In this episode of Modern Wisdom, Dr. Paul Hewitt explores the complex nature of perfectionism and its origins in childhood experiences. He explains how perfectionists develop the belief that they must appear flawless to be worthy of acceptance, leading to a pattern of hiding perceived imperfections and maintaining a carefully curated image in relationships.
The discussion covers the significant impact of perfectionism on mental and physical health, including its connections to anxiety, depression, and suicide risk. Dr. Hewitt shares insights from his research and clinical practice, describing how perfectionism affects relationships and discussing treatment approaches, with a focus on addressing the deeper psychological needs that drive perfectionist behavior rather than simply teaching coping skills.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Paul Hewitt and Chris Williamson explore perfectionism as a complex personality style rooted in feelings of inadequacy. According to Hewitt, perfectionists believe they must appear flawless to be accepted and worthy, leading them to constantly hide their perceived imperfections. This manifests in a harsh inner dialogue and an inability to celebrate achievements, as they quickly move on to the next challenge in their relentless pursuit of perfection.
Hewitt explains that perfectionism often stems from unmet emotional needs during childhood, particularly the need to feel worthy and accepted. He shares the story of a patient who, adopted as an infant, developed perfectionist tendencies from the fear of being "returned" if she showed any flaws. This exemplifies how early experiences can shape an individual's drive for perfection as a way to secure belonging and acceptance.
Perfectionism significantly impacts relationships, as Hewitt and Williamson discuss. Perfectionists often maintain a carefully curated image, avoiding genuine expression of vulnerabilities. Some develop "other-oriented perfectionism," becoming controlling and critical of others who don't meet their high standards. This behavior, Hewitt notes, can lead to isolation as others sense their lack of authenticity and withdraw from the relationship.
Hewitt's research reveals concerning links between perfectionism and various mental health issues, including anxiety, depression, eating disorders, and suicidal thoughts. He points out that socially prescribed perfectionism can predict suicide risk, even when controlling for other factors like depression. The constant stress and self-criticism associated with perfectionism can also lead to physical health problems and potentially shortened lifespans.
In addressing perfectionism, Hewitt advocates for psychodynamic therapy over skill-based interventions like CBT. He explains that this approach better addresses the deeper relational needs and proves more effective in maintaining long-term improvements. However, letting go of perfectionism presents a significant challenge, as it serves as a coping mechanism for underlying fears about self-worth and belonging.
1-Page Summary
Perfectionism is a challenging and deeply ingrained personality style that is characterized by feelings of inadequacy and flaws. Paul Hewitt and Chris Williamson discuss how those with perfectionistic tendencies navigate their lives and the costs of such a lifestyle.
Perfectionistic individuals often feel as though they are fundamentally flawed or defective, leading them to believe they don't fit in the world. Hewitt highlights the increase in perfectionism over the decades, noting traits like self-oriented and socially prescribed perfectionism. This ingrained personality style is marked by a core feeling of not being enough. Such individuals believe they need to appear perfect to others to be accepted and feel worthy, leading them to hide their imperfections.
Children who sense inadequacy may come to believe that appearing perfect or concealing their flaws will lead to acceptance and a sense of worth. This belief drives perfectionists not only to excel in tasks but also to avoid imperfection at any cost. They tie their self-worth and identity to performance and believe that achieving perfection would affirm their worth.
Perfectionists experience a paradox where their success brings neither satisfaction nor celebration, suggesting a deep-seated feeling of inadequacy. They are quick to move on to the next task, upping the demands on themselves. This reflects their belief that they must continuously strive for perfection to feel valued. They fear revealing any flaws and may avoid situations where they could be exposed, like public speaking. Hewitt notes that perfectionists long for connection and acceptance by trying to be perfect but often end up pushing people away by not being genuine.
As perfectionists contemplate abandoning the need to appear perfect, they face a terrifying void without that drive as their motivation. Hewitt describes the internal mind of a perfectionist as abusive, harsh, and critical. This harsh inner dialogue evaluates performance relentlessly and is filled w ...
The Nature and Core Experience of Perfectionism
Understanding the roots of perfectionism lies in the recognition of unmet emotional needs during early development. Research and clinical perspectives suggest that perfectionism often sprouts from these formative experiences.
Perfectionists commonly harbor deep-seated feelings of defectiveness or unacceptability, tracing back to early dealings with asynchrony or non-attunement. When basic human needs—to feel worthy, acceptable, or fit in—are not met, perfectionism can seed and grow.
An individual's unwavering quest for perfection frequently originates from a flawed self-concept and the fundamental desire to repair feelings of unworthiness. These individuals might feel inherently flawed and believe they must achieve perfection to be worthy of love and value. Therapist Paul Hewitt references the story of a patient who learned as a young girl, adopted at infancy, that she had to appear perfect to avoid being 'returned' to an orphanage, revealing how these profound fears can shape an individual's self-perception and behavioral patterns.
Perfectionism is intricately tied to the existential fear of not fitting in or belonging, which is often connected to issues of worth and acceptance. For people with perfectionistic tendencies, the drive to become perfect can be an attempt to fix an internal sense of deficiency and t ...
The Developmental Origins and Psychological Underpinnings of Perfectionism
Perfectionism is not simply about setting high standards; it carries emotional and relational consequences which are often overlooked. Paul Hewitt and Chris Williamson explore the complex manifestations of this trait.
For some perfectionists, life is about maintaining an image of flawlessness to foster acceptance and avoid rejection, despite feeling inadequate. Hewitt suggests perfectionists may not celebrate their achievements to preserve an image of being perfect. Instead of sharing their successes or satisfactions, they might focus on what’s still flawed, fueling the sense of inadequacy. They are likely to hide imperfections in relationships, never discussing events that didn't go well or revealing any perceived flaws.
Perfectionism can lead individuals to curate an image, avoiding the genuine expression of self. Hewitt discusses this sense of inauthenticity which, in turn, may cause others to withdraw, sensing a lack of genuineness. Intimacy, which typically grows through revealing one's vulnerabilities, becomes problematic for perfectionists who shy away from showing any shortcomings.
Other-oriented perfectionism signifies the need for those around perfectionists to meet their high standards. This attitude can lead to a controlling and critical approach toward others. Hewitt notes that this can cause distress not for the perfectionist but for the people in their lives. When others fall short, the criticism the perfectionist usually directs towards themselves turns outward, resembling narcissistic rage.
Hewitt asserts that in their qu ...
The Interpersonal and Behavioral Manifestations of Perfectionism
Paul Hewitt's research and observations suggest that perfectionism is not just a quirk or a drive to achieve excellence but a psychological trait linked to a range of serious mental health and physical problems, including suicidality.
Hewitt describes a patient who was highly perfectionistic and suicidal, providing an extreme example of where perfectionism can lead. Concerningly, perfectionism is connected to serious psychiatric and psychological problems like anxiety, depression, and eating disorders. Hewitt indicates that socially prescribed perfectionism predicts suicide, even when controlling for historically predictive factors such as depression and hopelessness. This is evident in the story of a musician who attempted suicide and was struggling with mental health issues commonly associated with perfectionism.
Paul Hewitt also notes that very famous people known for their perfectionistic traits often have personal lives or relationships that are significantly troubled, suggesting the negative psychological outcomes are linked to their perfectionistic tendencies. Hewitt raises the possibility of a connection between the rise in perfectionism and the increasing rates of depression and anxiety, as perfectionism can be a vulnerability factor for these issues.
The relentless self-criticism and fear of failure experienced by perfectionists, suggested by the anecdote of a patient who viewed achieving the highest score as a failure, can have damaging psychological consequences. Perfectionists may view the nee ...
Negative Psychological and Health Outcomes of Perfectionism
Even though the podcast did not explicitly address strategies for overcoming perfectionism, the conversation with Hewitt did suggest that the issue is complex, dealing with deep-seated issues of self-worth, belonging, and emotional needs that are essential to address.
The hosts discuss that overcoming perfectionism isn't a matter of reducing it from one level to another but rather addressing the underlying sense of worth, connectedness, and emotional needs that drive the perfectionist behaviors.
Hewitt talks about using psychodynamic therapy instead of skill-based interventions like CBT for treating perfectionism. He criticizes CBT's high dropout rates and lack of long-term effectiveness, particularly for socially prescribed perfectionism, which is associated with serious outcomes. In contrast, psychodynamic approaches address deeper relational needs and result in changes that are maintained or even improved post-treatment. This therapy aims to help individuals accept that both themselves and others are flawed and to find a place in the world that resonates with a healthier sense of self and relationship.
The conversation acknowledges that success doesn't satisfy the emotional needs behind perfectionism and may ...
Strategies and Challenges For Overcoming Perfectionism
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
