In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, Scott Simon and Andrew Limbong speak with John McWhorter and John Mauceri about the often-overlooked Black influence on Broadway musicals. The conversation explores how American show tunes emerged from the convergence of Black and white artistic traditions, challenging the perception of Broadway as predominantly white entertainment. McWhorter argues that without Black cultural contributions, Broadway music would lack its distinctive character and global appeal.
The episode examines how Broadway addressed racial themes decades before Hollywood, with productions like "South Pacific" and "No Strings" confronting prejudice directly while film studios edited out Black performances to avoid alienating Southern audiences. The discussion also tackles complex questions surrounding cultural authenticity and appropriation, particularly regarding "Porgy and Bess," exploring how art created across racial lines can be both celebrated for its merit and questioned for its origins.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
John McWhorter explains that American show tunes, often perceived as predominantly white entertainment, actually emerged from the convergence of Black and white artistic traditions during the 19th century. He argues that without Black cultural influence, Broadway music would lack its distinctive sound and global appeal—"would be nothing like it is and frankly have no international influence and really wouldn't be as good." McWhorter reframes Broadway as a hybrid art form created by the intersection of disparate musical practices, rather than a purely white form of entertainment.
Scott Simon and Andrew Limbong explore how Broadway confronted racial themes decades before the civil rights movement, while Hollywood avoided them. John Mauceri explains that film studios, driven by commercial motivations, isolated Black performances to avoid alienating Southern audiences. He cites "Cinderella Sue" from "Centennial Summer" being removed entirely for Southern screenings. In contrast, Broadway integrated its casts and narratives from the beginning, forcing audiences to confront race without the possibility of editing out controversial content. Mauceri notes that Hollywood executives prioritized profit over social integrity, censoring Black performances to maintain access to lucrative Southern markets.
Mauceri highlights how "South Pacific" directly addressed racial prejudice through "You've Got to Be Carefully Taught," with Hammerstein proclaiming in 1949 that hate is learned, not innate. By licensing the show to high schools nationwide, Rodgers and Hammerstein helped shape new generations' views on equality, though some critics expressed discomfort with the forthright anti-racism message.
"No Strings" marked a groundbreaking shift by pairing a white male lead with a Black female lead without any plot justification for their different races. Mauceri notes that composer Richard Rodgers intentionally made the pairing seem "just normal," and the absence of critical discussion about race itself revealed a significant societal shift.
"Porgy and Bess" remains one of Broadway's most complex works. McWhorter acknowledges that while questions of appropriation are valid, George Gershwin genuinely immersed himself in African American culture and music. Despite being written by white composers at a time when no Black composer could have received equivalent attention, the opera's artistic greatness has made it "a kind of American" work, massively cherished by Black audiences.
McWhorter argues that "Porgy and Bess" demonstrates how powerful artistry, when embraced by Black audiences, can transcend appropriation concerns and become genuine cultural property. He notes the historical context of racial exclusion made the opera a rare opportunity for Black artists to perform major roles. Yet McWhorter acknowledges the inherent complexity: Gershwin's thorough study resulted in music many viewed as authentic, but from a contemporary perspective sensitive to racial power dynamics, the work could justifiably be seen as exploitative. The evaluation of such art remains deeply context-dependent, shaped by both creative merit and the social realities of their origins.
1-Page Summary
John McWhorter explains that American show tunes, often thought of as a predominantly white enterprise with examples like Hello Dolly, Chess, or Carousel, are actually the result of a convergence between Black and white artistic traditions. He emphasizes that the distinctive sound and quality of Broadway music emerged from the union of African American and European influences during the 19th century.
McWhorter argues that without the presence and influence of Black art forms in the United States, American musical theater would lack the unique sound that has led to its global influence. He states directly that Broadway music “would be nothing like it is and frankly have no international influence and really wouldn’t be as good” without this Black presence. The synergy between the two traditions is crucial to both the excellence and the worldwide appeal of American show music.
Broadway's Musical Roots: The Black and White Art Shaping American Show Music
Scott Simon and Andrew Limbong explore how Broadway musicals confronted racial themes well before the modern civil rights era, offering a contrast to Hollywood’s commercial priorities and reluctance to address segregation and racism.
Scott Simon notes that decades before the modern civil rights movement, Broadway musicals exposed American audiences to integration through story and song. Andrew Limbong, in conversation with Scott Semmon, highlights Broadway’s willingness to directly engage with difficult questions around race, while Hollywood preferred to evade these issues.
John Mauceri explains that Hollywood’s commercial motivations led studios to isolate Black performances when adapting Broadway works or making films. In practice, this meant including a "Black number" in a mostly white musical, only to cut that segment out when screening films in the segregated South. He cites the example of the song "Cinderella Sue," performed by Avon Long in "Centennial Summer," being removed entirely for Southern audiences. This allowed Hollywood to sidestep direct confrontation of racial integration, keeping Black characters in minor, often servile roles such as maids, and eliminating anything that might challenge the status quo.
In contrast, Broadway, according to Mauceri, integrated its casts and narratives from the beginning, which "forced [audiences] to confront" race and racism head-on. Unlike film, theatre audiences witnessed integrated performances and stories about race without the possibility of avoiding or editing out controversial content. This direct engagement positioned Broadway as a cultural space willing to challenge prevailing social norms far earlier ...
Broadway's Tackling of Race and Racism vs. Hollywood's Avoidance
Oscar Hammerstein directly addresses the roots of racial prejudice in “South Pacific” with the song “You’ve Got to Be Carefully Taught.” John Mauceri highlights that, in the climax of Act II, Hammerstein puts into words what had otherwise remained unspoken until 1949: prejudice is not innate but learned. The song argues, “Children are really race-free, but you have to be carefully taught,” and starkly proclaims that hate is passed on by one’s family and society. Lines like “You’ve got to be taught before it’s too late, before you are six or seven or eight, to hate all the people your relatives hate,” underscore this message.
The impact of “South Pacific” extended beyond Broadway. Rodgers and Hammerstein licensed the show to schools across the United States, including high schools. Mauceri recounts how, as a high school freshman and rehearsal pianist, he witnessed young people across the country learning and absorbing these anti-racist values through participation in the musical. By making the material accessible to youth, the show helped shape new generations’ views on equality.
Not everyone was comfortable with Broadway’s direct challenge to racist attitudes. After the show’s debut, some critics and figures expressed unease with the forthright anti-racism message, revealing both the power of “South Pacific” and the discomfort that can arise from confronting prejudice on a public stage.
“No Strings” marked a groundbreaking change in Broadway’s depiction of interracial relationships. Scott Simon asks about the casting in the musical, and John Mauceri clarifies that the male lead was white (Richard Kiley) and the female lead was Black (Diahann Carroll). The show did not specify the race of either the writer or the fashion model characters. Composer Richard Rodgers intentionally crafted the roles so that the pairing would seem “just normal,” avoiding any plot justification or comment on their different races.
Mauceri notes that, while a couple of critics pointed out the interracial relationship wasn’t yet normalized in real society, many critics and audiences did not address the racial implications at all. Some avoided the topic out of fear or discomfort, while for others, the presentation felt so matter-of-fact that commentary seemed unnecessary or irrelevant. John McWhorter observes that this absence of discussion itself reveals a significant societal shift—or resistance to confronting realities about race on stage.
“Porgy and Bess,” composed by George and Ira Gershwin and DuBose Heyward, is widely rega ...
Racially Themed Musicals: "South Pacific," "No Strings," "Porgy and Bess"
McWhorter describes "Porgy and Bess" as some of the most beautiful and titanic music ever written, noted for being massively cherished by Black audiences—even his own mother. He states that, despite being written by white men, the work's artistic greatness elevates it beyond simple criticism of appropriation and positions it as a distinctly American creation. McWhorter argues that a work like "Porgy and Bess" shows how powerful artistry, when embraced by Black audiences, can transcend appropriation concerns and become cultural property genuinely valued within the Black community.
McWhorter specifically highlights how the enduring embrace of "Porgy and Bess" by Black audiences demonstrates the possibility for a work originally created outside the community to later be adopted and deeply valued as part of Black cultural heritage.
McWhorter notes the historical context in which "Porgy and Bess" was written, emphasizing that at the time, Black creators could not have received similar opportunities or recognition in American musical theater, however talented they were. This context makes the opera a rare and unique opportunity for Black artists of that era to perform major roles on significant stages.
Cultural Authenticity and Appropriation in White Artists' Portrayals of Black Experience
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
