In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore the remarkable story of the coelacanth, a fish species discovered in 1938 that was previously thought to have gone extinct with the dinosaurs. The episode covers the initial discovery by Marjorie Courtney-Latimer off the South African coast, and the subsequent identification of a second species in Indonesia in 1997.
The hosts delve into the unique biology of these deep-sea creatures, including their specialized hunting abilities and unusual reproductive cycle. They also examine how genetic analysis has changed scientists' understanding of the coelacanth's evolutionary relationships, and discuss the current threats to both known species, whose populations may number only in the hundreds to low thousands.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
In 1938, the scientific world was stunned when Marjorie Courtney-Latimer discovered a living coelacanth off the South African coast—a fish believed to have gone extinct with the dinosaurs. This 127-pound specimen, with its distinctive pale mauve-blue coloring and unique features, led to the species being named Latimeria chilumnae in her honor. Decades later, in 1997, biologist Mark Erdmann identified a second brown-colored species in Indonesia, expanding our understanding of these remarkable creatures.
Chuck Bryant explains that coelacanths are deep-sea dwellers, living primarily in the ocean's twilight zone between 500 to 800 feet deep. These nocturnal hunters possess several unique features, including an oil-filled spine and a hinged skull that allows them to open their mouths extremely wide. They use a specialized rostral organ to detect prey's electrical signals, and notably, they reproduce through a rare three-year internal gestation period, giving birth to live young.
Recent genetic analysis has reshaped our understanding of coelacanth evolution. While these fish belong to the sarcopterygian group—vertebrates with lobed, fleshy fins or limbs—researchers have found they're more closely related to lungfish than to tetrapods. Josh Clark points out that despite being called "living fossils," coelacanths have undergone significant changes over time, though their genome shows a slower rate of evolution compared to other species.
Clark notes that both known species of coelacanth face significant threats today. Population estimates range from hundreds to low thousands, with the West Indian Ocean population being particularly vulnerable. The main threats to these ancient creatures come from bycatch and habitat loss, especially affecting those off Tasmania where protective measures are limited. Their endangered status has prompted increased focus on conservation efforts to preserve these unique deep-sea dwellers.
1-Page Summary
The history of the coelacanth, a fish long believed to have been extinct, took an astonishing turn when it was rediscovered off the coast of South Africa in 1938.
In the 1930s, the coelacanth—a fish thought to have vanished alongside dinosaurs—reappeared, shocking the scientific community with its continued existence in the oceans.
Marjorie Courtney-Latimer, the director of the local museum in East London, South Africa, discovered an unusual fish among a trawler’s catch during a pre-Christmas inspection. The fish, a 127-pound specimen with a unique pale mauve blue color, hard scales, and four limb-like fins, was something she had never seen before. Despite the heat and the approaching holiday, Latimer made the decision to bring the fish to the museum for further examination.
The fish was later identified by Courtney-Latimer as a coelacanth, a species presumed extinct and known previously only from fossils. J.L.B Smith, upon receiving a sketch of the fish from Courtney-Latimer, recognized its significance despite the mounting process that could have obscured its key features. This monumental discovery was soon recognized as the zoological find of the century, leading to th ...
Rediscovery and Historical Significance of the Coelacanth
Chuck Bryant discusses the intriguing physical characteristics and reproductive strategies of coelacanths, large deep-sea fish known for their unique biology.
Coelacanths are recognized for their considerable size and distinctive traits that set them apart from other marine species.
Coelacanths reside primarily in the ocean's twilight zone, commonly between 500 to 800 feet deep, but they can live as deep as 2,000 feet. These nocturnal hunters have several unique features, including a notochord, which is a hollow, pressurized tube filled with oil, and an unusual hinged cranial element that allows them to open their mouths very wide by retracting the top part of their skull. This adaptation is advantageous for their predatory lifestyle, enabling them to consume more significant prey.
Although no direct input refers to coelacanth fins as precursors to tetrapod limbs, it is a widely recognized scientific fact that coelacanth fins are structured in a way that resembles the limb bones of terrestrial vertebrates, indicating their importance in the understanding of the evolutionary transition from aquatic to land environments.
Bryant notes that coelacanths possess a specialized rostral organ within the nasal region of their snout, capable of detecting the low-level electrical signals emitted by their prey. This organ is crucial for hunting in the dee ...
Physical Traits and Biology of the Coelacanth
The coelacanth's evolutionary history is under scrutiny as recent genome analysis provides new insights into its relationship to other vertebrates.
Recent genetic analysis shifts our understanding of the coelacanth's place in the evolutionary tree.
Researchers have found that while we're all sarcopterygians—vertebrates with lobed, fleshy fins or limbs—the coelacanth is not the direct ancestor of terrestrial vertebrates as was once believed. Rather, genomic analysis shows that the coelacanth is more closely related to the lungfish than to tetrapods, with all groups sharing a sarcopterygian ancestor.
Josh Clark argues that coelacanths, often labeled as "living fossils," have undergone significant changes, evidenced by differences in size when compared to their ancient counterparts. The coelacanth's full genome, which was studied and published in Nature, demonstrates slower evolution with a lower rate of genetic substitution than seen in other species, challenging the concept that coelacanths have remained unchanged through time.
Evolutionary History and Relationships of the Coelacanth
The enigmatic coelacanth, a rare and ancient type of fish once thought to be extinct, is facing modern-day challenges that warrant its listing as an endangered species.
Coelacanths, often known as "living fossils," are split into two known extant species. Clark points out that the West Indian Ocean Coelacanth, commonly found around the Comoros Islands off the east coast of Africa, and its cousin in Indonesian waters both have dwindling populations. Estimates suggest there could be around a thousand individuals in the Indonesian region, with far fewer off the coast of Africa.
These ancient creatures, which have survived for millions of years, are now threatened primarily by human activities such as bycatch and habitat loss. While some coelacanths find refuge in deep-sea cave dwellings where they have some protection, those off Tasmania are particular ...
Conservation Status and Threats to the Coelacanth
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser