#453 — AI and the New Face of Antisemitism
In this episode of Making Sense, Sam Harris speaks with Judea Pearl, who shares his early life experiences growing up in Bnei Brak, Israel, in a religious agricultural community established by his grandfather. Pearl describes his education under European academics who fled Hitler's regime and later became high school teachers in Tel Aviv.
The conversation covers Pearl's analysis of current AI systems' limitations, particularly regarding language models and their inability to discover new world models from data. Pearl also discusses his work with the Daniel Pearl Foundation following his son's death in 2002, including his efforts to foster Muslim-Jewish dialogue and his observations from a 2005 conference in Doha about barriers to progress in interfaith understanding.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 16, 2026 episode of the Making Sense with Sam Harris
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Judea Pearl's Background and Early Life
Born in 1936 in Bnei Brak, Israel, Judea Pearl grew up in a community established by his grandfather and other Polish Hasidic Jewish families. Pearl's father arrived in 1924 as a pioneer farmer, driven by the vision of creating a religious agricultural community. Pearl's education took place in a prestigious Tel Aviv high school, where he was taught by highly educated European academics who had fled Hitler's regime. These professors, unable to secure academic positions in Israel, instead devoted their expertise to teaching high school students.
Pearl's Perspective on AI Limitations and AGI Challenges
Judea Pearl expresses skepticism about current artificial intelligence approaches, particularly regarding language models (LLMs). He argues that while LLMs represent progress, they merely summarize human-authored knowledge rather than discovering new world models from data. Pearl points to fundamental mathematical and computational barriers that can't be overcome simply by increasing data or processing power. He explains that current AI systems struggle with causation, interpretation, and counterfactuals, suggesting that a major breakthrough beyond current approaches would be necessary to achieve Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
Pearl's View on Israel-Palestine Conflict and Anti-Semitism
Following the tragic death of his son Danny in a 2002 terrorist attack, Pearl became actively involved in fostering dialogue between Western and Muslim cultures. Through the Daniel Pearl Foundation, he organized Muslim-Jewish scholar meetings and participated in conferences aimed at promoting understanding. However, during a 2005 conference in Doha, Pearl discovered a significant barrier to progress: many moderate Muslim scholars believed their community's advancement was dependent on Israel's destruction, a perspective that Pearl found deeply concerning for meaningful dialogue.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Bnei Brak is a city in Israel known for its large ultra-Orthodox Jewish population. It was established in the early 20th century as a religious agricultural settlement. Polish Hasidic Jews, fleeing persecution and seeking to preserve their traditions, played a key role in its founding. The community emphasizes strict religious observance and has influenced Israeli religious and cultural life.
- A "pioneer farmer" in early 20th-century Israel refers to Jewish settlers who established agricultural communities in Palestine before the state's founding. These pioneers aimed to reclaim and cultivate the land, often under difficult conditions, to build a self-sustaining Jewish homeland. Their work was part of the Zionist movement's broader effort to create a national identity through agriculture and settlement. This role was crucial in transforming barren or undeveloped areas into productive farmland and communities.
- Many European academics fleeing Hitler's regime were highly qualified but faced limited university positions in Israel due to the young state's scarce resources and developing institutions. They chose to teach high school to continue their scholarly work and influence the next generation. Their presence significantly raised the quality and rigor of secondary education in Israel. This helped build a strong intellectual foundation during Israel's formative years.
- Language models (LLMs) are AI systems trained on vast amounts of text to predict and generate human-like language. They learn patterns, grammar, and context by analyzing word sequences but do not understand meaning or causality. LLMs generate responses by statistically predicting the next word based on prior text, without true reasoning. Their knowledge is limited to the data they were trained on and does not include new discoveries or insights.
- Causation in AI refers to understanding how one event directly influences another, beyond mere correlation. Interpretation involves AI systems making sense of data in a way that aligns with human reasoning and context. Counterfactual reasoning means imagining alternative scenarios to determine what would happen if conditions were different. These abilities enable deeper understanding and decision-making, which current AI models struggle to achieve.
- Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) refers to a type of AI that can understand, learn, and apply knowledge across a wide range of tasks at a human-like level. Unlike narrow AI, which excels only in specific areas, AGI would possess flexible reasoning and problem-solving abilities. Achieving AGI requires breakthroughs in understanding cognition, causality, and common sense, beyond current data-driven models. Its development could fundamentally transform technology, society, and the economy.
- The Daniel Pearl Foundation was established in memory of Judea Pearl's son, Daniel Pearl, a journalist kidnapped and murdered in 2002. Its mission is to promote cross-cultural understanding and dialogue, especially between Western and Muslim communities. The foundation supports initiatives that combat hatred and extremism through education and journalism. It aims to honor Daniel Pearl's legacy by fostering peace and mutual respect.
- The Israel-Palestine conflict is a long-standing territorial and political dispute over land claimed by both Jewish Israelis and Palestinian Arabs. Many Palestinians and some Muslim communities view Israel as an occupying force that displaced them and restricts their rights. This has led to deep mistrust and hostility, with some believing that Israel's existence hinders their political and social progress. Such views are rooted in historical grievances, ongoing violence, and failed peace efforts.
- The 2005 conference in Doha was a significant event aimed at fostering dialogue between Muslim and Jewish scholars to promote peace and understanding. It highlighted deep-rooted political and ideological divisions, especially regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict. The conference revealed that some moderate Muslim participants held views linking their community's progress to the elimination of Israel, complicating reconciliation efforts. This underscored the challenges in achieving meaningful dialogue amid entrenched conflicts.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Judea Pearl's Background and Early Life
Judea Pearl's beginnings are rooted deeply in the historical and intellectual migrations of the 20th century, reflected in his family’s establishment of a community and the European academic influence in his education.
Judea Pearl Was Born In 1936 In Bnei Brak, Established In 1924 by His Grandfather and Other Polish Hasidic Jewish Families
Born in 1936, Judea Pearl was born into a community steeped in religious tradition and pioneering spirit. Bnei Brak was established in 1924 by his grandfather, Chaim Pearl, along with 25 other Hasidic families from Poland, imbuing Pearl's early life with a strong sense of cultural and religious heritage.
Judea's Father, a Farmer, Came To Israel In 1924 to Establish a Religious Agricultural Community
Judea's father arrived in Israel the same year that Bnei Brak was founded and became one of its pioneering farmers. His ambition was not only to cultivate the land but to reinstate a biblical town with a religious and agricultural vision at its core.
Judea Was Educated At a Tel Aviv High School With Professors From Germany Displaced by Hitler
Judea found himself amongst a unique educational setting in Tel Aviv, as he was one of only four individua ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Judea Pearl's Background and Early Life
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Explore your family's pioneering spirit by researching and documenting your own ancestry to understand the challenges and triumphs they faced. Use online genealogy platforms to trace your roots and create a visual family tree that highlights key events and individuals who have shaped your family's history, much like Judea Pearl's family established Bnei Brak.
- Embrace the value of diverse educational backgrounds by seeking out mentors or educators with unique life experiences, similar to Judea Pearl's teachers. Look for local community classes or online courses taught by individuals who have transitioned from different careers or countries, and absorb the rich perspectives they bring to their teaching.
- Celebrate ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Pearl's Perspective on AI Limitations and AGI Challenges
Judea Pearl provides critical insights into the limitations of current artificial intelligence (AI) approaches and the challenges in achieving Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
Pearl Sees Deep Learning & LLM Approaches As Limited, Insufficient for AGI Development
Pearl casts doubt on the recent success of language models, saying that while they represent a step in the right direction, they are not sufficient for the development of AGI.
LLM Models Summarize Human-Authored Models Instead of Discovering New World Models From Data
Pearl points out that language models, or LLMs, essentially summarize world knowledge authored by humans rather than discovering or constructing these models directly from data. This observation suggests that LLM approaches offer a superficial mimicry of human intelligence rather than an actual understanding or innovation.
Pearl Claims Fundamental Barriers Exist In Math and Computation That Scaling AI With More Data and Power Can't Overcome
Pearl argues that current AI's mathematical foundations have inherent limitations that cannot be solved simply by increasing the amount of data or computational power.
Causation, Interpretation, and Counterfactuals Beyond Current AI Systems
He references his book, which discusses barriers defined by the ladder of causation. Pearl explains that deriving causation direc ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Pearl's Perspective on AI Limitations and AGI Challenges
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) refers to a type of AI that can understand, learn, and apply knowledge across a wide range of tasks at a human-like level. Unlike current AI, which is specialized and excels only in specific areas (narrow AI), AGI would possess flexible reasoning and problem-solving abilities. AGI aims to perform any intellectual task that a human can do, including abstract thinking and transferring knowledge between domains. Achieving AGI requires breakthroughs in understanding cognition, reasoning, and learning beyond current AI methods.
- Deep learning is a type of machine learning that uses neural networks with many layers to automatically learn patterns from large amounts of data. Large language models (LLMs) are deep learning models trained on vast text datasets to predict and generate human-like language. They function by analyzing the statistical relationships between words and phrases to produce coherent text. However, they do not inherently understand meaning or causality beyond these patterns.
- In AI, "world models" are internal representations that capture how the environment works, including cause-effect relationships. They allow an AI to predict outcomes of actions and reason about unseen situations. Unlike simple pattern recognition, world models enable understanding and planning. Building accurate world models is key for achieving deeper intelligence and generalization.
- Language models learn patterns from vast amounts of text written by humans, effectively capturing and reproducing existing knowledge. They do not independently generate new theories or causal explanations beyond what is present in their training data. Discovering new knowledge requires forming original models or hypotheses about how the world works, often involving causal reasoning and experimentation. This creative, inferential process goes beyond pattern recognition and statistical correlation.
- The "ladder of causation" is a framework by Judea Pearl that categorizes types of reasoning into three levels. The first level, association, involves observing correlations between variables without understanding cause. The second level, intervention, considers the effects of actively changing one variable to see its impact on others. The third level, counterfactuals, involves imagining alternative scenarios to understand what would have happened under different conditions.
- Correlation means two things happen together, but one does not necessarily cause the other. Causation means one event directly influences or brings about another. AI systems often detect patterns (correlations) but struggle to determine if one event causes another without additional knowledge or experimentation. Understanding causation requires reasoning about interventions and changes, which goes beyond just observing data.
- Interventional reasoning in AI involves understanding what happens when actions or changes are made to a system, like predicting outcomes of deliberate interventions. Interpretative reasoning goes further by explaining why those outcomes occur, often requiring understanding of underlying causes and counterfactuals (what would happen if conditions were different). These types of reasoning move beyond pattern recognition to causal understanding. Judea Pearl’s work emphasizes that current AI struggles with these deeper causal and interpretative tasks.
- Current AI systems primarily ...
Counterarguments
- LLMs and deep learning have shown remarkable progress in tasks that were previously thought to be intractable, suggesting that they may be closer to AGI than Pearl acknowledges.
- Some researchers argue that AGI might emerge from the scaling up of current technologies, as increased complexity can lead to emergent properties not predictable from the behavior of simpler systems.
- There is ongoing research into integrating causal reasoning into machine learning models, which may address some of Pearl's concerns about causation and counterfactuals.
- The idea that current AI lacks genuine understanding could be challenged by the argument that understanding is a matter of degree, and AI systems may achieve a functional understanding sufficient for many tasks.
- The assertion that AI cannot derive causation from correlation may be too absolute, as there are statistical and computational methods aimed at inferring causal relationships under certain conditions.
- The claim that AI cannot interpret interventions meaningfully may not account for the progr ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Pearl's View on Israel-Palestine Conflict and Anti-Semitism
Judea Pearl shares his perspective on the Israel-Palestine conflict and anti-Semitism, shaped by his experiences following the tragic death of his son, which occurred during a terrorist attack in 2002.
After Her Son Danny's 2002 Death in a Terrorist Attack, Pearl Engaged In Cultural Dialogue Between the West and the Muslim World
Judea Pearl was thrust into public life after his son Danny, a journalist, was killed by terrorists. In response, Pearl established the Daniel Pearl Foundation, dedicated to fostering communication and dialogue between Jews and Muslims, and between Western and Eastern cultures.
Pearl Organized Muslim-Jewish Scholar Meetings, Including a 2005 Doha Conference, to Foster Understanding and Progress
To advance this dialogue, Pearl, alongside a Pakistani scholar, initiated the Daniel Pearl Dialogue between Muslims and Jews. They traveled from town to town, engaging the public in discussions and meetings to promote understanding and participation from various communities.
Pearl Found Many Moderate Muslim Scholars Viewed Muslim Progress As Reliant on Israel's Destruction
Doha Conference: Calls to Eliminate Israel Seen As Barrier to Understanding and Progress
His e ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Pearl's View on Israel-Palestine Conflict and Anti-Semitism
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can start a book club focused on literature that explores Jewish-Muslim relations to deepen your understanding of cultural narratives. By selecting books written by authors from both communities, you can gain insights into the historical and personal aspects of Jewish-Muslim relations. For example, choose a mix of novels, memoirs, and historical accounts that shed light on the complexities of the relationship and encourage discussions on the themes within a diverse group of readers.
- Engage in a language exchange with someone from a different cultural background to build bridges through personal connection. Find a partner interested in learning your language while you learn theirs, such as Hebrew or Arabic, using online platforms that connect language learners. This mutual exchange not only fosters language skills but also provides an opportunity to share personal stories and cultural experiences, breaking down stereotypes and fostering empathy.
- Create a personal blog or vlog series docume ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
