Selects: What exactly is stoicism?
In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, hosts Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark explore Stoicism, from its origins with Zeno of Citium in ancient Greece to its influence on modern psychology and Silicon Valley entrepreneurs. They examine the philosophy's core tenets, including the four cardinal virtues of wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance, and explain how Stoics use practices like "negative visualization" to maintain emotional balance.
The hosts detail how Stoicism has shaped various traditions throughout history, from Christian morality to cognitive-behavioral therapy, and discuss its practical applications in extreme circumstances, as exemplified by Admiral James Stockdale during his time as a POW. They also address critiques of Stoicism, including concerns about its potential to promote passivity toward social issues and its approach to emotional control.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jul 19, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Historical Origins and Development of Stoicism
Stoicism emerged in ancient Greece when Zeno of Citium, following a shipwreck, developed the philosophy by combining cynicism's views on wealth with Socratic philosophy's pursuit of well-being through virtue. The philosophy later flourished in Rome, reaching its peak during the reign of Marcus Aurelius, whose "Meditations" became a foundational text for Stoic living.
The Core Tenets and Practices of Stoicism
According to Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark, Stoicism teaches that true happiness (eudaimonia) comes through four cardinal virtues: wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. The philosophy emphasizes focusing on what one can control, as explained in Epictetus's "The Enchiridion." Stoics practice "negative visualization" to prepare for challenges and maintain emotional balance by imagining worst-case scenarios. The philosophy advocates for living in harmony with the cosmic order and viewing obstacles as opportunities for growth.
The Influence and Application of Stoicism Throughout History
Stoicism has significantly influenced various traditions, from Christian morality to modern psychology. Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark note that cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) draws heavily from Stoic practices, particularly in its approach to managing emotions and perceptions. Notable figures like Admiral James Stockdale have credited Stoic philosophy, especially Epictetus's teachings, for their resilience in extreme circumstances, as demonstrated during Stockdale's time as a POW in Vietnam.
The Contemporary Significance and Critiques of Stoicism
While Stoicism has experienced a renaissance, particularly among Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, it faces criticism. Clark expresses concern that the philosophy's focus on internal virtues might lead to passivity in the face of social injustice, especially when promoted by wealthy individuals. Critics also argue that Stoicism's emphasis on emotional control might lack the spiritual depth found in Eastern philosophies and could potentially be psychologically harmful if misinterpreted or applied too rigidly.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can create a "Virtue Journal" to track daily actions aligned with the four Stoic virtues. Start by dedicating a page to each virtue: wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. Each evening, reflect on your day and note down instances where you practiced or observed these virtues. This exercise will help you become more conscious of these qualities in your life and strive to embody them more fully.
- Develop a "Control Circle" diagram to visually separate concerns into what you can and cannot control. Draw a large circle on a piece of paper, and within it, a smaller circle. Label the inner circle "What I Can Control" and the outer circle "What I Cannot Control." Whenever you face a decision or stressor, write it in the appropriate circle. This will help you focus your energy on actionable areas and foster a Stoic mindset.
- Engage in a weekly "Obstacle Brainstorming" session where you identify potential challenges and envision constructive responses. Choose a quiet time once a week to sit down and think about upcoming difficulties or ongoing struggles. For each one, brainstorm ways to turn the obstacle into an opportunity for personal growth, jotting down actionable steps you can take. This practice encourages a proactive approach to life's hurdles, in line with Stoic teachings.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Historical Origins and Development of Stoicism
The philosophy of Stoicism traces its roots back to ancient Greece and later found footing in Rome, influencing leaders and the cultured elite.
Stoicism Began In Greece With Zeno of Citium In the 3rd Century BC
The philosophy of Stoicism was developed by Zeno of Citium after his significant life experiences and influences from other philosophies.
Zeno of Citium, Shipwrecked Merchant, Developed Stoicism By Merging Cynicism With Socratic Philosophy
Zeno of Citium, who began Stoicism, sought a life of virtue in harmony with reason and nature. Following a shipwreck, Zeno wandered up to the stoa poikilie, or painted porch. There, he merged insights from cynicism, particularly its stance on wealth and fame as paths to ruin, with Socratic philosophy's pursuit of eudaimonia, or well-being, through virtue. This synthesis formed the new philosophy of Stoicism.
The philosophy quickly became one of the main schools of thought during the age of reason, offering a way of living focused on personal virtue and wisdom. Zeno's Stoicism agreed with Socrates about the importance of eudaimonia through virtues and merged it with cynics' views on the trappings of earthly possessions without advocating for outright poverty.
Early Stoics: Cleanthes, Cato, Seneca, Epictetus
Following Zeno, Stoicism was shaped by other significant philosophers including Cleanthes, Cato, Seneca, and Epictetus, contributing to its rich foundation and guiding principles.
Stoicism Thrived In Rome With Marcus Aurelius, Philosopher-Emperor
Rome became the center stage for the development of Stoicism, bringing it to its peak during the reign of Marcus Aurelius. ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Historical Origins and Development of Stoicism
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Stoicism indeed emphasizes virtue, reason, and nature, it can be argued that its approach to emotions is often misunderstood; it does not advocate for the suppression of emotions but rather for not being controlled by them.
- The text implies a seamless transition of Stoicism from Greece to Rome, but the adaptation of Stoic principles to Roman culture involved significant changes, reflecting the different social and political contexts.
- The focus on Stoicism as a philosophy for the elite might overlook its broader appeal and practicality for individuals from various walks of life in ancient times.
- The text mentions Stoicism's popularity during the age of reason, but it's worth noting that its influence waned with the rise of other philosophies and religions, and it was not continuously one of the main schools of thought throughout history.
- The contributions of later Stoics like Seneca and Epictetus might be seen as departures from or evolutions of Zeno's or ...
Actionables
- Start a 'Stoic thought of the day' routine by picking a simple Stoic principle each morning and finding opportunities to practice it throughout your day. For example, if you choose the principle of 'accepting what you cannot change,' actively recognize moments when you feel frustrated by uncontrollable circumstances and remind yourself to focus on your response instead.
- Create a 'Stoic virtue journal' where you reflect on your actions at the end of each day, assessing them against Stoic virtues like wisdom, courage, justice, and moderation. This could involve writing down instances where you felt you lived up to these virtues and areas where you could improve, thus fostering a habit of self-improvement in line with Stoic philosophy.
- Develop a 'Nature Alignment Tracker' where you lo ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Core Tenets and Practices of Stoicism
Stoicism, an ancient philosophy, upholds eudaimonia—true happiness—achieved through the prudent cultivation of essential virtues and emotional resilience.
Stoicism Emphasizes Eudaimonia Through Four Virtues: Wisdom, Courage, Justice, Temperance
Stoicism teaches that eudaimonia or true happiness is achieved through the cultivation of four cardinal virtues: wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. These virtues constitute the core of what is good in Stoic philosophy, and everything else is seen as an indifferent, which means they can be neither inherently good nor bad. Wealth, for instance, is considered a preferred indifferent, while a chronic illness would be dispreferred.
Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark elaborate that true happiness, from a Stoic perspective, lies not in external goods or passions but in living by reason and in accordance with nature. They convey that for Stoics, to label something as universally 'good,' it must be beneficial under all circumstances, unlike external goods that may not always prove beneficial, such as wealth in the hands of a person with a heroin addiction.
Stoic Principle: Focus On What You Can Control
Epictetus, a Stoic philosopher, distinguished between what is in our control and what is not, encapsulated concisely in his work "The Enchiridion." Stoics learn to appreciate things like wealth but remain unfazed by the prospect of losing them, underpinning the Stoic imperative to concentrate on what is within one’s own power.
Chuck Bryant discusses the importance of recognizing both positive and negative aspects of life without allowing them to derail one's objectives. A key tenet of Stoicism is to convert adversities into opportunities for growth by focusing solely on the aspects of life that one can control. Bryant points out the futility of succumbing to stress over uncontrollable events when one could instead channel energy into productive endeavors.
Stoicism Promotes Emotional Control and Resilience Through Rational Detachment
The Stoic approach entails maintaining composure regardless of life’s circumstances and detaching oneself from emotional responses to external events. Josh Clark suggests that Stoicism provides a method for tempering natural human reactions and staying focused on what one can control.
