SYSK’s Summer Movie Playlist: Some Movies That Changed Filmmaking
In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, hosts Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant explore films that introduced revolutionary techniques to cinema. The discussion covers early innovations like Soviet montage theory in "Battleship Potemkin," Buster Keaton's influential acting style in "The General," and the introduction of synchronized sound in "The Jazz Singer." They also examine how "Citizen Kane" changed visual storytelling through techniques like deep focus photography and nonlinear narratives.
The hosts delve into the French New Wave's impact on modern independent filmmaking through movies like "Breathless," known for its handheld camera work and jump cuts. The conversation includes Stanley Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey," examining how its groundbreaking special effects and unique narrative approach influenced subsequent filmmakers like George Lucas and Ridley Scott.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 27, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Landmark Technical and Editing Innovations In Early Cinema
Three groundbreaking films from early cinema introduced techniques that would shape filmmaking for generations. "Battleship Potemkin" pioneered Soviet montage theory, emphasizing rhythmic shot juxtaposition over narrative continuity. Its famous Odessa Steps sequence, featuring a baby carriage rolling down stairs, has been referenced in countless films from "The Untouchables" to "The Godfather."
"The General" showcased Buster Keaton's revolutionary deadpan acting style and ambitious stunts, including the famous scene where a house front collapses around him. Keaton's emotionless expression amid chaos influenced modern comedians like Bill Murray and Amy Poehler.
"The Jazz Singer" marked a pivotal moment in cinema history as the first feature-length film with substantial synchronized speech and music, using Warner Brothers' Vitaphone system to sync audio with film projection.
Narrative and Stylistic Techniques in Mid-20th Century Films
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discuss how "Citizen Kane" revolutionized cinema through innovative techniques like deep focus photography and nonlinear storytelling through flashbacks. Orson Welles' use of off-center framing and strategic lighting created a new visual language for film.
The hosts explain how the French New Wave, particularly "Breathless," introduced a raw, naturalistic style characterized by handheld camera work and jump cuts. Bryant notes that these techniques continue to influence modern independent filmmaking, serving both artistic and practical purposes.
The visionary artistry and impact of 2001: A Space Odyssey
Stanley Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey" remains impressive even today for its technical achievements and stunning visuals. The hosts discuss how the film's three-part structure and minimal dialogue created a unique, meditative experience. According to Bryant, Kubrick, working with Arthur C. Clarke and advised by Carl Sagan, deliberately left extraterrestrials unseen to avoid misrepresentation.
The film's special effects set new standards for depicting space travel, with Kubrick's attention to detail creating visuals that still feel futuristic. The hosts note that filmmakers like George Lucas and Ridley Scott were heavily influenced by "2001," with Lucas acknowledging it as superior to "Star Wars" in terms of technical achievement.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While "Battleship Potemkin" is often credited with pioneering Soviet montage theory, some critics argue that other filmmakers of the era, such as Dziga Vertov, also contributed significantly to the development of montage techniques.
- The influence of Buster Keaton's deadpan acting style is undeniable, but it's worth noting that other silent film actors, like Harold Lloyd, also had a significant impact on the comedy genre.
- "The Jazz Singer" was indeed a landmark in synchronized sound in cinema, but it was not the first film to feature synchronized sound; earlier short films and features experimented with sound, though not as successfully.
- "Citizen Kane" is frequently lauded for its innovative techniques, but some film historians argue that many of these techniques had been used before; Welles's achievement was in synthesizing them into a cohesive and influential whole.
- The French New Wave's influence on modern independent filmmaking is clear, but it's also important to recognize the movement's own influences, such as Italian neorealism, and how it was part of a larger global shift in cinematic storytelling.
- While "2001: A Space Odyssey" is praised for its technical achievements, some viewers and critics find the film's pacing slow and the narrative challenging to engage with, which could be seen as a flaw depending on one's cinematic tastes.
- Kubrick's decision to leave extraterrestrials unseen in "2001" can be interpreted in various ways; some might argue that showing extraterrestrials could have added to the film's impact and thematic exploration.
- The assertion that "2001: A Space Odyssey" set new standards for depicting space travel is generally accepted, but some might argue that other films, such as "Forbidden Planet" or "Metropolis," also set significant precedents in visual effects and design.
- The claim that George Lucas acknowledged "2001" as superior to "Star Wars" in terms of technical achievement could be contested by those who value the cultural impact and storytelling of "Star Wars" over the technical prowess of "2001."
Actionables
- You can explore the impact of editing on storytelling by creating a simple video montage using free editing software. Start by filming a series of short, related clips and then experiment with different sequences and rhythms to see how the order and duration of shots affect the viewer's perception of the story. For example, you might take clips of a routine activity like making coffee and reorder them to create different emotional impacts or narratives.
- Enhance your appreciation for visual storytelling by taking photographs that play with composition and lighting. Use your smartphone or camera to capture images with off-center subjects, varying depths of field, and strategic use of shadows. This could involve photographing a friend using a desk lamp to create dramatic shadows or taking a landscape photo where the main subject is not in the center, mimicking the techniques used in "Citizen Kane."
- Develop a deeper understanding of film structure by writing a short story or outline that employs a non-linear narrative. Instead of writing events in chronological order, mix up the sequence to reveal information in a way that adds mystery or depth. For instance, start your story with the climax, then alternate between past and present events to slowly unveil the characters' backstories and motives.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Landmark Technical and Editing Innovations In Early Cinema
Early cinema was an exciting time of innovation and creativity. Films such as "Battleship Potemkin," "The General," and "The Jazz Singer" introduced groundbreaking techniques that influenced generations of filmmakers and actors.
Battleship Potemkin Pioneered Soviet "Montage" Editing Technique
"Battleship Potemkin" was a landmark film, notably for its pioneering use of the Soviet montage theory. This style emphasized the impact and rhythm of the juxtaposition of shots over seamless narrative continuity.
Odessa Steps Sequence in Battleship Potemkin, Featuring Rhythmic Shot Juxtaposition, Widely Imitated and Referenced In Later Films
The film's Odessa Steps sequence, illustrating a tense battle on grand stairs, is particularly famous. It features the rhythmic intercutting that montage is known for, including the iconic moment of a baby carriage rolling down the steps—a scene that has been imitated in numerous other films. From "The Untouchables" to "Naked Gun," and works by famed directors like Woody Allen in "Love and Death" and "Bananas," as well as the assassination montage in "The Godfather" involving Mo Green's massage scene, the influence of the "Odessa steps sequence" is substantial and enduring.
Buster Keaton's the General (1926) Showcased Groundbreaking Stunts, Deadpan Acting
"The General" is renowned for its ambitious stunts and the deadpan style of Buster Keaton, one of cinema's greatest stunt performers. Among Keaton's legendary stunts is a scene where the front of a house collapses around him, yet he emerges unscathed by standing at the exact right spot.
Keaton's Unemotional Style Influenced Later Deadpan Comedians
Keaton's distinct, emotionless expressions amidst chaotic scenes, such as collapsing buildings and intense train chases, became his trademark. His comedic style is reflected in many modern comedians' work like Bill Murray, Amy Poehler ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Landmark Technical and Editing Innovations In Early Cinema
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- "Battleship Potemkin" was indeed a pioneer in montage editing, but it was not the only film to explore innovative editing techniques at the time. Other filmmakers, such as Abel Gance with his film "Napoleon," also made significant contributions to editing.
- While the Odessa Steps sequence is iconic, some critics argue that its historical accuracy is questionable, and it may serve more as propaganda than as a purely artistic endeavor.
- "The General" was groundbreaking, but it was initially a box-office failure and received mixed reviews, which suggests that contemporary audiences and critics did not universally recognize its innovations.
- While Keaton's influence on deadpan comedy is significant, it's important to acknowledge that comedy styles are multifaceted and other silent film comedians like Harold Lloyd and Charlie Chaplin also had substantial influences on the genre.
- "The Jazz Singer" was a landmark in s ...
Actionables
- You can explore the impact of editing on storytelling by creating a short video using only your smartphone. Start by filming a simple scene, like making a cup of coffee, and then edit it in different styles: one with quick, rhythmic cuts to build intensity, and another with longer, more contemplative shots. Compare how the different editing techniques affect the viewer's perception of the narrative.
- Experiment with non-verbal communication by recording a series of short, silent skits that convey emotions or simple stories through actions and facial expressions alone. Share these with friends or on social media to see if the intended message gets across without words, thus understanding the power of physical comedy and deadpan expression.
- Discove ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Narrative and Stylistic Techniques in Mid-20th Century Films
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant delve into the narrative and stylistic innovations that mid-20th century films introduced, changing the landscape of cinema through groundbreaking techniques used in movies like "Citizen Kane" and "Breathless."
Citizen Kane: Innovative Nonlinear Narrative and Cinematography
Citizen Kane's Deep Focus, Framing, and Lighting Created a New Visual Language For Cinema
Clark and Bryant discuss "Citizen Kane's" use of deep focus, a technique where both the background and foreground are sharply in focus. This allowed viewers to engage with every part of the frame during pauses. They also note Orson Welles' use of off-center framing and lighting, which were fundamental in establishing a new visual language for cinema. Welles' methods illustrated a mood using illumination, focusing the audience’s attention on certain parts of the scene and sometimes allowing key actions to occur off-screen for added depth.
Flashbacks Disrupted Linear Storytelling In a Groundbreaking Way
Welles' use of flashbacks in "Citizen Kane" disrupted the traditional linear narrative. Clark and Bryant highlight the efficiency and innovative narrative structure introduced by the film, which served as a precedent for future filmmakers.
French New Wave, Breathless (1960) Introduced a Fresh, Raw Style
"Jump Cut" Technique in Breathless Creates Jarring Flow
The French New Wave ushered in a fresh, raw style characterized by techniques that were initially viewed as amateurish, such as handheld camera work. "Breathless" in particular is known for its use of the jump cut editing technique. This method helped to express the rapid progression of time and movement by quickly cutting between shots of the same subject from different angles, creating tension and a dynamic flow of events.
