Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan on 'Remain,' their supernatural romance novel
In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan discuss their collaboration on a novel that blends romance with supernatural elements. The two creators, who typically work in different genres, share their experiences of developing a story together from its inception, rather than following the traditional model of adapting a completed novel for the screen.
The conversation explores how their creative partnership came about through their agents and how they maintained their distinct artistic approaches while working on a shared narrative. Sparks and Shyamalan describe their shared commitment to character development and explain how their collaborative process allowed each creator to contribute equally to the project, marking a departure from typical novel-to-film adaptations.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 26, 2026 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Origins and Circumstances of the Sparks-Shyamalan Collaboration
An unexpected creative partnership emerged when the agents of Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan initiated their introduction. Despite their contrasting backgrounds—Sparks in romance novels and Shyamalan in psychological thrillers—the two creators discovered shared approaches to storytelling. According to Sparks, such successful collaborations between different genres are rare in the industry, making their partnership particularly unique.
Blending two Creators' Genres and Styles
While Shyamalan is primarily known for supernatural thrillers, he reveals an early connection to romance, having written his first Hollywood screenplay in the genre and even being considered to adapt "The Notebook" at age 25. Both creators share a deep commitment to character development, with Sparks particularly admiring Shyamalan's ability to craft compelling character journeys. In their collaborative process, Sparks wrote the novel while Shyamalan directed the screen adaptation, allowing each to maintain their distinct creative vision while working within a shared narrative.
Unique Nature of Co-creation
Leila Fadel highlights how this collaboration differs from typical novel-to-film adaptations. Rather than following the traditional model where filmmakers take control after a novel's completion, Sparks and Shyamalan developed the story together from the beginning. Sparks notes that while his previous novel adaptations were typically filmmaker-controlled, this partnership offered equal creative input from both parties. Their collaboration, built on mutual trust and aligned artistic sensibilities, resulted in a cohesive narrative that successfully blends their distinct styles.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Nicholas Sparks is a bestselling author known for writing popular romance novels like "The Notebook" and "A Walk to Remember." M. Night Shyamalan is a filmmaker famous for directing psychological thrillers with supernatural elements, such as "The Sixth Sense" and "Unbreakable." Both have significantly influenced their genres, with Sparks shaping modern romance literature and Shyamalan redefining suspenseful storytelling in film. Their collaboration is notable because it bridges two distinct creative worlds.
- Romance novels focus on the emotional and romantic relationships between characters, often emphasizing love, passion, and personal growth. Psychological thrillers explore the mental and emotional states of characters, creating suspense through mind games, mystery, and complex psychological conflicts. These thrillers often involve tension, fear, and unexpected plot twists that challenge perceptions of reality. Both genres prioritize character development but differ in tone and narrative style.
- Typically, novel-to-film adaptations involve filmmakers acquiring rights after a book is completed, then independently interpreting the story for the screen. The author often has limited involvement or creative control during the film's production. This can lead to significant changes from the original novel's tone or plot. In contrast, Sparks and Shyamalan collaborated from the story's inception, sharing creative input throughout both the novel and film development.
- "The Notebook" is one of Nicholas Sparks' most famous and successful romance novels, widely credited with popularizing his work. The novel was adapted into a highly acclaimed film in 2004, which became a cultural touchstone in the romance genre. M. Night Shyamalan being considered to adapt it early in his career highlights his initial interest in romance storytelling. This connection underscores the unexpected common ground between Sparks and Shyamalan despite their different primary genres.
- Character development refers to the process of creating a detailed, believable personality for a character, showing their traits, motivations, and changes over time. A character journey is the transformation or growth a character undergoes throughout the story, often influenced by challenges and experiences. This journey helps audiences connect emotionally and understand the character’s decisions and growth. Effective character development and journeys make stories more engaging and meaningful.
- Agents act as intermediaries who represent creators and seek opportunities to advance their careers. They use their industry connections to identify potential collaborations and partnerships. By introducing clients to each other, agents facilitate creative projects that might not occur otherwise. Their role includes negotiating terms and ensuring both parties' interests are aligned.
- Collaborations between creators from different genres are rare because each genre has distinct conventions, audience expectations, and storytelling techniques. Combining these can create creative tension and require careful balancing to satisfy both styles. Industry professionals often prefer sticking to familiar genre boundaries to minimize risk. Successful cross-genre partnerships demand strong mutual understanding and flexibility.
- A "distinct creative vision" refers to an individual's unique perspective, style, and ideas in storytelling. In collaboration, it means each creator contributes their own approach without losing their personal artistic identity. This allows the final work to reflect a blend of different strengths and viewpoints. Maintaining distinct visions helps preserve originality while fostering innovation through partnership.
- Leila Fadel is a journalist known for her work in cultural and social reporting. She often covers stories related to arts and media collaborations. Her relevance here is as an external observer providing insight into the uniqueness of the Sparks-Shyamalan partnership. Her perspective adds credibility to the discussion of their collaborative process.
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Origins and Circumstances of the Sparks-Shyamalan Collaboration
Agents Initiate Unlikely Creator Pairings
In a Hollywood tale as intriguing as their ensuing work, the collaboration between Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan came to be through the connective actions of their agents.
Hollywood Connection Sparks Collaboration; Idea From Shyamalan's Agent
It all began when Shyamalan's agent in Los Angeles, familiar with someone from Blinding Edge Pictures, proposed that Shyamalan and Sparks should meet. The idea for the two storytellers to join forces emerged from the belief that they could create something valuable together.
Despite Their Incongruous Past Genres, Sparks and Shyamalan Found Similarities in Their Storytelling Approaches
Although Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan hail from very different genres—Sparks is known for romance novels turned films, while Shyamalan is renowned for his psychological thrillers—they found common ground in the ways they bring stories to life.
Rare Occurrence, Hard to Replicate
Sparks & Shyamalan: Unique Collaboration and Dynamic
According to Sparks, it's not common for s ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Origins and Circumstances of the Sparks-Shyamalan Collaboration
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can explore cross-genre collaboration by partnering with someone whose work you admire but is in a different field. For example, if you're a writer who focuses on science fiction, reach out to a local artist who specializes in historical paintings. Propose a project where you write a short story inspired by one of their pieces, and they create an artwork based on your narrative. This can lead to a unique blend of ideas and possibly a joint exhibition or publication.
- Enhance your networking strategy by connecting with professionals who have complementary skills and interests. Start by making a list of qualities or skills you're looking for in a collaborator, such as creativity or a different perspective. Use social media platforms like LinkedIn to search for individuals who fit this profile, and then initiate conversations with them about potential collaborative projects. This could be as simple as co-authoring a blog post or as complex as starting a new business venture together.
- Build trust with potential coll ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Blending two Creators' Genres and Styles: Process and Challenges
Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan, two prolific creators known for their distinct storytelling styles, have taken on the unique challenge of blending their talents to produce a single narrative.
Sparks and Shyamalan Combined Their Distinct Styles
Sparks and Shyamalan are recognized for their genre-specific contributions, with Sparks being synonymous with romantic dramas, and Shyamalan with supernatural thrillers.
Sparks Is Known For Dramas; Shyamalan For Thrillers
Shyamalan, though known for his work in the supernatural thriller genre, revealed an interesting tidbit from his past: his first Hollywood screenplay was a romance, and he was even approached to adapt "The Notebook" when he was 25.
Creators Prioritize Strong Characters and Engaging Story Arcs
Both Sparks and Shyamalan have a high regard for the art of character development. Sparks, in particular, admires Shyamalan's adeptness at crafting strong character journeys. They prioritize the depiction of real people and the creation of engaging story arcs to keep the audience engaged, whether the audience is flicking through pages or watching on a screen.
Creators Co-writing to Imprint On Shared Narrative
Sparks Wrote the Novel; Shyamalan Directed the Adaptation, Yielding Distinct Interpretations
After coming up with a story together, Nicholas Sparks went on to wri ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Blending two Creators' Genres and Styles: Process and Challenges
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Collaborate with someone who has a different creative style to write a short story or script. By combining your unique perspectives, you can create a narrative that has elements of both your styles, much like a romantic drama with a supernatural twist. For example, if you enjoy writing science fiction and your partner prefers mystery, work together to craft a story that involves a mysterious alien encounter.
- Develop a character-driven narrative in your next creative project, focusing on the emotional journey of the characters. Whether you're writing a novel, a screenplay, or even a role-playing game, ensure that the characters have depth and evolve throughout the story. You could start by outlining each character's backstory, motivations, and how they will change by the end of the narrative.
- Experiment with writing a story where ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Unique Nature of Co-creation For Novel and Film
Leila Fadel brings to light the rare and synergistic collaborative process between Nicholas Sparks and M. Night Shyamalan for their novel and film project.
Collaborative Process Between Sparks and Shyamalan Was Unprecedented
Unlike typical adaptations where the filmmaker takes over after a novel's completion, both Sparks and Shyamalan developed a story together, thus highlighting an innovative co-creative approach.
Sparks' Novel Adaptations Had Filmmakers In Control
Sparks recalls that traditionally, filmmakers would control the adaptation process of his novels, but this alliance stands out as an exception with both parties having an equal creative say from the beginning.
Shyamalan Frustrated With Directors Not Realizing His Vision
Shyamalan opens up about his past frustrations where directors misunderstood his vision. However, with Sparks, he found a trustful relationship without such frustrations.
Sparks and Shyamalan's Remain Project Fostered Trust and Alignment
Their unique collaboration fostered a hard-to-replicate dynamic, resulting from mutual trust and an alignment of artistic sensibilities.
Difficult-to-replicate Creative Partnership
Sparks underscores the distinctive quality of ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Unique Nature of Co-creation For Novel and Film
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While the collaboration between Sparks and Shyamalan is presented as unique, it is not the only instance of authors and filmmakers working closely together from a project's inception; other creative partnerships may also have involved a similar level of co-creation.
- The assertion that the partnership is difficult to replicate might overlook the potential for other artists to form equally successful and harmonious collaborations, given the right circumstances and mutual understanding.
- The idea that the co-creation yielded a cohesive narrative that perfectly balances both creators' styles assumes that the integration of their sensibilities was seamless, which may not account for the complexities and potential compromises inherent in any collaborative artistic process.
- The novelty of the collaboration is emphasized, but it is possible that other adaptations, while not publicized as such, have involved a similar level of cooperation and mutual influence between the author and filmmaker.
- The suggestion that Shyamalan's past frustrations with directors not realizing his vision ...
Actionables
- You can seek a creative partner with a different skill set to co-develop a project, ensuring both parties are involved from the outset. Start by identifying your strengths and interests, then look for someone whose abilities complement yours but differ enough to bring a new perspective. For example, if you're a writer, partner with a visual artist to create a graphic novel, where both of you brainstorm the storyline and characters together, blending narrative and visual elements from the beginning.
- Establish a mutual feedback loop with a collaborator to maintain trust and alignment. Set up regular check-ins where you and your partner openly discuss progress, share ideas, and address any concerns. This could be as simple as weekly coffee meetings or virtual calls where you both present what you've worked on and give constructive feedback, ensuring that both visions are respected and integrated.
- Document your collaborative process through a shared digital jour ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