Stoics Practice "Negative Visualization" to Prepare For Challenges and Stay Emotionally Balanced By Imagining Worst-Case Scenarios
Stoics utilize "negative visualization" as a technique to maintain b ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Core Tenets and Practices of Stoicism
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Eudaimonia is a Greek term that translates to "happiness" or "welfare." It represents the state of flourishing and well-being achieved through virtuous living and fulfilling one's potential. In ancient philosophy, particularly in Aristotle's works, eudaimonia is considered the highest human good and the ultimate goal of ethical and practical reasoning. It encompasses living a life of virtue, excellence, and practical wisdom, leading to a sense of fulfillment and true happiness.
- The cardinal virtues in classical philosophy are prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance. These virtues are considered fundamental and serve as the foundation for ethical behavior and moral decision-making. They are seen as essential qualities that guide individuals in leading a virtuous and balanced life. The term "cardinal" signifies that all other virtues hinge upon and are encompassed by these four core virtues.
- In Stoicism, "indifferents" are external factors like wealth or health that are neither inherently good nor bad. They are considered indifferent because they do not determine a person's moral worth or virtue. Stoics focus on cultivating internal virtues like wisdom and courage rather than becoming overly attached to external circumstances.
- Living in accordance with nature in Stoicism means aligning one's actions and thoughts with the natural order of the universe. It involves accepting the things that are beyond our control and focusing on developing virtues that are in harmony with the fundamental principles of the cosmos. This concept emphasizes living in a way that is consistent with reason, virtue, and the interconnectedness of all things. By following this principle, Stoics aim to find peace and fulfillment by embracing the inherent order and flow of the universe.
- Epictetus was a Stoic philosopher who lived in the 1st and 2nd centuries AD. "The Enchiridion" is a concise manual or handbook written by Epictetus that encapsulates key Stoic teachings and principles. In this work, Epictetus ...
Counterarguments
- Stoicism's emphasis on emotional control may be criticized for potentially leading to emotional suppression, which can be unhealthy if not managed properly.
- The idea that external goods are indifferent might be challenged by arguing that material conditions can significantly impact one's ability to live a virtuous life.
- The focus on personal control could be seen as ignoring the importance of collective action and social responsibility in addressing issues that are beyond individual control.
- The Stoic practice of negative visualization might be counterproductive for some individuals, potentially leading to increased anxiety or a pessimistic outlook.
- The Stoic aim for harmony with a cosmic order may be critiqued from a scientific perspective, which does not necessarily support the existence of a predetermined cosmic order.
- The Stoic principle of focusing only on what one can control might be seen as a limitation in situations where influencing or attempting to change uncontrollable factors is possible and desirable.
- The Stoic ideal of rational detachment could be argued to overlook the value of emotional intelligence and the role emotions play in human connection and decision-making.
- The Stoic approach to adversities as opportunities for growth might ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Influence and Application of Stoicism Throughout History
Stoicism, an ancient Greek philosophy, has wielded significant influence across various traditions and continues to be applied in multiple domains of life, from individual conduct to modern therapeutic practices.
Stoicism's Impact on Various Traditions
Throughout history, Stoicism has had a profound impact on diverse systems of thought and practice.
Stoic Influence on Christian Morality and Virtues
Stoicism informed Christianity in many ways, exhibiting its pervasive influence over Christian beliefs and moral practices. The stoic emphasis on virtues and personal ethics blended into Christian morality, complementing its doctrines and influencing the development of its own virtues.
Stoicism's Influence on Modern Psychology and Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy
Stoicism’s principles have reached far beyond its ancient roots, extending into the sphere of modern psychology, specifically cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark articulate that CBT’s strategies, such as exposure therapy and the cognitive model of emotion, are reminiscent of stoic practices like negative visualization and theories of perception. Albert Ellis, a prominent figure in the development of CBT, drew from Stoicism, particularly the teachings of Epictetus, that our reactions to events are the source of discomfort, not the events themselves.
Notable Figures Inspired by Stoicism
Several notable historical figures have drawn from Stoicism, employing its teachings as a guide for life, economics, and survival under extreme conditions.
Marcus Aurelius' "Meditations": A Classic Guide to Stoic Virtuous Living
Emperor Marcus Aurelius, one of the most well-known stoic thinkers, authored "Meditations," a text that has served as a timeless guide to stoic philosophy and virtuous living. The insights within "Meditations" reflect Aurelius’ commitment to the stoic principles of ethics and personal improvement.
Adam Smith: Father of Modern Economics and Stoic Influence
Adam Smith, often ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Influence and Application of Stoicism Throughout History
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The extent of Stoicism's influence on Christian morality and virtues can be debated, as Christianity has a rich and varied history with many influences.
- While Stoicism has contributed to modern psychology, it is not the sole influence on cognitive-behavioral therapy, which also draws from other philosophical and psychological traditions.
- The assertion that Adam Smith was influenced by Stoic thought in his economic work may be overstated or require more nuanced exploration, considering the complex interplay of moral philosophy and economic theory in his writings.
- The personal application of Stoic principles by individuals such as Marcus Aurel ...
Actionables
- You can create a "Stoic Virtue Journal" where each day you reflect on a virtue such as wisdom, courage, justice, or temperance, and write down how you practiced or observed it in your daily life. This exercise encourages mindfulness and ethical living, akin to the self-examination Marcus Aurelius practiced. For example, if you chose courage, you might note a situation where you spoke up for someone else or faced a personal fear.
- Develop a "Stoic Response Flowchart" for personal use to navigate challenging situations, inspired by the cognitive model of emotion. Start with an event, followed by your initial thoughts, then question those thoughts for rationality and helpfulness, and conclude with a healthier perspective or action. For instance, if you're stuck in traffic and begin to feel angry, the flowchart would guide you to question the usefulness of your anger and help you shift to a more constructive response, like using the time to listen to an audiobook.
- Engage in a "Modern Stoic Week," where you apply a stoic concept to your life each day, such as practicing gratitude, focusing on what y ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Contemporary Significance and Critiques of Stoicism
Stoicism, the ancient Greek philosophy, has seen a modern renaissance, particularly among Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, due to its teachings on emotional control and rationality. However, it has not been without its criticisms.
Stoicism's Resurgence Among Silicon Valley Entrepreneurs
Stoicism has experienced a significant resurgence in popularity, especially within the Silicon Valley community, due to its practical life guidance and teachings about focusing on what one can control.
Stoicism's Emphasis on Emotional Control, Rationality, and Virtue Appeals to Modern Individuals Seeking Practical Life Guidance
Stoicism encourages focusing on important things within one's power to change, which appeals to individuals seeking to navigate the complexities of modern life.
Stoicism Criticized For Elitism, Detachment From Less Privileged Struggles due to Wealthy Proponents
Critics like Clark express concern that stoicism might inadvertently keep underprivileged individuals placated by focusing on internal virtues and maintaining an even keel, especially when wealthy proponents popularize the philosophy. This could lead to a detachment from the struggles of less privileged communities and a lack of action towards social change.
Criticisms of Stoicism: Lack of Mystique/Spiritual Depth Versus Eastern Philosophies, Focus On Neutrality/Impassiveness in Adversity
Stoicism's Focus Seen As Passive Acceptance of Social Injustice
Clark speculates that stoicism may lead to passivity in the face of social injustice because it doesn't seem to provide explicit guidance on enacting societal change. Stoicism's emphasis on personal resilience might be misconst ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Contemporary Significance and Critiques of Stoicism
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Stoicism promotes resilience and emotional control, which can be empowering for individuals in any socioeconomic status, not just the privileged.
- The philosophy's focus on what one can control may encourage proactive behavior rather than passivity, as individuals learn to act effectively within their sphere of influence.
- Stoicism has been interpreted in various ways throughout history, and some modern interpretations emphasize active engagement in social justice and community support.
- The comparison of Stoicism's lack of spiritual depth to Eastern philosophies may overlook the rich spiritual and ethical dimensions inherent in Stoic thought.
- Emotional control in Stoicism is not about suppression of feelings but about responding to emotions in a reasoned way, which can be psychologically beneficial.
- Stoic ...
Actionables
- You can integrate stoic principles with community engagement by volunteering in a way that aligns with your values and control. Choose a local organization that addresses social issues you care about and offer your time or skills. This allows you to practice stoicism's focus on personal action while contributing to societal change.
- Develop emotional intelligence alongside stoic practices by keeping a daily reflection journal. At the end of each day, write down situations that evoked strong emotions and analyze them to understand others' perspectives. This habit encourages empathy and self-awareness, balancing stoic emotional control with emotional intelligence.
- Create a "sphere of influence" map to visualize and prioritize ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
