Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Who's Up For A Circular Economy

Who's Up For A Circular Economy

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, hosts Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark examine the environmental impact of our current "take, make, waste" economic system. They explore how various industries contribute to environmental degradation through practices like planned obsolescence and single-use products, with specific examples from the electronics, construction, and fashion sectors.

The hosts discuss emerging alternatives through the concept of a circular economy, where companies are developing innovative solutions like modular products and appliance leasing services. They also address the challenges of transitioning to more sustainable practices, including inadequate recycling systems, corporate resistance to change, and the need to shift consumer behavior. The complexity of achieving truly sustainable solutions is illustrated through real-world examples of both successes and unexpected drawbacks.

Listen to the original

Who's Up For A Circular Economy

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 7, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Who's Up For A Circular Economy

1-Page Summary

Problems With the Current Linear "Take-Make-Waste" Economic Model

In their podcast discussion, Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark examine the environmental impact of our current "take, make, waste" economic system. According to the hosts, this linear model promotes wasteful practices through planned obsolescence and single-use products, contributing significantly to environmental degradation.

Several industries exemplify these issues. The electronics sector, they note, produces items that are often impossible to repair, while the construction industry generates substantial waste through demolitions. In the fashion industry, Clark points out that clothing production accounts for 10 percent of global CO2 emissions, with 85 percent of garments ultimately ending up in landfills.

Companies and Industries Adopting Circular Economy Principles

Some companies are working to break away from this wasteful model. Dutch firm Niagara has developed modular mattresses and carpets that can be partially replaced or repaired, extending their lifespan. Unilever has partnered with the Ellen MacArthur Foundation to reduce plastic waste through refillable packaging options.

Bryant and Clark discuss how some firms are exploring innovative business models, such as Dutch company Bundles, which leases and maintains home appliances instead of selling them outright. This "pay-per-wash" approach ensures products remain in use longer through regular maintenance and refurbishment.

Challenges and Barriers To Implementing a Circular Economy

The hosts explain that transitioning to a circular economy faces significant obstacles. Current recycling systems are inadequate, and companies often resist change due to profitable linear business models. Consumer behavior presents another challenge, with Bryant noting that American consumers may need education to shift their perceptions about practices like appliance leasing.

The discussion highlights how even well-intentioned sustainability efforts can have unexpected drawbacks. For instance, Clark points out that washing clothes made from recycled materials still releases microplastics into the ocean, demonstrating the complexity of achieving truly sustainable solutions.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Planned obsolescence is a strategy where products are intentionally designed to have a limited lifespan or become outdated quickly, prompting consumers to buy replacements sooner. This practice aims to boost sales by shortening the time between purchases. Manufacturers may use this approach to ensure continued demand for their products.
  • A circular economy is a model that promotes sustainable resource use by emphasizing practices like sharing, reusing, and recycling materials to minimize waste and environmental impact. It aims to keep products and materials in use for as long as possible, contrasting with the traditional linear economy's focus on disposal. The principles of a circular economy include designing out waste and pollution, maintaining product use, and regenerating natural systems to create a more sustainable economic system. This approach is gaining traction globally as a way to address climate change, reduce resource consumption, and foster long-term growth.
  • Refillable packaging options are containers or packages that can be refilled or reused multiple times without losing their functionality. This approach aims to reduce waste by offering sustainable alternatives to single-use packaging, promoting a circular economy. Companies like Unilever are exploring refillable packaging as a way to minimize plastic waste and encourage more environmentally friendly consumption habits. Refillable packaging aligns with the principles of reduce, reuse, and recycle, contributing to efforts for more sustainable packaging solutions.
  • Microplastics are tiny plastic particles that come from various sources like clothing, packaging, and industrial processes. They are less than 5 mm in size and can enter ecosystems, causing pollution. Primary microplastics are already small when they enter the environment, while secondary microplastics result from the breakdown of larger plastic items. These particles persist in the environment, particularly in aquatic ecosystems, contributing to water pollution.
  • The Ellen MacArthur Foundation is a charity founded by Dame Ellen MacArthur, a retired sailor known for breaking the world record for the fastest solo circumnavigation of the globe. The foundation collaborates with businesses and educational institutions to promote the transition to a circular economy, aiming to reduce waste and promote sustainability. Ellen MacArthur's sailing achievements have helped raise her profile and support the foundation's mission.

Counterarguments

  • The "take, make, waste" model is not inherently wasteful; it is the lack of proper waste management and recycling infrastructure that leads to environmental degradation.
  • Repairability of electronics is sometimes compromised for the sake of innovation, miniaturization, and performance improvements.
  • Demolition waste in construction can be mitigated through better design and deconstruction practices, suggesting the problem is not the industry itself but the methods employed.
  • The fashion industry's impact on CO2 emissions is complex and can be influenced by factors such as energy sources, materials used, and transportation methods, not just the production process.
  • Modular mattresses and carpets, while extending the lifespan of products, may still face challenges in consumer acceptance, potential cost implications, and the environmental impact of the materials used.
  • Refillable packaging options may not always reduce plastic waste if the refilling infrastructure is not widely adopted or if consumers prefer the convenience of single-use packaging.
  • Appliance leasing models like Bundles' "pay-per-wash" could result in higher costs for consumers over time and may not be economically viable for all customer segments.
  • Resistance from companies to adopt circular business models may be due to legitimate concerns about financial viability, market readiness, and technological limitations, not just profit motives.
  • Educating consumers about new practices such as appliance leasing may not be as challenging as suggested if the benefits are clearly communicated and aligned with consumer values.
  • The issue of microplastics from washing recycled materials is a valid concern, but it can be addressed through improved filtration systems and by developing new materials that shed fewer fibers.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Who's Up For A Circular Economy

Problems With the Current Linear "Take-Make-Waste" Economic Model

Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark discuss the unsustainable "take, make, waste" economic model's damaging impacts on the environment. They argue for a rethinking of this traditional system to mitigate waste and pollution.

Linear Economy: A Wasteful, Environmentally Harmful System

The current economic model, as described by Bryant, takes resources, manufactures products with short lifespans, and disposes of them in landfills. This linear system is deemed highly inefficient and environmentally harmful by Clark and Bryant.

Linear Model Incentivizes Obsolescence and Single-Use, Causing Waste and Pollution

Since the Industrial Revolution, the linear economy has dominated and thrived as a revenue generator. It promotes obsolescence through products designed to break down quickly, compelling consumers to prematurely dispose of them and buy replacements. One tangible example cited by the hosts concerns food packaging like mini bags of Lay's potato chips, which are neither designed to be recycled nor reused.

Worst Offenders in the Linear Economy: Food, Electronics, Consumer Goods, Construction

Industries Create Waste Via Excessive Packaging and Short Lifespans

The electronics industry is a prime example of the linear model's issues, introducing products that are often impossible to repair, such as laptops with non-replaceable batteries. The construction industry also contributes significantly to environmental waste, especially through demolitions and renovations that consume extensive resources.

In the food sector, waste is appare ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Problems With the Current Linear "Take-Make-Waste" Economic Model

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The linear "take, make, waste" economic model describes a system where resources are extracted, products are manufactured, used, and then disposed of as waste. This linear approach is criticized for its inefficiency and environmental harm, as it leads to excessive consumption, pollution, and resource depletion. The model encourages a throwaway culture by prioritizing short-term product use over long-term sustainability. Transitioning to a circular economy, where resources are reused and recycled, is seen as a more sustainable alternative to the linear model.
  • Obsolescence in products refers to their intentional design or marketing to become outdated or non-functional within a short period, encouraging consumers to replace them frequently. This strategy drives continuous consumption but contributes to environmental issues like waste and resource depletion. Manufacturers often create products with limited lifespans or non-repairable components to stimulate demand for newer versions. Obsolescence can lead to a cycle of disposal and repurchase, impacting sustainability and resource management.
  • Single-use packaging contributes to environmental issues due to its disposability after a single use, leading to significant waste generation. This type of packaging often ends up in landfills, contributing to pollution and resource depletion. Additionally, the production of single-use packaging consumes resources like water, energy, and raw materials, further exacerbating environmental impacts. The widespread use of single-use packaging in various industries, such as food and consumer goods, highlights the need for sustainable alternatives to reduce waste and environmental harm.
  • The fashion industry contributes to global CO2 emissions through various stages of production, including fabric manufacturing, transportation, and garment disposal. The industry's reliance on energy-intensive processes and materials like polyester significantly imp ...

Counterarguments

  • The linear model has historically driven economic growth, technological advancement, and improved living standards.
  • Some argue that the responsibility for waste and pollution lies not only with the production model but also with consumer behavior and demand.
  • Technological innovation within the linear economy has led to some products becoming more energy-efficient and less wasteful over time.
  • The linear economy provides jobs and economic activity in sectors like manufacturing, waste management, and logistics.
  • There are challenges in transitioning to a circular economy, including the need for significant investment, changes in consumer behavior, and the development of new technologies.
  • Some products in the linear economy are designed for durability and longevity, even if they are not the norm.
  • Recycling and waste-to-energy technologies can mitigate some of the environmental impacts of the linear economy.
  • The linear model's impact on the environment can be reduced throug ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Who's Up For A Circular Economy

Companies and Industries Adopting Circular Economy Principles

Companies across the globe are embracing the principles of a circular economy, focusing on product longevity through repairability, reusability, and recyclability.

Companies Design Products to Be Repairable, Reusable, Recyclable

These companies aim to depart from the traditional linear economy's "take-make-dispose" model. Instead of planned obsolescence, they are emphasizing planned permanence with products that have a longer lifespan and can be easily repaired.

Dutch Firm Niagara Creates Modular Mattresses and Carpets to Extend Lifespan

With the goal to combat waste and extend product use, Dutch company Niagara designs modular mattresses made from recyclable materials. Their approach allows individual mattress parts to be replaced or repaired, significantly reducing the need to discard the entire product. This innovation comes in response to the millions of bulky mattresses filled with nasty chemicals that end up in landfills yearly in both the U.S. and Europe.

In addition to mattresses, Niagara tackles the carpet industry, where massive amounts of this product are thrown away each year, with only a fraction being recycled in the U.S.

Unilever, Ellen Macarthur Foundation Partner to Cut Plastic Waste With Refillable Packaging

Josh Clark brings up the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, known for popularizing the circular economy concept. In alignment with these ideals, Unilever has partnered with the foundation to cut down on plastic waste by providing consumers with options for refilling detergent and shampoo bottles or receiving concentrates to minimize waste.

Firms Explore Leasing and Renting Models to Extend Product Use

Dutch Company Bundles Leases, Maintains, and Reuses Home Appliances

A novel take on the circular economy is seen through the leasing and renting model of appliances. Bundles, a Dutch company, delivers high-quality home appliances and is responsible for their maintenance and ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Companies and Industries Adopting Circular Economy Principles

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The upfront cost of designing products for repairability, reusability, and recyclability can be higher, potentially making products more expensive for consumers.
  • Some industries may find it challenging to adopt circular economy principles due to the nature of their products or the complexity of their supply chains.
  • The effectiveness of circular economy models can be limited by consumer behavior; if consumers are not willing to return products for repair or recycling, the benefits are diminished.
  • The infrastructure for recycling and repairing is not equally developed in all regions, which can limit the practical implementation of circular economy principles.
  • There may be technological limitations to the recyclability of certain materials, making it difficult to achieve a truly circular economy.
  • Leasing and renting models may not appeal to all consumers, who may prefer ownership for reasons such as perceived value, convenience, or personal attachment to products.
  • The transition to a circular economy may lead to job losses in industries that are heavily reliant on the linear " ...

Actionables

  • You can start a neighborhood repair café where locals can bring in items for fixing, fostering a community of repair and reuse. By organizing a monthly meet-up in a local community center or garage, you encourage the repairability aspect of the circular economy. Neighbors can share tools and expertise to fix everything from electronics to clothing, reducing the need to buy new items and keeping them out of landfills.
  • Create a personal inventory of your belongings to identify opportunities for leasing or borrowing instead of owning. Use a simple spreadsheet to track items you use infrequently, such as power tools or party supplies. Then, research local rental options or initiate a borrowing system among friends and family. This approach minimizes your personal consumption and supports the idea of shared ownership, aligning with the circular economy's emphasis on extending product use.
  • Choose to support businesses that offer modular products or refillable packaging when m ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Who's Up For A Circular Economy

Challenges and Barriers To Implementing a Circular Economy

Bryant and Clark explore the difficulties of transitioning from a traditional linear economy to a circular one, highlighting design flaws, consumer habits, and infrastructural shortcomings.

Shifting To a Circular Economy Requires Changes in Design, Manufacturing, and Behavior

The hosts explain that the circular economy is in its conceptual stage and requires significant changes in design, manufacturing, and consumer behavior. They note that the current linear economy is purposefully designed for product obsolescence. The emphasis on the conceptual phase in the design process is crucial for creating durable goods, such as mattresses, that could potentially last indefinitely. The discussions suggest that the entrenched linear model generates significant wealth, thereby creating reluctance to move towards a circular system.

Companies Resist Change Due to Profitable Models and Fear of Disruption

Despite not explicitly stating that companies resist change, indications are given that the current profitable linear models and fear of disruption present barriers. Companies design products for obsolescence which is a lucrative practice. The necessity to redesign not just products but also recycling infrastructure is underlined because waste is often a conscious choice by companies that choose not to make packaging recyclable. An example of a better system is Charles Chips' use of reusable metal tins, which contrasts with today's throw-away culture.

Barriers to Circular Economy: Infrastructure, Logistics, Consumer Inertia

Clark and Bryant point out that recycling, while often idealized, is the least desirable option in a circular economy, suggesting that current systems are inadequate. The decline in recycling materials globally is flagged as a worrying trend, and the rapid increase in consumption implies the insufficiency of the existing recycling infrastructure.

Recycling Systems Are Inadequate for a Circular Economy

The inadequacy of recycling systems is evident in the way plastics from recycled clothes are washed back into the ocean and the reduction in secondary materials reentering production. Even materials like aluminum, which have a high recycling rate, still see a significant percentage ending up in landfills, reflecting consumer behavior not fully in tune with recycling practices.

...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Challenges and Barriers To Implementing a Circular Economy

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The circular economy is an economic model that aims to minimize waste and make the most of resources by keeping products and materials in use for as long as possible. Challenges in implementing a circular economy include redesigning products for durability, changing consumer behavior towards reuse and recycling, and improving recycling infrastructure to handle materials more effectively. Companies often resist transitioning to a circular economy due to existing profitable linear models and concerns about potential disruptions to their business practices.
  • In a linear economy, products are designed with a limited lifespan, encouraging frequent replacements and generating more sales. This design flaw leads to product obsolescence, where items become outdated or non-functional sooner than necessary, driving consumer demand for new purchases. Manufacturers often intentionally create products with short lifespans to stimulate continuous consumption, contributing to environmental waste and resource depletion. Transitioning to a circular economy involves rethinking this approach to design and production, aiming for longer-lasting, sustainable goods to reduce waste and promote a more efficient use of resources.
  • Companies resist change towards a circular economy due to the profitability of existing linear models and the fear of disruption. Designing products for obsolescence is a common practice that generates revenue. The reluctance to shift to circular practices stems from the financial success and stability of the current linear economic model. Transitioning to a circular economy requires significant redesign efforts and investments that companies may be hesitant to undertake.
  • The inadequacy of current recycling systems in the context of transitioning to a circular economy means that the existing systems are not efficient or effective enough to handle the increasing volume and complexity of waste generated. This inadequacy is evident in issues like materials being improperly recycled, leading to pollution, and a significant portion of recyclable materials still ending up in landfills. The challenges highlight the need for substantial improvements in recycling infrastructure and processes to align with the principles of a circular economy. This inadequacy underscores the necessity for systemic changes and innovations to address the limitations and shortcomings of current recycling practices.
  • Consumer behavior plays a crucial role in transitioning to a circular economy as it influences the demand for sustainable products and drives the need for changes in how products are designed, used, and disposed of. Educati ...

Counterarguments

  • The transition to a circular economy might stifle innovation by focusing too much on durability and reuse at the expense of technological advancements.
  • Some argue that product obsolescence is not always purposeful but can be a result of technological progress and consumer demand for new features.
  • The wealth generated by the linear model is used to fund research and development, which could lead to more sustainable solutions in the long run.
  • Companies may resist change not only due to profitable models but also due to the substantial risks and investments required to shift to a circular economy.
  • The argument that companies design products for obsolescence may overlook the complexity of balancing cost, consumer expectations, and environmental considerations.
  • The inadequacy of recycling systems might be attributed to technological limitations and economic viability rather than a lack of effort from companies or consumers.
  • Consumer behavior is diverse and complex, and not all consumers have the same level of environmental awareness or the financial means to choose more sustainable options.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA