The Warrens: Paranormal Power Couple
In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore the work of Ed and Lorraine Warren, paranormal investigators who founded the New England Society for Psychic Research in 1952. The episode examines their most notable cases, including the Amityville haunting, the Annabelle doll investigation, and the Enfield Poltergeist, while detailing their methods and approach to supernatural phenomena.
The discussion also covers the controversy surrounding the Warrens' legacy. This includes skepticism about their investigative methods, allegations about predetermined conclusions in their cases, and claims that some of their most famous investigations were fabricated. The episode addresses personal controversies as well, including accusations about Ed Warren's relationship with a minor and claims that the couple exploited vulnerable families for publicity.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 6, 2026 episode of the Stuff You Should Know
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Warrens' Paranormal Investigation Background and Methods
Ed and Lorraine Warren established themselves as pioneering paranormal investigators after founding the New England Society for Psychic Research in 1952. Ed, a self-described demonologist, and Lorraine, who claimed to be a clairvoyant and transmedium, combined their skills to investigate cases involving Catholic imagery, speaking in tongues, levitation, and possession. Through their media-savvy approach and compelling storytelling, they helped bring ghost hunting into the mainstream.
Major Paranormal Cases the Warrens Investigated
The Warrens were involved in several high-profile cases that later became the basis for books and films. In the Amityville case, they investigated the Lutz family's claims of supernatural occurrences in a house where murders had previously taken place. The Warrens attributed the haunting to a cursed Native American burial ground, though the Lutz family later admitted to fabricating parts of their story.
In the Annabelle case, the Warrens performed an exorcism on a supposedly possessed Raggedy Ann doll, which they later housed in their museum. Despite their efforts, they reported that the doll continued to cause supernatural disturbances.
The Enfield Poltergeist case in London involved the Hodgson family experiencing paranormal phenomena. While the Society for Psychical Research classified it as a poltergeist case, the Warrens suggested demonic possession, though their direct involvement has been questioned.
Other notable cases included the Snedeker family's haunting in a Connecticut funeral home and Arne Johnson's murder trial, where he claimed demonic possession as a defense.
Criticism and Skepticism of the Warrens' Work
The Warrens faced significant criticism from skeptics who questioned their methods and integrity. Josh Clark notes that they typically began investigations with a predetermined hypothesis of demonic activity, seeking evidence to support this conclusion. Several of their famous cases, including Amityville and Snedeker, have been exposed as fabricated or exaggerated.
More serious allegations emerged in 2017 when Judith Penny claimed a 40-year affair with Ed Warren that began when she was 15, allegedly with Lorraine's knowledge. The Warrens have also been accused of exploiting vulnerable families for publicity and profit, with specific allegations that they paid Ray Gorton to fabricate the Snedeker haunting story.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can develop critical thinking skills by researching both sides of a controversial topic before forming an opinion. Start by choosing a subject related to paranormal claims, read articles from both proponents and skeptics, and then use a Venn diagram to visually map out the commonalities and differences in their arguments. This exercise will help you evaluate evidence more objectively and avoid confirmation bias.
- Enhance your media literacy by creating a mock investigative report on a local legend or myth. Gather information from various sources, interview people with differing viewpoints, and write a balanced report that presents all sides of the story. This practice will teach you to discern fact from fiction and recognize the influence of storytelling in shaping public perception.
- Practice ethical decision-making by role-playing scenarios where you must choose between exploiting a situation for personal gain or acting with integrity. For example, imagine you've discovered a historical artifact in your backyard. You can create a fictional narrative to gain fame and fortune or report it to the proper authorities for genuine historical examination. Reflect on the consequences of each choice to understand the importance of ethics in personal and professional life.
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Warrens' Paranormal Investigation Background and Methods
Ed and Lorraine Warren carved a unique path in paranormal investigation following the founding of their psychic research group and pioneering ghost hunting through publicity.
Warrens Founded Psychic Research Group In 1952: Ed as Demonologist, Lorraine as Clairvoyant/Transmedium
The Warrens' interest in the paranormal began informally while they were on the road selling Ed’s paintings. As this interest grew, Ed, a self-described demonologist, and Lorraine, who identified as a clairvoyant and transmedium, formally established the New England Society for Psychic Research in Connecticut in 1952. They combined their skills to delve into various cases of paranormal activity.
Warrens' Paranormal Cases: Catholic Imagery, Tongues, Levitation, Possession
The Warrens were involved in numerous cases featuring elements such as Catholic imagery, speaking in tongues, levitation, and demonic possession. Lorraine's abilities as a clairvoyant and transmedium allowed them an intimate view into these supernatural occurrences, which became hallmarks of their investigatio ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Warrens' Paranormal Investigation Background and Methods
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The legitimacy of Ed and Lorraine Warren's titles and expertise, such as Ed being a self-described demonologist and Lorraine identifying as a clairvoyant and transmedium, is not universally recognized and lacks formal accreditation.
- The methods used by the Warrens in their investigations have been criticized for lacking scientific rigor and for not following a standardized protocol that is typically used in scientific research.
- The Warrens' cases often relied heavily on anecdotal evidence and personal testimony, which are not considered strong evidence in the scientific community due to their subjective nature and susceptibility to bias and misinterpretation.
- The use of Catholic imagery and practices in their investigations may not resonate with individuals from different religious or non-religious backgrounds, and could be seen as promoting a specific religious viewpoint.
- The Warrens' approach to publicizing their cases through media and storytelling has been criticized for sensationalizing paranormal investigation, which ...
Actionables
- You can explore your own psychic potential by keeping a dream journal to record any unusual or recurring dreams that might indicate clairvoyant abilities. By regularly noting down your dreams upon waking, you may start to notice patterns or symbols that could be interpreted as psychic insights. For example, if you dream about a friend you haven't seen in years and then unexpectedly run into them, this could be a sign of latent clairvoyant ability.
- Start a local discussion group focused on paranormal topics to share experiences and learn from others interested in the supernatural. This can be as simple as creating a Facebook group or posting on community boards to gather individuals who have had their own experiences or are curious about the paranormal. Through regular meetings, you can exchange stories, discuss theories, and perhaps even plan visits to reputedly haunted locations in your area.
- Develop your storytelling skills by writing fic ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Major Paranormal Cases the Warrens Investigated
The Warrens, Ed and Lorraine, were noted paranormal investigators involved in a number of high-profile cases. Some of these cases, which have become the subject of books, documentaries, and films, are known for their controversial nature and alleged supernatural activity.
The Amityville House (Amityville Horror)
In Amityville, New York, the Lutz family experienced bizarre occurrences in their house, which was the site of Ronald DeFeo Jr.'s murder of his family. The Warrens investigated and claimed the land was haunted due to a cursed Native American burial ground, potentially influencing the murders.
Lutz Family Experienced Strange Occurrences In a House in Amityville, New York, Where a Previous Owner Had Murdered His Family
The Lutz family faced numerous oddities, such as terrible odors, feelings of possession, swarms of flies, and an unseen pig ghost named Jodie.
Warrens Claimed House Was on Cursed Native American Burial Ground, Causing Murders
The Warrens speculated that the house was built on a Native American cemetery used for dark rituals, which they believed caused the site's evil.
Doubts About Warren's Role, Lutz Family Admits Fabricating Parts
There emerged significant doubts about the Warrens' involvement and the credibility of the Lutzes' experiences. Under legal scrutiny, the Lutz family admitted it fabricated parts of the story, and the Warrens have been accused of inventing the Native American burial ground detail to amplify the supernatural narrative.
The Annabelle Doll
A Raggedy Ann doll, said to be possessed by a demon and not the spirit of a girl named Annabelle, led to the involvement of the Warrens, who performed an exorcism. They housed the doll in their museum under glass, but reports claim it continued to cause problems.
Nurse Receives Doll Allegedly Possessed by Spirit Annabelle
A nurse received the Annabelle doll, which exhibited strange behaviors, such as moving on its own and leaving notes.
Warrens Claimed a Demon Inhabited the Doll and Performed an Exorcism to Contain It In Museum
The Warrens reported that a demon inhabited the doll, and after an exorcism, they confined it to their museum, claiming further issues were resolved.
Even After the Exorcism, the Warrens Claim the Doll Continued Causing Problems, Showing the Limits of Their Methods
Despite the containment attempt, there were reports of continued supernatural occurrences, suggesting the limits of the Warrens' methods.
The Enfield Poltergeist
The Hodgson family in London's Enfield district were plagued by paranormal phenomena in 1977. The investigations were split between a poltergeist case by the Society for Psychical Research and a claim of demonic possession by the Warrens, though their direct involvement has been questioned.
1977 Enfield: Hodgson Family Faces Paranormal Events
Objects moved, unusual sounds were heard, and a daughter exhibited signs of possession in the Enfield case, creating a media and research frenzy.
Society f ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Major Paranormal Cases the Warrens Investigated
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Skepticism about the existence of the supernatural and the ability to investigate it scientifically.
- Questions about the credibility of the Warrens' investigations and the methods they used.
- The possibility that psychological factors, such as suggestion and the power of belief, could explain the experiences of those involved in the cases.
- The role of media and popular culture in amplifying and possibly distorting the accounts of paranormal events.
- The potential for financial or attention-seeking motives behind some of the claims made by the Warrens or those they investigated.
- The lack of empirical evidence supporting the existence of cursed grounds, demonic possessions, or haunted objects.
- The ethical considerations of promoting potentially harmful ...
Actionables
- You can explore local history to uncover any legends or notable events that might inspire creative storytelling or community engagement. Dive into your town's archives, speak with long-time residents, or visit historical landmarks to gather stories. Then, use these tales to write a short story, create a themed event, or start a blog that brings your community's unique history to life.
- Start a journal to document any unusual occurrences in your own home, using it as a way to practice critical thinking and observation skills. Note down times, dates, and descriptions of events without jumping to conclusions. Over time, review your entries to look for logical explanations or patterns that could demystify the occurrences or, alternatively, deepen the mystery.
- Engage in a creativ ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Criticism and Skepticism of the Warrens' Work
The Warrens, famous for their paranormal investigation work, have faced criticism and skepticism over the years for their practices and claims, with allegations ranging from unscientific methods to sexual exploitation.
Skeptical Society Calls Warrens' 1997 Evidence Unscientific, Fraudulent
The Warrens Were Criticized For Starting With a Demonic Activity Hypothesis and Supporting It With Evidence
Josh Clark acknowledges inconsistencies in the Warrens' stories and notes the potential for exploitation. Critics have argued that the Warrens would begin their investigations with a presumption of demonic activity and then seek evidence to support this hypothesis, a method frowned upon by skeptics.
Warrens' Famous Cases, Like Amityville and Snedeker, Shown As Fabricated or Exaggerated
The Warrens' claim that the Amityville house was built on a cursed Native American burial ground fed into a popular trope and even inspired the movie "Poltergeist." Their investigations have led to doubts and allegations suggesting the cases were fabricated or exaggerated. In particular, a ghost boy photo from their Amityville investigation, which some regarded as evidence, has been surrounded by skepticism. The Warrens have also been implicated in contributing to the satanic panic of the 80s through their possession and ghost haunting narratives.
There's a specific allegation that the Warrens paid Ray Gorton to fabricate the Snedeker haunting story, with Gorton later admitting that the story was entirely fictional and labeling the Warrens as grifters.
Allegations of Sexual Abuse and Exploitation
Judith Penny Claimed a 40-year Affair With Ed Warren From Age 15, With Lorraine's Awareness
In 2017, Judith Penny revealed that she had a sexual relationship with Ed Warren that began when she was a teenager, claiming that Lorraine knew about and permitted this affair. According to Penny, Lorraine even pressured her to have an abortion when she became pregnant by Ed to protect the family business.
Warrens Accused Of Exploiting Vulnerable Families For Publicity and Profit
The Warrens have been accused of exploiting families in crisis ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Criticism and Skepticism of the Warrens' Work
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The Warrens' approach to paranormal investigation, while unconventional, may be considered a form of qualitative research that prioritizes subjective experiences and anecdotal evidence over empirical methods.
- The inconsistencies in the Warrens' stories could be attributed to the complex nature of paranormal phenomena, which may not always present itself in a consistent or predictable manner.
- The Warrens' focus on demonic activity could be seen as a reflection of their personal beliefs and religious background, which may resonate with individuals who share similar views.
- The Amityville case and other famous investigations have become part of cultural lore, and the Warrens' involvement may have contributed to the broader discussion on paranormal phenomena, regardless of the veracity of the specific details.
- The ghost boy photo and other pieces of evidence presented by the Warrens may be open to interpretation, and some individuals may find them compelling despite skepticism from others.
- The Warrens' narratives around possession and hauntings could be seen as an attempt to provide explanations for experiences that are otherwise difficult to understand, offering comfort to those who feel affected by such phenomena.
- Allegations regarding the fabrication of stories, such as the Snedeker haunting, may be contested by those who beli ...
Actionables
- You can develop critical thinking skills by practicing the Socratic method in everyday conversations, asking probing questions to uncover the truth behind claims and stories you encounter. For example, when someone shares a sensational story, instead of taking it at face value, engage them with questions like "What evidence supports this claim?" or "Could there be an alternative explanation for these events?" This practice will help you discern fact from fiction in various narratives, much like scrutinizing the claims made by the Warrens.
- Enhance your media literacy by creating a personal checklist of criteria to evaluate the credibility of documentaries, news stories, and other media content. Include points such as checking for the presence of supporting evidence, the reputation of the sources, and the potential for bias or sensationalism. When you come across a new piece of media, use your checklist to assess its reliability. This approach will help you become more discerning of the content you consume, similar to analyzing the Warrens' media portra ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
