In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts examine MacGuffins, the plot devices that drive stories forward while having limited significance to the actual plot. They explore how MacGuffins serve to motivate characters but often become less important as stories progress, using examples from classic films like "Psycho" and "Pulp Fiction" to illustrate the concept.
The hosts also delve into differing perspectives on how MacGuffins should function in storytelling, highlighting a key debate between filmmakers Alfred Hitchcock and George Lucas. While Hitchcock believed MacGuffins should matter only to the characters, Lucas argued that audiences should care about them too, demonstrating how this storytelling tool can be interpreted and applied in different ways.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant explore the concept of a MacGuffin, a plot device that drives narrative forward while having limited significance to the actual plot. While MacGuffins motivate characters to action, their importance lies not in the object or goal itself, but in how characters interact with it.
The hosts discuss several classic examples of MacGuffins in film. In "Psycho," the $40,000 stolen by Janet Leigh's character serves as a MacGuffin that gets her to the Bates Motel but is quickly forgotten. The mysterious briefcase in "Pulp Fiction" demonstrates another classic MacGuffin - its contents are never revealed, and its significance fades as the story progresses. Similarly, in "Escape from New York," a cassette tape containing the President's speech drives the main character's mission but proves ultimately inconsequential to the plot.
The hosts highlight a fundamental disagreement between filmmakers about how MacGuffins should function. Alfred Hitchcock, who coined the term, believed MacGuffins should be important to the characters but insignificant to the audience and narrator. In contrast, George Lucas, using R2-D2 as an example in "Star Wars," argued that audiences should care about MacGuffins as much as the characters do. This debate exemplifies how filmmakers have different approaches to using MacGuffins in their storytelling, leading to varied interpretations of what constitutes a true MacGuffin in film.
1-Page Summary
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant explore the concept of a Macguffin, a plot device that moves the narrative forward in a story or movie. However, there is ambiguity around its precise definition and role within the plot.
A Macguffin is an element that motivates the characters but ultimately has limited significance in the plot's outcome. Clark and Bryant agree that while a MacGuffin propels characters to action, the item or goal itself is not as important as the actions taken to acquire or engage with it.
There is a noted ambiguity in defining and understanding what constitutes a MacGuffin. Filmmakers and screenwriters have varied perspectives on whether the audience should care about a MacGuffin. Alfred Hitchcock described it as something vitally important to the characters, but insignificant to the narrative itself. In contrast, George Lucas believed the audience should also be invested in the MacGuffin.
Chuck Bryant likens MacGuffins to a device for hunting tigers in Scotland; it's meant to seem relevant within the confines of the story but is ultimately inconsequential, signifying its intended lack of real-world value.
The hosts discuss that often a MacGuffin is introduced early in the story, setting up the central conflict or myste ...
The Concept and Definition of a Macguffin
A MacGuffin is an object, device, or event that is necessary to the characters in a story, but insignificant, unimportant, or irrelevant in itself to the audience. Here are some classic examples of MacGuffins in films.
In Alfred Hitchcock's thriller "Psycho," the $40,000 stolen by Janet Leigh's character serves as a MacGuffin.
Chuck Bryant pointed out that the stolen $40,000 is the reason Leigh's character flees and ultimately ends up at the Bates Motel. Although it motivates her character at the start, the money quickly becomes unimportant to the plot and isn't mentioned again as the story shifts focus to the infamous motel and its unsettling proprietor.
Similarly, in John Carpenter's "Escape from New York," a cassette tape with a recording of the President's speech acts as a MacGuffin.
The tape's significance lies in its role as a plot device which drives the main character's mission in the dystopian world. However, the specifics of the recorded speech and the tape's contents are ultimately inconsequential t ...
Examples of Macguffins in Classic Films
The concept of the MacGuffin, coined by Hitchcock, has become a staple in film narrative but is interpreted differently among filmmakers.
Hitchcock famously used MacGuffins as elements that the film's characters are deeply concerned with, but which have no real importance to the story or the viewer. The MacGuffin serves as a narrative device that propels the characters' actions and motivates the plot, yet often remains unimportant to the audience's experience of the film.
George Lucas, on the other hand, diverged from Hitchcock's view. Although he considered R2-D2 a MacGuffin in "Star Wars," he believed the audience should actually care about the MacGuffin. Josh Clark highlighted R2-D2’s role in "Star Wars Episode IV" where the droid is pursued for carrying the Death Star plans, making him a target. Lucas argued that the audience's emotional investment in the MacGuffin is crucial; if the viewers did not care about R2-D2 as much as the characters do, the film would lose some of its emotional impact.
The debate between Clark and Bryant over whether the Ark of the Covenant qualifies as a MacGuffin in "Indiana Jones" showcases the ambiguity and diversity in its use. The Ark, which drives the plot yet ends up being stored away inconsequentially, provides an example of how t ...
Disagreements in Filmmakers' Use of Macguffins
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
