My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark • Exactly Right

Dive into the peculiar and spine-tingling memories from childhood on "My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark," where Karen and Georgia unearth stories that chilled the blood of youthful listeners around campfires and in shadowy backyards. This episode, without bearing its title, takes listeners through a nostalgic and hair-raising journey, uncovering the extremes that parents sometimes went to in order to keep children in check during outdoor escapades. From the legend of an uncanny, malevolent Girl Scout, to Greasy Pete and an itinerant eyeball, these tales stir a mix of amusement and a recognition of the power of stories in shaping childhood caution.

Beyond folklore, the podcast episode also shares bone-chilling personal anecdotes that resonate with the theme of danger lurking in the mundane. A listener recounts the terror of an attempted break-in experienced as a twelve-year-old, highlighting the significance of teaching children about the reality of stranger danger and the necessity of knowing how to respond. Meanwhile, a supposedly menacing shark encounter during a boogie boarding session offers a startling yet ultimately innocent twist, blending tension with the relief that occasionally follows false alarms. Join Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark as they explore the intersection where childhood fears meet adult awareness in these true tales that have trotted from past to present.

This episode delves into two high-profile cases of violence and theft that captured global attention. First, the tragic murder of US Army soldier Vanessa Guillen, who faced sexual harassment in the military, sparked a reform movement and new federal laws addressing the pervasive issue of assault in the armed forces.

Second, the hosts examine the notorious 1911 theft of Leonardo da Vinci's Mona Lisa from the Louvre. This infamous crime ironically catapulted the painting into worldwide fame, turning it into one of the most recognizable artworks today. Both cases, though vastly different, had far-reaching consequences that continue to reverberate today.

In this episode of My Favorite Murder, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark examine a chilling insurance fraud plot involving murder and mobsters fleeing across borders. They recount the story of low-level mobsters conspiring to fake a death for monetary gain, culminating in a bizarre chase onto America's Most Wanted and the International Most Wanted List.

The hosts also delve into the Glensheen Mansion murder, providing listeners a glimpse into this historic location's opulent design and a haunting crime scene detail. The episode concludes on a lighter note, sharing the unique tale of a Lyft driver and passenger bonding over a shared interest in true crime, forging an unexpected romantic connection.