French New Wave Rejected Traditional Narratives For Naturalistic Minimalism
In discussing the French New Wave and "Breathless," Clark acknowledges the movement's signi ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Narrative and Stylistic Techniques in Mid-20th Century Films
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While "Citizen Kane" is often credited with popularizing deep focus, off-center framing, and innovative lighting, these techniques were not invented by Orson Welles and had been used by filmmakers before him, albeit less prominently.
- The non-linear narrative of "Citizen Kane" was groundbreaking, but it was not the first film to use a non-linear structure; earlier films and literature had experimented with this narrative technique.
- The jump cut, while notably used in "Breathless," can be disorienting or confusing for some viewers, and its effectiveness is often dependent on the context within which it is used.
- The French New Wave's rejection of traditional narratives in favor of naturalistic minimalism is not universally appreciated; some critics and audiences prefer the structure and polish of traditional narratives.
- The assertion that the French New Wave has a significant influence on modern independent filmmaking could be overstated, as contemporary filmmaking is influ ...
Actionables
- You can experiment with photography to understand visual storytelling by taking a series of photos with varying depths of field, compositions, and lighting. Start by capturing images that have everything in focus, then try placing subjects off-center and playing with shadows and highlights to convey different moods or stories. Share these photos on social media or with friends to get feedback on the storytelling impact.
- Create a short video using your smartphone to explore non-linear storytelling, similar to the flashbacks in "Citizen Kane." Record several clips that represent different moments in a story you want to tell. Use a basic video editing app to rearrange these clips out of chronological order to create a compelling narrative that reveals information in an unconventional way. Share this video with peers to see if the non-linear structure enhances the story.
- Try editing a video you've already shot by incorporating jump cuts to convey energy and time ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The visionary artistry and impact of 2001: A Space Odyssey
"2001: A Space Odyssey" has been a seminal piece of science fiction cultural history for both its astounding visuals and its lasting impact on the genre.
2001: Space Odyssey (1968) Blends Science With Surreal Visuals
The podcast hosts express that Stanley Kubrick’s 1968 film "2001: A Space Odyssey" not only blew minds upon its release but continues to impress audiences even in present-day with its technical achievements and stunning aesthetics.
Three-Part Structure and Dialogue-Sparse Sequences Created Immersive, Meditative Experience
The groundbreaking film has a unique three-part structure that contributed to its meditative experience. The first movement of 2001 is the Dawn of Man, where the use of a bone tool transitions into a shot of a space station. The second focuses on the HAL 9000 computer sequence, and the final movement leads the protagonist into the next stage of human development, featuring almost no dialogue, which creates an immersive viewing experience.
Kubrick's Choice to Leave Extraterrestrials Open to Interpretation
Chuck Bryant notes that Kubrick, working alongside Arthur C. Clarke and with advice from Carl Sagan, made the pivotal decision to leave extraterrestrials unseen and open to interpretation. Kubrick avoided showing extraterrestrials to prevent a misrepresentation influenced by Sagan's input that extraterrestrial life, if it exists, would most likely not be humanoid in form.
2001 Inspired Many Later Sci-fi Films Artistically and Technically
Film's Special Effects Set New Standard For Space Travel Depictions
Kubrick's obsessive attention to detail led him not only to create visual marvels that still feel futuristic but also to destroy all the sets and props after production, cementing 2001’s place as a pinnacle of special effects that could not be easily replicated.
2001's Cerebral Storytelling Challenged Conventional Genre Narratives
Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant further discuss the film's scientific grounding and focused avoidance of actual extraterrestrial beings depicted on scree ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The visionary artistry and impact of 2001: A Space Odyssey
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While "2001: A Space Odyssey" is indeed influential, some critics argue that its pacing is too slow and the narrative too ambiguous, which can alienate viewers used to more conventional storytelling.
- The technical achievements, while groundbreaking for the time, may not seem as impressive to modern audiences accustomed to more advanced CGI and special effects.
- The three-part structure, while unique, can be seen as disjointed or lacking in cohesion, making it difficult for some viewers to follow the film's thematic throughline.
- Kubrick's decision to leave extraterrestrials open to interpretation can be frustrating for viewers who prefer more concrete explanations in their science fiction narratives.
- The film's influence on later sci-fi films is undeniable, but some may argue that it has been surpassed by more recent works that have benefited from technological advancements and more sophisticated storytelling techniques.
- The claim that "2001" set a new standard for space travel depictions might be contested by those who believe that ot ...
Actionables
- You can explore the power of ambiguity in storytelling by writing a short story that leaves key elements open to interpretation, much like the extraterrestrials in "2001: A Space Odyssey." Start with a simple plot and introduce elements that can have multiple meanings. Share your story with friends or on a writing forum and ask for their interpretations to see how ambiguity can enrich a narrative.
- Create a visual art piece using everyday materials to mimic the aesthetics of "2001." For example, use kitchen utensils, foil, and lights to construct a model that captures the essence of the film's space travel depictions. Display your creation in a personal space to remind you of the film's impact on visual standards.
- Engage with the film's meditat ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
