Podcasts > The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett > Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

By Steven Bartlett

In this episode of The Diary Of A CEO, Steven Bartlett examines the recent surge in ADHD diagnoses and prescriptions across the UK and US. The discussion delves into the neurological basis of stress responses in children, explaining how the brain's key components—the amygdala and hippocampus—develop during early childhood and how their development affects stress regulation throughout life.

The episode explores how early life experiences and family environment influence a child's stress response system, with data showing that children who experience adverse childhood events are more likely to develop ADHD. The conversation also addresses concerns about the current treatment landscape, including the widespread use of medication, and presents alternative approaches that focus on addressing underlying stressors rather than just managing symptoms.

Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 27, 2025 episode of the The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

1-Page Summary

The Alarming Rise in ADHD Diagnosis and Prescriptions

Recent statistics reveal a dramatic increase in ADHD diagnoses and medication prescriptions across both the UK and US. In the UK, ADHD diagnoses among boys aged 10-16 have more than tripled to 3.5%, while prescriptions for men aged 18-29 have increased 50-fold. The US shows similar trends, with 15.5 million adults diagnosed with ADHD and 10.5% of children holding a current diagnosis.

Stress Response in Children: Neurological and Physiological Basis

The brain's stress response system involves two key components: the amygdala and hippocampus. Research shows that the amygdala, which regulates stress responses, remains offline during the first 1-3 years of life. However, early-life stressors can prematurely activate it, leading to a hypervigilant stress response. In children with ADHD, an underdeveloped hippocampus (the brain's "off switch" for stress) can result in an overactive amygdala, making stress regulation more challenging.

Impact of Early Experiences and Family Environment

Research indicates that nurturing parenting during the first three years can significantly impact stress regulation, even neutralizing genetic stress sensitivity. Various psychosocial stressors affect child development, including divorce, parental mental illness, and sibling rivalry. Studies show children with high adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are nearly four times more likely to have ADHD. Even seemingly minor events like moving homes or a sibling's birth can significantly impact a child's stress levels.

Limitations of ADHD Treatment and Need For a Holistic Approach

Erica Komisar critiques the widespread reliance on medication as a quick fix for ADHD symptoms, warning that stimulant medications can cause severe side effects, including growth issues in adolescents. She advocates for a more comprehensive approach that addresses underlying stressors rather than merely treating symptoms. Komisar emphasizes the importance of parental guidance, emotional regulation, and understanding the root causes of stress in effective ADHD management. She suggests that maintaining structure with empathy and helping children feel heard and understood is crucial for their psychological development.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The increase in ADHD diagnoses and prescriptions could be due to better awareness and recognition of the condition rather than an actual rise in prevalence.
  • Some argue that the rise in ADHD diagnoses may be influenced by pharmaceutical companies' marketing strategies.
  • The relationship between stress response systems (amygdala and hippocampus) and ADHD is complex, and not all children with ADHD have identifiable issues with these brain structures.
  • There is debate over whether nurturing parenting can neutralize genetic predispositions to stress sensitivity, as genetic factors can be very strong determinants of neurological development.
  • The link between adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) and ADHD could be correlational rather than causal, and other factors may contribute to the development of ADHD.
  • Medication for ADHD, when properly prescribed and monitored, can be a safe and effective treatment for many individuals, and the side effects are not severe for everyone.
  • The holistic approach to ADHD management, while beneficial, may not be sufficient for all individuals, and some may require medication to manage their symptoms effectively.
  • The idea that ADHD can be effectively managed solely through parenting techniques and environmental adjustments may not acknowledge the biological and neurological components of the disorder that can require medical intervention.
  • The suggestion that seemingly minor events like moving homes or the birth of a sibling can significantly impact a child's stress levels and contribute to ADHD may overstate the impact of these events and not take into account the resilience of many children.

Actionables

  • Create a stress-free bedtime routine for your child that includes calming activities like reading or listening to soft music, which can help in regulating their stress response system and potentially mitigate ADHD symptoms.
  • By establishing a consistent, soothing bedtime routine, you're providing a structured environment that can help your child's brain relax and recover from daily stressors. For example, you might introduce a "wind-down" hour before bed where screens are off, and the focus is on quiet play or storytelling.
  • Develop a "feelings journal" with your child to encourage emotional expression and self-awareness, which can be a non-medical approach to managing ADHD-related stress.
  • Encouraging your child to express their emotions through writing or drawing in a journal can help them process their feelings and improve their emotional regulation. You can make this a shared activity where you both sit down for a few minutes each day to draw or write about your day, which also strengthens your bond and empathy.
  • Organize regular family meetings to discuss and plan for potential stressors, like an upcoming move or a new sibling, to help your child feel prepared and less anxious.
  • In these meetings, give your child a voice to express their concerns and participate in finding solutions. For example, if a new sibling is on the way, involve your child in preparing the nursery or picking out baby items, which can help them feel included and reduce feelings of rivalry or stress.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

The Alarming Rise in ADHD Diagnosis and Prescriptions

Recent statistics show a stark increase in ADHD diagnosis and prescriptions for medication, raising questions about the trends in how we diagnose and treat this condition.

ADHD Diagnoses and Medication Surge Over two Decades

Between 2000 and 2018, there has been a significant rise in the number of ADHD diagnoses, drawing attention to the potential overdiagnosis or increasing recognition of the disorder.

UK ADHD Diagnoses For Boys, 10-16, Rose From 1% to 3.5%; Prescriptions For Men, 18-29, Increased 50-fold

In the UK, ADHD diagnoses among boys aged 10 to 16 have more than tripled, jumping from roughly 1% to about 3.5% by 2018. This dramatic rise is accompanied by an even more startling increase in prescriptions for ADHD medication among men aged 18 to 29, which saw a nearly 50-fold surge during the same time frame. These figures highlight a growing concern regarding the way ADHD is addressed in male populations.

15.5 Million US Adults and 10.5% of Children Have ADHD

Turning to the US ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Alarming Rise in ADHD Diagnosis and Prescriptions

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The increase in ADHD diagnoses could reflect improvements in awareness and understanding of the disorder, leading to more people being correctly identified and receiving help.
  • The rise in prescriptions might indicate better access to treatment and a reduction in the stigma associated with mental health disorders, allowing more individuals to seek medication.
  • Changes in diagnostic criteria over the years, such as those from the DSM-IV to DSM-5, could account for some of the increase in ADHD diagnoses.
  • The increase in ADHD diagnoses among adults could be due to the growing recognition that ADHD is not just a childhood disorder and can persist into adulthood.
  • The surge in diagnoses and prescriptions could be partially due to better healthcare coverage and access, which allows more individuals to be evaluated and treated for ADHD.
  • Some argue that the rise in ADHD diagnoses may be due to societal factors, such as the increased demands on attention in the digital age, rather than overdiagnosis.
  • The increase in ADHD medication use could reflect a shift in treatment preferences or more ef ...

Actionables

  • You can start a personal journal to track attention and behavior patterns, which might help identify ADHD-like symptoms in yourself or loved ones. By noting down daily activities, levels of focus, and any challenges faced, you create a personal record that can be useful if you ever seek a professional evaluation. For example, if you notice consistent difficulties in completing tasks or staying organized, these could be indicators worth discussing with a healthcare provider.
  • Create a simple "medication awareness" spreadsheet for your community to share experiences with ADHD medications, without revealing personal details. This could be a shared document where people anonymously enter the type of medication, duration of use, and perceived effectiveness or side effects. It's a way to informally gather data and observe trends within your own community, which might reflect the broader trends mentioned about the rise in prescriptions.
  • Voluntee ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

Stress Response in Children: Neurological and Physiological Basis

Understanding the stress response in children involves exploring the neurological and physiological underpinnings that control and mediate their reactions to stressful situations.

Amygdala's Role and Fight-Or-flight in Childhood Stress

The amygdala, a primitive brain part responsible for regulating stress responses, is pivotal in how children respond to stress. Research suggests that for the first 1-3 years of life, the amygdala isn't fully online, which has significant implications for a child's early development.

Amygdala, Primitive Brain Part, Regulates Stress, Offline for First 1-3 Years of Life

During the early years, when the amygdala is not yet fully functioning, children are less capable of responding to stress in the hyperaroused 'fight-or-flight' manner typically seen in older children and adults. This developmental window is essential for forming secure attachments and basic trust that can buffer against future stress.

Early-Life Stressors Prematurely Activate Amygdala, Causing Hypervigilant Stress Response

However, when children experience stressors early in life, it can prematurely activate the amygdala. This early activation may lead to a hypervigilant stress response mechanism. A child with a prematurely activated amygdala may be more likely to perceive situations as threatening, which can lead to persistent feelings of anxiety and stress long-term, affecting behavior and health.

Importance of the Hippocampus in Stress Regulation

The hippocampus, another vital part of the brain, plays a crucial role in the regulation of stress. It's often referred to as the brain's "off switch" for stress because it provides negative feedback to the stress response initiated by the amygdala.

Hippocampus "Off Switch" Underdeveloped in ADHD, Causes Ov ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Stress Response in Children: Neurological and Physiological Basis

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The role of the amygdala in stress responses is complex, and while it is a key player, it is not the only factor; other brain regions and systems, including the prefrontal cortex and the autonomic nervous system, also play significant roles in stress regulation.
  • The degree to which the amygdala is "offline" in the first 1-3 years of life is a matter of ongoing research, and some studies suggest that the amygdala can be active and responsive to certain stimuli even in infancy.
  • The concept of the amygdala being responsible for a "hypervigilant stress response" is an oversimplification, as stress responses are the result of multiple neural pathways and are influenced by a variety of factors, including genetics, environment, and individual experiences.
  • The assertion that early-life stressors always lead to negative outcomes may not account for the variability in individual resilience and the potential for positive adaptation or post-traumatic growth.
  • The relationship between hippocampal development and ADHD is not fully understood, and while there may be correlations, causation has not been definitively established.
  • The idea that the hippocampus acts as an "off switch" for stress is a simplification; stress regulation is a dynamic process involving multiple feedback loops and regulatory mechanisms.
  • The link between ADHD and heightened stress rea ...

Actionables

  • You can create a calming corner in your home to help children self-regulate stress. Set up a small, quiet space with comfortable pillows, stress-relief toys, and books that teach about emotions. This encourages children to take breaks and practice self-soothing, which can support the development of a healthy stress response.
  • Introduce mindfulness activities to your family routine to strengthen the hippocampus. Engage in simple breathing exercises or guided meditations designed for children, which can be found in various apps or online resources. Regular practice can help in regulating stress responses and promoting calmness, especially in children with ADHD.
  • Foster secure attachments by establishing consis ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

Impact of Early Experiences and Family/Environment on Child's Stress Regulation

Understanding how early experiences and family or environmental factors impact a child's ability to regulate stress is critical to fostering healthy development.

Nurturing Parenting's Role In First 3 Years

Research highlights the powerful role of attentive and nurturing parenting in the formative years of a child's life.

Caregiving and Attachment Can Neutralize Genetic Stress Sensitivity

Attentive caregiving and secure attachment can be of immense significance for children born with the sensitivity gene—a short allele on the serotonin receptor—which makes them more sensitive to stress. Although children with this gene are more prone to mental illness due to their increased stress sensitivity, nurturing parenting in the first year can neutralize the expression of this gene. It's revealed that when such children receive emotionally and physically present attachment security, it mitigates the potential negative outcomes, making them just as healthy as those without the gene.

Moreover, the role of epigenetics is crucial as it shows the environment's influence on gene expression. Empathic parenting can supersede genetic dispositions, as research indicates that nurture in early childhood can alter the expression of the gene in sensitive children. Recognizing and reflecting a child's feelings, showing empathy before discipline, and ensuring they feel acknowledged and valued are crucial components of this nurturing approach.

Psychosocial Stressors Impacting Child Development

A host of psychosocial factors can influence the development of a child and their ability to manage stress.

Child Stressors: Divorce, Parental Mental Illness, Sibling Rivalry, Caregiver-Child Disruptions

Erica Komisar points to various stressors in a child's environment that can trigger a state of fight or flight, indicating an underlying stress condition. Children are particularly susceptible to stresses at home, such as parental divorce, which exacerbates stress even in cases where parents handle the separation deftly.

Sibling rivalry, parental mental illness, or addictions also contribute significantly to stress. For children with an ACE score of four or mo ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Impact of Early Experiences and Family/Environment on Child's Stress Regulation

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The "short allele on the serotonin receptor gene" refers to a specific variant of the gene that affects serotonin transport in the brain. This variant is linked to increased sensitivity to stress and a higher risk of developing mood disorders. It influences how the brain regulates emotions and responds to environmental stressors. Understanding this gene helps explain why some children are more vulnerable to stress but can benefit greatly from supportive caregiving.
  • Epigenetics refers to chemical changes that affect how genes are turned on or off without altering the DNA sequence itself. These changes can be influenced by environmental factors like stress, diet, or parenting. Epigenetic modifications can activate or silence genes, impacting how traits develop and how the body responds to stress. This means experiences, especially early in life, can shape gene activity and influence long-term health outcomes.
  • The ACE score stands for Adverse Childhood Experiences score, which measures the number of stressful or traumatic events a child has experienced. It is calculated by counting different types of adverse experiences such as abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction before age 18. Each type of experience counts as one point, and the total score reflects the cumulative impact on the child's health and development. Higher ACE scores are linked to greater risks of physical and mental health problems later in life.
  • Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are traumatic events occurring before age 18 that disrupt a child's sense of safety and well-being. These experiences can alter brain development and stress response systems, increasing vulnerability to behavioral and attention problems. ADHD symptoms may emerge or worsen due to the heightened stress and emotional dysregulation caused by ACEs. Thus, ACEs contribute to a higher risk of ADHD by impacting neurological and psychological functioning.
  • The "fight or flight" response is an automatic physiological reaction to perceived danger or stress. It triggers the release of stress hormones like adrenaline, preparing the body to either confront or escape the threat. This response increases heart rate, blood flow to muscles, and alertness, but prolonged activation can harm a child's emotional and physical health. In children, frequent activation due to stress can impair their ability to regulate emotions and develop resilience.
  • Nurturing parenting influences gene expression through epigenetic changes, which modify how genes are turned on or off without altering the DNA sequence. This can reduce the activity of stress-related genes, lowering a child's physiological stress response. Positive caregiving also strengthens brain circuits involved in emotion regulation, improving resilience. Together, these biological and neural changes help neutralize genetic sensitivity to stress.
  • Attachment security refers to the strong emotional bond a child forms with a caregiver, providing a sense of safety and trust. This secure bond helps children explore their environment confidently and manage stress effectively. It develops through consistent, responsive caregiving that meets the child's needs. Secure attachment supports healthy emotional and social development throughout life.
  • The percentages reflect increased odds of parent-repor ...

Counterarguments

  • The role of genetics in stress sensitivity and mental health is complex, and while nurturing parenting can have a positive impact, it may not fully neutralize genetic predispositions in all cases.
  • The emphasis on the first three years may overshadow the importance of continued support and nurturing throughout childhood and adolescence.
  • The text implies a deterministic view of gene expression, whereas in reality, gene-environment interactions are bidirectional and dynamic throughout a person's life.
  • The impact of psychosocial stressors on child development can vary widely among individuals, and some children demonstrate remarkable resilience in the face of adversity.
  • The statistics provided on the likelihood of ADHD in relation to ACEs may not account for all variables, and correlation does not necessarily imply causation.
  • The text may underemphasize the role of broader social and community factors in a child's ability to regulate stress, focusing primarily on the ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Most Replayed Moment: Is Modern Parenting Causing ADHD? Your Decisions Shape Your Child’s Mind!

Limitations of Adhd Treatment and Need For a Holistic Approach

In a critical look at how ADHD is currently treated, Erica Komisar argues for a shift towards a more holistic approach that addresses underlying stressors rather than merely silencing symptoms with medication.

Quick Fix Overreliance on Medication For Adhd Symptoms

Komisar critiques the common practice of quickly resorting to medication as a solution for children with ADHD symptoms. She considers this approach as a form of malpractice, as it may silence the child's pain without addressing the root of their stress. She warns that stimulant medications can cause severe side effects, including panic attacks, anxiety disorders, depression, and growth issues in adolescents. Komisar shares her own clinical experiences where young male patients did not grow physically due to being put on stimulants at a young age, implying that medication can lead to more harm than good.

Addressing Underlying Causes of Child Stress and Dysregulation

Komisar emphasizes the importance of understanding and addressing the deep-rooted issues that may cause a child to experience stress. She suggests that effective ADHD management involves parental guidance and a close look at the child's life dynamics and psychosocial stressors. Komisar implies that individuals with ADHD may have brains that are more sensitive to stress rather than fundamentally different.

