Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore the widespread occurrence of flood myths across different cultures worldwide. They examine notable examples, including the biblical story of Noah's flood and the Epic of Gilgamesh, discussing how these narratives share common themes of survival, divine intervention, and civilization's renewal despite originating from different regions and time periods.

The hosts delve into various theories that might explain these parallel flood stories, from the spread of Proto-Indo-European cultures to the influence of Christian missionaries. They also examine how geomythologists connect these ancient narratives to actual geological events, such as the Mediterranean's breach of the Bosporus Strait and the formation of the Persian Gulf, showing how myths often preserve memories of historical events.

Listen to the original

Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 7, 2026 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

1-Page Summary

Noah's Flood and Other Ancient Flood Myths Parallels

The story of Noah's flood isn't unique - it shares remarkable similarities with flood narratives from cultures worldwide. The Epic of Gilgamesh, discovered by Assyriologist George Smith, contains a flood story that predates the Old Testament by several hundred years. In this version, the god Enlil instructs Utnapishtim to build a boat because humans were too noisy, rather than too wicked as in the biblical account.

A study identified flood myths in 50 different cultures, from Chinese mythology to Aboriginal Australian traditions. These stories often share themes of survival, divine intervention, and civilization's renewal after catastrophic floods.

Theories Explaining Flood Myths in Different Cultures

Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark explore several theories behind these widespread flood narratives. The "localized flood" theory suggests that ancient regional floods were exaggerated into global narratives over time, particularly as Proto-Indo-Europeans spread throughout Europe.

Another theory points to Christian missionaries' influence during colonization. For instance, the Maori people had no flood myth before missionary contact in 1814, but afterward developed one resembling Noah's story. However, Clark notes that some flood myth similarities existed independently of missionary influence.

Geomythology's Approach To Understanding Historical/Geological Basis For Myths

Geomythologists study how myths might represent actual geological events. One compelling example links the Mediterranean's breach of the Bosporus Strait 7,000 years ago to both Gilgamesh's and Noah's flood narratives. According to oceanographers William Ryan and Walter Pittman, this event created a waterfall 200 times larger than Niagara Falls.

Other geological events, like the Persian Gulf's formation 7,500 years ago and Doggerland's submergence, may have inspired regional flood myths. A 2016 study even found geological evidence supporting China's Emperor Yu flood myth, demonstrating how ancient narratives often preserve memories of real historical events.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The similarities between flood myths could be coincidental, given the universal presence of water bodies and the common occurrence of floods in human environments.
  • The "localized flood" theory may oversimplify the transmission and evolution of myths, not accounting for the complex interplay of cultural exchange, trade, and migration.
  • The influence of Christian missionaries on the development of flood myths in other cultures could be overstated, as some cultures may have developed or altered their flood narratives independently or through syncretism.
  • Geomythology, while providing valuable insights, may sometimes draw connections between myths and geological events that are speculative or not supported by sufficient evidence.
  • The interpretation of geological evidence in the context of myths can be subjective, and alternative explanations for the same evidence might exist.
  • The assumption that ancient narratives accurately preserve memories of real events may not always hold true, as myths are often altered over time for various reasons, including political, religious, or social motivations.
  • The idea that Proto-Indo-European migration spread the flood narrative across Europe may not fully account for the possibility of independent development of flood myths in different regions.
  • The assertion that the breach of the Bosporus Strait inspired the flood narratives of Gilgamesh and Noah could be challenged by alternative theories or interpretations of the origin and spread of these myths.

Actionables

  • You can explore your own cultural heritage's myths and legends to uncover potential historical events they may be based on. Start by researching the folklore from your background, then cross-reference these stories with known historical or geological events in the region. For example, if you have Irish ancestry, look into the legends of the Tuatha Dé Danann and see if they correlate with any archaeological findings from ancient Ireland.
  • Create a personal art project that visualizes the common themes of survival and renewal found in flood myths. Use any medium you're comfortable with, like drawing, painting, or digital art, to depict your interpretation of these themes. This could be a series of illustrations showing the stages of a flood myth or a single piece that captures the essence of rebirth following a catastrophe.
  • Engage in a creative writing exercise where you craft a short story inspired by the flood myths, incorporating modern elements. Imagine a flood occurring in your hometown and write a narrative that includes local landmarks and contemporary issues, such as climate change. This will help you connect with the universal themes of these ancient stories while grounding them in a current context.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

Noah's Flood and Other Ancient Flood Myths Parallels

Discussions on the parallels between Noah's biblical flood in the Old Testament and ancient flood narratives reveal the commonality and significance of these tales across different cultures.

Epic of Gilgamesh Features a Flood Like Noah's Story

Gilgamesh Predates Old Testament; Biblical Account Adapts Mesopotamian Myth

The Epic of Gilgamesh, acknowledged as the first literary work, includes a flood narrative that closely resembles the story of Noah's flood. Assyriologist George Smith discovered the story within the text of Gilgamesh during his research. This narrative, which dates back 3400 years, predates the Old Testament by several hundred years, suggesting that the Noah story could have been adapted from the older Mesopotamian text. In the Epic of Gilgamesh, Utnapishtim is instructed by the god Enlil to build a boat to save himself from a flood sent because humans were too noisy, contrasting with the biblical reason that humans were too wicked.

Flood Myths Span Chinese, Canadian, British, and Aboriginal Australian Cultures

Themes of Repopulation After Deluge

Flood myths are not unique to the Mesopotamian region or the Abrahamic religions. In fact, a study cited in the discussion identified 50 different cultures with their own flood myths, indicating a widespread occurrence of flood narratives. These stories span cultures across the globe, including Chinese, southern Canadian, and British Isles societies.

For example, in Chines ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Noah's Flood and Other Ancient Flood Myths Parallels

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The idea that the biblical flood account was adapted from the Epic of Gilgamesh is a hypothesis, not a proven fact. There could be other explanations for the similarities, such as a shared cultural memory of a real event or a common mythological theme.
  • The dating of the texts and the stories they contain can be complex and subject to interpretation. Some scholars might argue that the dating of the biblical texts is uncertain or could be older than commonly thought.
  • The presence of flood myths in various cultures does not necessarily indicate a shared historical event; it could also be a result of convergent cultural evolution or a response to local flooding events that were common in human history.
  • The interpretation of flood myths and their significance can vary greatly among scholars, and some might argue that each myth should be understood within its own cultural and historical context rather than being directly compared to others.
  • The suggestion that flood myths reflect a shared human inqu ...

Actionables

  • Explore the commonalities of human experience by starting a journal where you reflect on the themes of renewal and repopulation in your own life. For instance, after a personal setback, write about how you can rebuild or start anew, drawing parallels to the resilience shown in flood myths.
  • Foster a deeper connection with nature by creating a small garden or nurturing houseplants, using this as a metaphor for the interplay between humanity and the natural world. As you care for your plants, consider how civilizations have historically interpreted natural disasters like floods and what these interpretations say about our relationship with the environment.
  • Engage with dive ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

Theories Explaining Flood Myths in Different Cultures

Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark explore the origins of widespread flood myths in various cultures, examining different theories that attempt to explain the prevalence of these tales.

"Localized Flood" Theory: Ancient Regional Floods Exaggerated Into Global Narratives

Bryant and Clark delve into the "localized flood" theory, which suggests that ancient regional floods may have been exaggerated into narratives of global floods. These stories, affected by cultural transmission and transformation over generations, could explain the similarities between flood myths across different societies.

The Proto-Indo-Europeans are pinpointed as one group that may have experienced a flood. As they spread throughout Europe, their descendants, who spoke languages such as English and Germanic, carried the mythology with them, implying that this localized event had a global impact.

Absence of Flood Myths Supports Theory

Supporting this theory is the idea that cultures without a flood myth simply may not have experienced a local flood, or it was not significant enough to be immortalized into their oral traditions.

Missionaries Introduced Noah's Flood, Leading Cultures to Adapt Their Flood Myths to Resemble the Judeo-Christian Version

Bryant and Clark also discuss the role of Christian missionaries during the colonization period. It is theorized that the story of Noah's great flood from Judeo-Christian theology was introduced to local cultures across the world and led to the adaptation of existing myths or the creation of new ones that mirrored this narrative.

South Pacific Flood Myths Mirror Noah's Story After Missionary Contact

A key example is seen in the Maori flood myth from the South Pacific, which did not exist before contact with Christian missionaries in 1814. After this encounter, a flood myth emerged within the culture, showing remarkable similarities to the story of Noah.

Josh Clark adds that even if missionaries spread the story of Noah's flood, some similarities in flood myths exist outside of this context. Post-contact, flood myths in the South Pacific that were originally based on tsunamis transformed to resemble Noah's flood, with narratives featuring prolonged rain and a more significant deluge.

Frequent Floods in History May Have Le ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Theories Explaining Flood Myths in Different Cultures

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The "localized flood" theory may not account for the universality of flood myths in cultures that did not have significant contact or shared history, suggesting other psychological or sociological reasons for the prevalence of such myths.
  • The spread of the Proto-Indo-Europeans and their mythology does not explain flood myths in cultures that were not influenced by Proto-Indo-European languages or cultures, indicating that other factors may have contributed to the development of these myths.
  • The absence of flood myths in certain cultures could be due to loss of cultural heritage, lack of documentation, or prioritization of other types of myths, rather than the absence of significant floods.
  • The influence of Christian missionaries on local flood myths could be overstated, as some cultures may have developed flood narratives independently or through syncretism rather than direct adaptation of the Noah story.
  • The Maori flood myth's resemblance to Noah's story after missionary contact could be coincidental or influenced by other factors, such as shared human responses to natural disasters, rather than direct missionary influence.
  • Flood myths that share similarities with Noah's flood outside of missionary influence could be due to convergent cultural evolution or common archetypal themes rather than a single source of inspiration.
  • The theory that frequent historical floods led to similar flood-based origin myths does not consider the possibility of shared ancient knowledge or myths passed down through trade and intercultural contact.
  • The idea that catastrophic floods w ...

Actionables

  • You can explore your family's history to uncover any local events that may have become exaggerated over time. Start by interviewing older relatives about stories they've heard from their ancestors, then compare these tales to historical records to see how they may have changed. For example, a great-grandparent's story of a severe storm might have grown into a legend of a catastrophic event in the family narrative.
  • Create a digital storybook of local myths from your community, focusing on natural disasters. Gather stories from neighbors, local historians, or community leaders, and compile them into an online collection. This could highlight how similar events are interpreted differently across cultures or regions. For instance, two neighborhoods might have distinct tales about the same flood event, showing the personal and cultural influences on storytelling.
  • Engage in a creative writing exercise where you reimagine a well-known ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal?

Geomythology's Approach To Understanding Historical/Geological Basis For Myths

Geomythology explores how mythological narratives, like flood myths, may actually represent real geological events while also serving as culturally and metaphorically rich stories.

Geomythology: Geological Events in Myths and Legends

Chuck Bryant speaks about the correlation between myths and geological events, suggesting the study of geomythology uncovers the historicity within these myths. Geomythologists, who are trained geologists, work with experts from various fields to find the real-life events behind these tales.

Geomythologists Correlate Myths With Known or Suspected Natural Disasters

Geomythologists suggest that legends and folklore hold eyewitness accounts of natural disasters, encoded with metaphorical language to describe events like volcanic eruptions. One example is the legend of a god spouting fire from a volcano as a metaphorical warning of a volcanic eruption. Geomythologists rely on methods from paleohydrology and paleobathymetry to align geological evidence with such myths.

There is a hypothesis that suggests the Mediterranean's breach of the Bosporus Strait approximately 7,000 years ago could be the historical event underpinning the flood narratives in the Epic of Gilgamesh and Noah's biblical account. The resultant flood, which would have felt like a global catastrophe, generated a waterfall with a volume 200 times that of Niagara Falls and is a probable source for these ancient deluge stories.

Black Sea Flood: Waterfall 200 Times Larger Than Niagara, Possible Source of Flood Myths

Oceanographers William Ryan and Walter Pittman's theory posits that the massive flood from this breaching event could have inspired various flood myths due to the sheer scale of the waterfall and the catastrophic inundation it caused.

In other instances, the creation of the Persian Gulf around 7,500 years ago from what was once a fertile river valley, now a large body of water, and Doggerland's flooding, possibly from the Storegga Slide, are seen as geographical events t ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Geomythology's Approach To Understanding Historical/Geological Basis For Myths

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The correlation between myths and geological events may sometimes be coincidental rather than causal, as myths can arise from human imagination without direct experience of natural disasters.
  • Geomythology may overemphasize the role of natural disasters in myth creation, neglecting other cultural, psychological, or social factors that contribute to the development of myths.
  • The interpretation of myths is highly subjective, and different geomythologists may draw conflicting conclusions from the same mythological narratives.
  • Some myths may have been altered or embellished over time, making it difficult to accurately trace their origins to specific geological events.
  • The evidence linking specific myths to geological events is often circumstantial and may not meet the rigorous standards of proof required in the geological sciences.
  • While geomythology provides a fascinating ...

Actionables

  • You can explore local myths and legends to identify potential geomythological connections by visiting nearby historical societies or libraries and looking for stories that describe natural events. For example, if you live near a river, investigate any flood myths in your region and then research past flooding events to see if there's a correlation.
  • Start a creative writing project that reimagines a local myth with a geological perspective by first identifying a regional myth and then using online geological databases to find events that could explain the myth's origin. Write a short story or poem that weaves together the mythological narrative with the scientific explanation, like a modern retelling of an ancient tale.
  • Engage with your community by starting a geomyt ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA