This is a preview of the Shortform book summary of Less is More by Jason Hickel.
Read Full Summary

1-Page Summary1-Page Book Summary of Less is More

Capitalism is fundamentally dependent on continual growth for its success.

The unrelenting drive for growth that characterizes the capitalist system, according to Jason Hickel, stems not from its fundamental nature but from specific historical events and the intrinsic workings of the system.

The transition to capitalism involved a deliberate and turbulent change, masterminded by the elite to create conditions favorable for wealth accumulation.

Hickel challenges the common belief that capitalism emerged organically from feudalism, contending that it was born out of forceful takeovers and the concentration of authority within powerful factions. Hickel argues that the ascent of capitalism did not occur through gradual development but was instead the result of specific actions designed to create a setting favorable for wealth accumulation.

The rise of capitalism was greatly shaped by a deliberately created shortage that began through the process of enclosing common lands and the subsequent colonization, leading to the development of a readily available and economically sustainable labor pool.

Hickel identifies the transformation of communal lands into individual possessions during the enclosure movement as a critical shift that deliberately produced scarcity. The profound and divisive transformation deprived the peasants of their means of self-sustenance, forcing them to look for wage labor and leading to an excess of workers desperately searching for employment. Simultaneously, colonial appropriation provided vast frontiers for resource extraction, driven by the same logic of dispossession and exploitation that underpinned enclosure....

Want to learn the ideas in Less is More better than ever?

Unlock the full book summary of Less is More by signing up for Shortform.

Shortform summaries help you learn 10x better by:

  • Being 100% clear and logical: you learn complicated ideas, explained simply
  • Adding original insights and analysis, expanding on the book
  • Interactive exercises: apply the book's ideas to your own life with our educators' guidance.
READ FULL SUMMARY OF LESS IS MORE

Here's a preview of the rest of Shortform's Less is More summary:

Less is More Summary Investigating the connection between the growth of the economy, the health of the environment, and the wealth of society.

Hickel suggests that a growing economy does not necessarily lead to enhanced well-being for people, particularly in wealthy countries where basic needs are largely met.

Economic growth does not automatically result in enhanced human wellbeing, as aspects like longevity and literacy rates do not always advance in tandem with it.

Hickel challenges the "McKeown Thesis," highlighting that the substantial rise in life expectancy within the United Kingdom after the 1870s stemmed chiefly from advancements in public health initiatives, including enhanced sanitation, the proliferation of vaccinations, and the improvement of working conditions, rather than from economic growth. Jason Hickel posits that the distribution and use of resources, determined by political choices, have a greater impact on societal results than simply the presence of resources generated by economic growth.

Countries possessing considerable wealth have shown that strong societal results are achievable with markedly lower economic output per person than that of the United States, suggesting that much of the growth...

Try Shortform for free

Read full summary of Less is More

Sign up for free

Less is More Summary Exploring diverse economic approaches to develop into a society that flourishes sustainably without dependence on expansion.

Hickel argues that addressing the extensive environmental issues and the urgent climate crisis requires a shift from focusing on economic growth to adopting a novel economic paradigm that moves beyond the chase for growth and the confines of capitalism.

Degrowth advocates for a strategic reduction in material and energy use in wealthy societies, offering a legitimate pathway to rapidly improve people's well-being while reducing the impact on the environment.

Hickel advocates for a deliberate reduction in the unnecessary use of resources and energy to ensure our economic practices are in harmony with the Earth's natural ecosystems, thereby nurturing a feeling of stability, equity, and equal opportunities for everyone. He emphasizes the need to shift towards an economic framework that sustains equilibrium without the necessity for perpetual growth, instead of just concentrating on reducing GDP.

Degrowth strategies promote a shift towards a system that prioritizes use over ownership, in addition to other initiatives designed to cut down on waste and lessen the ecological footprint of manufacturing activities.

Hickel outlines specific approaches designed to support the...

What Our Readers Say

This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
Learn more about our summaries →

Less is More Summary Addressing global inequalities necessitates an emphasis on equitable distribution of environmental consequences and a thorough investigation into the limits of technological solutions for ecological issues.

Hickel argues that addressing the profound global disparities is crucial for successfully confronting the ecological crisis.

Wealthy nations have consumed a disproportionate amount of the planet's ecological resources, incurring an ecological debt to the countries of the global South.

Hickel highlights the significant imbalance in the consumption of resources, the environmental footprint, and historical emissions that exists between affluent nations and other regions of the world. Jason Hickel argues that the dramatic increase in the use of resources after 1945, largely driven by the increased consumption patterns of wealthy countries, is pushing us towards surpassing the limits of Earth's capacity. The practice of consuming resources at a rate that surpasses the planet's capacity for renewal, along with relying on low-cost labor and materials from developing countries, is akin to accumulating an "ecological debt" owed to poorer nations.

Tackling global warming requires a complete overhaul of the world's economic structure, guaranteeing equitable distribution of resources and widespread involvement in the decision-making...

Less is More

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The enclosure movement was a historical process in England where common lands were privatized by wealthy landowners, depriving peasants of their traditional access to resources. This forced many peasants off the land, creating a surplus of laborers who had to seek work in emerging industries for low wages. The deliberate scarcity of resources pushed people into wage labor, fueling the early stages of capitalism by providing a readily available and exploitable labor force. This process significantly transformed the social and economic landscape of England during the transition from feudalism to capitalism.
  • The Jevons Paradox is an economic theory that suggests as technological efficiency increases, leading to reduced resource consumption per unit of output, overall resource consumption may actually increase due to a corresponding increase in demand for the now cheaper resource. This paradox implies that improvements in efficiency can sometimes lead to more consumption, potentially offsetting the environmental benefits of efficiency gains. It highlights a complex relationship between technological progress,...

Counterarguments

  • Capitalism's adaptability and innovation can lead to sustainable practices that do not necessarily require perpetual growth.
  • Some argue that capitalism's competitive nature drives efficiency and technological advancements that can address environmental issues.
  • The enclosure movement and colonialism can be seen as complex historical processes with multiple causes, not solely as deliberate strategies for creating labor scarcity.
  • Critics of degrowth suggest that economic growth is necessary for improving living standards, particularly in developing countries.
  • It is argued that economic growth can be decoupled from environmental harm...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free