Dorie Greenspan and Paul Hollywood discuss their new and nourishing cake cookbooks
In this NPR's Book of the Day episode, bakers Dorie Greenspan and Paul Hollywood discuss their latest cookbooks and approaches to cake baking. Greenspan's "Anytime Cakes" focuses on straightforward homemade cakes organized by shape, while Hollywood's "Celebrate" explores baking traditions and the social aspects of creating cakes with family and friends.
The conversation delves into specific recipes, baking techniques, and the cultural differences between American and British baking. Both authors share practical tips for home bakers, from proper oven preparation to fruit handling, while highlighting the evolution of baking skills across both countries. The discussion also touches on the importance of following recipes precisely before attempting variations, along with insights into translating baking terms between US and UK audiences.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 26, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Dorie Greenspan's "Anytime Cakes" for Simple, Homemade Cakes
Renowned baker Dorie Greenspan's latest book, "Dorie's Anytime Cakes," emphasizes comfortable, homemade cakes over elaborate creations. The book is organized by cake shapes—round, cornered, loaf, and Bundt—and features both classic recipes and creative variations, like her matcha latte cake with coconut milk.
Greenspan's and Hollywood's Cake Recipes & Techniques
Greenspan's approach focuses on easily assembled cakes, such as her marble Bundt cake and Texas sheet cake. She shares essential tips, including thorough oven preheating and proper fruit preparation. Meanwhile, Paul Hollywood brings his own perspective to baking, combining traditional British recipes with modern twists, exemplified by his innovative "Hollywood Hot Dog" creation.
Paul Hollywood's "Celebrate" and His Baking Philosophy
In "Celebrate," Hollywood emphasizes the importance of baking with family and friends. He shares personal stories of baking with his son and discusses traditional celebrations, including the British harvest tradition of making wheat sheaf bread. The book features his signature recipes, including his famous "bake-off chocolate cake" topped with Maltesers.
US vs. UK Baking Differences and Similarities
Greenspan notes that American bakers are quickly catching up to their British counterparts in skill level, while Hollywood looks forward to hosting a two-country baking competition between the US and UK. The discussion highlights the challenges of translating baking terms across cultures, with Hollywood emphasizing the importance of following recipes precisely before experimenting with variations.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Dorie Greenspan's focus on comfortable, homemade cakes is appealing, some bakers might argue that the artistry and challenge of creating elaborate cakes are what make baking exciting and rewarding.
- Organizing recipes by cake shape is practical, but it could be limiting for those who want to adapt recipes to different shapes or sizes based on their available bakeware or occasion needs.
- Creative variations like a matcha latte cake with coconut milk may not appeal to all tastes, and some traditionalists might prefer sticking to classic flavors.
- The emphasis on easily assembled cakes might overlook the educational value that comes from tackling more complex baking projects, which can improve a baker's skills.
- Essential baking tips like thorough oven preheating and proper fruit preparation are useful, but experienced bakers might be looking for more advanced techniques and tips to elevate their baking.
- Paul Hollywood's combination of traditional British recipes with modern twists could be seen as less authentic by purists who value traditional methods and recipes.
- Innovative recipes such as the "Hollywood Hot Dog" might not resonate with everyone, especially those with a preference for classic baking.
- The idea of baking with family and friends is heartwarming, but not everyone has the opportunity or desire to bake in a social setting, preferring instead to bake as a solitary activity.
- The concept of a US vs. UK baking competition, while exciting, might reinforce stereotypes or create unnecessary rivalry between the two baking cultures, rather than promoting a mutual appreciation for different baking styles.
- The challenges of translating baking terms across cultures are real, but some bakers might find this process enriching and a way to learn about other baking traditions.
- Hollywood's stress on following recipes precisely might discourage creativity and experimentation in less experienced bakers who could learn from making adjustments and trying new things.
Actionables
- You can start a "Shape of the Month" baking challenge where you focus on mastering cakes of different shapes each month, like round in January, loaf in February, and so on, to improve your baking skills and add variety to your homemade desserts.
- This approach allows you to gradually expand your baking repertoire and get comfortable with various cake forms. For example, in January, you might try different round cake recipes, experimenting with flavors and techniques, and then move on to loaf cakes, exploring different ingredients and textures.
- Organize a "Bake and Share" event with friends or family where each person brings a homemade cake inspired by a traditional recipe with their own twist, encouraging creativity and sharing baking experiences.
- This could be a monthly gathering where everyone gets to taste different cakes and discuss the modifications they made to the traditional recipes. For instance, someone might bring a classic Victoria sponge cake but with a lavender-infused cream, while another might make a chocolate cake with a spicy chili twist.
- Create a "Baking Terms Lexicon" where you compile a list of baking terms from different cultures and their equivalents, which can be a fun and educational project to better understand and appreciate the diversity in baking.
- This lexicon could be a physical notebook or a digital document where you write down terms you come across in recipes, along with their definitions and equivalents in other cultures. For example, you might note that "caster sugar" in the UK is known as "superfine sugar" in the US, or that "cornflour" in the UK is "cornstarch" in the US.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Dorie Greenspan's "Anytime Cakes" for Simple, Homemade Cakes
Dorie Greenspan, known for her expertise in the baking world, has a special preference for comforting, homemade cakes over elaborate creations, as expressed in her book, "Dorie's Anytime Cakes."
Greenspan's Preference for Comforting Cakes Over Elaborate Creations
Dorie Greenspan has earned renown not just for her skill but for her baking philosophy, which she describes as making something delicious by hand to share with loved ones. This sentiment evokes a sense of homeliness and warmth, steering away from her previous ventures into extravagant and nerve-racking projects like meticulously designed wedding cakes or whimsical yet intricate creations such as Darth Vader sculptures.
The Structure and Contents of "Dory's Anytime Cakes"
Book Organization by Cake Type: Round, Cornered, Loaf, Bundt
Robin Young notes that "Dorie's Anytime Cakes" is methodically organized into chapters based on the cake shapes: round cakes, cakes with corners, loaf cakes, and Bundt cakes. This structured approach allows readers to easily navigate through the variety of simple yet delightful cake options suitable for any time.
Greenspan Features Classic Cake Recipes and Creative Twists On Favorites
In her book, Greenspan presents ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Dorie Greenspan's "Anytime Cakes" for Simple, Homemade Cakes
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Greenspan's preference for simple cakes is clear, some bakers might argue that the artistry and challenge of elaborate creations are equally rewarding and should not be undervalued.
- The emphasis on homeliness and warmth might not resonate with everyone; some individuals may bake for artistic expression or professional development rather than to evoke a sense of comfort.
- Organizing a cookbook by cake shape might be intuitive for some, but others might prefer a categorization based on flavor profiles, ingredients, or occasion.
- While the book aims to provide simple and delightful options, some readers might find that even "simple" recipes can be intimidating or too time-consuming for true "anytime" baking.
- The balance between classic and inventive recipes is subjective, and some bakers might feel that the book leans too much towards one side or the other, depending on their personal taste or baking ex ...
Actionables
- Start a "Cake Swap" group with friends or neighbors to share homemade cakes and recipes. Each member bakes a cake from a simple recipe and meets monthly to exchange their creations, fostering a sense of community and allowing everyone to taste different homemade cakes.
- Create a "Bake It Yours" journal to document personal twists on classic cake recipes. Whenever you bake, jot down any ingredient swaps or creative additions you make, such as using almond extract instead of vanilla or adding fruit layers to a loaf cake. This will help you develop your own signature cakes over time.
- Organize ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Greenspan's and Hollywood's Cake Recipes & Techniques
Cooking enthusiasts rejoice as insights into the sweet world of baking are shared, with different approaches by culinary figures like Dori Greenspan and Paul Hollywood taken into consideration.
Greenspan's Emphasis on Easy-To-make, Approachable Cakes
Greenspan's latest book, "Dori's Anytime Cakes," is all about simple, "homey" cakes that are both easy to assemble and delightful to taste.
Quickly Assembled Cakes: Marble Bundt and Texas Sheet
Producer Karen Millen-Meadson made a marble bundt cake from Greenspan's book, which typifies the theme of quickly assembled cakes. Greenspan explains the batter is marbled by layering scoops of chocolate and vanilla batter and swirling them with a knife. The Texas sheet cake, another of Greenspan's offerings, is a large, crowd-feeding cake that's unique in that it gets frosted while still warm.
Greenspan's Tips: Preheating and Preparing Fruit
Greenspan's focus extends to key baking tips. For instance, when making a visiting cake, she incorporated rum-soaked raisins and apples, illustrating the hand-mixing method and the importance of experiencing the aroma of ingredients. She emphasizes the need to let cakes cool before icing, to preheat the oven thoroughly, and to plump the fruit by soaking it in hot water before adding it to a cake.
Hollywood's Take On British Baked Goods and Modern Recipes
Paul Hollywood is known for his takes on British baked goods and adding modern twists to time-honored recipes.
Classics Like Chelsea Buns, Wheat Sheaf Bread, and Inventive "Hollywood Hot Dog"
Although not explicitly mentioned in the transcript, Hollywood is famed for his classics like Chelsea buns and Wheat Sheaf bread. ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Greenspan's and Hollywood's Cake Recipes & Techniques
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Greenspan's emphasis on easy-to-make cakes is appealing, some bakers might argue that more complex recipes can lead to more rewarding and unique creations.
- The technique of marbling batter for a marble bundt cake, as described by Greenspan, might be seen as too simplistic for experienced bakers looking for a challenge.
- The Texas sheet cake being frosted while warm could be criticized by some as potentially leading to a less aesthetically pleasing finish compared to letting the cake cool completely first.
- Preheating the oven is a standard practice, but some might argue that certain recipes or ovens may require a more nuanced approach to temperature management.
- Soaking fruit in hot water before adding it to cakes is a useful tip, but some bakers might prefer other methods, such as macerating fruit in sugar or alcohol to impart different flavors.
- Paul Hollywood's traditional British baked goods might not appeal to those who prefer more international or innovative flavors.
- The "Hollywood Hot ...
Actionables
- You can experiment with flavor infusions in simple cake recipes by adding extracts, spices, or zests to the batter. For instance, if you're making a vanilla cake, try adding almond extract or lemon zest to give it a unique twist. This allows you to personalize your baking without altering the fundamental recipe.
- Create a "mix-in" station for your next baking project to encourage customization and creativity. Set out bowls of nuts, chocolate chips, dried fruits, or candy pieces that can be added to a basic batter or dough. This way, you and your family or guests can have fun creating your own versions of classic recipes.
- Try using a slow cooker to warm ingredients l ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Paul Hollywood's "Celebrate" and His Baking Philosophy in Family Traditions
Hollywood's Goal: Inspire Readers to Bake With Loved Ones
Paul Hollywood emphasizes the joy that comes from baking with family and friends. Through "Celebrate," he aims to inspire readers not just to bake but to make it an engaging and fun activity shared with loved ones.
Baking With His Son: Joyful Memories
Reflecting on personal experiences, Hollywood recalls how he once gave his young son a choice between playing video games and baking. His son chose to spend time baking with his dad, creating a lasting memory of bonding over the shared activity.
Baking To Mark Occasions and Celebrate Seasons
Hollywood speaks about celebrations tied to specific times of the year, such as the end of September and the beginning of October in the UK, which is akin to the US Thanksgiving. During this period, he used to make wheat sheaves out of bread to celebrate the wheat harvest.
Hollywood's Own Favorite Baked Goods Featured In "Celebrate"
Signature Recipes: Bake Off and Decadent Chocolate Cakes
"Celebrate" is a compilation of Hollywood's favorite recipes throughout the year, including the "bake-off chocolate cake." He shares his passion for a good chocolate sponge, which he belie ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Paul Hollywood's "Celebrate" and His Baking Philosophy in Family Traditions
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Hollywood's goal is to inspire baking with loved ones, some readers may not have family or friends nearby, making this aspect of his philosophy less accessible to them.
- The emphasis on baking as a family activity might inadvertently overlook or undervalue the therapeutic and meditative aspects of baking alone for some individuals.
- The association of baking with specific seasonal celebrations may not resonate with readers from different cultural backgrounds or those who do not follow traditional seasonal festivities.
- The focus on decadent and rich recipes like the "bake-off chocolate cake" might not align with the dietary preferences or restrictions of all readers, such as those looking for healthier or allergen-free options.
- The ornamental aspe ...
Actionables
- Start a family baking challenge where each member picks a recipe they've never tried before to bake together on weekends. This encourages bonding and creates a playful competition that can become a cherished weekly event. For example, you might choose a theme like "desserts from around the world" and each week, a different family member selects a country whose dessert they'd like to bake, allowing everyone to explore new cultures and flavors together.
- Create a seasonal baking calendar that aligns with local agricultural events or produce availability. Use this calendar to plan baking activities that celebrate these occasions, such as making strawberry shortcakes during strawberry season or apple pies in the fall. This not only connects you with the rhythms of nature but also ensures that you're using the freshest ingredients available.
- Organize a "bake it forward" initiative in your community, wh ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Us vs. Uk Baking Differences and Similarities
Differences between US and UK baking are often a source of confusion and fascination, as highlighted by the insights of famed bakers Greenspan and Hollywood.
Greenspan and Hollywood on Rising Skills of American Bakers
Greenspan: Us Closes Gap With Uk In Baking Prowess
Greenspan acknowledges that American bakers are rapidly closing the gap with their UK counterparts in terms of baking prowess. This observation marks a significant shift, considering the long-held belief that British bakers traditionally held a firm lead in the craft.
Hollywood to Host Two-country Baking Competition
Paul Hollywood expresses his enthusiasm about the idea of a two-country baking competition between the US and UK, showcasing the skills of bakers from both sides of the Atlantic. This reflects an acknowledgment of the rising skills of American bakers and sets the stage for an exciting international culinary showdown.
Translating Baking Terms: Us vs. Uk Challenges
The challenge of translating baking terms from one side of the Atlantic to the other is a common hurdle for bakers. For example, what Americans know as "pancakes" are referred to as "flak jacks" in the UK, but British flapjacks are actually oat squares. Moreover, the term "pudding" can be a source of confusion, as it usually denotes a creamy milk-based dessert se ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Us vs. Uk Baking Differences and Similarities
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The perception of a gap in baking skills between American and British bakers may be subjective and vary depending on specific baking traditions or techniques.
- The idea that British bakers have traditionally held a firm lead may overlook the contributions and innovations of American bakers in certain areas of baking.
- A two-country baking competition, while exciting, may not fully represent the diversity and range of baking skills present within each country.
- The challenges in translating baking terms are not unique to the US and UK; such challenges exist between many countries with different culinary traditions and languages.
- The term "flak jacks" is not commonly used in the UK or the US; the correct term for American pancakes in the UK is simply "pancakes," and "flapjacks" in the UK are indeed oat squares, which could lead to confusion if not properly researched.
- The broad use of the term "pudding" in the UK may actually reflect a rich culinary diversity that is not accurately captured by the term's narrower ...
Actionables
- You can start a "Bake and Learn" social media challenge where participants create dishes from both American and British baking traditions and share their results online. This encourages learning about different baking techniques and terminology while fostering a friendly cross-cultural exchange. For example, you might bake American-style pancakes one week and British flapjacks the next, posting photos and discussing the differences in preparation and taste with followers.
- Organize a virtual "Baking Buddy" system where you pair up with a baker from the other country to exchange recipes and baking tips. This peer-to-peer learning experience can help you understand the nuances of each other's baking culture. You could send each other traditional recipes to try out, then have a video call to discuss the experience, the challenges of translating terms, and the outcomes of following the recipes precisely.
- Create a personal baking journal where you document your baking pr ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
