In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore the role of dolls in human society, from their function as developmental tools for children to their complex cultural significance. The discussion covers how dolls help children develop social and emotional skills through role-play and caregiving interactions, while also examining their historical use in both ritualistic and recreational contexts.
The episode delves into significant developments in doll history, including innovations like the first talking doll and the emergence of ultra-realistic "Reborn" dolls used in therapeutic settings. The hosts also address more challenging aspects of doll culture, including their role in reinforcing gender roles and racial stereotypes, and their psychological impact on children as revealed through historical studies.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Dolls serve as crucial tools in children's development, particularly in fostering social and emotional skills. Through role-play and caregiving interactions with dolls, children develop empathy, patience, and emotional recognition. Unlike puppets, action figures, or stuffed animals, dolls are specifically designed to be huggable and interactive, enhancing their effectiveness as comfort objects and tools for emotional exploration.
While toys weren't always strictly gendered, the 1940s marked a significant shift when dolls became explicitly marketed to girls, reinforcing traditional gender roles and beauty standards. During the Jim Crow era, dolls perpetuated harmful racial stereotypes. The Clarks' landmark studies in the 1940s revealed the devastating psychological impact of discriminatory dolls on Black children, who overwhelmingly associated positive traits with white dolls and negative traits with black dolls.
Ancient dolls served both ritualistic and play purposes, with the oldest known rag doll being "Bangwell Putt" from Massachusetts. Paper dolls experienced a boom from 1890 to 1920, offering interactive dress-up possibilities. The 20th century saw several innovative dolls, including the popular Kewpie doll, Chatty Cathy (the first successful talking doll), and Betsy Wetsy, which sparked a trend in lifelike dolls requiring hands-on care.
While studies confirm dolls' positive role in developing empathy and patience, they can also perpetuate harmful stereotypes about beauty and gender. Modern "Reborn" dolls, known for their extreme realism, serve therapeutic purposes, particularly for dementia and Alzheimer's patients. However, as Josh Clark notes, their ultra-realistic appearance can trigger the "uncanny valley" effect, causing discomfort or even phobic reactions in some people.
1-Page Summary
Understanding the role dolls play in the lives of children can provide insight into their developmental contributions.
Dolls have a unique role in fostering key skills in children, particularly relating to social development and emotional understanding.
Dolls are often used as models of human-like figures which facilitate the development of empathy, patience, and emotional recognition in children. Through interactions with dolls, children practice caregiving, which teaches them to be emotionally available. They learn to problem-solve and take the perspective of another, responding to the doll's "feelings," which can foster empathy as the doll's "needs" may differ from their own.
Additionally, dolls serve as a form of emotional expression for children, allowing them to project and work through their feelings. This occurs as kids express emotions through the dolls, providing a safe outlet where they may not feel comfortable directly communicating such feelings to parents or peers.
It is important to note that, in this context, the definition of dolls is specific and does not encompass other toys like puppets, action figures, or stuffed animals. The di ...
The Nature and Purpose of Dolls
The history of dolls reflects broader cultural narratives, particularly around gender and race, and their evolution has sometimes reinforced damaging stereotypes.
In the past, toys weren't always marketed with strict gender divisions. But by the turn of the 20th century, that began to shift. A significant change occurred in the 1940s when the marketing of toys became more gendered, targeting dolls specifically to girls, which reinforced the gender association of dolls with girlhood.
During the 1940s, toys began to be exclusively marketed on a gender basis, setting a pattern for the societal expectation that dolls are primarily playthings for girls. This shift contributed to the entrenchment of traditional gender roles from an early age.
Historically, dolls have been instrumental in reinforcing both gender roles and specific beauty standards. The dolls marketed to girls were typically designed to be pretty and provide a model of femininity, domesticity, and appearance for young girls to emulate.
During the Jim Crow era, dolls did not escape the pervasive racism of the time.
In catalogs like Montgomery Ward, Black dolls were portrayed as inferior, less cute, and sometimes downright ugly, not reflecting the true diversity and beauty of Black people or children. Conversely, white dolls were portrayed as beautiful, desirable collector's items, thus perpetuating a hierarchy of value based on skin color.
The Clarks, Mamie, and Kenneth, conducted landmark doll tests in the 1940s, showing the effects of these racist toys on Black children. They presented children with t ...
The Gendered and Racial History of Dolls
The history of dolls has evolved from ritualistic uses to becoming a core element of childhood play and learning. Significant innovations have marked the path of these treasured toys through the centuries.
Ancient Egyptian paddle dolls, possibly used in religious rituals, date back to 2000-1800 BCE. These dolls had bead string hair and tattoo-like designs. In the ancient world, dolls served dual roles: for rituals and for play. For instance, the Akua Baa dolls of Ghana were used in both ritualistic contexts and play. Rag dolls made from fabric such as cloth and linen have also been used across the ages for play. However, the perishable nature of the materials means few examples have survived. The oldest known rag doll is "Bangwell Putt," which belonged to Clarissa Field from Massachusetts.
The oldest rag doll found is 2000 years old, discovered in an Egyptian trash pile and originally painted with a single bead attached to its hair. The faceless design of some rag dolls, like Bangwell Putt, which has detailed hands but no facial features, may be linked to the importance of touch and corn husk doll traditions.
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discuss the paper doll trend, which peaked from 1890 to 1920. They emphasized the ability to change outfits and the interactive element of this type of doll. Paper dolls became an effective marketing strategy, encouraging newspaper, magazine, and product purchases, and their concept still evolves today, as evidenced by modern equivalents like magnetized fashion kits.
The Kewpie doll, introduced in 1912, was the first big doll of the 20th century and remained hugely popular until Mickey Mouse arrived. Following Kewpie, Raggedy Ann took the top spot in popularity.
Kewpie's influence extended into pop culture, inspiring an ...
Significant Doll Trends and Innovations Throughout History
Dolls play a significant role in child development, teaching social and emotional skills. However, they can also have unsettling effects, especially when they are made to look exceptionally realistic.
Studies over the years have highlighted that dolls can be instrumental in teaching children valuable life skills. Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant underscore the historical use of dolls for indoctrinating kids into cultural and societal norms, suggesting that dolls have played a crucial role in child development for centuries.
There is abundant research underscoring that dolls help kids develop a wide range of positive attributes such as empathy, patience, and the ability to recognize emotions.
However, it's important to note that dolls can also perpetuate harmful stereotypes, reinforcing narrow standards of beauty that may influence children's self-perception and expectations of others.
Reborn dolls, known for their life-like appearance, are used in therapeutic settings but can cross into unsettling territory because of their realism.
Reborn dolls, resembling real infants, are used extensively for therapeutic purposes. They are detailed down to fine aspects like veins and often have a smell reminiscent of real babies. These dolls are not mass-produced and can be quite expensive, running into hundreds of dollars. They have proven particularly useful for patients with Alzheimer's and dementia by triggering memories and comforting emotions without the need for pharmacological interventions.
The Psychological and Cultural Impact of Dolls
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
