The Cost of Compliance for Our Kids
In this episode of Good Inside, Dr. Becky Kennedy and author Sunita Sah challenge traditional views of defiance, exploring how it can function as a valuable life skill rather than a behavioral problem. They examine how societal messages often equate "being good" with compliance, leading many people to ignore their own needs and values to please others, from childhood into their professional lives.
The conversation delves into practical aspects of developing healthy defiance, including recognizing internal signals of discomfort and learning to express boundaries effectively. Kennedy and Sah outline how these skills help children and adults alike develop trust in their own judgment, even when facing external pressure to comply, and discuss specific techniques for saying "no" while maintaining relationships.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 11, 2025 episode of the Good Inside with Dr. Becky
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Reframing Defiance and Its Societal Perceptions
In their discussion, Becky Kennedy and Sunita Sah explore how defiance, traditionally viewed as problematic behavior, can be reframed as a valuable skill essential for authentic living. Sah, author of "Defy, The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes," explains that while society often views defiance as aggressive or disruptive, it's actually a learnable skill that aligns with personal values.
Understanding Compliance Patterns
Kennedy and Sah discuss how the tendency toward compliance often stems from childhood messages that equate "being good" with obedience. Sah notes that in professional environments, this manifests as workers staying silent even when they notice mistakes, primarily due to fear of negative judgment. This pattern of compliance, they explain, can lead adults to consistently ignore their own needs and values in favor of pleasing others.
Developing Defiance as a Skill
The development of defiance involves several key stages, according to Sah and Kennedy. It begins with recognizing internal signals of discomfort or unease - what many call a "gut reaction." The next crucial step is learning to express this discomfort through techniques like asking clarifying questions or directly stating one's unease. The final stages involve actually saying "no" and following through with that decision. Kennedy emphasizes that this skill is particularly important for children to develop, as it helps them learn to trust their own judgment and maintain healthy boundaries, even when faced with external pressures to comply.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Reframing defiance as a valuable skill involves shifting the perspective on defiance from being solely negative or disruptive to recognizing it as a tool for asserting personal boundaries and values. It entails viewing defiance as a means of authentic self-expression and standing up for what one believes in, rather than simply as disobedience or conflict. This reframing encourages individuals to see defiance as a way to assert autonomy and individuality, fostering a sense of empowerment and self-respect. By understanding defiance in this light, individuals can harness it as a constructive force for personal growth and authenticity.
- Defiance aligning with personal values means that standing up for what one believes in, even if it goes against societal norms, can be a reflection of one's core principles and beliefs. It suggests that defiance, when rooted in authenticity and integrity, can be a way to honor one's values and maintain a sense of self-respect. This concept challenges the notion that defiance is always negative or rebellious, highlighting how it can be a constructive expression of individuality and autonomy. It emphasizes the importance of understanding and asserting one's boundaries and needs, even in the face of external pressures to conform.
- Compliance patterns are linked to childhood messages through early conditioning that associates obedience with being valued or loved. Children often learn to prioritize external approval over their own needs, leading to a tendency to comply to avoid disapproval or punishment. This conditioning can persist into adulthood, influencing behavior in professional settings where the fear of judgment can suppress individual voices. Understanding this connection can help individuals recognize and address ingrained compliance patterns rooted in childhood experiences.
- In professional environments, the impact of compliance on workers can lead to a culture where employees stay silent about mistakes due to fear of judgment. This behavior can result in a lack of open communication and hinder problem-solving within the workplace. Workers may prioritize conformity over expressing their concerns, which can stifle innovation and growth in the organization. Over time, this pattern of compliance can erode individual autonomy and lead to a work environment where critical feedback is suppressed.
Counterarguments
- Defiance, while valuable, must be balanced with cooperation and collaboration to function effectively in society.
- Viewing defiance as a universally positive trait may overlook the importance of context and the potential negative consequences when it is misapplied.
- The idea that compliance is primarily rooted in childhood obedience may oversimplify the complex reasons why individuals conform to societal norms.
- In professional environments, speaking out is not always met with negative judgment, and there are often systems in place to encourage and protect whistleblowers.
- The assumption that compliance always leads to ignoring one's own needs and values may not account for situations where compliance is a strategic choice or aligns with an individual's values.
- Recognizing internal signals of discomfort is subjective and can sometimes be misleading if not grounded in rational assessment.
- The emphasis on developing defiance in children must be carefully managed to ensure it does not encourage disrespectful or harmful behaviors.
- The process of saying "no" and following through is not always straightforward and can have complex implications for personal and professional relationships.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Reframing Defiance and Its Societal Perceptions
Becky Kennedy and Sunita Sah engage in discussions reevaluating defiance, advocating for a shift in how society perceives it from a negative trait to a valuable skill aligned with authentic living and self-expression.
Defiance: A Valuable Learned Skill, Not a Negative Trait
Becky Kennedy navigates the familiar parental challenge of disobedient children and suggests a shift in thinking about defiance—often seen as a hassle. In this conversation, Sunita Sah, author of "Defy, The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes," provides a fresh understanding of defiance, transforming it from an inconvenience to something more profound.
Society's View of Defiance As "Bad" Stems From Childhood Messages About Obedience
Sunita Sah talks about societal views of defiance as loud, bold, and aggressive, suggesting instead that it is a learnable skill that aligns with personal values. She reflects on societal messages from childhood that equate being good with being obedient and compliant, while defiance is labeled as bad behavior. This view is cemented by her findings that in the U.S. and UK, people comply with requests at "shockingly high rates," hinting that society prizes compliance.
Reframe Defiance As Authentic Living and Self-Expression, Not Just Rebellion
Kennedy discusses how non-compliant children are often tagged as "defiant problem kids," revealing the negative connotation of defiance. Yet, she notes that the qualities desired in adulthood often require a degree of defiance. Sah stresses that speaking up is vital, and without learning this skill, it becomes a ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Reframing Defiance and Its Societal Perceptions
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Defiance, when not properly channeled, can lead to disruptive behavior that undermines group cohesion and collective goals.
- There is a fine line between healthy defiance that encourages individuality and destructive defiance that can harm oneself or others.
- In certain contexts, such as in the military or in emergency situations, obedience is crucial for safety and efficiency, and defiance can be dangerous.
- Defiance as a skill may not always align with societal norms and laws, which could lead to legal or social consequences for the individual.
- Teaching children to prioritize their internal signals over external pressures without proper guidance could result in a lack of discipline and respect for authority.
- The concept of defiance as a positive trait may not be universally applicable across different cultures, which may have d ...
Actionables
- You can start a "Defiance Diary" where you record moments you chose to stand by your values despite external pressures. This diary will serve as a personal reflection tool, helping you to recognize patterns in your behavior and identify situations where you might be succumbing to conformity rather than expressing your true self. For example, if you chose to speak up in a meeting despite a popular opinion differing from yours, jot down the experience, your feelings, and the outcome.
- Create a "Values Clarification Chart" for yourself, listing your core values and instances where you've had to defend them. This chart can be a simple spreadsheet or a visual poster that you update regularly. By doing this, you're reinforcing what matters most to you and preparing yourself to act in alignment with those values when challenged. For instance, if honesty is a top value and you find yourself in a situation where a white lie could be easier, refer to your chart to remind yourself of the importance of truthfulness.
- Engage in role-playin ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Patterns of Compliance Over Defiance
Sunita Sah and Becky Kennedy explore the psychological tendency toward obedience and how compliance, often due to fear or early teachings, can overpower personal feelings of discomfort or internal disagreements.
Fear of Negative Evaluation Drives Compliance
People Fear Rejecting Requests Over Perception Concerns
Sah explains that long-established practices of obedience have strengthened neural pathways, leading to a habit of compliance. In professional environments like healthcare, this manifests as workers refraining from speaking up even when a mistake is observed, due to fear of being negatively judged. Under pressure, people may comply out of a lack of training in how to defy, which leads to feelings of discomfort when considering opposition to requests.
"Being Good" Often Means Obeying Others
This can lead individuals to ignore internal signals of discomfort or disagreement.
The ingrained teaching to obey authority figures from childhood often persists into adulthood, according to Sah and Kennedy. They discuss how parenting for compliance remains with individuals as they grow older. Kennedy remembers a childhood where "being good" meant complying with parents and authority figures, even when it clashed with personal values or judgments.
There is a tension in parenting between the convenience of a child's compliance and the understanding that defiance may be a valuable skill set worth developing. "Being good" is often equated with pleasing others and politeness, creating a social expectation that can suppress ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Patterns of Compliance Over Defiance
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The tension in parenting between a child's compliance and the value of developing defiance as a skill set highlights the delicate balance parents face in nurturing obedience while also encouraging independence and critical thinking. It underscores the challenge of fostering a child's ability to follow rules and authority figures while also empowering them to question, challenge, and assert their own beliefs and boundaries. This balance is crucial for a child's healthy development, as it allows them to navigate societal expectations while also developing a sense of autonomy and self-advocacy. Parents must navigate this tension to raise children who can both respect authority and think for themselves, preparing them for a balanced and assertive adulthood.
- Conflict-avoiding behavior as a virtue suggests that in certain cultures or contexts, prioritizing harmony and avoiding confrontation is seen as a positive trait. This belief stems from the i ...
Counterarguments
- Compliance can be a rational choice in certain contexts, where the cost of defiance outweighs the benefits, and it does not necessarily indicate a lack of courage or integrity.
- Fear of negative evaluation might sometimes motivate individuals to achieve higher standards of performance, acting as a constructive form of social feedback rather than merely driving compliance.
- The concept of "being good" can be subjective and multifaceted, and in some cultures or contexts, it may include assertiveness and the ability to stand up for oneself or others.
- Obedience to authority is not inherently negative and can be essential for the functioning of various societal structures, such as legal systems, educational institutions, and workplaces.
- Parenting that encourages compliance does not necessarily preclude the development of critical thinking or the ability to defy; it can also provide a framework for understanding when and how to challenge authority effectively.
- Defiance as a skill set can be valuable, but it must be balanced with the ability to cooperate and compromise, which are also important life skills.
- Politeness and the desire to please others can be seen as social lubricants t ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Stages and Process Of Developing Defiance Skill
Developing the skill of defiance is a multi-stage process that involves recognizing internal discomfort, expressing dissent, and asserting one's decisions.
Defiance Starts By Acknowledging Internal Tension or Unease
Defiance often begins with recognizing a tension or conflict with what is being asked. Sunita Sah mentions the importance of recognizing internal signals of unease as the first stage of defiance. These signals may vary, from feelings in the stomach, to experiencing dry mouth, or getting a headache. The acknowledgement might be a gut feeling or a butterfly feeling, taking a moment to consider what it's about. Kennedy describes the necessity for children to practice recognizing a feeling of tension, suggesting that tuning into our gut reaction is the beginning of developing defiance. She also illustrates a scenario where a young adult woman at a bar decides whether to go home with a stranger, emphasizing the importance of tuning into and honoring her gut reaction.
Tuning Into Your Initial Gut Reaction
Tuning into one's initial gut reaction is crucial. Sah implies that defiance begins with recognizing your own discomfort with a situation, suggesting that listening to one's gut reaction is the first step. Kennedy described her direct communication when ordering a coffee, specifying that she wanted it "pretty dark." When the coffee came out lighter than she asked for, she noticed her dissatisfaction, indicating an awareness of her initial reaction to the situation.
Expressing Discomfort or Dissent Is Key to Defiance
Vocalizing that you cannot comply is a crucial step in the process of defiance. Sah suggests using scripts and responses such as "What do you mean by that?" to express discomfort or to challenge statements that one feels uneasy about. Kennedy points out that it's important to speak up when feeling uncertain or seeking clarity, as doing so can interrupt the pattern of automatically complying with demands. Saying something like "I'm not comfortable with this" or asking clarifying questions can change the environment and indicate that you are not immediately complying.
Expressing Uncertainty or Seeking Clarity Breaks Automatic Compliance
The conversation around saying "no" implies that expressing discomfort or dissent, such as in situations where a person's boss makes them uncomfortable, is essential for breaking out of the pattern of just agreeing. After receiving her coffee that was not to her liking, Kennedy went back and requested a new one, exemplifying her dissent from the initial outcome and her pursuit to correct it. Sah’s mother defied the norm by confronting some boys and demanding clarity on their racial taunt, rejecting automatic compliance.
Defiance Involves Saying "No" and Following Through
Stage four represe ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Stages and Process Of Developing Defiance Skill
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Developing the skill of defiance involves recognizing internal discomfort, expressing dissent, and asserting one's decisions. It starts with acknowledging feelings of unease or tension, tuning into initial gut reactions, and vocalizing discomfort or dissent. This process includes saying "no" and following through with decisions, prioritizing one's values or needs over automatically complying with others' expectations. Practicing small acts of defiance helps in becoming comfortable with asserting oneself and standing by personal choices.
- Tuning into initial gut reactions involves paying attention to your immediate feelings or instincts in a situation. It's about being aware of the initial emotional response you have before rationalizing or overthinking a decision. This practice helps in recognizing discomfort or unease early on, guiding you to make decisions aligned with your true feelings. Tuning into your gut reaction is a way to tap into your intuition and use it as a valuable guide in navigating various circumstances.
- Using scripts and responses like "What do you mean by that?" is a way to seek clarification or further information when you are unsure about a statement or request. It is a technique to prompt the other person to elaborate on their words or intentions, helping you better understand the situation or address any uncertainties. This approach can be useful in communication to ensure clarity and to express your need for more information before making a ...
Counterarguments
- Defiance without discernment can lead to negative consequences or strained relationships.
- Recognizing internal discomfort is subjective and can sometimes be based on unfounded fears or biases.
- Gut reactions are not always accurate indicators of what is best or right in a situation.
- Expressing dissent is important, but it should be done with consideration for context and potential repercussions.
- Breaking automatic compliance assumes that compliance is inherently negative, which is not always the case.
- Saying "no" and following through is important, but there ar ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
