Screens without Shame: Jonathan Haidt and Catherine Price
In this episode of Good Inside with Dr. Becky, Dr. Kennedy and her guests Catherine Price and Jonathan Haidt examine how technology affects human behavior and development. Their discussion explores the deliberate design choices that make digital products addictive, focusing on how these choices impact young users and family relationships. They also address how phones can disrupt meaningful connections between parents and children.
The experts share practical strategies for managing technology use at home, including establishing phone-free zones and involving children in conversations about device usage. They discuss the need for a coordinated response from tech companies, schools, and communities to create healthier technology habits, noting an emerging movement among young people who are choosing to delay their engagement with certain social media platforms.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 27, 2026 episode of the Good Inside with Dr. Becky
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Technology's Design and Impact on Human Behavior and Development
Experts Catherine Price, Jonathan Haidt, and Becky Kennedy explore how modern technology affects human behavior and development, particularly focusing on its addictive nature and impact on attention spans.
Price reveals that tech companies intentionally design their products to be addictive, using techniques similar to slot machines, including bright colors, variable rewards, and sounds. This design particularly affects young users, with Haidt noting that students who reduce screen time show marked improvements in productivity and engagement with their surroundings.
Kennedy emphasizes that technology addiction isn't merely a matter of willpower, as these devices are deliberately engineered to capture attention. Haidt suggests waiting until age 16 for social media access, given its significant impact on developing brains.
Parental Challenges In Managing Home Technology Use
The experts discuss how technology strains family relationships and parenting. According to Haidt, phones act as "experience blockers" and "relationship blockers," disrupting marriages and parent-child interactions. Kennedy notes the challenge of maintaining meaningful connections when devices constantly compete for attention.
The experts acknowledge that even they struggle with managing technology in their homes. Kennedy suggests involving children in addressing excessive phone use, recommending that parents encourage their children to politely call out problematic device use. Price adds practical solutions like establishing phone-free mealtimes and creating family charging stations outside bedrooms.
Need For a Systemic Approach To Addressing Issues
The discussion emphasizes the importance of a unified response from tech companies, schools, families, and communities. Price and Kennedy argue that tech companies must design less addictive products, while Haidt advocates for phone-free schools to boost student engagement and social interaction.
Price observes an emerging youth movement resisting tech companies' influence, with many children willingly postponing use of apps like TikTok and Instagram. The experts suggest that this resistance, combined with community-wide support and education about technology's impacts, could help create healthier technology habits for future generations.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While tech companies may design products with addictive elements, they also contribute to innovation, education, and connectivity, providing significant benefits to society.
- Some argue that technology addiction is a matter of personal responsibility and that individuals should be educated to manage their use rather than blaming the design of the technology.
- There is evidence suggesting that not all screen time is detrimental and that the quality and context of technology use are important factors to consider.
- Delaying social media access until age 16 might not be practical or enforceable, and education about responsible use might be a more effective strategy.
- Phones and technology can also facilitate experiences and relationships, such as long-distance communication and access to educational resources.
- The idea that technology strains family relationships may not account for the ways in which families can use technology together positively, such as for joint media engagement or learning.
- Some experts and studies suggest that technology can be integrated into educational settings in ways that enhance learning and engagement rather than detracting from it.
- The movement of youth resisting tech companies' influence may not represent the majority of young users, and many may find value and community through these platforms.
- Calls for tech companies to design less addictive products may overlook the complexity of the market demand for engaging content and the challenges in defining and regulating "addictiveness."
- The effectiveness of phone-free schools is debated, with some arguing that teaching responsible use of technology within schools might better prepare students for the digital world.
- Community-wide support and education initiatives may face challenges due to varying beliefs about technology's role in society and the difficulty in achieving consensus on best practices.
Actionables
- You can create a "tech timeout" jar where family members contribute a small amount of money each time they use their phone during designated phone-free times, with the collected funds going towards a shared experience like a family outing. This strategy turns the effort to reduce screen time into a positive and tangible goal, reinforcing the value of shared experiences over individual screen time.
