This is a preview of the Shortform book summary of This Changes Everything by Naomi Klein.
Read Full Summary

1-Page Summary1-Page Book Summary of This Changes Everything

The deficiencies in an economy driven by market dynamics when addressing the ecological crisis.

Klein argues that the current capitalist system, with its focus on deregulated markets, privatization of public resources, and relentless pursuit of growth, is inherently at odds with the urgent actions needed to tackle climate change successfully. She believes that this fundamental paradox has long been a major obstacle to our collective action in tackling the environmental emergency.

Effective climate change mitigation efforts are at odds with neoliberal ideology.

Klein underscores that the core tenets, which include transferring public services to private ownership, reducing the role of government oversight, and significant cuts in financial support, pose considerable barriers to taking meaningful measures against climate change. Klein posits that the enthusiastic embrace of specific strategies has markedly impeded our ability to address the climate emergency with efficacy.

Efforts to privatize have hindered necessary funding for infrastructure that is sustainable.

Klein posits that our advancement towards an era propelled by renewable energy sources has been markedly impeded due to the transfer of public utilities such as energy and water into private ownership. Energy companies, often driven by the imperative to maximize profits for shareholders, tend to resist the transition to renewable energy sources, especially when these options are seen as not as profitable as conventional energy resources derived from the earth. Municipalities that possess their own utility companies often have a stronger influence on the generation of their energy and, despite certain challenges, these organizations concentrate on reducing emissions that contribute to climate change and channeling earnings back into projects that foster the development of the community.

Klein highlights how towns in Germany, including Hamburg, have reclaimed their energy systems, with the community choosing to restore local authority over utility services to accelerate the transition to renewable energy sources. In Boulder, Colorado, the community voted to investigate the creation of a publicly owned utility committed to achieving their environmental sustainability goals. These successes show an increasing recognition of the need to take back democratic governance over the production and distribution of energy as a step towards a sustainable energy future.

Strict oversight is impeded by insufficient regulations on businesses involved in the coal, oil, and natural gas sectors.

Klein argues that the fundamental tenet of neoliberal economic ideology, which is the removal of regulatory constraints, creates a political climate in which it is impractical to limit the unchecked power of the fossil fuel industry. She underscores the necessity for governmental actions to tackle climate change head-on through the enforcement of strict rules on emissions, banning specific activities, levying penalties, and offering monetary inducements for the adoption of eco-friendly alternatives.

The author contends that the measures described stand in stark contrast to the ideologies of conservative think tanks, which have played a pivotal role in both questioning the validity of climate change and promoting corporate deregulation. The author believes that these think tanks acknowledge the inherent clash between their political objectives...

Want to learn the ideas in This Changes Everything better than ever?

Unlock the full book summary of This Changes Everything by signing up for Shortform.

Shortform summaries help you learn 10x better by:

  • Being 100% clear and logical: you learn complicated ideas, explained simply
  • Adding original insights and analysis, expanding on the book
  • Interactive exercises: apply the book's ideas to your own life with our educators' guidance.
READ FULL SUMMARY OF THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING

Here's a preview of the rest of Shortform's This Changes Everything summary:

This Changes Everything Summary Political convictions present significant barriers to addressing climate change.

Klein suggests that the contentiousness surrounding climate change arises because the steps required to avert catastrophe directly challenge the substantial power that the fossil fuel industry and other prominent entities have recently gained. These powerful actors have been remarkably successful at stalling climate action through a combination of aggressive lobbying, campaign donations, and the cynical use of trade deals to overturn regulations.

The significant influence of the fossil fuel industry on the formulation of policies

Klein delves into the ways the fossil fuel industry has exerted its significant economic power to obstruct the enactment of robust climate policies. She believes that the industry understands the threat climate science poses to its core business model and therefore expends an extraordinary amount of energy and money fighting to maintain its grip on the system.

Aggressive advocacy and monetary donations to political figures are obstructing the progress of legislation intended to protect the environment.

Klein highlights how the fossil fuel industry, joined by conservative foundations and allies in business, has fought furiously to oppose...

Try Shortform for free

Read full summary of This Changes Everything

Sign up for free

This Changes Everything Summary Striving for economic fairness while also targeting environmental goals, thus maintaining social justice.

Klein suggests that the ongoing ecological emergency offers a unique and powerful opportunity to push for a transition to an economic framework that promotes equality and inclusiveness, prioritizing the protection of those most at risk while moving away from constant growth. Naomi Klein suggests that by combining climate action with the pursuit of social and economic justice, we can achieve a substantial decrease in emissions while also improving the lives of many people worldwide.

Addressing global inequalities is essential in mitigating the impact of climate change.

Klein underscores the importance of tackling and remedying worldwide imbalances to progress toward a future that sustains itself without relying on carbon. She believes that wealthy, industrialized countries have a moral obligation to support developing nations as they transition to sustainable energy and deal with the consequences of climate change. Failing to uphold our responsibilities to those communities that have contributed the least to the climate crisis will only perpetuate a pattern of development heavily dependent on significant carbon emissions.

Industrialized nations must recognize the...

What Our Readers Say

This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
Learn more about our summaries →

This Changes Everything Summary It is of utmost urgency to find equitable resolutions to the climate emergency.

Klein emphasizes the urgency of the climate crisis, stressing that our response must be equitable and encompassing. The writer emphasizes the importance of addressing the root issues of the crisis to avert permanent alterations to the planet's climate mechanisms within what they call "decade zero."

Our current approach carries the risk of continuing to rely heavily on a carbon-dependent economy.

Klein argues that continuing on a trajectory of "business as usual" will lead to catastrophic warming, making the planet largely uninhabitable for a vast percentage of the population. The author emphasizes the swift escalation of greenhouse gas emissions, the perils associated with aggressive energy procurement techniques, including the extraction of petroleum from bituminous deposits and the use of high-pressure fluids to fracture geological formations, as well as the profound effects these practices have on vulnerable communities around the world.

The planet is being driven toward a disastrous rise in temperature because of a marked increase in emissions of greenhouse gases.

Klein emphasizes the continuous rise in emissions of greenhouse gases worldwide, even though there...

This Changes Everything

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Carbon trading systems are mechanisms where companies can buy and sell permits to emit carbon dioxide. The goal is to create a financial incentive for companies to reduce their emissions. However, critics argue that these systems can be complex, prone to manipulation, and may not always lead to significant emissions reductions.
  • The Blockadia movement is a term used to describe a global grassroots resistance movement against fossil fuel extraction projects and environmental degradation. It involves local communities, indigenous groups, and environmental activists coming together to protect their lands and waters from harmful industrial activities. Blockadia actions often involve civil disobedience, protests, and legal challenges to prevent the expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure. The movement highlights the power of local resistance in shaping environmental policies and challenging the status quo.
  • Geoengineering involves...

Counterarguments

  • Market dynamics can drive innovation and efficiency in renewable energy technologies, potentially leading to faster and more cost-effective climate solutions.
  • Privatization can sometimes lead to more efficient and better-managed utilities, which could include a faster transition to renewable energy if incentivized correctly.
  • Regulations can sometimes be too burdensome and stifle innovation; a balance must be struck between necessary oversight and allowing businesses the flexibility to innovate.
  • Austerity measures, in some cases, can lead to more efficient use of resources, which could include better allocation of funds for climate mitigation strategies.
  • Market-based solutions like carbon pricing have been supported by many economists as a way to reduce emissions by providing financial incentives to reduce carbon footprints.
  • Technological progress, including the development of carbon capture...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free