In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore one of military history's most famous tactical blunders: the British Light Brigade's ill-fated charge during the Crimean War. They examine the complex political backdrop of the conflict, which began as a religious dispute but evolved into a major war featuring prominent figures like Florence Nightingale and Mary Seacole, who revolutionized battlefield medicine.
The episode details how miscommunication and personal tensions between British commanders led to the Light Brigade's charge into heavily fortified Russian positions. The hosts discuss how this military disaster, which saw 675 riders charge against 3,000 Russian troops, became immortalized through Alfred, Lord Tennyson's poetry and went on to influence various cultural works, while also addressing the broader impact of modern war journalism during the conflict.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The Crimean War (1853-1856) pitted Russia against an unlikely coalition of the Ottoman Empire, France, Britain, and Sardinia. The conflict began as a religious dispute over Christian holy sites in the Ottoman Empire but escalated into a full-scale war. The conflict is notable for pioneering modern war journalism and featuring prominent figures like Florence Nightingale, who reduced mortality rates from 41% to 2% in field hospitals, and Mary Seacole, who independently provided crucial medical care at the front. Disease claimed most of the half-million lives lost during the war.
In September 1854, Allied forces began their siege of Sevastopol, with approximately 60,500 troops encircling the city from the south. This strategy inadvertently allowed Russians to fortify their defenses. During the Battle of Balaclava, Russians attempted to cut Allied supply lines, leading to a series of clashes. Communication breakdowns between Lord Raglan, commanding from an elevated position, and his subordinates in the valley, combined with personal tensions between commanders, set the stage for the fateful charge.
The British Light Brigade, comprising 675 riders, charged into approximately 3,000 Russian troops and their artillery due to misinterpreted orders. Captain Lewis Nolan's possible misconstruing of Lord Raglan's directive led the brigade into the "Valley of Death," where they faced heavily fortified Russian positions. Despite the mission's near-suicidal nature, the brigade momentarily seized the Russian guns, though suffering heavy casualties. Alfred, Lord Tennyson immortalized this event in his famous poem, which Josh Clark notes celebrates the soldiers' dedication to duty.
The charge became enshrined in historical memory through Tennyson's poem, published just six weeks after the event. According to the hosts, the incident sparked various cultural works, including films that both celebrated and critiqued the event. William Howard Russell, a war correspondent, coined the term "thin red line" in his coverage. Tennyson later attempted to raise funds for Crimean War veterans through his poetry, though with limited success, collecting only 24 pounds. The event remains a powerful symbol of military courage in the face of doomed circumstances.
1-Page Summary
The Crimean War remains a significant conflict in European history, known for its religious disputes, early examples of modern journalism, prominent figures like Florence Nightingale and Mary Seacole, and the high mortality rate predominantly due to disease.
The Crimean War took place from 1853 to 1856 and was primarily a struggle over territories of the declining Ottoman Empire. Russia faced an unlikely coalition of the Ottoman Empire, France, Britain, and Sardinia. The war is notably remembered for its siege on the Crimean Peninsula and was fundamentally rooted in a dispute over religious authority.
The eruptions of hostilities began over a religious disagreement within the Ottoman Empire between the French Catholics and the Russian Orthodox Church, with both desiring control over the Christian holy sites. This conflict quickly escalated into a full-blown war. The allied nations opted to invade the Crimea because it was the base of the Russian Black Sea Fleet, which was perceived as a threat to Mediterranean security.
The war also marked one of the first instances of modern war journalism as well as the fame of two notable women in wartime medical care. Florence Nightingale, often called "the lady with the lamp," dramatically reduced the mortality rate from 41% to an astonishing 2% by implementing evidence-based treatments in field hospitals. Meanwhile, Mary Seacole, a ...
The Crimean War Context
The lead-up to the famous Charge of the Light Brigade is set against the backdrop of the siege of Sevastopol, an event that would dramatically unfold into one of history's most infamous military blunders.
In September 1854, Allied forces landed on the Crimean coast, determined to capture the port city of Sevastopol. Their forces, consisting of 30,000 French troops, about 26,000 British soldiers, and approximately 4,500 Turks, intended to take over the city and dismantle the Russian navy harbored there.
Rather than pursuing a direct assault, the Allies decided to encircle Sevastopol from the south. This strategy, while deemed sound at first, inadvertently gave the Russians time to strengthen their defenses and bolster their numbers. As a result, the city that had been initially weakly defended became a robust fortress.
A risky Russian tactic placed their troops between Allied forces positioned in Sevastopol and those in Balaklava. Their goal was to sever the Allied supply line essential for the siege at Sevastopol. In a confrontation known as the Battle of Balaclava, the Russians managed to seize artillery positions on Causeway Heights and moved towards the town of Catticoi. The Allied heavy brigade was successful in repelling the Russian cavalry, but it was now within this complex and tumultuous scene that the Light Brigade received the conflicting orders that would catalyze their ill-fated charge.
Lord Raglan, commanding from an elevated position, could see the battlefield differently from his men below, leading to potential confusion over the orders given. The geographical separation between Raglan and his troops meant a 20-minu ...
Prelude To the Charge of the Light Brigade
The dramatic events surrounding the Charge of the Light Brigade showcased both the bravery and the folly of military engagement, punctuated by poetic tribute to the soldiers’ valor amidst grave misunderstanding.
During the battle, the British Light Brigade, consisting of 675 riders, faced a dire situation as they charged into approximately 3,000 Russian troops and their artillery. The intent behind Lord Raglan's order was for the cavalry to quickly reach the front to prevent the Russians from taking away the heavy guns they had captured.
However, the orders delivered to the Light Brigade were anything but clear, leaving too much room for interpretation in the complicated battlefield. Captain Lewis Nolan, perhaps misconstruing Lord Raglan’s directive, pointed the Light Brigade in an erroneous direction toward the deadliest part of the valley, where the Russians held a significantly stronger position.
Raglan's command, perhaps misunderstood, seemingly directed the brigade to the center of three substantially fortified Russian points, ultimately leading to one of history's most infamous military mistakes.
In what became known as the "Valley of Death," the 670-strong Light Brigade executed their charge. Despite the near-suicidal nature of the mission, which was likely based on a misunderstanding or a miscommunication, they pressed on, incurring heavy casualties but momentarily seizing the Russian guns.
The Charge of the Light Brigade Itself
The Charge of the Light Brigade remains an enduring symbol of bravery and sacrifice in the face of overwhelming odds, rooted in the historical memory through Alfred, Lord Tennyson's poem.
The hosts discuss how Tennyson's poem, published just six weeks after the infamous military blunder of the Light Brigade, captured the public's imagination and solidified the tragic charge in the annals of history. William Howard Russell, a war correspondent, coined the term "thin red line" in his journalism, which became synonymous with the stoic British infantry. Despite the disastrous miscommunication that led to the charge, Tennyson's verses celebrated the valor of the soldiers who obeyed orders in the face of certain death.
Additionally, Tennyson's own recital of the poem, although poorly performed, was recorded on a wax cylinder and is available on the internet, further preserving the event's legacy.
Tennyson wrote his poem "The Charge of the Heavy Brigade at Balaclava" and later, Rudyard Kipling penned "The Last of the Light Brigade," both works echoing the themes of Tennyson's iconic poem and shedding light on the plight of veterans from the Crimean War. The poem was part of Tennyson's efforts to raise money to support veterans years after the war had ended. However, these fundraising attempts only yielded modest results, collecting a mere 24 pounds from a campaign led by Tennyson.
The Charge of the Light Brigade ...
Impact and Legacy of the Light Brigade Charge
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
