covered in eyes and light, resembling modern UFO descriptions. They consider that ancient descriptions of angels may parallel contemporary UFO encounters—entities transcending conventional physics and capable of passing through solid matter.
Lindsey raises the unsettling pattern of scientists involved in UFO investigations disappearing under suspicious circumstances, fueling suspicions of threat suppression and heightening the intrigue surrounding this domain of inquiry.
Sean Ryan travels to Sedona seeking clarity through New Age spirituality, but crystals, psychics, and psychedelics fail to provide answers. A defining moment comes through an encounter with an elderly gate guard who seemingly reads Ryan's mind, addressing his specific unspoken worries. During this same period, Ryan receives a text from his late friend Dan's daughter Taylor, whom he's never met, reaching out because her father considered Ryan his best friend. Ryan also repeatedly notices a man resembling his late friend Gabe around the resort, interpreting these sightings as a protective presence and evidence of supernatural guidance.
Ryan's struggle climaxes during a psychedelic experience where he envisions hell and questions if he's there for loving his family more than Christ. Upon returning home, he attends Mass and hears a priest deliver a homily directly addressing his spiritual dilemma. Ryan adopts daily Mass attendance, consistently finding that the priest's messages align with his internal challenges, convincing him these are evidence of divine guidance rather than coincidence.
Ryan abandons his prior belief in New Age spirituality and shifts away from politics and government as sources of hope. He credits his transformation to cultivating openness and willingness to receive guidance, even when he was skeptical and resistant.
Payne Lindsey approaches faith with curiosity, confirmed Catholic but not orthodox, with interest in unexplained phenomena and spiritual experiences. He pursues investigative work marked by serendipity and synchronicity that sometimes seem like divine guidance. Payne speculates on the afterlife and reincarnation, wondering if the government conceals proof of life after death to avoid destabilizing social order.
Ryan's story underscores how profound vulnerability and the failure of all other methods pushed him toward genuine transformation. His spiritual awakening came through personal experiences transcending rational explanation. The dialogue between Ryan and Payne ultimately shows that authentic spiritual encounters often come through openness and willingness to receive guidance, especially when all other means have failed.
1-Page Summary
Payne Lindsey begins his journey as a broke freelance filmmaker, living with his brother and with no investigative background. Fascinated by shows like "Unsolved Mysteries" and inspired by the documentary "The Jinx," Lindsey sets out to solve an unsolved disappearance in South Georgia, initially planning to create a documentary. Lacking resources, he decides to start with a podcast as a proof of concept. The Tara Grinstead case, Georgia’s top unsolved crime at the time, becomes his major focus. Grinstead’s mysterious 2005 disappearance—her car at home, the door locked, and a latex glove in the yard—leads Lindsey to investigate. He applies his storytelling and observational skills, focusing on building rapport and presenting himself as relatable rather than aggressive or confrontational, leveraging his ability as an observer and documenter to engage sources, conduct interviews, and eventually become part of the unfolding story.
Facing a tight production schedule, Lindsey releases the first episode of "Up and Vanished" before completing his investigation, transforming the podcast into a raw, real-time investigative tool. This approach invites listeners—mainly locals initially—to contribute tips and information, often resulting in new evidence surfacing and even prompting suspects to talk. Community engagement intensifies as each episode ends on a cliffhanger, spurring immediate feedback and tips that sometimes make it into the show that same week. Lindsey uses social media ads, particularly on Instagram, to drive local interest in Ocilla, Georgia, which quickly expands to statewide and broader audiences. Local news outlets pick up on the podcast’s growing influence. At times, the flow of tips leads Lindsey to sites of possible evidence, some of which law enforcement investigates within hours of his visits, underscoring the podcast’s impact on the pace and direction of the investigation.
Lindsey’s unconventional approach draws rapid attention from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI), which initially shows both interest and hostility. The GBI reacts to leads he uncovers and even subpoenas user data from his online forums, appearing to prioritize narrative control and public image over cooperation. At one point, Lindsey faces a sweeping gag order designed to curb podcast discussion in the county and experiences intimidating interactions with agents. His information is clearly considered valuable by law enforcement, yet there is persistent tension and lack of trust.
