'The Persian' is a spy thriller written by former CIA analyst David McCloskey
In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, former CIA analyst David McCloskey discusses his new spy thriller and shares insights from his intelligence background. He explains how he incorporates declassified information into his novels while managing the CIA's security review process, and describes how real-world events can impact the writing of spy fiction.
McCloskey offers a detailed comparison of CIA and Mossad operations, noting key differences in how these agencies conduct their missions. He describes Mossad's need for creative operative covers due to limited diplomatic relations, contrasting this with the CIA's embassy-based operations. The discussion includes observations about the ongoing tensions between Israel and Iran, with McCloskey's fictional plot points sometimes mirroring real-world events.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 15, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
McCloskey's Writing Process & Real-World Impact
McCloskey discusses how global events influence his spy novels, revealing the challenges of adapting his work to rapidly changing geopolitical situations. While he managed to update "Moscow X" following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, similar revisions weren't possible for "The Persian" during the Israel-Iran conflict. Drawing from his background as a CIA analyst, McCloskey incorporates declassified information into his novels, enriching them with authentic details while navigating the CIA's security review process.
Fiction Meets Reality in Israel-Iran Relations
In a striking coincidence, McCloskey's novel "The Persian" opens with Israel assassinating an Iranian military leader and scientist—a plot point conceived before similar real-world events occurred. This parallel demonstrates McCloskey's deep understanding of the ongoing "shadow war" between Israel and Iran, informed by his insider knowledge of covert operations.
Intelligence Agency Operations and Methods
McCloskey shares insights into the operational differences between the CIA and Mossad, based on his intelligence background. He explains that Mossad's lack of diplomatic relations with neighboring countries forces them to employ more "exotic" covers for their operatives, unlike the CIA's ability to operate through American embassies. Additionally, McCloskey reveals that Mossad operates with quick-response, temporary teams—what he describes as "building the plane while flying"—in contrast to the CIA's more institutional approach to intelligence operations.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While McCloskey's novels may reflect real-world events, it's important to note that fiction still simplifies and dramatizes complex geopolitical situations, which can lead to oversimplifications or misrepresentations.
- The use of declassified information can add authenticity to spy novels, but it can also be outdated or incomplete, as it has been released to the public for a reason and may not represent current intelligence practices or capabilities.
- The challenge of updating novels to reflect rapidly changing global situations could be seen as a limitation of traditional publishing in the digital age, where real-time updates and more agile publishing methods could be more effective.
- The inability to revise "The Persian" during the Israel-Iran conflict might reflect a missed opportunity to address evolving geopolitical dynamics in a timely manner, which could be a drawback for readers seeking current insights.
- The plot point in "The Persian" that mirrors real-world events could be coincidental and not necessarily indicative of a deep understanding of the Israel-Iran conflict, as fiction often draws from real-life scenarios.
- Insider knowledge of covert operations can enhance the realism of spy novels, but it can also raise ethical questions about the disclosure of sensitive information, even if it is fictionalized or declassified.
- Discussing operational differences between intelligence agencies like the CIA and Mossad can be insightful, but such comparisons may oversimplify the complexities and nuances of how these organizations operate in the field.
- The portrayal of Mossad using more "exotic" covers due to a lack of diplomatic relations could perpetuate stereotypes or misconceptions about the agency's methods and capabilities.
- The depiction of the CIA operating through American embassies might not fully capture the diversity of covers and methods used by the agency in various contexts.
- The contrast between Mossad's quick-response teams and the CIA's institutional approach may not account for the full spectrum of operational styles within each agency, as both likely employ a range of tactics depending on the mission.
Actionables
- You can enhance your creative writing by integrating current events into your storylines, mirroring how real-world geopolitical events influence McCloskey's novels. Start by selecting a recent news article and brainstorm how it could impact the characters or world in your fiction. For example, if you're writing a political thriller, consider how a new diplomatic agreement could shift your characters' alliances or objectives.
- Develop a deeper understanding of international relations by comparing the operational tactics of different organizations, akin to how McCloskey contrasts the CIA and Mossad. Create a simple chart or list comparing two organizations you're interested in, noting their strategies, structures, and public perceptions. This exercise can be applied to any sector, such as comparing two companies' approaches to customer service or two schools' educational philosophies.
- Explore the use of specialized knowledge in your hobbies or work projects, drawing inspiration from McCloskey's use of declassified information. If you're a history buff, for instance, you might research and incorporate lesser-known historical facts into a trivia game or blog post. If you're into technology, you could delve into the latest tech releases and explain their significance in a user-friendly guide for non-tech-savvy friends or colleagues.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Mccloskey: Writing Process & Real-World Impact on Fiction
Author McCloskey shares insights on how real-world events intertwine with his creative process and the challenges they pose to his spy novels.
Mccloskey's Fiction Overtaken by Real-World Events in Novels
McCloskey's writing journey involves revising his works in response to global occurrences. He faced the challenge of updating his novel "Moscow x" amidst Russia's invasion of Ukraine, however, he couldn't make similar revisions to "the Persian" during the Israel-Iran conflict. These real-world events often outpace his fictional narratives, presenting unique hurdles.
Despite Challenges, Mccloskey Finds Intelligence and Military Operations Provide Rich Material For His Spy Novels
As a former CIA analyst, McCloskey taps into declassified knowledge for his spy thrillers, injecting authenticity into his fiction. The CIA's review process, which may eliminate specific details for security reasons, has allowed ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Mccloskey: Writing Process & Real-World Impact on Fiction
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While real-world events can provide rich material for fiction, there is a risk of stories becoming outdated or irrelevant if they are too closely tied to current events.
- The process of revising novels to reflect real-world events could lead to delays in publication and may frustrate readers who prefer a stable, unchanging narrative.
- Relying on declassified knowledge and the CIA review process might limit the creative freedom of the author, potentially resulting in a narrative that is constrained by what is permissible to disclose.
- The inclusion of sensitive information, even if declassified, could inadvertently expose operational methods or historical intelligence practices that may still be relevant, posing a risk to national security or the safety of individuals.
- Using ongoing conflicts such as the shadow war between Israel and Iran could be seen as capitalizing on real-world violence and suffering for entertainment purposes, which might be considered insensitive or unethical by some readers.
- There is a possib ...
Actionables
- You can create a personal journal that parallels current events with fictional twists to practice creative writing and critical thinking. Start by selecting a recent news headline and imagine how it could evolve differently. Write a short story or a diary entry from the perspective of a character living in your alternate version of events. This exercise can enhance your ability to think divergently and craft compelling narratives.
- Develop a hobby of collecting and analyzing open-source intelligence to better understand world events and their potential implications. Use publicly available resources like news articles, social media, satellite imagery, and government publications to piece together a clearer picture of an ongoing situation, such as the tensions between two countries. This can improve your research skills and your ability to synthesize information from various sources.
- Engage in role-playing games (RPGs) tha ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Intersection of McCloskey's Fiction and Israel-Iran Tensions
Author McCloskey’s new novel "The Persian" features a plot that closely resembles real-world events involving Israel and Iran, highlighting the entwined nature of his fiction with geopolitical realities.
Opening Mirrors Real-World Assassination of Iranian Leader by Israel Before Novel's Publication
"The Persian" begins with Israel executing a surprise attack that results in the assassination of an Iranian military leader and a scientist. McCloskey conceived this plot point before the actual events occurred, creating an uncanny parallel between his fiction and the tensions between Israel and Iran. The book's release shortly after this real-life "shadow war" incident emphasizes the close resemblance between McCloskey's narrative and the ongoing Israel-Iran covert operations.
McCloskey's Insider Knowledge of Israel-Iran Covert Operations Realistically Depicts the "Shadow War" In His Novels
McCloskey's storytelling appears to be informed by a profound understanding of Israel-Iran relations, e ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Intersection of McCloskey's Fiction and Israel-Iran Tensions
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The resemblance between McCloskey's novel and real-life events could be coincidental rather than indicative of insider knowledge.
- The realistic depiction of Mossad's operational methods in the novel could be based on publicly available information or common espionage tropes rather than a profound understanding of covert operations.
- The timing of the novel's release in relation to real-world events could be opportunistic for marketing purposes rather than a reflection of the author's insights into geopolitical events.
- The novel's narrative might oversimplify the complexity of Israel-Iran relations and the factors that contribute to their conflict.
- The plot's alignment with actual events might influence readers' perceptions of the real Israel-Iran tensions, potentially leading to misunderstand ...
Actionables
- You can explore the dynamics of international relations through fiction by writing a short story that parallels a current global event. Choose a recent news headline, research the background, and create a narrative that mirrors the real-world situation, much like McCloskey's approach. This exercise can enhance your understanding of geopolitical issues and the impact of international affairs on individual lives.
- Enhance your critical reading skills by analyzing a political thriller for its reflection of real-world tactics. Pick a novel that involves espionage or international conflict and compare the fictional strategies used within the story to documented intelligence operations. This will help you develop a keener eye for realism in fiction and a deeper appreciation for the complexities of global espionage.
- Develop a better grasp of world politics by ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Intelligence Agencies' Operations and Tradecraft Insights From McCloskey's Background
McCloskey, drawing from his CIA experience, sheds light on the operational differences between the CIA and Mossad, offering insights into the mindsets and methods that define these agencies.
McCloskey's CIA Experience Reveals CIA vs. Mossad Methods and Mindsets Differences
Drawing from his extensive background in intelligence, McCloskey provides insights into the contrasting approaches of the CIA and Mossad, shaped by the unique geopolitical situations each agency confronts.
Mossad Uses More "Exotic" Covers Than CIA
McCloskey explains that due to Israel not having diplomatic relations with its neighbors, Mossad operatives cannot work out of Israeli embassies as the CIA often does through American embassies. This has compelled Mossad to adopt more "exotic" covers for their operatives, driven by the need to operate covertly in challenging environments.
McCloskey's Talks With Mossad Reveal the Agency's Use of Quick-Response, Temporary Teams Rather Than a Permanent Structure
McCloskey sheds light on Mossad's different approach to organization and task execution in contrast with the CIA's more established and institutional framework.
"Building the Plane While Flying vs. CIA's Institut ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Intelligence Agencies' Operations and Tradecraft Insights From McCloskey's Background
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While McCloskey's insights are valuable, they may reflect a period-specific understanding of CIA and Mossad operations, which could have evolved since his time in the agency.
- The use of "exotic" covers by Mossad may not necessarily be more prevalent than the CIA's use of non-official covers, as the CIA also operates in environments where diplomatic cover is not feasible.
- The characterization of Mossad's temporary teams versus the CIA's permanent structure may oversimplify the operational diversity and adaptability of the CIA, which also employs flexible and temporary measures when necessary.
- The contrast between Mossad's dynamic approach and the CIA's stable method may not account for the full spectrum of operational modes within each agency, a ...
Actionables
- You can adopt a dynamic approach to problem-solving by forming temporary focus groups with friends or colleagues to tackle specific issues. Instead of relying on a fixed group of people, invite different individuals who bring diverse perspectives and skills relevant to the particular challenge you're facing. For example, if you're trying to improve your fitness routine, create a temporary group with a nutritionist, a personal trainer, and someone who recently achieved their fitness goals to get a well-rounded approach.
- Enhance your adaptability by practicing role-playing in unfamiliar social settings. Choose a character or persona that is not your usual self and interact with others while maintaining this new role. This could be as simple as pretending to be a confident public speaker at a local toastmasters club if you're usually shy, or acting as a knowledgeable enthusiast at a wine tasting if you're not a connoisseur. The key is to step out of your comfort zone and adapt to new social environments, which can improve your flexibility in thinki ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
