Think about all the images, messages, and stories you’re confronted with throughout the day. Open the newspaper in the morning, and you’ll see photos of wars, profiles of political candidates and entrepreneurs, and reports on the latest stock prices. Scroll through social media, and you’ll encounter a barrage of photos, videos, ads, and memes, all communicating some message. Go to the store, and products will catch your attention—consciously and subconsciously—with designs and slogans.
According to Roland Barthes, an influential 20th-century French philosopher and literary critic, these objects and images that we consume throughout the day are filled with myth. He says on a broad level, myth is a mode of communication—a myth conveys a message. Myths occur when society’s dominant institutions (for example, the government, the advertising industry, or Hollywood) imbue an image, object, or phrase with meaning. These meanings then serve to shape the way people in society view the world. By creating these associations,...
Unlock the full book summary of Mythologies by signing up for Shortform.
Shortform summaries help you learn 10x better by:
Here's a preview of the rest of Shortform's Mythologies summary:
Before discussing where myth appears in society, let’s first define myth as Barthes presents it. Barthes explains that a myth is a message that’s conveyed when an object, image, or phrase becomes associated with a concept or value, and thus takes on a symbolic meaning. For example, a national flag may be associated with the concept of freedom, conveying a message about that nation to its citizens. Myths shape the way we view the world and hold power over us when society’s dominant institutions—for example, the government, the advertising industry, or Hollywood—craft these messages for us.
In this first section, we’ll discuss the process of mythmaking. First, we’ll look at the basic components of myth to better understand what it...
Barthes argues that myths have two basic, interrelated components: a form and a concept. The form of a myth is concrete: It is the actual object, image, or phrase that we perceive with our senses. Anything can become the form, or raw material, of a myth—it could be a song, a photo, or an everyday object such as a car or an article of clothing.
Barthes explains that on their own, these materials have a literal meaning. When we see a car, we recognize it as a vehicle of transportation. When we listen to a song, we understand its words. However, the power of myth is that it imbues these things with additional meaning. Myth occurs when society connects the raw material of form to an abstract concept.
As an example, consider a fictional political candidate. At rallies, she always plays a specific song as she walks onto the stage to get the crowd excited. Over time, voters begin to associate the song with the candidate: her supporters play it at marches and her opponents stop listening to it. The song comes to represent the candidate’s particular brand of politics (for example,...
This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
Now that we understand what Barthes means by myth, we’ll turn to a discussion of how myths are created and utilized in society. It’s important to recognize this because myths are being employed every day to influence our thoughts and perceptions of the world.
According to Barthes, myth is essentially a means of culture creation. But more specifically, he argues that it’s the creation of an “ideal culture” that obscures reality and diversity. And particularly in the examples he analyzes, from 1950s France, he says myth is created by the “bourgeois” (upper-middle class) for the “petit bourgeois” (lower-middle class) and “proletariat” (working class). So, although Barthes doesn’t use the word, he’s essentially arguing that myth is propaganda.
He suggests that institutions in society (for example, the government, the fashion and advertising industries, and the media) create associations between certain signs and concepts, and the general population internalizes these associations and comes to see them as natural. For example, a Jeep is associated with outdoor adventure—this association is conveyed in all Jeep advertisements, and therefore a Jeep will appeal to...
Barthes suggests that a defining characteristic of myth is its ability to appear as “natural,” even though it is constructed. This means that people don’t question the myth and instead accept it as fact. When society’s dominant institutions utilize mythology to influence the population’s thoughts, this can serve to perpetuate and reinforce social inequalities. In this way, by not questioning the mythology around us, we participate in our own subjugation.
(Shortform note: For example, sociologists and psychologists analyze the ways that women participate in their own oppression by supporting the norms and values associated with patriarchy. This often comes in the form of “benevolent sexism”—that is, the belief that women need to be protected and cared for by men. By adopting this belief, women relegate themselves to a lower-status position in the social hierarchy.)
Barthes argues that myth is both necessary and problematic. It’s necessary to some degree, he says, because it creates a simplified and comfortable world for people in the face of harsh realities. For example, he...
"I LOVE Shortform as these are the BEST summaries I’ve ever seen...and I’ve looked at lots of similar sites. The 1-page summary and then the longer, complete version are so useful. I read Shortform nearly every day."
Jerry McPheeIn his essay “The Blue Blood Cruise,” Barthes examines myths that perpetuate class distinctions. He describes a news segment about members of European royalty taking a yacht cruise of the Greek islands in 1954. As part of the media covering this event, Barthes says a King was pictured wearing a short-sleeved shirt, and a Queen was wearing a print dress, both of which would be unacceptable and unimaginable in any other context. The reports made mention of such details as the participants waking at 6 a.m., and the men shaving themselves, as if these daily minutiae were worthy of public press.
Barthes says the myth here lies in the presentation of royalty pretending to be regular people. But the deeper message conveyed by this spectacle is that they’re by definition not regular people. Otherwise why would short sleeves and shaving be newsworthy? So, Barthes says, this kind of myth creates and reinforces...
In his essay “Novels and Children,” Barthes explores gender inequality myths as he describes a segment from Elle magazine about women writers. In this article, a number of female writers are featured, and for each of them, the magazine reports how many novels she’s written, along with how many children she has. He points out that the article spends as much time discussing the women’s roles as wives and mothers as it does discussing their careers.
This myth is layered with meanings, as myths tend to be, Barthes says—there is the surface-level meaning which is about celebrating women’s achievements and purportedly showcasing women’s equality. And then there’s the deeper meaning, which according to Barthes, is that a woman is never complete without children. He says that this article conveys the message that women are allowed to indulge themselves with careers only if they’ve also done their primary duty and had children. He says women are essentially...
This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
As an example of a myth constructing racial ideologies, we’ll look at Barthes’s essay “Bichon Among the Blacks.” In this essay, Barthes describes a story from a French magazine called Match about a young white couple who visited Africa with their toddler son, Bichon, to pursue artistic inspiration. The featured photo of the article shows the blonde toddler with three dark-skinned African tribespeople. The article, he says, places a heavy emphasis on the “courage” of the family.
To begin with, Barthes notes that if there were any real danger to Bichon, the parents most certainly wouldn’t have placed their child in this position. So, the implication that this took courage is disingenuous at best. The myth presented here is a narrative about race, with the white couple being presented as heroic in their willingness to be among the “savage” Africans. So, he says, what on the surface tells the heartwarming story of racial groups mingling peacefully conceals the deeper message of racial difference, promoting an insidious myth of white supremacy.
This is an example of why myth can be so...
Next, we’ll look at an analysis of a myth that reinforces idealized beauty standards. Here Barthes analyzes the depiction of actress Greta Garbo’s face in film and photos. He points to lighting, makeup, and editing techniques meant to make her face appear perfect, without ever revealing a blemish or wrinkle. He says her face represents a cultural ideal of beauty, purity, and youth that is both unattainable and unforgettable.
Barthes calls Garbo’s face “an idea” in that it conveys a message about what he calls “amour courtois”—the concept of a noble and chivalrous kind of love. The population is meant to perceive her as something of a divine being, having a kind of beauty they should aspire to, yet can never attain. He points out that this is true of other celebrities as well, and that women so fervently idolized the legendary film star Rudolph Valentino that some were driven to suicide after his death in 1926.
Again, we can see here the notion that the **myth is both...
With Shortform, you can:
Access 12,000+ non-fiction book summaries.
Highlight what you want to remember.
Access 1,000+ premium article summaries.
Take notes on your favorite ideas.
Read on the go with our iOS and Android App.
Download PDF Summaries.
Finally, we’ll look at the way myth can reinforce political agendas through Barthes’s critique of Billy Graham at the Vel’ d’Hiv. Barthes describes a televised event in which the American Evangelist Billy Graham delivered sermons at the Vel’ d’Hiv stadium in Paris in 1955. He analyzes the way Graham’s performance, as myth, contained theatrical elements and concealed political messages.
Barthes views Graham as another version of a hypnotist or seance performer, and suggests that the crowd is mesmerized by what is essentially a calculated formula for cult-like indoctrination. He says Graham is viewed as a prophetic figure even though he says little to nothing with any intelligence or depth to it. Barthes goes as far as to argue that “if God is really speaking through Dr. Graham’s mouth, it must be acknowledged that God is quite stupid.” It is, according to Barthes, the performance which sways people, not Graham’s message. But the subtle message is there, and Barthes says that the message is anti-communist propaganda.
On this issue, Barthes’s analysis is ruthless in his criticism of Graham, as well as of those who fall prey to such myths. He explains that Graham’s visit to...
Barthes says that the most insidious thing about our cultural myths is their invisibility—the fact that we don’t notice them allows us to accept them without question. See if you can spot the myths you encounter today.
As you scroll through the internet today, take note of any advertisements you come across. Stop and contemplate a few of them. Can you decipher any hidden messages in the images or phrasing used? Are any subtle messages being conveyed about race, gender, class, beauty, or politics? Describe one in as much detail as possible.
This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.