- Develop a personal "attention investment portfolio" where you allocate specific hours of your day to activities that don't involve technology, treating your attention as a valuable resource. For example, you might decide to invest one hour in reading, another in a hobby like painting, and a third in exercise, ensuring these activities are done without the presence of digital devices.
- Start a "tech buddy" system with a friend or family member where you both agree to hold each other accountable for reducing screen time. Set specific goals, such as no social media after 8 PM or no phones during meals, and check in with each other daily to discuss challenges and successes. This mutual support can help maintain motivation and provide a sense of camaraderie in the effort to manage technology use.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Technology's Design and Impact on Human Behavior and Development
Experts Catherine Price, Jonathan Haidt, and Becky Kennedy delve into the design of today's tech products, discussing their impact on our attention, development, and the broader systemic issues associated with digital technology's addictive nature.
Tech Products Designed to Be Addictive and Hijack Attention
Catherine Price shines a light on the design of phones, which are engineered to fragment users' attention from the moment they wake up to check their notifications. Price explains that tech firms hire engineers who craft apps to hack our brains, employing the same [restricted term] triggers found in slot machines, such as bright colors, variable rewards, and sounds, making them irresistible to users, especially the young.
Technology Affects Focus, Attention, and Task Accomplishment
Jonathan Haidt expresses concern over students' inability to focus and complete tasks due to heavy social media use, which can occupy upwards of four hours a day. When these students curb their screen time, they become more productive, engaged in their surroundings, and less stressed. Haidt reflects on their renewed ability to enjoy activities such as going out with friends or attending Broadway plays in New York City. He also contends that technology, especially when given to children early, can harm their development and desensitize them to content that could damage their relationships and mental health.
Technology: A Systemic, Not Just Willpower Issue
The conversation then shifts to the systemic nature of the issue, with Becky Kennedy highlighting the difficulty of resisting the urge to check devices. She suggests that it's un ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Technology's Design and Impact on Human Behavior and Development
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- [restricted term] is a brain chemical that creates feelings of pleasure and reward. When triggered, it reinforces behaviors by making us want to repeat them. Tech products use unpredictable rewards, like notifications or likes, to repeatedly stimulate [restricted term] release. This cycle can lead to compulsive use, similar to addiction.
- Slot machines use bright colors and flashing lights to capture and hold players' attention. Variable rewards mean players receive wins unpredictably, which creates excitement and anticipation. Sounds like jingles and bells reinforce winning moments, triggering [restricted term] release in the brain. This combination conditions players to keep playing, seeking the next unpredictable reward.
- Variable rewards refer to unpredictable and inconsistent incentives that apps give users, such as random likes, messages, or notifications. This unpredictability triggers [restricted term] release in the brain, similar to gambling, making users want to check the app repeatedly. The uncertainty of when a reward will come keeps users engaged longer. This design exploits human psychology to increase app usage.
- Children's brains are still forming neural connections, making them more sensitive to external stimuli like technology. Excessive screen time can alter brain regions involved in attention, impulse control, and emotional regulation. Early exposure to addictive tech can disrupt the development of self-control and decision-making skills. This can lead to difficulties in managing distractions and making thoughtful choices later in life.
- Technology addiction is driven by design choices that exploit human brain chemistry, making devices inherently hard to resist. This means the problem is embedded in the system itself, not just a matter of personal discipline. Individual willpower is limited because these technologies trigger automatic, unconscious responses. Therefore, blaming users ignores the powerful external forces shaping their behavior.
- Engineers use psychological principles to create features that capture and hold users' attention. They design apps with variable rewards, like unpredictable notifications, to trigger [restricted term] release, reinforcing repeated use. These techniques mimic gambling mechanics to make interactions feel rewarding and engaging. Their goal is to maximize user engagement, often prioritizing time spent on the app over user well-being.
- Waiting until age 16 to allow social media use is based on brain development research showing that the prefrontal cortex, responsible for decision-making and impulse control, matures significantly during adolescence. Early exposure to social media can interfere with this development, increasing vulnerability to addiction and mental health issues. Delaying access helps protect young people from harmful content and reduces the risk of developing unhealthy digital habits. This age threshold aims to balance social benefits with developmental readiness.
- Fre ...
Counterarguments
- While tech products are designed to capture attention, they also offer significant benefits such as increased connectivity, access to information, and educational tools.
- Not all tech companies or engineers prioritize addictive features; some are actively working on ethical design and digital well-being initiatives.
- Users, including young people, can develop media literacy and self-regulation skills to mitigate the impact of addictive design elements.
- The impact of social media on focus and task completion may vary widely among individuals, with some reporting positive effects on productivity when used in a disciplined manner.
- Cultural experiences and social activities are not universally enjoyable or accessible, and for some, digital platforms may offer valuable alternative forms of engagement and learning.
- Technology can be a tool for positive development when used appropriately, and early exposure can lead to improved digital literacy and future readiness.
- The systemic issue of technology addiction can be addressed through policy, education, and industry standards, rather than solely focusing on individual willpower.
- There are successful examples of yo ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Parental Challenges In Managing Home Technology Use
Jonathan Haidt and Catherine Price discuss how technology strains parents' lives and relationships, making it hard for families to manage device use effectively.
Technology Strains Parents' Lives and Relationships
Parents Exhausted, Distracted, Disconnected From Partners and Children due to Device Use
According to a marriage therapist, couples issues have increased, with couples having less sex, and being exhausted and distracted by their phones. Jonathan Haidt describes phones as "experience blockers" and "relationship blockers," noting that they disrupt marriages by causing partners to be more absorbed in their devices rather than connecting with each other.
Haidt highlights the negative impact on infants and children, explaining that the presence of devices during critical developmental periods blocks meaningful interaction and eye contact with children. Kennedy experiences this firsthand, noting how device use can distract parents from engaging with their children. Additionally, she mentions the challenge of trying to talk to her husband when he's absorbed in his phone, showing that device use can create barriers to communication between partners and lead to feelings of neglect.
Difficulties In Changing Family Tech Habits Due to Rewards and Peer Pressure
Kids Push Limits, Parents Give In
Kennedy acknowledges that she and her co-hosts struggle with managing technology in their homes, indicating that even experts find it hard to set boundaries and model healthy tech habits. Haidt shares his personal experience of failing to enforce rules about technology usage in the bedroom, even though he knew better. Kennedy suggests that managing the rhythm of technology use in the family is challenging, especially when technology is habitually used from the start of the day.
She also implies that structural changes, such as keeping devices out of reach, can help families better manage their technology use. Kennedy discusses the importance of involving children to address excessive phone use, advising parents to ask their children to call them out politely when they're using their phones too much. This approach can transform calls for attention into helpful reminders rather than criticism.
Adults Struggle With Setting Boundaries and Modeling Healthy Tech Use
Kennedy agrees with Haidt in emphasizing the difficulty that adults have in setting boundaries around technology use and the importance of having conviction in their decisions. They acknowledge the struggle that parents face when implementing technology restrictions and the tendency to waver in the face of resistance from their children.
Kennedy underscores the importance of making adjustments based on new information, comparing it to a pilot adjusting a flight's course. She emphasizes the need for parents to find their authority without aggression and to be convinced themselves of the rules they set regarding technology use in the home.
Strategies For Parents to Manage Technology Intentionally
Kids' Involvement Makes Changes More Effective and Sustainable
Kennedy emphasizes that involving kids in discussions about ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Parental Challenges In Managing Home Technology Use
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While technology can be distracting, it also offers opportunities for connection, such as video calls with distant family members or shared digital experiences like gaming or watching movies together.
- Not all device use is detrimental to relationships; some couples may find that sharing content or engaging in online activities together strengthens their bond.
- The impact of technology on children's development is complex, and some research suggests that interactive screen time can be beneficial for learning and development when used appropriately.
- Parents may not always give in to children's demands regarding technology; some families successfully implement and maintain strict tech boundaries.
- The idea that technology use should be managed from the start of the day may not account for individual differences in family schedules or the potential benefits of technology for morning routines, such as educational apps or productivity tools.
- Involving children in monitoring phone use could potentially place undue responsibility on them and might not always be age-appropriate or effective.
- The comparison of parenting to piloting may oversimplify the complexities of family dynamics and the unpredictable nature of raising children.
- The suggestion to inspire children to join a "rebellion" against technology might not resonate with all families and could be seen as an oversimplification of the nuanced way ...
Actionables
- Create a family "tech-free adventure" jar where each member can contribute ideas for outings or activities that don't involve screens. Once a week, draw an activity from the jar to ensure quality time is spent together without the distraction of devices. This could include hikes, board game nights, or a visit to a local museum, fostering shared experiences and deeper connections.
- Develop a "screen savings" system where each family member earns points for time spent away from screens, which can be exchanged for rewards like a favorite meal, an extra bedtime story, or a small toy. This gamifies the process of reducing screen time and makes it a fun challenge that everyone can participate in.
- Implement a "creative hour" each day where technology is replac ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Need For a Systemic Approach To Addressing Issues
The discussion centers around the need for a united front involving tech companies, schools, families, and communities to address the pervasive issue of technology addiction and misuse.
Tech Companies Must Design Less Addictive, Harmful Products
Kennedy and Price argue that there is a pressing need for tech companies to design products that do not exploit addictive behaviors. The current situation where products mimic slot machine tactics calls for tech companies to take responsibility for the inherent addictiveness of their designs.
Regulations Needed to Limit Children's Access to Technology For Development Protection
The conversation hints at supporting regulations to limit children's access to technology, drawing a parallel with the stringent limitations on alcohol access for minors. This is borne out of a desire to respect and protect children's development against the strategies of companies aimed at hooking young, impressionable users.
Schools and Communities Support Healthy Technology Use
Phone-Free Schools Boost Focus, Engagement, and Social Interaction
Price and Haidt discuss initiatives to get phones out of school settings. They believe that creating phone-free schools boosts students' focus, engagement, and social interaction. When phones are removed, anecdotal evidence suggests a return to more traditional forms of engagement, such as increased laughter and more library book checkouts.
Educating Families On Tech Impacts and Play Alternatives
Price emphasizes the importance of educating families about technology's impacts and providing children with alternative ways to play. The discussion did not provide specific information regarding educational initiatives from schools and communities.
Changing Technology Culture and Narrative Requires Collective Effort
Inspiring Youth to Reclaim Childhood By Resisting Tech Overuse
Haidt promotes reclaiming a childhood reminiscent of past generations, where physical play holds sway over technology. The discussion includes presenting an attractive notion of childhood to kids, one that encourages them to embrace play and interactions away from technological devices.
Creating Healthy Tech Habits Requires Collaboration
The need for a collective effort to change the culture surrounding technology use is most poignant. For real change, various stakeholders must collaborate—including tech companies, policymakers, educators, and communities. Price and Haidt illustrate this through the "Rebels Code," a set of ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Need For a Systemic Approach To Addressing Issues
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Tech companies may argue that consumer choice and personal responsibility should play a larger role in technology use, rather than solely blaming product design for addictive behaviors.
- Some may contend that regulations limiting children's access to technology could hinder their ability to learn and adapt to a digital future, where tech literacy is crucial.
- Critics might suggest that phone-free schools could disadvantage students by not preparing them for a world where digital multitasking and technology use are ubiquitous in the workplace.
- There could be a perspective that education on technology's impacts should not just focus on the negatives but also highlight the positive aspects of technology, such as access to information and opportunities for learning.
- The idea of a "Rebels Code" might be seen as idealistic, with some arguing that it's unrealistic to expect widespread youth adherence to such principles in the face of strong social and cultural pressures.
- Some may argue that the emerging youth movement against tech companies is not as widespread or effective as suggested, and that most children continue to use technology extensively.
- It could be pointed out that focus ...
Actionables
- You can create a tech usage plan for your household that includes specific times for tech-free activities to encourage more face-to-face interactions and outdoor play. For example, designate "Tech-Free Tuesdays" where the evening is reserved for board games, reading, or a family walk, helping to balance screen time with physical and social activities.
- Start a personal project to document your daily experiences without technology, like a journal or scrapbook, to rediscover the joy of living in the moment. This could involve taking up a new hobby such as painting or gardening, where progress is recorded in a physical format, fostering a sense of achievement and presence away from digital distractions.
- Engag ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
