On NPR's Book of the Day, author Kate Riley discusses her novel about life in an insular religious community that shares roots with the Amish and Friends traditions. Drawing from her own experience living in a similar community for a year, Riley explores how members share all property and resources, make decisions through consensus, and navigate the tensions between individual needs and group dynamics.
Through her protagonist Ruth, Riley examines the challenges of intellectual curiosity within a cloistered environment. The discussion touches on broader themes of fulfillment versus happiness, with Riley suggesting that while no lifestyle can fully protect people from life's difficulties, the pursuit of fulfillment might offer a more meaningful path than the singular chase of happiness.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Kate Riley explores a religious community that stems from the "peace church" tradition. According to Riley, this community, which shares roots with groups like the Amish and Friends, originated in Europe and faced persecution for their belief in adult baptism rather than infant baptism.
Riley describes the community's lifestyle as deeply communal, comparing it to "summer camp your whole life." Members share all property and resources, making decisions through consensus and prayer. This arrangement, while fostering close relationships, requires significant negotiation among members to balance individual and group needs.
The story centers on Ruth, a character whose defining trait is her insatiable curiosity. Riley portrays Ruth's internal struggle between her desire for knowledge and her community's limitations on learning. Ruth questions whether her curiosity is inherently wrong, reflecting broader themes of intellectual repression within cloistered environments.
Riley's narrative draws from her year-long experience living in a similar cloistered Christian community. She channels her personal insights through Ruth's character, particularly in depicting the protagonist's feelings of alienation and her questioning nature. Through carefully crafted vignettes, Riley captures the daily experiences of life within such a secluded environment.
While Riley was raised to believe that pursuing personal happiness should be life's primary goal, her observations of community life led her to a different conclusion. She suggests that no lifestyle can fully shield people from life's inherent challenges, noting that relationships and love inevitably bring both joy and pain. Instead of pursuing happiness alone, Riley proposes that seeking fulfillment might be a more meaningful goal, even while acknowledging that life's fundamental challenges remain unavoidable.
1-Page Summary
Kate Riley presents a portrait of a religious community, detailing its origins, core beliefs, and the day-to-day lifestyle that encapsulates a blend of camaraderie and complexity.
The community Riley depicts in her novel belongs to the "peace church" tradition, which is known to include groups such as the Amish and the Friends. She explains that this group originated in Europe and faced persecution by Catholics due to their belief in adult baptism. They rejected the idea of infant baptism, emphasizing the requirement for mature, conscious conversion to their faith.
Riley describes the community's way of life as deeply communal—the members own no private property and share all their resources. Decisions within this community are not made unilaterally but are reached through consensus with prayer playing a pivotal role in guiding these decisions.
The Religious Community and Its Beliefs and Lifestyle
The protagonist of the story, Ruth, is an archetype of human curiosity and the internal conflicts that come with a yearning for knowledge. Her character embodies the struggle between the thirst for understanding and the constraints of her environment.
Ruth's defining trait is her deep curiosity about everything around her. She has an unquenchable thirst for knowledge, driving her to read any material she can lay her hands on, despite the limitations of her community on what she can access. Ruth's eagerness transcends the mere facts and figures; she yearns to understand how things work and to explore the vast extent of knowledge that lies beyond her immediate world.
The core of Ruth's internal struggle is her questioning of the very nature of her inquisitiveness. Amidst her pursuit of knowledge, she grapples with doubts about the righteousness of her curiosity. She wonders whether this trait is inherently "bad" and if perhaps she ought to restrain herself and accept the limited information deemed suitable by her community's standards. This internal conflict resonates with universal themes of intellectual repression and the innate human desire to seek out the unknown ...
Protagonist's Inner Conflict and Desire to Learn
Kate Riley's background living among a cloistered Christian community deeply informs the narrative arc and character development within her novel. Though there is no specific anecdote about Riley's year in the community provided, her insights shape the protagonist's journey in the story.
Riley's personal experiences are echoed in her novel, showcasing a deep understanding of life in a cloistered community. The internal struggles and emotions conveyed in the novel are a direct reflection of Riley's own introspections and the reality of living in such an isolated environment.
Riley's protagonist, Ruth, mirrors her curiosity and the challenges she faced while living in a community similar to the one described in the book. Ruth's fervent desire to comprehend the world around her parallels Riley's questions about her surroundings and a deeper yearning for knowledge behind the cloistered confines.
Author's Experiences in a Similar Community Informing the Novel
Exploring the complex dance between happiness and fulfillment, Kate Riley challenges the conventional wisdom that we should exclusively chase personal bliss.
Kate Riley's upbringing was steeped in the belief that personal happiness is paramount. She was taught that finding happiness should be an individual's central pursuit and that one should go to any lengths to seek it.
However, Riley's own observations and conversations with lifetime members of various communities have led her to a crucial realization. No specific way of life, no matter how carefully curated, can shield an individual from the inherent difficulties of human existence. As Riley succinctly puts it, "As long as you love things in the world, you are going to be hurt in the world. No marriage is easy. No relationship with your children is 100% good no matter where you are." This insight suggest that perhaps the goal of life should be broader than the pursuit of personal happiness.
Expanding on this idea, Riley posits that f ...
Happiness vs. Fulfillment as Life's Primary Goal
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser