In Being Mortal, surgeon Atul Gawande looks at the experience of aging and dying in the 21st century. In his view, the modern approach to these stages of life undermines our ability to live well up to the end—to do better, we need to accept death as a natural part of the human experience and prioritize the well-being of the dying.
Critics widely praised Being Mortal and considered it one of the best books of the year when it was published in 2014. It’s since been [adapted into a TV...
Unlock the full book summary of Being Mortal by signing up for Shortform.
Shortform summaries help you learn 10x better by:
Here's a preview of the rest of Shortform's Being Mortal summary:
People today live longer and better than ever before thanks to modern medical technology and other advances, but Gawande argues that the process of aging and dying has become worse. In this section, we’ll look at four problems he identifies in our modern approach to the end of life: We rarely live with aging parents and grandparents, we rely on medical institutions, we don’t manage physical frailty well, and we don’t prepare for death.
One defining feature of the way we experience aging today concerns the typical household, contends Gawande: We no longer live in a multigenerational setting. Research shows that the percentage of elderly people living with their children dropped from 60% in the early 20th century to less than 15% in 1960.
Updated Statistics on Multigenerational Living in the US and Elsewhere
Gawande mainly addresses a US audience in Being Mortal, so these statistics may not be relevant for other regions. In this commentary section, we’ll address US statistics and briefly note multigenerational trends in other regions.
While it’s generally true in the US that fewer...
A third aspect of our modern experience of the end of life deals with our reliance on medical institutions for end-of-life care. In our era of advanced healthcare, we typically relegate the aging and dying to hospitals and nursing homes if they need regular care.
(Shortform note: Gawande doesn’t suggest that the majority of seniors live in long-term care facilities—just those who have difficulty living without help. Census data show that less than 3% of the American population lived in nursing homes as of 2020. This amounts to 1.4 million people out of a population of 54.1 million people aged 65 or older. The vast majority of these nursing home residents have chronic conditions that need ongoing care.)...
This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
One way we can improve our experience of aging and dying is by reorienting our end-of-life care toward present-oriented priorities.
Referring to the work of psychologist Laura Carstensen, Gawande observes that our priorities change depending on how much time we believe we have left to live. People close to death have a present-oriented outlook: They value close relationships, treasured memories, and simple pleasures. However, the people caring for them tend to have a future-oriented outlook. They value ambitious life goals, personal independence, meeting new people, and having new experiences—and they often assume their patients share their outlook.
(Shortform note: While Gawande portrays this present-oriented outlook as generally positive for the aged and terminally ill, it may also have some downsides. According to Carstensen, one downside is that it makes the elderly more susceptible to scams and being taken advantage of. She reasons that,...
According to Gawande, another way we can improve our experience of our mortality is by talking about aging and dying more openly. We tend to avoid these conversations, but that leaves us ill-prepared to deal with the challenges aging and dying present.
These challenges elicit powerful emotions we must acknowledge to reduce some of the fear and uncertainty that surrounds death. For instance, the dying often fear the process of decline—the pain, memory loss, or the suffering their loved ones endure. These fears are often mixed with powerful hopes, as well—hope for a cure, for comfort, for the ability to stay lucid.
(Shortform note: Gawande’s advice here is echoed by the American Cancer Society (ACS), which encourages those facing death to clearly identify what they’re feeling. Common emotions include fear, anger, guilt and regret, grief, anxiety and depression, and loneliness. In addition, the ACS notes that those facing death long to find meaning and purpose. They encourage the dying to reflect and share personal wisdom and insights with family and friends. They suggest such practices...
"I LOVE Shortform as these are the BEST summaries I’ve ever seen...and I’ve looked at lots of similar sites. The 1-page summary and then the longer, complete version are so useful. I read Shortform nearly every day."
Jerry McPheeA third way we can improve our approach to mortality has to do with autonomy. Gawande believes that helping the dying preserve their autonomy is one of the most important aspects of end-of-life care. He distinguishes between negative and positive autonomy.
Negative autonomy is the absence of constraints. This is the autonomy we look for when we simply want our body to be fully functional and healthy. To Gawande, this autonomy is no longer critical for the aging and terminally ill—on the contrary, as our bodies weaken, it’s vital to acknowledge our limitations and dependence.
(Shortform note: Studies show that those suffering from severe physical limitations—those who’ve lost their negative autonomy—feel happiest when they have strong social support and reduced pain. For these reasons, caregivers should provide the dying with comprehensive social support and pain management to help them cope with the loss of physical function.)
Positive autonomy, by contrast, is the freedom to direct your life. **According to Gawande, this freedom is crucial for those facing death, as it allows them to live according to...
According to Gawande, a final way we can improve our approach to dying is to be judicious in our end-of-life healthcare. This involves being decisive about what we want and resisting the urge to address every ailment the dying face.
Gawande insists we should decide exactly what we want for our last days. Do we want to undergo every possible life-saving treatment? Or are we willing to forego treatment so we can stay clearheaded and have more time with our loved ones? Should doctors try to resuscitate us? Or will we let our bodies naturally give out? We must consider these difficult questions if we hope to give ourselves and our loved ones peace and closure in our final moments.
(Shortform note: Gawande doesn’t specify when we should plan our end-of-life care, just that we should plan it. We have to be in a sound state of mind to plan it, so we should do it while we’re still capable of expressing our wishes and making complicated decisions. This planning typically involves several components, such as creating a living will ([also known as an advanced...
This is the best summary of How to Win Friends and Influence People I've ever read. The way you explained the ideas and connected them to other books was amazing.
End-of-life care involves making numerous decisions. As we’ve seen, there’s value in considering what you might want in your end-of-life care while you have time to make those decisions. In this exercise, you’ll have the opportunity to begin thinking about three particular aspects of end-of-life care: where you’d prefer to die, what life-prolonging measures you’ll accept, and how your body should be handled after death. These are sensitive topics, but considering them well in advance is an invaluable exercise.
In the space below, write your thoughts about where you’d prefer to spend your last days. Do you want to be at home? Would you rather be in a hospital? Somewhere else?