Komisar discusses the possibility that the heightened sensitivity to stimuli commonly seen in ADHD could be an indicator of underlying stress sensitivities contributing to the condition. She describes ADHD as a "bucket" that often includes individuals with untreated anxiety and argues that society’s reliance on drugs as a quick fix is superficial.

Pointing out that stress can be regulated if parents introspectively consider their part in contributing to their child's stress, Komisar advocates for not yelling at children and being an emotionally regulated parent. She notes that early presence, especially during the first three years of life, is essential in achieving the emoti ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Limitations of Adhd Treatment and Need For a Holistic Approach

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The term "bucket" diagnosis means ADHD can include a variety of different underlying issues, not just one clear cause. Untreated anxiety can mimic or worsen ADHD symptoms, making it hard to distinguish between the two. This overlap means some people diagnosed with ADHD might actually have anxiety or both conditions together. Proper diagnosis requires careful evaluation to identify all contributing factors.
  • Stimulant medications for ADHD increase brain chemicals like dopamine and norepinephrine to improve focus. However, they can overstimulate the nervous system, leading to panic attacks and heightened anxiety. Long-term use may affect mood regulation, potentially causing depression in some individuals. Growth issues can occur because stimulants may suppress appetite, reducing nutrition essential for normal physical development.
  • ADHD brains may have heightened reactivity to stress hormones, making them more sensitive to environmental pressures. This sensitivity can amplify difficulties with attention and impulse control. Rather than being a fixed neurological difference, ADHD symptoms might partly reflect how stress affects brain function. Understanding this can shift treatment focus toward managing stress, not just symptoms.
  • The first three years of life are critical for brain development, especially in areas that control emotions and stress responses. During this period, consistent, nurturing care helps children learn to manage their feelings and develop secure attachments. Early emotional experiences shape neural pathways that influence lifelong emotional regulation. Disruptions or lack of emotional support in these years can lead to difficulties in managing stress and emotions later.
  • The "fight or flight state" is a natural, automatic response to perceived danger, triggering stress hormones that prepare the body to either confront or escape a threat. In ADHD, this state can be overactive or easily triggered, leading to heightened stress and difficulty regulating emotions and attention. Chronic activation of this response may worsen ADHD symptoms by increasing anxiety and impulsivity. Understanding and calming this state helps manage underlying stress contributing to ADHD behaviors.
  • Parental emotional regulation refers to a parent's ability to manage their own emotions calmly and effectively, especially during stressful interactions with their child. When parents stay emotionally regulated, they model healthy coping skills and create a safe environment that reduces the child's stress response. This stability helps the child feel secure, which supports better brain development and emotional control. Conversely, parents who frequently express anger or frustration can increase a child's anxiety and worsen behavioral symptoms.
  • Komisar's critique means that psychiatry often focuses on reducing visible symptoms, like hyperactivity, through medication rather than exploring why the child is distressed. This approach can ignore emotional or environmental factors causing the child's behavior. By "silencing distress," she suggests medication may mask problems without healing underlying trauma or stress. This can lea ...

Counterarguments

  • Medication can be a necessary and effective component of ADHD treatment for many individuals, providing symptom relief that allows them to function better in daily life.
  • The side effects of stimulant medications are not universally experienced and can often be managed with proper medical supervision and dosage adjustments.
  • While addressing underlying stressors is important, it is not always clear what these stressors are, and they may not be the primary cause of ADHD symptoms in all cases.
  • ADHD has a strong genetic component, suggesting that while stress may exacerbate symptoms, it is not the sole cause of the disorder.
  • Behavioral interventions and parental strategies are important, but they may not be sufficient on their own for all children with ADHD, especially those with severe symptoms.
  • The concept of ADHD as a "bucket" diagnosis may oversimplify the complexity of the disorder and the variety of symptoms and co-occurring conditions that can be present.
  • Early parental presence is important, but it is not the only factor in a child's emotional development, and not all parents have the luxury of being present, especially in single-parent or low-income families.
  • Psychiatry and psychology professionals follow evidence-based practices, and while medication is used, it is often part of a broader treatment plan that includes therapy and behavioral interventions.
  • Unpacking traumas and losses is important in therapy, but not all individuals with ADHD have identifiable traumas or losses that contribute ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA