The Unsolved Murder of Hall and Mills
In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, hosts Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark examine the Hall-Mills murder case of 1922, where Reverend Edward Hall and Eleanor Mills were found dead in a meticulously staged crime scene. The investigation faced initial challenges due to jurisdictional disputes and eventually focused on the reverend's wife, Frances Hall, and her family members as prime suspects, though they were ultimately acquitted despite substantial evidence against them.
The hosts delve into how this case became a media sensation, drawing crowds to the crime scene and earning the "Trial of the Century" moniker. They also explore the possibility that this case influenced F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby," noting similarities between the real-life murder and themes in the novel, including class division and infidelity.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 19, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Hall-Mills Murder Case
The Hall-Mills murder case stands as one of America's most sensational criminal investigations, featuring a tragic tale of forbidden love and brutal murder.
The Crime and Investigation
On September 14, 1922, Reverend Edward Hall and his mistress Eleanor Mills were found murdered in a particularly gruesome fashion. The crime scene appeared staged, with their bodies arranged together and love letters scattered around them. Eleanor had been shot three times and nearly decapitated, while Reverend Hall was executed with a single shot. The investigation was initially hampered by jurisdictional disputes between counties, requiring the governor's intervention to facilitate cooperation.
Suspects and Investigation
While initial theories pointed to robbers or the Ku Klux Klan, suspicion eventually fell on Frances Hall (the reverend's wife) and her brothers. The evidence against the Hall family mounted when their alibis proved weak, and witnesses, including Ralph Gorseline and Jane Gibson (known as "the pig woman"), placed them at the crime scene. A 1926 investigation revealed that Eleanor's tongue and vocal cords had been cut out, leading to the indictment of Frances Hall, her brothers, and her cousin.
Media Sensation
The case captured national attention, with spectators flocking to the crime scene and vendors selling murder-scene relics. The trial became known as the "Trial of the Century," with public interest reaching its peak during the reading of the victims' love letters in court. Despite the evidence presented, Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark note that Mrs. Hall and her family were acquitted, though questions about the true perpetrators remain unanswered.
Literary Connection
Bryant and Clark discuss the intriguing possibility that the Hall-Mills case may have influenced F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby." While no direct evidence confirms this connection, they note striking parallels in themes of class division, infidelity, and the treatment of working-class characters between the real-life case and Fitzgerald's novel. Bryant suggests that these similarities are compelling enough to indicate that Fitzgerald might have used the case as inspiration for his work.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore the impact of historical events on literature by reading "The Great Gatsby" and noting themes that reflect the societal issues highlighted in the Hall-Mills case, such as class division and infidelity. This can deepen your understanding of how real-world events can influence literary works and provide a richer reading experience.
- Create a simple crime mystery game for a social gathering using elements from the Hall-Mills case, like staged crime scenes and sensational media coverage, to engage friends in critical thinking and problem-solving. This can be a fun way to apply historical cases to modern entertainment and encourage collaborative storytelling.
- Write a short story or a piece of creative nonfiction inspired by the Hall-Mills case, focusing on the emotional and psychological aspects of the characters involved. This exercise can help you explore human behavior and motivations, as well as practice your writing skills in a historical context.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Hall-Mills Murder Case
The Hall-Mills murder case remains one of the most enigmatic and sensationalized crimes in American history, as it combines elements of love, betrayal, and mystery.
Summary of the Crime
Reverend Hall and Mistress Mills Murdered In 1922
On September 14, 1922, the bodies of Reverend Edward Hall and his mistress Eleanor Mills were found brutally murdered. The affair between them was well-known in their church community, and their spouses, James Mills and Frances Hall, were aware of it.
Bodies Staged As a Romantic Tryst Gone Wrong, Love Letters Scattered
Eleanor Mills was shot three times in the head, her throat cut so severely that she was close to decapitation. Reverend Hall was shot point-blank, execution style, with a .32 caliber pistol. The couple saw Hall and Mills meeting on a bridge on the day of the murder, and their bodies were later discovered by a young couple on Old Phillips Farm. The crime scene suggested a staged romantic encounter, with the bodies placed together and a scarf draped over Eleanor's throat. Reverend Hall’s body was positioned with his business card propped against his foot, and Eleanor's tongue and vocal cords had been removed. Around the bodies, love letters between the two victims were scattered.
Investigation Hindered by Police Incompetence and Jurisdictional Disputes
There were immediate jurisdictional disputes between Middlesex County and Somerset County, leading to two initial separate investigations which hindered the effectiveness of the crucial early hours. Despite public pressure, Middlesex assistant prosecutor John Tulin noted that there was no evidence to support the robbery motive suggested by family members. Ultimately, the governor had to intervene for the counties to collaborate.
Potential Perpetrators and Theories
Initial Suspects: Robbers or Ku Klux Klan Members
Initial suspects included robbers or members of the Ku Klux Klan, as Edward Hall was known to carry valuables, and the Klan was infamously active in punishing moral transgressions. However, theories implicating these groups were seen as implausible, primarily due to the presence of the love letters at the crime scene.
Evidence Implicates Hall Family As Murderers
The Hall family, particularly Frances Hall and her brothers, were implicated as without solid alibis and had sufficient means and motive. Mrs. Hall's alibi weakened when it was revealed that she and her brother Willie, suspected of prowling around the time of the murders, could not corroborate their story. Testimonies weakened their defense, with Ralph Gorseline admitting to hearing the shots and seeing brother Henry, corroborated by his mistress, Catherine Rastell, further incriminating the family. Jane Gibson, "the pig woman," reported seeing Mrs. Hall and her relatives at the murder scene.
A renewed investigation in 1926 found that Eleanor Mills’ tongue and vocal cords were cut out, leading to a gra ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Hall-Mills Murder Case
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore your local history by visiting a nearby historical society or archive to research a notable event or figure from your area. By delving into old newspapers, photographs, and records, you can uncover stories that may have been forgotten or overlooked, much like the details of the Hall-Mills case. This can give you a personal connection to the past and a deeper appreciation for the complexities of historical events.
- Write a short story or script inspired by the themes of love, betrayal, and mystery, using the Hall-Mills case as a creative springboard. Crafting a narrative that weaves these elements together can be a cathartic way to process the emotional impact of such stories and explore human nature's darker facets without needing any specialized skills.
- Start a true crime dis ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Potential Literary Influence
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant suggest that there might be a connection between a historical event known as the Hall-Mills case and a classic piece of American literature, F. Scott Fitzgerald’s "The Great Gatsby."
Comparison to the Great Gatsby
While there’s no direct transcript evidence showing that the Fitzgeralds followed the Hall-Mills case, Clark and Bryant discuss the potential influence it might have had on the novel.
Class Divides, Infidelity, and Working-Class Victim Mistreatment in the Case and the Great Gatsby
In the Hall-Mills case, Edward Hall had an affair with Eleanor Mills, a woman married to a school janitor who also took care of the church. The case was characterized by a significant class divide, with Frances Hall hailing from wealth and Edward Hall being a pastor, not particularly wealthy but living a luxurious lifestyle, ostensibly by marrying up. These details of class divides, infidelity, and mistreatment of working-class characters strikingly echo several thematic elements of "The Great Gatsby."
Speculative Literary Influence: Fitzgerald Likely Used Case as Novel's Launching Point
Chuck Bryant speculates that the idea for this discussion might ha ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Potential Literary Influence
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The suggestion of a connection between the Hall-Mills case and "The Great Gatsby" is speculative and not based on direct evidence.
- Fitzgerald may have drawn from a variety of contemporary sources and personal experiences, not just a single case like Hall-Mills.
- The themes of class divides, infidelity, and mistreatment of working-class characters are common in literature and may not necessarily point to a specific real-life influence.
- The timing of the publication of "The Great Gatsby" and the occurrence of the Hall-Mills case might not align in a way that supports the theory of direct influence.
- Fitzgerald's own life and the social circles he frequented could have provided ample material for the themes explored in "The Great Gatsby" without the need for a specific case like Hall-Mills.
- The idea that Fitzgerald used the Hall-Mills case ...
Actionables
- Explore the influence of historical events on modern creativity by reading a classic novel and researching a contemporary event that occurred during its writing. This can help you understand how writers may draw inspiration from their surroundings, even subconsciously. For example, if you're reading "The Great Gatsby," you might look into the social issues and prominent news stories of the 1920s to see how they could have influenced Fitzgerald's themes and characters.
- Develop your observational skills by creating a journal where you document current events and personal experiences, then use them as a basis for short fictional stories. This practice can sharpen your ability to see potential narratives in everyday life and improve your storytelling abilities. You could start by writing about a local event or personal encounter, then expand it into a more complex story, mirroring how a novelist might work.
- Enhance your critical thinking by forming a book club th ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
