'How to Commit a Postcolonial Murder' is a dark new novel about sisterhood
In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, Nina McConigley discusses her novel about two biracial sisters growing up in Wyoming and their complex relationship shaped by family trauma. The story follows Georgie and Agatha, who at ages 12 and 14 make a decisive choice regarding their abusive uncle—a choice that affects their relationship for years to come.
The discussion examines how the sisters navigate their dual Indian-American identity while feeling like outsiders in both cultures. McConigley connects their personal experiences to broader themes of colonialism, exploring how historical exploitation manifests in family dynamics, cultural displacement, and generational trauma. The sisters' story becomes a lens through which to view the lasting impacts of colonial experiences on identity and belonging.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 4, 2026 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Sisterhood and Family Dynamics
In Nina McConigley's novel, sisters Georgie Iyer Creel and Agatha Krishna share a complex bond shaped by trauma. The story focuses on a pivotal summer when Georgie was 12 and Agatha was 14, during which they made a critical decision regarding their abusive uncle. Their relationship develops against the backdrop of a close-knit but neglectful family, where their mother's blind devotion to her abusive brother creates additional tension.
Identity and Belonging As Indian-Americans
McConigley explores the sisters' struggles with their biracial identity through the concept of "half-sees." Growing up in White Marley, Wyoming, neither sister feels fully accepted as American or Indian. The author draws from her own experiences as a biracial individual to portray the complexities of navigating dual cultural identities.
Trauma, Abuse, and the Sisters' Response
The sisters' story centers on their response to sexual abuse by their uncle. Rather than confiding in their parents, they devise a plot to murder their uncle, driven by shame, fear, and a desperate need to end the abuse. This decision leaves them grappling with guilt and creates lasting strain on their relationship.
Colonialism and Its Lasting Impacts
McConigley's title, "How to Commit a Post-Colonial Murder," connects personal struggles with historical exploitation. The sisters' pursuit of justice against their uncle mirrors colonial exploitation within their family's legacy. Their biracial identity and complex family dynamics symbolize the broader impacts of colonialism, including cultural displacement and generational trauma. The author weaves together various forms of separation, from geopolitical divisions to personal identity splits, highlighting the lasting effects of colonial experiences.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore your family history to better understand your own identity by creating a family tree that includes not just names and dates but also stories, cultural backgrounds, and personal anecdotes. This can help you see the broader context of your family's experiences and how they may have shaped your own perspectives and identity.
- Write a short story or personal essay that weaves together elements of your cultural heritage and personal experiences, similar to how the author used her biracial identity in her storytelling. This can be a cathartic way to process your own feelings about identity and belonging, and it can also be shared with friends or family to foster deeper understanding.
- Start a journal where you reflect on instances where you've felt tension between different aspects of your identity, much like the characters did with their Indian-American heritage. Use these reflections to identify patterns, triggers, and coping mechanisms that you can apply in your daily life to navigate complex identity issues with greater awareness and self-compassion.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Sisterhood and Family Dynamics
In Nina McConigley's novel, the central theme revolves around the bond between sisters Georgie Iyer Creel and Agatha Krishna, which is both fortified and tested through their shared trauma.
Sisters Georgie and Agatha Krishna Bond Through Trauma
The Novel Explores the Sisters' Struggle With Their Decision's Aftermath Against Their Abusive Uncle, Uniting and Dividing Them
The story delves into a pivotal summer from Georgie’s perspective when she was 12 and Agatha Krishna was 14, which laid the groundwork for a critical decision they made concerning their abusive uncle. This traumatic event serves as the focal point of the novel, exploring how this shared experience both unifies and separates the sisters. As Georgie and Agatha Krishna navigate the aftermath of their actions, they struggle with feelings of guilt and the challenge of reconciling with each other.
Sisters' Bond Shaped by Close-Knit, Neglectful Family
The Mother's Adoration of Her Abusive Brother Creates Family Tension and Conflict for the Sisters to Navigate
McConigley’s narrative sheds light on the complex family dynamics that shap ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Sisterhood and Family Dynamics
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Reflect on your own family dynamics by journaling about past events that have shaped your relationships. Write down specific instances that have either brought you closer to or created distance between you and your siblings or family members. This can help you understand the complexities of your own familial bonds and identify areas where you might seek reconciliation or set boundaries.
- Create a 'sisterhood pact' with your sibling or a close friend where you both commit to supporting each other through personal challenges. This pact could include regular check-ins, a promise to listen without judgment, and a mutual agreement to encourage personal growth and healing. It's a way to formalize the support system that can be crucial during tough t ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Identity and Belonging As Indian-Americans
Georgie and Agatha Krishna, as characters embodying the biracial experience, confront the complexities of identity and belonging within both Indian and American cultures.
Georgie's Remarks Subvert Indian-American Identity Stereotypes
"Half-Sees": The Sisters' Struggle For Acceptance in America and India
The term 'half-sees' aptly captures the struggle for acceptance that Georgie and Agatha Krishna face as Indian-Americans. They feel a pinch of resentment towards their parents' decision to marry outside of their respective cultures, which has resulted in the sisters being biracial.
Sisters' Mixed Heritage and Upbringing in White Marley, Wyoming, Shape Their Identity
Exploring Complexities of Dual Cultural Identities in Indian and American Societies
Underlining their dichotomous identity, Georgie expresses that they are not fully embraced as American in their home state of Wyoming, nor are they accepted a ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Identity and Belonging As Indian-Americans
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can create a personal identity map to visually represent and explore your own cultural influences and how they intersect. Draw a large circle on a piece of paper and divide it into sections that represent different aspects of your identity, such as ethnicity, nationality, language, traditions, and values. In each section, write down your experiences and feelings related to that aspect. This exercise can help you understand and appreciate the complexity of your own identity, similar to how Georgie and Agatha navigate their biracial experiences.
- Start a cultural exchange diary with someone from a different background to foster mutual understanding and acceptance. Find a partner who is interested in exploring cultural identities, and agree to exchange weekly diary entries discussing your cultural practices, challenges, and insights. This can be a friend, a colleague, or an online pen pal. The goal is to create a safe space for sharing and to learn from each other's experiences, which can lead to a deeper appreciation of the complexities faced by individuals with mixed heritage. ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Trauma, Abuse, and the Sisters' Response
Two sisters embark on a harrowing journey of trauma, revenge, and the struggle to cope with the fallout of their actions after enduring sexual abuse at the hands of their uncle.
Sisters Seek Revenge Against Abusive Uncle After Enduring Sexual Abuse
Impact of Uncle's Abuse on Sisters: Shame, Fear, Conflicted Loyalty
Sexual abuse lies at the heart of why the sisters choose to resort to extreme measures. Bound by a heavy blanket of shame and fear, the sisters decide against confiding in their parents, understanding all too well the potential repercussions on their family dynamics, which could range from disbelief to dismantling the family unit.
Sisters' Plot to Murder Uncle Shows Desperate Bid to End Abuse
They find themselves ensnared in a complex web of emotions, not least of which is a sense of loyalty to their family, despite the trauma inflicted upon them by one of its members. This conflict feeds into their desperate resolve as they orchestrate a plot to murder their uncle, aiming to halt the abuse once and for all.
Examining Consequences: Trauma and Strain On Sisters' Relationship
In the aftermath of their plot against "Vinnie Uncle," the sisters are left to grapple with a suffocating legacy of guilt and trauma. The act of murder, ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Trauma, Abuse, and the Sisters' Response
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Create a safe space journal where you can express feelings of shame or fear without judgment. Start by choosing a private notebook or digital document that is password protected. Write down your emotions, thoughts, and experiences related to any personal trauma or difficult situation you're facing. This can be a cathartic way to process feelings without the fear of them being exposed to others.
- Develop a personal code of ethics to navigate conflicting loyalties. Take some time to reflect on your values and write them down. Consider scenarios where these values might be challenged, and plan how you would act in those situations. This exercise can help you make decisions that align with your integrity, especially when faced with difficult family dynamics.
- Engage in role-playing e ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Colonialism and Its Lasting Impacts
In "How to Commit a Post-Colonial Murder," the intertwining of personal struggles with historical exploitation reveals the enduring impact of colonialism on individual lives and family legacies.
Title Explores Links Between Colonialism and Characters' Personal Struggles
Nina McConigley's novel delves deep into the effects of colonialism by connecting it to the intimate aspects of its characters’ lives. The title itself cleverly layers the theme of colonialism with the personal lives of the characters, suggesting a parallel between colonial exploitation and the violation the sisters experienced, feeling powerless over their own bodies due to abuse.
Sisters' Pursuit of Justice Against Their Uncle Reflects Colonial Exploitation Within Their Family's Legacy
The sisters ultimately blame both the British colonial legacy and their predatory Uncle Vinnie for their suffering, revealing a broader context in which personal vendettas symbolize historical injustices and exploitation. The title "How to Commit a Post-Colonial Murder" specifically hints at this quest for justice, which reflects colonial exploitation in the family's history.
Colonialism's Aftereffects, Such as Cultural Displacement and Generational Trauma, Shape the Sisters' Worldview and Actions
The mother's struggle with adjusting to life in Wyoming serves as an example of cultural displacement resulting from the legacy of colonialism. Generational trauma manif ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Colonialism and Its Lasting Impacts
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore your family history to understand personal connections to larger historical events. Start by talking with older relatives about their experiences and how they may have been shaped by historical events like colonialism. Document these stories in a journal or a digital archive to reflect on how your family's past may influence your own perspectives and identity.
- Create a book club focused on post-colonial literature to gain insights into the experiences of others. Choose novels and memoirs that delve into the effects of colonialism on personal lives, similar to McConigley's work. Use these discussions to draw parallels to your own life experiences and to deepen your understanding of the lingering impacts of colonialism.
- Write a personal essay or a short story that weaves hist ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
