Why Habits Feel Hard with Charles Duhigg
In this episode of Good Inside, Dr. Becky Kennedy and Charles Duhigg explore the science behind habit formation and how to change habits effectively. Duhigg explains the three-part structure of habits—cue, routine, and reward—and describes how the brain's basal ganglia automates actions to conserve mental energy. He suggests that modifying either the cue or reward, rather than the routine itself, leads to more successful habit changes.
The conversation then shifts to practical applications in parenting and communication. Kennedy and Duhigg discuss strategies for teaching children about habits and maintaining control over their behaviors. They also examine three modes of conversation—practical, emotional, and social—and explain how matching communication styles can improve relationships and prevent disconnection. Their discussion includes specific techniques like "looping for understanding" and reframing challenging behavior.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 6, 2026 episode of the Good Inside with Dr. Becky
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Science and Structure of Habits
In this episode, Becky Kennedy and Charles Duhigg explore the neuroscience of habits and effective strategies for changing them. Duhigg explains that habits follow a three-part loop: a cue triggers a routine, which leads to a reward. This understanding provides a framework for habit modification.
Role of Neuroscience in Habit Formation
Duhigg describes how the basal ganglia in our brain automates actions to conserve mental energy, creating habit loops that persist even when we stop consciously noticing cues. Rather than trying to modify the routine itself, Duhigg suggests that changing either the cue or reward proves more effective for altering habits.
Applying Habit Knowledge To Parenting
Kennedy and Duhigg discuss practical applications of habit science in parenting. Duhigg shares how he teaches his children about habit mechanisms to help them understand they have control over their behaviors. Kennedy demonstrates this approach through examples like using post-it notes as cues for children to complete tasks, followed by emotional rewards such as acknowledgment and gratitude.
Types of Communication and the Importance Of Matching
Duhigg introduces three modes of conversation: practical, emotional, and social. He emphasizes that successful communication requires both parties to engage in the same type of conversation simultaneously. When communication styles are mismatched—such as responding to emotional concerns with practical solutions—frustration and disconnection can result.
Specific Communication Strategies For Improving Relationships
Kennedy and Duhigg share several effective communication techniques. Duhigg introduces "looping for understanding," where you ask deep questions about values and experiences, then paraphrase responses to demonstrate active listening. Kennedy suggests viewing children as "good kids having a hard time" rather than "bad kids doing spoiled things." Both emphasize the importance of open-ended questions and showing genuine wonder to encourage thoughtful dialogue and deeper connections.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While changing the cue or reward may be effective for altering habits, some habits may require a change in the routine itself, especially if the routine is harmful or unhealthy.
- The basal ganglia's role in habit formation is complex, and while it is involved in automating actions, other brain regions and factors also play significant roles in habit formation and modification.
- The idea that children have control over their behaviors through understanding habit mechanisms may oversimplify the challenges some children face due to developmental disorders, mental health issues, or environmental factors.
- Using physical cues like post-it notes might not be effective for all children, as individual differences in learning and motivation can affect how well such strategies work.
- Emotional rewards such as acknowledgment and gratitude are important, but they may not always be sufficient to reinforce desired behaviors, particularly in complex behavioral issues or when intrinsic motivation is lacking.
- The three modes of conversation (practical, emotional, and social) may not encompass all types of communication, and there may be more nuanced ways to understand and engage in successful communication.
- The concept of matching communication styles is useful, but it may not account for situations where one party lacks the ability or awareness to match the other's style, necessitating more adaptive communication strategies.
- "Looping for understanding" assumes that both parties are willing and able to engage in deep conversation, which may not always be the case, especially in conflict situations or when there are power dynamics at play.
- Viewing children as "good kids having a hard time" is a positive approach, but it may not always be appropriate in situations where children's behavior is intentionally harmful or when it disregards the impact of their actions on others.
- Encouraging open-ended questions and genuine wonder is beneficial, but it may not be suitable in all contexts, such as when clear guidance or boundaries are needed, or when the child is not responsive to such approaches.
Actionables
- Create a habit alteration journal to track and adjust your habit loops by noting down the cue, routine, and reward for each habit you want to change. For example, if you're trying to reduce snacking, write down the time of day (cue), the act of snacking (routine), and how you feel afterward (reward). Then, experiment with changing the cue (alter the time of day) or reward (choose a healthier snack or activity that provides satisfaction) and observe the effects on your habit loop.
- Develop a "communication mode matching" game to play with friends or family where you practice aligning your communication styles. Take turns sharing a statement, and the other person must respond in the same communication mode (practical, emotional, or social). This exercise can help you become more aware of and adept at matching communication styles in real-life interactions, reducing misunderstandings and fostering better relationships.
- Introduce a "curiosity jar" at home where family members can write down open-ended questions or topics they're curious about. During shared meals or family time, pull out a question or topic and engage in a discussion, encouraging everyone to ask follow-up questions and express genuine interest. This practice can deepen family connections and create a culture of curiosity and open communication.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Science and Structure of Habits
Becky Kennedy and Charles Duhigg discuss habits, focusing on their structure and the neuroscience behind their formation and change, especially pointing out strategies for altering habits through understanding the underlying components and neural functions.
Understanding the Anatomy of Habits: Cue, Routine, Reward
Habits: Cue, Routine, Reward Loop
Charles Duhigg explains the basic structure of a habit as a loop consisting of a cue, routine, and reward. A cue triggers a behavior (routine), which is followed by a reward, completing the circuit. Becky Kennedy applies this understanding by using a post-it note as a cue to remind her child to pick up towels – a simple, effective example of creating a positive habit loop with a specified cue, routine, and reward.
Role of Neuroscience in Habit Formation and Change
Habits Are Driven by Basal Ganglia, Automating Actions to Conserve Mental Energy
Duhigg delves into the neuroscience of habits, explaining how the basal ganglia, a region in the brain, drives the habit process. It helps conserve mental energy by automating actions. Even when we stop noticing cues consciously, our brain still responds to them through established habits. Becky Kennedy reflects on the concept of the "wrapper" of an experience and how it impacts the reception and perception of rewards in habit loops.
Shifting the Cue or Reward Is More Effective for Habit Change Than Routine Modification
Kennedy and Duhigg stress that understanding the habit loop empowers people to change their habits by focusing on the cue and reward rather than the routine itself. Emotional rewards, like expressing pride, create lasting positive memories, while recognizing a reward can increase its impact, reinforcing the habit loop. Duhigg suggests c ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Science and Structure of Habits
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While the cue-routine-reward loop is a widely accepted model, some researchers argue that habits are more complex and can involve additional factors such as beliefs, intentions, and environmental variables that are not captured in this simple loop.
- The role of the basal ganglia in habit formation is well-established, but it is not the only brain structure involved. Other areas, such as the prefrontal cortex, also play critical roles in habit formation and control, suggesting a more distributed neural network is at play.
- The emphasis on changing cues or rewards may not always be practical or sufficient for altering deeply ingrained habits, which may require more comprehensive behavioral interventions.
- Emotional rewards are highlighted as creating lasting positive memories, but negative emotions can also be powerful motivators for habit change, which is not addressed in the text.
- The idea that recognizing a reward can increase its impact may not hold true for all types of rewards or for all individuals, as some may be more motivated by intrinsic factors rather than external recognition.
- The suggestion to create opportunities to repair negative situations with rewards instead of punishments may not be applicable in all contexts, especially where certain behaviors have serious consequences that require immediate and clear disciplinary action.
- Cognitive routines that encourage deeper thinking are suggested to help maintain habits, but for some individuals, overthinking can lead to analysis paralysis an ...
Actionables
- You can use a digital habit tracker to log your routines and identify the cues and rewards associated with them. By tracking your behavior for a week, you'll notice patterns that reveal your habit loops. For example, if you find yourself snacking while working, the cue might be sitting at your desk, and the reward could be a brief distraction. Once identified, you can change the cue (alter your work environment) or the reward (choose a healthier snack or a short walk) to modify the habit.
- Create a "habit swap" list to replace less desirable routines with more beneficial ones while keeping the same cue and reward. If you habitually check social media when you feel bored (cue) and seek the reward of entertainment, swap the routine of scrolling through feeds with reading an article or playing a brain game. The key is to maintain the same cue and reward structure to ease the transition.
- Design a "reward amplif ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Applying Habit Knowledge To Parenting
Charles Duhigg and Becky Kennedy discuss how understanding and teaching habit science can empower children and help in parenting strategies.
Empowering Children to Develop Their Own Habit-Forming Skills
Duhigg has been teaching his children about the science behind habits, helping them understand they have control over behaviors they might feel powerless against. By imparting knowledge of habit mechanisms, he enables them to control their actions.
Teaching Kids Habit Science To Control Behavior
Kennedy shares an experience where she encouraged her child to think of ways to remember tasks, like picking up his towel, without her having to write a reminder. By insisting he could do it himself, she stressed not doing for her child what he could do for himself, teaching him to determine his own habit-forming process.
Using Habit Loops to Build Positive Routines
Kennedy illustrates the importance of communication in disciplinary actions. She views these not as punishments but protections, helping kids understand the reasons behind measures like not having a phone in their rooms and the long-term rewards that come from being held to a higher standard.
Instilling Habits With Cues, Routines, and Rewards
Duhigg concurs with Kennedy, stating that the most potent rewards are emotional ones that create safety and relieve tension for a child. He argues that consistent reminders, rather than shaming, help a child develop good habits, like proper table manners. Kennedy further elucidates the process, using a simple post-it note as a cue for her son to remember his tasks, followed by emotional rewards such as acknowledgment and gratitude once the task is completed.
Escaping Jobs You're Trying to Leave ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Applying Habit Knowledge To Parenting
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While teaching children about habit formation is beneficial, it may not be suitable for all ages, and the concepts may need to be adapted to be age-appropriate.
- Some children may struggle with self-regulation and require more direct intervention and support from parents rather than being left to develop their own strategies.
- The assumption that all children can develop good habits through understanding habit loops may not account for those with neurodevelopmental disorders who may need specialized approaches.
- Emotional rewards are important, but some critics argue that over-reliance on praise can lead to children performing tasks solely for approval, which may not foster intrinsic motivation.
- The use of cues and rewards might inadvertently create a dependency on external factors for motivation, rather than fostering internal self-discipline.
- The text assumes that all parents have the time, knowledge, and resources to implement these strategies effectively, which may not be the case in all family situations.
- Some cultural perspectives may not align with the individualistic approach of encouraging children to develop their own habit-forming strategies, preferring more communal or family-oriented approaches.
- The effectiv ...
Actionables
- Create a family habit-tracking chart to visualize progress and encourage accountability. Set up a chart on your fridge or family bulletin board where each family member can add stickers or checkmarks for completing their daily habits. This visual aid not only helps track consistency but also provides a sense of accomplishment and can be a conversation starter about habits and routines.
- Develop a "habit brainstorming" game for family game night. Turn the concept of habit formation into a fun activity by having each person come up with a new habit they want to develop and then collectively brainstorming the cue, routine, and reward for it. This game can be played with cards, a whiteboard, or simply through discussion, and it helps to reinforce the habit loop in a playful and engaging way.
- U ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Types of Communication and the Importance Of Matching
Charles Duhigg introduces the concept that communication isn't just about words but also involves practical, emotional, and social aspects. He emphasizes how successful conversation results from tuning into and matching your partner's conversation type.
The Three Conversation Modes: Practical, Emotional, Social
Duhigg explains that conversations are multifaceted, often involving practical, emotional, and social aspects. These modes may not always be clear, but brain imaging can reveal the underlying framework of communication. For a conversation to be successful, it's essential that both parties engage in the same "type" of conversation simultaneously, in what Duhigg refers to as the 'matching principle'. This alignment is crucial for both individuals to feel truly connected and to hear each other.
Successful Communication Requires Tuning Into and "Matching" Your Partner's Conversation Type
Duhigg uses the example of a mismatched conversation to illustrate his point. He depicts a scenario where a wife aims to have an emotional conversation because she feels upset and devalued, yet her husband responds with practical advice, leading to a mismatched exchange. This discord escalates their frustration as they fail to acknowledge each other's needs and to connect.
Duhigg emphasizes the importance of recognizing and validating the partner's emotions before moving on to the practical discussion to resolve the issue. This approach demonstrates effective matching, which can quell frustration and foster a more productive dialogue. Kennedy builds on this notion by stating that when one partner shifts to accommodate the other's emotional needs, it creates a bridge for connection, paving the way for mutual understanding ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Types of Communication and the Importance Of Matching
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Charles Duhigg is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and author known for his work on habits and productivity. His insights on communication draw from psychological research and real-world examples. He explores how understanding different conversation modes can improve relationships and teamwork. His perspective is valued for blending scientific findings with practical advice.
- Practical conversation mode focuses on solving problems or sharing information, like discussing plans or giving instructions. Emotional mode centers on expressing feelings and seeking empathy, such as sharing sadness or joy. Social mode involves building relationships and bonding through casual talk or humor. Each mode serves a different purpose and requires different responses to connect effectively.
- Brain imaging techniques like fMRI show different brain areas activate during practical, emotional, and social conversations. For example, emotional conversations engage regions linked to empathy and emotion processing, such as the amygdala and insula. Practical conversations activate areas involved in problem-solving and logical reasoning, like the prefrontal cortex. These distinct patterns support the idea that communication modes have unique neural signatures.
- The 'matching principle' means responding in the same emotional or conversational mode as your partner to create connection. To identify it, listen carefully to whether the other person is expressing feelings, seeking practical solutions, or engaging socially. Applying it involves first acknowledging the partner’s current mode before shifting the conversation. This alignment helps both parties feel understood and reduces conflict.
- Mismatched conversation modes cause frustration because each person’s brain processes and responds to communication differently depending on the mode. When one person seeks emotional connection but the other offers practical solutions, the emotional needs remain unmet, triggering feelings of being ignored or misunderstood. This disconnect activates stress responses in the brain, increasing tension and reducing empathy. Over time, repeated mismatches erode trust and willingness to engage openly.
- To recognize a partner's emotions, listen actively and observe their tone, facial expressions, and body language. Validate emotions by acknowledging their feelings with phrases like "I see you're upset" or ...
Counterarguments
- While brain imaging can provide insights into communication processes, it may not always accurately capture the nuances of conversation modes or the subjective experience of communication.
- The 'matching principle' might oversimplify complex communication dynamics; sometimes, a mismatch in conversation types can lead to new insights or help individuals process their thoughts and emotions differently.
- The emphasis on emotional validation before practical discussion may not be universally applicable; some individuals or cultures may prefer to focus on practical solutions before addressing emotional aspects.
- The idea that successful communication requires matching conversation types might not account for the value of diversity in communication styles, which can enrich interactions and lead to more creative problem-solving.
- The concept of matching conversation types may not fully consider the role of individual personality differences in communication preferences and the potential for growth when individuals are challenged by different modes of conversation.
- The focus on matching conversation types could inadvertently discourage individuals from expressing themselves authentically if their natural communication style do ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Specific Communication Strategies For Improving Relationships
Charles Duhigg and Becky Kennedy offer insights on enhancing communication in relationships, especially with children, through active listening, empathy, and open communication.
Active Listening and Reflecting Back What You've Heard
Duhigg introduces "looping for understanding," a method where you ask someone, particularly when they're upset, a deep question about their values, beliefs, or experiences. After listening, you paraphrase what they've said, showing you've understood their point of view. This strategy is followed by asking if you've got it right to confirm that you were actively listening, making them more inclined to return the favor and listen to you.
Open-Ended Questions and Paraphrasing Show Understanding
Super communicators, as Duhigg mentions, ask many more questions than the average person, including open-ended questions that encourage sharing about values, beliefs, and experiences. Kennedy further suggests that asking such questions allows for longer, more meaningful conversations that are foundational in building relationships.
Aligning Communication Modes to Bridge Divides
Kennedy compares understanding different types of conversations to knowing different languages, suggesting that both parties need to actively ensure they're engaging in the same mode of communication or "language."
Empathizing Before Practicality Deescalates Conflicts
Kennedy suggests that viewing a child as a "good kid having a hard time" rather than a "bad kid doing spoiled things" can help reduce tension and foster better communication. By reflecting on what children say, adults can understand their true feelings, such as their dislike of having no choice over their time. Kennedy notes sitting with a child in their emotion, not aimed at altering the emotion but at addressing the sense of aloneness. Duhigg explains that by first empathizing and demonstrating understanding, one can connect with others even amid disagreements which could deescalate conflicts.
Kennedy emphasizes the importance of not changing a child's emotions but changing the feeling of being alone. Recognizing and validating children's emotions rather than responding with practical solutions or criticism can help in deescalating conflicts. Duhigg encourages asking about feelings, demonstrating that you're paying attention, and proving that you're listening as ways to defuse tension and foster a connection.
Encouraging Wonder and Open-Ended Ques ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Specific Communication Strategies For Improving Relationships
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While active listening and empathy are important, they may not always be sufficient for resolving deep-seated issues or behavioral problems, which might require professional intervention or different strategies.
- The concept of "looping for understanding" assumes that both parties are willing and able to engage in this kind of communication, which may not always be the case due to various factors such as emotional state, cognitive abilities, or cultural differences.
- The effectiveness of asking open-ended questions can vary depending on the individual's communication style and comfort with self-expression; some people, including children, may find it challenging to articulate their thoughts and feelings in response to open-ended questions.
- The strategy of aligning communication modes assumes a level of communication competence that not all individuals possess, and it may require significant effort and skill development for some.
- The approach of empathizing before offering practical solutions may not always be appropriate, especially in situations where immediate action is required to address a problem or ensure safety.
- The emphasis on not changing a child's emotions but changing the feeling of being alone might not address ...
Actionables
- Create a "conversation jar" with prompts for family dinners to encourage sharing and active listening. Write down a variety of open-ended questions on slips of paper that cover topics like dreams, fears, favorite memories, and personal challenges. Each family member can draw a question to answer during the meal, ensuring everyone practices asking and responding to deep, meaningful questions.
- Start a "feelings journal" to practice empathy and understanding with your children. Whenever a conflict or emotional moment arises, write down what happened, how your child seemed to feel, and what you think the underlying issue might be. Use this journal to reflect on patterns and to prepare for future conversations where you can validate their feelings and connect on a deeper level.
- Develop a "wonder routine" with your chi ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