In contrast, Lindsey forms a productive relationship with the Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) during the Crystal Rising disappearance case. The CBI is more open to outside help and investigative input, recognizing the stalling effect of traditional methods on cold cases. This collaboration leads to constructive sharing of information and ongoing communication with CBI officials, with Lindsey still actively involved as new leads emerge.
In February 2017, Ryan Duke is arrested and confesses—under the influence of drugs—to killing Tara Grinstead, based on an account that is incoherent and medically compromised. Many, including Lindsey and his listeners, doubt the veracity of the confession and suspect Bo Dukes, who later confesses to burning Tara’s body with Ryan Duke but is only charged with improper disposal. Bo Dukes is released quickly, while Ryan Duke faces murder charges.
Years pass with the prosecution sticking to a weak narrative, culminating in a trial where the jury finds Ryan Duke not guilty, validating Lindsey’s and the jury’s suspicion that the GBI pursued the wrong suspect due to pride and pressure to close the case. Meanwhile, Bo Dukes becomes notorious, exploiting his role as an insider on message boards, posting graphic details about the crime, flirting with female listeners, and enjoying the infamy and attention from the podcast’s community.
Investigating disappearances places Lindsey in perilous encounters. In Colorado, he meets “Catfish John,” a suspect in Crystal Rising’s disappearance, whose erratic, incoherent behavior reflects deep substance abuse and mental decline. Lindsey’s in-person confrontation with Catfish John, which turns aggressive, involves threats and a failed attempt to assault Lindsey with a motorcycle helmet.
When investigating Ashley Loring Heavy Runner’s disappearance, Lindsey confronts Sam, a last known contact, in rural Montana. Sam emerges from a car with a large revolver. Lindsey responds calmly, introducing himself and building rapport to de-escalate the situation, resulting in a tense but ultimately peaceful three-hour conversation.
Lindsey also confronts “Paul,” another person of interest, who threatens him and expels him from his home. Paul’s agitation, threats to call dogs, and recent violent behavior highlight the constant danger Lindsey faces. In all cases, Lindsey employs a mix of calmness, quick-thinking, and intentional self-presentation—sometimes appearing naive or non-threatening—to extract information or escape harm.
True Crime Investigation and Podcasting
Exploring the unknown, Payne Lindsey and Shawn Ryan discuss compelling encounters and intersections between UFOs, ghostly events, the spiritual realm, and mysteries involving scientists. Their conversations weave between personal anecdotes, investigative journalism, and philosophical speculation.
The legitimacy of UFO research has only grown stronger since major media outlets exposed secret government programs. Payne Lindsey recalls pivotal reporting by The New York Times and Politico in 2017, which revealed the existence of a classified U.S. government UFO program. The fact that millions were spent on secret research led Lindsey to question why such programs exist if UFOs are dismissed as mere fantasy. He reasons that the government would not pursue research at this scale unless there was credible evidence worth investigating.
A growing number of credible witnesses, including decorated military pilots and defense personnel, continue to report sightings of anomalous craft defying the known laws of physics. Lindsey highlights that these individuals risk their careers and reputations, often facing ridicule and skepticism. The absence of clear personal gain heightens the credibility of their claims. To Lindsey, the probability that all such reports are false would itself be bizarre and statistically anomalous.
One of the most striking abduction cases is that of Travis Walton in 1975, Snowflake, Arizona. Walton and five other loggers reported seeing a metallic craft hovering above their truck. Walton approached the object, after which he vanished for five days. During his absence, police suspected foul play, even subjecting the loggers to polygraph tests. Walton was found days later, weakened and disoriented, having lost significant weight. Investigators documented burn marks and radiation in the area. The other witnesses remained consistent in their stories, and despite skepticism, evidence pointed to something inexplicable.
The paranormal extends into terrestrial locales, as shared by Lindsey and Ryan from their personal investigations.
In Marblehead, Massachusetts, Payne Lindsey lived in a house built in 1767 and encountered several inexplicable events. He describes hearing the distinct sound of someone running up three flights of stairs. Multiple inspections failed to explain this repeated phenomenon. Lindsey also recounts a friend’s experience in the house—a friend awoke to see a shadow figure at the door with the family cat evidently watching the entity. Another recurring anomaly was a sink that inexplicably turned on once a week, with no rational explanation even after inspection.
