In this episode of Modern Wisdom, Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak examine the psychological challenges facing high achievers. They explore the "hedonic treadmill" phenomenon—why ambitious people struggle to celebrate accomplishments and constantly feel dissatisfied despite success. The conversation addresses how unprocessed emotional pain, particularly grief, invisibly undermines wellbeing, and why expressing rather than suppressing difficult emotions leads to healing and wisdom.
Williamson and Smoak also discuss the fear of being perceived and how it paralyzes creative ambition more than fear of failure itself. They emphasize that lasting success comes from consistent execution of fundamentals over time, not quick fixes or shortcuts. The episode concludes with insights on building authentic personal brands through a combination of credibility, humanity, and inspiration. Throughout, both speakers draw from personal experiences to illustrate how understanding these principles can lead to sustainable achievement and genuine fulfillment.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak explore why high achievers struggle to celebrate their accomplishments through the concept of the "hedonic treadmill." Both personally relate to this challenge, with Smoak noting that achievements feel like obligations rather than wins. Williamson explains that rising standards turn success into a baseline expectation—what was once extraordinary becomes routine warm-up territory within ambitious peer groups. Podcast milestones and skill mastery pass with minimal acknowledgment, while Smoak describes hitting a million TikTok followers only to feel numb.
This extends to material possessions and status. Williamson notes how the thrill of a new car or house quickly fades into the mundane. Smoak references Tony Robbins, observing that "material success without spiritual fulfillment can feel like the ultimate failure." High achievers constantly feel "in the gap" between ever-increasing goals and present reality, creating perpetual dissatisfaction. Williamson calls this the "arrival fallacy"—the belief that fulfillment lies at the next milestone, which is never truly reached.
However, recognizing this impossibility can be liberating. Williamson references Oliver Berkman's insight that the inbox will never be empty, turning productivity into a "low-stakes game" rather than existential struggle. Smoak emphasizes "there's nowhere to get," suggesting the process matters more than the endpoint. Both caution against seeking identity in external achievements, encouraging a focus on growth, service, and finding joy in the journey itself.
Smoak and Williamson discuss the importance of processing rather than suppressing emotional pain, emphasizing that unprocessed emotions invisibly undermine wellbeing and relationships. Smoak states, "If you cannot talk about it, you are not healed from it and it will run your life subconsciously." Williamson elaborates that suppression intensifies suffering, creating cycles of shame and self-judgment: "I'm angry, I shouldn't be angry. But you are." He notes that suppression often masquerades as strength, but true strength is in allowing oneself to feel.
Smoak introduces the concept that suffering equals pain multiplied by resistance, noting that resistance—refusing to feel or accept reality—creates lasting distress. He recounts trying desperately to change his father's unchangeable illness, creating far greater pain than acceptance would have required.
Central to their discussion is the idea that healing comes through embracing and expressing emotions without judgment. Smoak says, "You cannot heal what you cannot feel and you cannot feel what you are unwilling to reveal." He shares that speaking openly about anger toward his father and facing grief was the gateway to clarity: "On the other side of processed emotion is divine revelation. I got to nothing but love and gratitude for the relationship that I had with my old man."
Both hosts find that processed grief delivers not only peace but wisdom, humility, and deep gratitude. Smoak's experience caring for his dying father—confronting stress, helplessness, and emotional discomfort—functioned as a modern coming-of-age ritual that dissolved his ego and raised his stress threshold. He now draws fulfillment from helping others manage grief, transforming his greatest wound into a source of meaning and purpose. Williamson emphasizes, "Adversity should not be wasted," for it seeds the deepest growth and wisdom.
Williamson and Smoak explore how the deepest barrier to ambition isn't fear of failure or success, but the paralyzing fear of being perceived. Smoak points to the "little middle schooler inside of us" wondering what others will think. This fear surfaces at every growth stage—from posting online for the first time to public speaking to dealing with cancellation. The core wound, Smoak describes, is "What if they confirm that I am not enough? What if they confirm that I am incompetent?"
Williamson expands on the torment caused by misrepresentation and unfair criticism. When people believe a false narrative about you, the psychological distress can be immense, particularly because it affects reputation and sense of justice. This creates persistent narratives that are hard to dispel.
Rather than fighting this fear directly, Smoak advocates focusing on genuine inspiration—the authentic drive to create and share. When inspired, his output flowed freely; when fear took over, inspiration dried up. Creating from authentic inspiration diminishes the weight of public opinion and connects more deeply with true supporters. Conversely, focusing on external perception activates the inner critic and halts creativity.
Smoak emphasizes understanding, rather than battling, the parts of oneself that fear judgment. By exploring the origins of these fears—recognizing the anxious inner child afraid no one will value his efforts—he's able to observe fear rather than be consumed by it. This creates distance and clarity, allowing conscious choice rather than reflexive inhibition. Both note that self-doubt reappears at every new level of visibility, making the ongoing process of understanding and moving through these fears essential for continuous growth and creative freedom.
Williamson and Smoak underscore that lasting achievement stems from persistent, fundamental actions rather than quick fixes. Williamson shares how his podcast took two years and 150 episodes to reach 10,000 subscribers, and spent a year stuck at just 7,000 followers—but he continued regardless, driven by love of the work. He notes that "most people stop right before they strike gold," and that over 90% quit after just 90 days. His top recommendation is simple: "Post every day for six months."
Smoak references Mr. Beast's advice: "Create 100 videos and understand they're all gonna suck. And then maybe you can start to get kind of good at it." The obvious path, Williamson says, is just "not stopping"—even when motivation wanes.
Williamson contrasts discipline, motivation, and obsession, noting that "obsession is doing it no matter what—it's climbed inside of you." What seems like discipline to others is actually the cooled residue of past obsession. Smoak relates how years spent consuming podcasts became essential preparation for his work.
Williamson stresses that consistency must be relentless—he hasn't missed a social media upload in two and a half years. Missing days breaks the chain and begins a reverse snowball effect. Both agree that mastery is forged over thousands of lonely, unrecognized hours, and that extraordinary success is the by-product of methodical, repetitive, unvalidated work—a process that cannot be bypassed.
True brand loyalty comes from a blend of credibility, humanity, and inspiration. Smoak and Williamson emphasize three essential content types: informational (teaching competencies), relational (showing humanity through unscripted moments and humor), and aspirational (sharing personal journeys of overcoming adversity). When creators combine these three pillars, audiences form loyalty rooted in respect and genuine connection.
Diversifying content across these pillars avoids staleness. Mixing deep topics with light, comedic moments satisfies the full range of human desires, while viral content often stems from genuine inspiration rather than calculation. Smoak describes content creation like a kid in a sandbox: building whatever interests him, inspired by curiosity and play. This method fuels joy that audiences find magnetic.
True protection from burnout comes from radical authenticity. Smoak emphasizes he's not interested in pleasing everyone—his focus is making a meaningful difference for those ready to listen. When criticism or cancellation attempts arise, consistent vulnerability allows the true story to shine. By building his reputation on radical authenticity, Smoak notes he's essentially "uncancelable" because nothing can be uncovered that isn't already out in the open. For creators, this alignment with core values and honest self-expression is the ultimate antidote to burnout, backlash, and the pressure to please.
1-Page Summary
Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak explore why high achievers often find it difficult to celebrate their accomplishments, framing this struggle through the concept of the “hedonic treadmill.” Both emphasize that what once felt like a genuine achievement quickly becomes an expectation or obligation in high-performing circles, rendering true satisfaction elusive.
Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak both admit to personally struggling to celebrate their own wins, with Smoak stating, "I have a hard time celebrating my achievements and wins because in my mind, it was my obligation to achieve them." Williamson elaborates, explaining that high standards turn success into a minimum expectation. As standards rise, achieving a goal simply becomes the new baseline; anything less feels like failure. High performers continually set standards that exceed their current capabilities, ensuring that aspirations always outstrip reality and reinforcing a constant sense of dissatisfaction between what has been achieved and what is still desired.
This pattern is further compounded by the normalization of high achievement within ambitious peer groups. Smoak notes how his own social circle treats previously exceptional accomplishments as routine—like casually discussing 16- or 20-mile runs, which would have once seemed impossible. What was once an extraordinary record is soon demoted to a mere warm-up, and what used to be a hard-won skill is now regarded as mere competence.
Both recount moments when achievements that once prompted pride now pass by with little notice. Williamson cites moving past podcast subscriber milestones or skill mastery with little more than a dinner to mark the occasion, while Smoak describes hitting a million followers on TikTok only to feel numb and unsure about what comes next.
Williamson and Smoak describe the fleeting rush that accompanies new material possessions or external milestones, and how quickly that excitement fades. Williamson compares the thrill of buying a new car or moving into a new house—obsessing over every detail at first—before both become just another ordinary part of life.
This cycle extends to the pursuit of status and accolades. Smoak observes that the excitement of achieving status, success, or material goals quickly turns to habituation, making any newly reached goal feel unsatisfying. Referencing Tony Robbins, he notes that even after attaining wealth or fame, individuals may find themselves feeling empty—proof that "material success without spiritual fulfillment can feel like the ultimate failure." Smoak underscores that what people truly desire is the feeling attached to achievement, not the achievement itself; the status symbol briefly provides a [restricted term] rush before reverting to the mundane. As Williamson puts it, "your old PR that you celebrated at the time is now a warm-up set"—the same applies to status, speed, or proficiency.
For high achievers, rising standards means they constantly feel "in the gap"—not between their past and present but between their ever-increasing goals and current reality. This leaves ambitious individuals perpetually feeling inadequate, with each new level of success only raising the bar for the next round of striving. Smoak reiterates that "you never arrive," emphasizing that our desires always race ahead of what reality can deliver. The result is not acute suffering but a "mild discomfort" as reality fails to measure up to expectation.
Williamson draws a parallel to "arrival fallacy." Whether it’s a black belt, a thousand meditation hours, or factual expertise, each is just a more sophisticated version of the same trap—a belief that fulfillment lies at the next mile ...
Hedonic Treadmill: High Achievers Struggle to Celebrate Wins
The conversation between Michael Smoak and Chris Williamson explores the importance of processing, rather than suppressing, emotional pain. Their dialogue reveals that only by honestly confronting and expressing difficult feelings such as grief, anger, and sadness can one foster wellbeing, authentic relationships, and transformation through adversity.
Both Smoak and Williamson emphasize the unseen impact of unprocessed emotions. Smoak states, “If you cannot talk about it, you are not healed from it and it will run your life subconsciously in some way. Your relationships, your work, your body, your health.” He draws a direct line between emotional suppression and depression, noting that what is buried unexpressed doesn't vanish but instead controls behaviors and perceptions from the subconscious, undermining authenticity in life.
Williamson elaborates that suppression does not shield anyone from suffering but rather intensifies it, leading to cycles of shame and self-judgment: “I'm angry, I shouldn't be angry. But you are. … I shouldn't feel shame. And then you feel bitterness about your shame and then you feel frustration at your bitterness about your shame. And it's this infinite regress.” He and Smoak agree that suppression often masquerades as strength, but true strength is in letting oneself feel.
Smoak describes an experience where, in front of 300 people, he was overwhelmed by emotion because he had not allowed himself to grieve or feel angry and sad over his father's decline. This moment illustrated the cost of emotional denial, which, left unaddressed, asserts control subconsciously, shaping responses and relationships without conscious choice.
Smoak introduces the concept, echoed by Arthur Brooks and Buddhist thought, that suffering equals pain multiplied by resistance: “If you can just eliminate the resistance, pain in life is inevitable, but suffering is optional.” The resistance—refusing to feel, stubbornly clinging to desired outcomes—is what creates lasting distress. Smoak recounts trying desperately to change the unchangeable during his father’s illness, creating far greater pain than acceptance would have required.
A central insight is that healing and liberation come through embracing and expressing emotions without judgment. Smoak says, “You cannot heal what you cannot feel and you cannot feel what you are unwilling to reveal.” For him, healing required permission to experience the full spectrum—anger, sadness, guilt, even happiness—as they arose, and to express them honestly to others.
Both agree that acknowledgment leads to transformation. Williamson notes, “The acceptance part is, this is just happening and I have to allow it to move through me.” He observes that true insight follows not from denying emotion, but from feeling and allowing it. Smoak shares that speaking openly about anger toward his father and facing grief was the gateway to clarity: “On the other side of processed emotion is divine revelation. I got to nothing but love and gratitude for the relationship that I had with my old man.”
Smoak’s experience confirms the power of sharing: “You are only as healed from something as your ability to share it.” Over time, emotionally honest conversations allowed him to recall his father without breaking down, signaling healing. This move from suppression to expression dissolves the control unprocessed pain holds, liberating individuals to live more fully.
Both hosts find that processed grief delivers not only peace but also wisdom, humility, and deep gratitude. Through revealing, feeling, and speaking about his darkest moments—moving home, attending to his father after falls, cleaning up injuries—Smoak learned his true capacity for patience and empathy. He now sees his suffering as the greatest gift, equipping him to guide others through grief: “Your purpose in this life is to take what God delivered you from and turn around and help other people do the same thing.”
Williamson notes that these trials create empathy and humility, as echoed by Alain de Botton: “The best men have been broken, and how this leads to a certain humility, recognition of limits, and a humbleness that wasn't there before.” The adversity, rather than minimizing one’s life, gives it depth and texture.
Smoak shares that the death of his father was the ...
Emotional Grief: Expression Over Suppression
Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak explore how the deepest barrier to ambition isn’t simply a lack of willpower or the fear of success or failure, but the paralyzing fear of being perceived—by others, by critics, and even by oneself. Overcoming this inner obstacle requires not brute force, but a shift toward inspiration and self-understanding.
Michael Smoak and Chris Williamson agree that the central block to pursuing one’s ambitions is not usually the fear of failing or even succeeding. Smoak points to the “little middle schooler inside of us” wondering what others will think—will we be accepted, or cast aside? He recounts how this fear surfaces at every stage, from the anxiety of posting for the first time online and public speaking to worrying about reputation when dealing with cancellation or increased public exposure. The fear of perception recurs with every larger audience or new creative risk, such as adopting a different style, cracking an edgy joke, or displaying vulnerability.
Smoak describes common milestones where perception anxiety appears: for beginners, it’s the terror of posting content and feeling “cringe”; for more experienced individuals, it arises with a growing audience, speaking engagements, or controversies where one’s character is publicly judged. Even for seasoned creators, a new challenge—such as moving to a higher-profile podcast ranking—causes fear to resurface.
This fear is deeply rooted: Smoak describes the underlying wound as “What if they confirm that I am not enough? What if they confirm that I am incompetent?”—beliefs often seeded in childhood or adolescence. The pain isn’t only rejection but confirmation of one’s worst internal doubts about belonging and worthiness.
Chris Williamson expands on this with the torment caused by misrepresentation and unfair criticism. When people believe a false narrative about you—especially one you know to be untrue—the psychological distress can be immense, particularly because it affects your reputation and sense of justice. The fear is not simply about being insulted, but the agony that others will believe something damaging and act on it, even in the absence of evidence. This can create a persistent narrative that is hard to dispel and particularly excruciating if you’re powerless to refute it.
Rather than attempting to fight the fear of perception directly, Smoak advocates for focusing on inspiration—the authentic, compelling drive to create and share. When he was inspired, his output flowed freely; when fear of judgment took over (as after being canceled), inspiration dried up and he felt blocked and lost. Inspiration, for Smoak, comes from tuning in to the messages that feel deeply true rather than chasing trends, playing to the crowd, or seeking virality.
Staying grounded in genuine inspiration diminishes the weight of public opinion. Smoak notes that authentic videos drawn from personal truth connect more deeply with true supporters and self-selected audiences while filtering out fleeting or superficial onlookers. This approach leads to more genuine impact.
Conversely, focusing on external perception activates the inner critic and halts creativity. When Smoak’s attention drifted to how he would be perceived after cancellation, he found it difficult to know what to create next, as the inspiration was blocked by anxiety and uncertainty.
He stresses that connecting with a wide range of experiences and interests—whether producing videos on personal loss or odd snacks—helps maintain enthusiasm and creative momentum, and keeps perfectionism and paralysis at bay. New challenges, such as public speaking practice or openly processing fears, help creators develop not only confidence and clarity but also profound new ideas. Repeated action in the face of fear transforms the initial terror into capability and even mastery.
Perception: Beyond Willpower to Inspiration
Chris Williamson and Michael Smoak underscore that lasting achievement stems from persistent, fundamental actions rather than quick fixes or revolutionary tactics. Their lived experiences reveal that success, especially in creative and entrepreneurial fields, comes from patiently doing what works, long before results are apparent.
Williamson shares how building his podcast required years of work before seeing real traction: it took two years and 150 episodes to reach 10,000 subscribers, another 150 for 100,000, and by 1,000 episodes, half had been made before reaching 250,000 subscribers. The show spent a year stuck at just 7,000 followers, but he continued regardless, driven by love of the work, even before anyone listened or cared. This experience reflects his belief that “most people stop right before they strike gold,” whether in content creation, fitness, or diet, quitting just before they find a flow or breakthrough.
For social media growth, Williamson’s top recommendation is simple: “Post every day for six months.” He notes that over 90% of people quit after just 90 days. He applies the same logic to podcasting statistics: “90% of podcasts don't make it past episode three, and of the 10% that do, 90% don't make it past episode 20.” Thus, simply making 21 episodes already places a creator in the top percentile. Success is rare not because of complexity or secret tactics, but because so few endure the repetition.
Michael Smoak references Mr. Beast’s advice: “Create 100 videos and understand they're all gonna suck. And then maybe you can start to get kind of good at it.” Smoak and Williamson both cringe at their early content, recognizing that mastery demands time spent working through mediocrity without outward validation. The obvious path, Williamson says, is just “not stopping”—even when motivation wanes and the grind is unglamorous.
Williamson contrasts discipline, motivation, and obsession. “Discipline is doing what you don’t want; motivation is wanting to do it; obsession is doing it no matter what—it’s climbed inside of you." He describes his own journey: an obsession with the gym that kept him from socializing in university, or consuming information about his craft to the point that it became natural and later appeared to outsiders as discipline. What seems like discipline to others is actually the cooled residue of past obsession.
Smoak relates how he spent years consuming podcasts and information, at first only for himself, not knowing that it would later become foundational to his work. He now sees that period as essential preparation. The difference between those who quit and those who break through, in their view, is the nature of the drive: for some it’s a mere obligation, but for the obsessive, it’s an undeniable calling they can’t ignore.
Williamson stresses that consistency must be relentless: uploading an episode or post is a non-negoti ...
Consistency and Fundamentals: Doing the Obvious For a Long Time
True brand loyalty and meaningful connection aren’t forged just through authority or aspiration alone. They come from a blend of credibility, humanity, and inspiration, brought to life by creators who aren’t afraid to show every facet of themselves. A genuine digital persona isn’t built on audience-pleasing, but on authenticity, playfulness, and consistent vulnerability, which together create an enduring, unshakeable presence.
Michael Smoak and Chris Williamson emphasize the essential trio of content types: informational, relational, and aspirational.
Informational content comes from a position of authority—teaching others what you know. Smoak gives examples from his own work, like breaking down the benefits of creatine, public speaking tips, or methods to limit filler words. This type of content anchors a creator as a trustworthy resource, clearly competent in their area.
Relational content allows audiences to connect emotionally by showing the creator's unscripted, everyday moments, quirks, and unique humor—what Smoak calls a “frictionless, less buttoned-up” approach. Whether it's a chaotic review of Oreo-flavored Coke (which became his most viral video), joking about youthful antics, podcast banter about everyday experiences, or simply goofing around with friends, these unscripted snippets showcase the creator’s realness and keeps them from becoming a distant, untouchable expert. Play and fun are foregrounded—for Smoak, content creation is easy because he treats it as fun and refuses to let the pressures of adulthood kill that enjoyment.
Aspirational content comes from sharing personal journeys of overcoming adversity—such as surviving difficult relationships or hardships to reach health, wealth, and fulfillment. Smoak notes that sharing what you’ve overcome signals to audiences that they, too, can transform their lives. This pillar positions the creator not as a distant figure in an ivory tower, but as someone flawed and human who's moved through adversity just like their audience might aspire to.
When a creator combines teaching and credibility, relatable vulnerability, and inspiration gained from personal growth, the audience is fully invested—not just following for tips, but forming loyalty rooted in respect and connection.
Creators can avoid stagnation and deepen connections by diversifying content across these three pillars.
Mixing deep topics like philosophy or pain with light, comedic moments satisfies the full range of human desires. For example, episodes that alternate between practical advice, belly-laugh humor, and heartfelt stories keep engagement high and reflect genuine human complexity.
The most shared moments often arise from inspiration, not calculation. Smoak's most viral video came from acting on genuine inspiration, not a template or strategic rule. Audiences sense when content comes from a place of true personal excitement rather than formula or trend-chasing.
Smoak describes content creation like a kid in a sandbox: building whatever interests him, inspired by curiosity and play. There’s no rigid strategy—just ongoing experimentation. This method fuels joy that audiences feel is magnetic, making content creation both sustainable and rewardi ...
Authenticity & Relatability in Branding: Pillars of Genuine Connection
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
