#2374 - Ben van Kerkwyk
In this episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, Ben van Kerkwyk discusses recent archaeological discoveries in Egypt, including a massive underground labyrinth complex in Hawara that contains a mysterious 40-meter metallic object. The conversation examines ancient Egyptian artifacts that display precision manufacturing capabilities beyond what was previously thought possible for their era, including vases with micron-scale accuracy and evidence of advanced mathematical knowledge.
Van Kerkwyk and Rogan explore the possibility that these artifacts may have originated from an earlier, pre-dynastic civilization. They discuss archaeological findings that suggest advanced technological capabilities as far back as 14,000 BC, including the presence of modern materials like titanium in ancient objects. The episode also covers the challenges researchers face when investigating these discoveries, including institutional resistance and national security restrictions.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 3, 2025 episode of the The Joe Rogan Experience
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Advanced Ancient Egyptian Artifacts Discovery
Archaeologists have uncovered a massive underground complex in Hawara, Egypt, containing a labyrinth potentially more impressive than the Pyramids of Giza. Within its chambers lies a mysterious 40-meter metallic object that has sparked significant interest.
The Hawara Labyrinth
According to historical accounts from Herodotus, this underground marvel contains thousands of rooms across multiple levels, with massive courts and intricate architecture. Modern technology, including ground-penetrating radar and space-based scans, confirms the structure extends nearly a hundred meters underground. Tim Akers notes that the 40-meter metallic object found in the central atrium has a material composition unlike anything previously encountered, leading Ben van Kerkwyk to suggest this could be the millennium's most significant archaeological discovery.
Ancient Egyptian Technological Precision
Ben van Kerkwyk and Joe Rogan discuss the extraordinary craftsmanship found in ancient Egyptian artifacts. Analysis reveals micron-scale precision in vase manufacturing that cannot be replicated with known ancient tools. These precision vases contain elevated levels of thorium decay products and incorporate complex mathematical principles like pi and the golden ratio. The discussion extends to massive construction feats, including the movement of 1200-ton obelisks, which challenge our understanding of ancient Egyptian capabilities.
Evidence of Earlier Advanced Civilizations
Van Kerkwyk presents evidence suggesting these structures and artifacts may have been inherited from a pre-dynastic civilization. He references ancient Egyptian texts describing the Shemsu Hor, semi-divine beings who preceded dynastic Egypt by 12,000 years. Supporting this theory, precision-crafted vases dating back to 12-14,000 BC have been discovered, along with signs of advanced craftsmanship predating known Egyptian achievements.
Archaeological Controversies and Suppression
Louis de Courdier and van Kerkwyk reveal that investigations into these discoveries face significant obstacles. The Mattaher expedition, which confirmed the labyrinth's existence in 2008-2009, was halted by Egyptian national security concerns. Van Kerkwyk also discusses the discovery of titanium in ancient artifacts—a metal not used until the 1800s—noting that academic skepticism and institutional barriers have prevented further investigation of these findings.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The discovery of a massive underground complex is significant, but comparing it to the Pyramids of Giza without thorough study and peer-reviewed research may be premature.
- The existence of a labyrinth as described by Herodotus has been debated among historians, and without concrete evidence, it remains a subject of speculation.
- Advanced technology like ground-penetrating radar can confirm structures underground, but interpretations of these findings can vary and require validation through excavation and direct study.
- The 40-meter metallic object's composition should be analyzed and confirmed by multiple independent sources to avoid premature conclusions about its origins or significance.
- Micron-scale precision in ancient artifacts is impressive, but attributing it to unknown advanced technology without considering the skill and ingenuity of ancient craftsmen may underestimate their capabilities.
- Elevated levels of thorium decay products in vases could have alternative explanations, such as contamination or natural occurrences, which should be explored.
- The movement of large obelisks by ancient Egyptians is well-documented, and while challenging, current archaeological understanding provides plausible methods for how this could have been achieved without implying unknown advanced technology.
- Claims of a pre-dynastic civilization and semi-divine beings are speculative and should be approached with caution, requiring more substantial archaeological evidence.
- The dating of precision-crafted vases to 12-14,000 BC would be revolutionary if confirmed, but such claims require rigorous scientific verification and consensus within the archaeological community.
- National security concerns halting archaeological expeditions are not uncommon, but they do not necessarily imply suppression of groundbreaking discoveries; there could be other valid reasons for such actions.
- The presence of titanium in ancient artifacts is an extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary evidence, including thorough metallurgical analysis and contextual understanding.
- Academic skepticism is a natural and healthy part of the scientific process, ensuring that claims are thoroughly vetted before being accepted, and institutional barriers often exist to maintain rigorous standards of evidence.
Actionables
- You can explore ancient Egyptian history through virtual reality experiences that simulate the Hawara labyrinth, giving you a sense of the scale and complexity of the structure without needing archaeological expertise.
- Virtual reality (VR) technology has become increasingly accessible, and there are platforms where users can create or explore historical simulations. By using VR, you can virtually walk through reconstructions of ancient sites, which can be both educational and awe-inspiring. This immersive experience can provide a deeper appreciation for the craftsmanship and engineering skills of ancient civilizations.
- Start a creative writing project inspired by the mysterious findings, such as the 40-meter metallic object, to engage with the material in a personal and imaginative way.
- Writing fiction based on historical mysteries can be a fun and engaging way to connect with the past. You could craft a story that incorporates the enigmatic artifacts and structures mentioned, using them as a backdrop for adventure, intrigue, or even science fiction. This activity not only fosters creativity but also encourages you to research and learn more about the topics to create a believable narrative.
- Engage in a citizen science project that supports the decoding of ancient symbols or languages, contributing to the understanding of artifacts like the precision-crafted vases.
- Many online platforms allow volunteers to participate in projects that require human pattern recognition, which computers can't always replicate. By participating, you can help decode ancient texts or symbols, contributing to the broader understanding of historical artifacts. This can be done from your computer and doesn't require prior knowledge, as you'll be guided through the process by experts.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Advanced Ancient Egyptian Artifacts Discovery: Labyrinth and Metallic Object
Archaeologists and historians have revealed a massive underground complex in Hawara, Egypt, that holds remarkable secrets, including a structure that is possibly more grand than the Pyramids of Giza, and a mysterious metallic object located deep within its chambers.
Labyrinth: Massive Underground Complex With 40-meter Metallic Object Under Hawara, Egypt
A 40-meter long metallic object has been detected in the central atrium of a labyrinth located 60-70 meters underground under Hawara. This extensive and architecturally complex labyrinth, believed to be more impressive than the pyramids, includes multiple levels akin to a shopping mall, with a grand central chamber linking these levels.
Labyrinth Surpasses Pyramids in Grandeur, Boasting Thousands of Rooms and Massive Courts
According to historical accounts from Herodotus, the labyrinth far surpasses the pyramids in grandeur, with his descriptions mentioning 1,500 rooms on one level and a possibility of 3,000 rooms in total. There are also massive open courts within the structure. Diodorus Siculus adds that navigating such a vast maze could require a guide to prevent one from being lost for days. He describes a temple within the labyrinth, which features rooms and chambers that twist and turn, as well as giant open courts with columns and a roof made of a single stone, exquisitely crafted with carving and painting.
Modern Expeditions Confirm the Labyrinth's Structure Spans Hundreds of Meters Underground
Modern technologies have confirmed the labyrinth's breadth, with ground-penetrating radar scans revealing the structure on both sides of a canal at the site. Moreover, space-based scans have shown that the labyrinth extends nearly a hundred meters deep. GeoScan and Merlin Burrows methodologies have further confirmed the structure's vast reach underground. These methods also suggest that there may be a significant, water-free ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Advanced Ancient Egyptian Artifacts Discovery: Labyrinth and Metallic Object
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore local history by visiting nearby historical sites or museums to gain a deeper appreciation for the past, similar to the excitement of the Hawara discovery. By engaging with the history in your area, you can develop a personal connection to the broader human story, much like the labyrinth connects modern people to ancient Egypt. For example, you might find a local museum exhibit on indigenous cultures or a historic landmark that offers guided tours.
- Start a creative writing project inspired by the labyrinth's mystery, such as a short story or a piece of interactive fiction. Use the elements of the Hawara complex, like the grand chambers and the unclassified metallic object, as a springboard for your imagination. This could be a fun way to exercise creativity while paying homage to the sense of wonder that ancient civilizations inspire.
- Participate in a vi ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Technological Precision of Ancient Egyptian Stonework Challenging Understanding
Ben van Kerkwyk and Joe Rogan discuss how the extraordinary craftsmanship of ancient Egyptian stonework and the technological precision seen in their artifacts challenge the current understanding of their capabilities.
Egyptian Artifacts Display Extraordinary Craftsmanship
Analysis Shows Micron-Scale Precision in Ancient Egyptian Vase Manufacturing
Ancient Egyptian artifacts, such as vases, display exceptional craftsmanship, with analysis showing micron-scale precision in manufacturing. This level of precision in the artifacts is unreplicable with the known ancient tools, like copper, which was the oldest tool material found from Egypt's Old Kingdom (around 2600-2800 BC), as well as bronze alloys found from later periods.
Van Kerkwyk highlights the precision of these artifacts, referencing Max, who is doing fusion experiments, to suggest that extraordinary measures were taken in vase manufacturing. Additionally, the analysis of precision vases showed that they are radioactive, containing two to three times the thorium decay products compared to base rock samples and non-precision vases.
Furthermore, van Kerkwyk points out laser analysis, scientific, and measurement data from the VaseScan project that show that the vases were designed with mathematical and geometric principles in mind, including elements like pi, phi (the golden ratio), and the Fibonacci sequence.
Artifacts Display Machining Marks Unreplicable by Known Ancient Tools
Some artifacts, including a diorite vase described by Flinders Petrie that was as thin as one-fortieth of an inch, and a pre-dynastic diorite vase with a super thin neck, display machining marks that have no match with the production capacities of known ancient Egyptian tools. Especially evident are vertical lathe centering points on granite columns that suggest the involvement of a more complex technology in their creation.
Scale of Ancient Egyptian Structures Defy Conventional Explanation
Joe Rogan and van Kerkwyk discuss how the scale and technology of the ancient structures defy conventional explanations for the time period. They examine megalithic blocks weighing 450 tons and ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Technological Precision of Ancient Egyptian Stonework Challenging Understanding
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The precision of ancient artifacts may not necessarily challenge known capabilities, as there could be undiscovered or underestimated manual techniques and tools that were used.
- Radioactivity in vases could be due to the presence of naturally occurring radioactive materials in the clay or stone used, rather than anything unusual about the manufacturing process.
- Mathematical and geometric principles like pi, phi, and the Fibonacci sequence could have been approximated through empirical methods rather than precise calculations.
- Machining marks on artifacts could be the result of manual polishing and grinding techniques that have simply not been fully understood or replicated in modern experiments.
- The scale of ancient structures, while impressive, may not defy conventional explanations, as historical records and archaeological evidence suggest that large labor forces and clever engineering were employed.
- The movement of megalithic blocks and obelisks could have been achieved using sledges, rollers, and lubricated tracks, as depicted in ...
Actionables
- Explore precision in everyday objects by measuring and comparing items around your home with a digital caliper. This can give you a hands-on understanding of precision and tolerances. For example, measure the thickness of various plates or the diameter of a coin and note the variations, if any. This activity can help you appreciate the level of precision in ancient artifacts by providing a modern context.
- Create a small-scale model of an obelisk or pyramid using common materials like clay, wood, or foam. Focus on replicating the geometric principles you've learned about. This can be a fun way to grasp the complexity of ancient construction techniques and the challenges they might have presented. You could even try to incorporate weight distribution principles by creating a balanced structure on a smaller scale.
- Engage in a thought experiment where you brainstorm alternative methods for moving heavy objects without modern ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Theories of Advanced Civilizations Predating Dynastic Egypt
Recent discussions explore the possibility that structures and artifacts from ancient Egypt may have been inherited from a civilization that existed long before the dynastic period. Ben van Kerkwyk suggests technological advancements and precise engineering seen in Egyptian relics are not fully accounted for by our understanding of that era.
Egyptians Reused Structures From Older Advanced Civilization
Ancient Egyptian Texts Describe Semi-Divine Beings and a Pre-dynastic 12,000-Year History
Ben van Kerkwyk references ancient Egyptian texts that hint at a lengthy pre-dynastic history. They tell of semi-divine beings—Shemsu Hor, followers of Horus—who walked the earth for 12,000 years prior to dynastic Egypt, pointing to the possibility of an advanced prehistoric civilization.
Van Kerkwyk notes that Egyptian kings styled themselves after gods, reusing and emulating structures and symbols from this bygone era. Ancient texts, carbon dating discrepancies, and historical accounts, such as Pliny the Elder's writings, suggest that dynastic Egypt may have been predicated on a much more ancient and technically sophisticated civilization. This suggestion is supported by evidence of precise vases that date back as far as 12 to 14,000 BC, found in burials from periods preceding known dynastic culture.
Analysis of Egyptian Structures Challenges Conventional Timeline
Throughout Egypt, there are signs of technologically advanced craftsmanship predating dynastic achievements. For instance, column bases at Karnak and unfinished columns contrast with lower-tech crafting, suggesting the repurposing of structures from an older advanced civilization.
Van Kerkwyk mentions the extraction of massive stones and utilization of advanced artifacts—like the tubular drill marks and saw cuts on hard stone—which suggest techniques beyond ancient Egyptian capabilities, possibly hinting at previously unknown knowledge or inherited technology.