Shawn Ryan shares his time in a Civil War-era cabin used for a survival show. On two separate nights, he and others heard deliberate, loud bangs on the roof around 2 a.m., distinct from animal activity. Reviewing footage, the crew consistently noted static interference aligning perfectly with each footstep sound. On another occasion, six crew members heard the sound of cowboy boots walking across the cabin loft, with all present looking up simultaneously. Despite thoroughly checking, no source for the footsteps was ever found, and video confirmed static interference tied to the sounds. These accumulated incidents defied practical explanation.
Payne Lindsey explores the convergence of UFO and ghostly phenomena, speculating that both could be linked through dimensions or realms outside human perception. He observes a pattern in UFO reports: objects or beings appear and vanish instantaneously, rarely flying away conventionally. Lindsey suggests these events might involve transitions through other dimensions or layers of reality—a noti ...
Unexplained Phenomena and the Paranormal
The conversation between Shawn Ryan and Payne Lindsey navigates the intense journey from seeking answers in New Age spirituality and external solutions to profound, personal encounters with faith and the divine. Both share stories of transformation anchored in vulnerability, spiritual openness, and the mysterious alignment of events that seem to reveal a higher power’s guidance.
Sean Ryan travels to Sedona seeking clarity, driven by curiosity about crystal energy, energy vortexes, psychics, and therapeutic use of psychedelics. Despite hiking to vortexes and investing in crystals, Sean finds no answers to his existential questions. Crystals, psychics, and even psychedelic sessions ultimately fail to offer guidance.
A defining moment comes through a surreal encounter with an elderly gate guard he’s never seen before. Amidst internal turmoil, the guard seemingly reads Sean’s mind, addressing Sean’s specific, unspoken worries about modern controversies, podcast direction, and world anxieties, telling him pointedly, “That’s not your battle, man.” Sean is shaken by the man’s inexplicable insight, feeling exposed as though the guard were a ghost.
During the same deeply emotional period, Sean, still mourning his close friend Dan Cirillo, receives a text from Dan’s daughter Taylor—a person he has never met. She reaches out to Sean, sharing that her father regarded Sean as his best friend and wanted her to connect. The timing and message of Taylor’s outreach reinforces a sense that something orchestrated beyond chance is at work in Sean’s life.
As if echoing this message, Sean also begins noticing a man who bears an uncanny resemblance to his late friend Gabe, repeatedly appearing around the resort. Rather than feeling disturbed, Sean interprets these sightings as a reassuring, protective presence, further deepening the sense that his path is supernaturally guided during this period of transformation.
Sean’s struggle with faith acceptance climaxes during a psychedelic experience, where he plunges into what he interprets as hell—a vivid vision of anxiety, fear, and utter blackness. The absence of love leads Sean to question if he is in hell for loving his wife and children more than Christ, a realization that fills him with dread and existential agony. Deeply unsettled, he returns home desperate for guidance.
Attending Mass upon his return, Sean hears a priest deliver a homily that directly addresses his spiritual dilemma: prioritizing love for family over love for Christ. For Sean, this sermon feels uncannily tailored to his internal struggle, serving as a validating message of reassurance and divine responsiveness to his search for answers.
Sean adopts the habit of daily Mass attendance, consistently finding that the priest’s messages align with whatever internal challenges he faces. The frequency and specificity of these coincidences convince Sean that these are not mere accidents, but instead evidence of divine guidance.
Reflecting on his journey, Sean abandons his prior belief in crystals, energy vortexes, psychedelics, and New Age spirituality. He comes to see these as misguided searches for answers outside authentic faith. Likewise, Sean’s focus shifts away from politics and government as sources of hope or change. Once invested in political cycles and hoping for external solutions, he now regards such pursuits as meaningless, convincing himself that true change comes from spiritual development and direct, personal action to support the vulnerable.
Sean credits his transformation to cultivating openness, stillness, and the willingness to receive guidance. He notes that, despite believing he wasn’t open (being skeptical, even resistant), events pulled him toward profound spiritual awareness when he most needed it.
Payne Lindsey approaches faith from a place of curiosity, confirmed Catholic but not religiously orthodox, with interest in unexplained phenomena such as UFOs, ghosts, and spiritual experiences. Payne p ...
Spirituality, Faith, and Personal Transformation
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