Advanced Artifacts and Techniques Suggest Lost Civilization
The conversation delves into the idea of an advanced lost civilization, as evidenced by artifacts such as the Serapeum's hundred-ton stone boxes and thousand-ton statues. The logistics behind moving such vast objects and the engineering precision seen in structures like the valley temples reference the potential existence of a civilization during the African Humid period with capabilities far exceeding those known from later periods.
C ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Theories of Advanced Civilizations Predating Dynastic Egypt
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The interpretation of ancient texts is highly subjective, and references to semi-divine beings and pre-dynastic histories can be symbolic or mythological rather than historical accounts.
- The reuse of structures and symbols by Egyptian kings could be indicative of cultural continuity and reverence for ancestral traditions rather than evidence of a lost advanced civilization.
- Carbon dating and other scientific dating methods have limitations and uncertainties, especially when applied to artifacts and structures that have been exposed to various environmental and human factors over millennia.
- Technological advancements in ancient Egypt may have been incremental and not necessarily indicative of a lost advanced civilization; ancient peoples were capable of remarkable feats with the technology available to them.
- The existence of massive stone structures and artifacts can be explained through known ancient techniques of quarrying, transporting, and construction, which do not require the assumption of a lost advanced civilization.
- The idea of cataclysmic events erasing evidence of ancient civilizations is speculative and not widely supported by geological and archaeological evidence.
- The presence of undiscovered structures in the Sahara is a hypothesis that requires further ...
Actionables
- You can explore ancient Egyptian history through creative writing by crafting short stories or narratives that imagine the lives of people during the pre-dynastic era. This activity encourages you to research and incorporate historical elements, fostering a deeper connection with the subject matter and enhancing your understanding of ancient cultures.
- Start a hobby of model-making to recreate ancient Egyptian artifacts and structures using accessible materials like clay, wood, or 3D printing pens. This hands-on approach allows you to appreciate the craftsmanship and complexity of ancient techniques while also providing a tangible connection to historical speculations.
- Engage in a thought experiment where you envision modern society experienc ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Archaeological Findings: Controversies and Cover-Ups
Louis de Courdier and Ben van Kerkwyk highlight the difficulties and potential suppression efforts faced by expeditions investigating ancient Egyptian structures and artifacts, including those involved in the Mattaher expedition.
Suppression and Obstruction of Expeditions to Study Ancient Egyptian Structures and Artifacts
Louis de Courdier indicates that in Egypt, the control of information is strict, whether it pertains to academic institutions or individuals conducting expeditions. The release of information is regulated by Egyptian authorities, inhibiting the flow of knowledge about discoveries.
Mattaher Expedition Proves Labyrinth Exists; National Security Halts Discussion
De Courdier and Ben van Kerkwyk shed light on the Mattaher expedition's findings, which substantiated the existence of the labyrinth at Hawara. The expedition finished its on-site work in 2008 and 2009 and was ready to disseminate data, but after a small public lecture at Ghent University, team members were warned with national security sanctions by Egypt, halting further discussion of their findings. Van Kerkwyk suggests that concerns over national security and political decisions, rather than individual fault, are to blame for the suppression of these findings.
Evidence of Advanced Technology, Including Titanium Use, In Ancient Egyptian Artifacts Faces Academic Skepticism
Ben van Kerkwyk discusses the unexplained presence of titanium, a metal not used until the late 1800s, in ancient artifacts. He reveals that a Scanning Electron Microscope analysis detected titanium in the grooves of an ancient tool, suggesting the use of advanced technology in ancient Egypt. Howe ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Archaeological Findings: Controversies and Cover-Ups
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The strict control of information by Egyptian authorities could be in place to protect national heritage and prevent the spread of misinformation.
- The existence of the labyrinth at Hawara, as confirmed by the Mattaher expedition, may require further verification by other independent researchers to be considered a consensus in the archaeological community.
- National security concerns may be valid if the findings have the potential to cause unrest or if the sites are vulnerable to looting or vandalism.
- The detection of titanium in ancient artifacts could be the result of contamination from modern tools or environments rather than evidence of advanced ancient technology.
- Academic skepticism is a natural part of the scientific process, ensuring that only well-substantiated findings ar ...
Actionables
- You can explore the history of technology by visiting local museums with Egyptian collections and asking curators about the materials used in artifacts. This can give you a firsthand look at the technology and materials of ancient civilizations and prompt discussions that may not be commonly addressed in mainstream narratives.
- Start a casual book club focused on alternative historical theories, where members read and discuss works that challenge traditional academic perspectives. This can help you and your group gain a broader understanding of different viewpoints and the challenges faced by researchers in these fields.
- Engag ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
