Navigating the Parent-Grandparent Dynamic
In this episode of Good Inside, Dr. Becky Kennedy examines the complex relationships between parents and grandparents, focusing on how childhood experiences shape current parenting approaches. She explores common emotional triggers that arise when parents observe interactions between their children and grandparents, and explains how these reactions often stem from unmet childhood needs.
The episode covers practical strategies for managing intergenerational family dynamics, including setting boundaries while maintaining respect for grandparents' roles. Kennedy also addresses how parents can navigate changes in grandparents' health and abilities, providing guidance on discussing these changes with children and adapting family interactions accordingly. The discussion offers insights for parents seeking to build healthy relationships between all generations of their family.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 2, 2025 episode of the Good Inside with Dr. Becky
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Managing Intergenerational Relationships and Communication
Becky Kennedy explores the complexities of relationships between parents and their own parents, focusing on emotional triggers and effective communication strategies in family dynamics.
Understanding Emotional Triggers
Kennedy explains how parents might experience complex emotions when they see their children receiving emotional support from grandparents that they themselves never received. She notes that even small actions, like grandparents leaving candy wrappers around, can trigger deeper feelings of disrespect or judgment. These triggers often stem from unmet childhood needs and the desire for support rather than criticism.
Navigating Emotions from Upbringing
According to Kennedy, our childhood experiences significantly influence how we parent our own children. She emphasizes that feelings of resentment or grief toward parents aren't character flaws but natural responses reflecting self-worth and desires for connection. Kennedy suggests various coping strategies, including "re-parenting" oneself through self-reflection and acknowledging childhood emotions.
Setting Boundaries with Grandparents
Kennedy advocates for a balanced approach to grandparent involvement, suggesting clear communication protocols and boundary-setting while maintaining respect for grandparents' contributions. She recommends inviting grandparents to help in tangible ways, such as household tasks, while preserving parental autonomy in decision-making.
Addressing Health and Ability Changes
When discussing grandparents' declining health, Kennedy stresses the importance of honest, compassionate communication. She particularly emphasizes including children in these conversations, validating their observations about changes in grandparents' abilities, and helping them understand these changes while maintaining meaningful connections through adapted activities and engagement methods.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While acknowledging childhood emotions is important, there may be a risk of overemphasizing past grievances, which could hinder present relationships and personal growth.
- The concept of "re-parenting" oneself might not be universally applicable or beneficial, as some individuals may require professional therapy to address deep-seated issues.
- Setting boundaries with grandparents is crucial, but overly strict boundaries could potentially limit the positive influence and spontaneous interactions that can enrich family life.
- The recommendation to involve grandparents in household tasks might not be suitable for all families, especially if there are underlying tensions or if the grandparents are not physically able to assist.
- Including children in conversations about grandparents' declining health is important, but there should be careful consideration of the child's emotional readiness and the manner in which this information is conveyed.
- The idea that small actions by grandparents can trigger feelings of disrespect might not take into account the possibility that such feelings could be based on misinterpretations or hypersensitivity on the part of the parents.
- The emphasis on the influence of childhood experiences on parenting could inadvertently lead to a deterministic view, underestimating the capacity for change and the influence of other life experiences.
- The suggestion to maintain meaningful connections through adapted activities might not address the unique challenges some families face, such as geographical distance or significant communication barriers.
- The focus on emotional triggers related to unmet childhood needs might not sufficiently acknowledge the role of current stressors and adult life challenges in shaping parental emotions and reactions.
Actionables
- Create a family history emotion map to identify and address intergenerational patterns. Start by drawing a simple tree with branches representing family members and use different colors or symbols to mark significant emotional events or patterns you've observed. This visual tool can help you spot where feelings might be rooted and consider how to approach them constructively.
- Develop a "grandparent contribution jar" where family members can write down specific tasks or support they wish to receive from grandparents. This can range from reading stories to helping with homework. Regularly review and discuss these slips of paper as a family to facilitate clear communication and ensure everyone's needs are met while respecting boundaries.
- Organize monthly "family council" meetings where everyone, including children, can express their feelings about family dynamics, health concerns, or changes in grandparents' abilities. Use this time to plan activities that adapt to these changes, ensuring that connections remain strong and everyone feels heard and valued.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Managing Intergenerational Relationships and Communication
Navigating the complex dynamics of intergenerational relationships can be a tender process, as Becky Kennedy sheds light on the emotional triggers and the importance of empathy in communication between parents and their own parents.
Recognize Emotions and Triggers in a Parent's Parenting Approach
Witnessing Parental Support Once Lacking In Childhood Triggers Resentment and Grief
Kennedy points out an emotionally charged scenario where parents observe their children receiving the emotional support from grandparents that they themselves did not receive. This can trigger a mix of resentment and grief because of the unmet emotional needs from their own childhoods.
Parents' Frustrating Actions Stem From Care and a Desire to Be Involved, Despite Misaligned Execution
Small actions by grandparents, such as leaving behind candy wrappers, can become triggers that spark deeper feelings of being disrespected or having one's parenting judged. These seemingly minor incidents are indicative of larger issues, such as the desire for more support rather than opinions or feeling evaluated rather than helped with single issues. Conversations can turn sour when parents feel that grandparents' suggestions are critiques of their parenting abilities rather than simple offers of help or sharing of experience.
Approach Conversations With Parents/In-laws Through Empathy and Shared Goals
Kennedy insists on the importance of approaching delicate conversations with empathy, recognizing the mutual love and concern for the grandchild. She suggests beginning by establishing common ground and clearly communicating needs and boundaries in a way that doesn't invite defensiveness.
Collaborate Out of Shared Love and Concern For Grandchild
Parents should initiate conversations with their parents or in-laws by highlighting the shared love for the children, which creates a sense of being on the same team. By focusing on shared goals, all parties can continue feeling positive about their roles in the child's life.
...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Managing Intergenerational Relationships and Communication
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Create a shared digital photo album with your parents or in-laws where everyone can contribute pictures and comments about the children's milestones and daily life. This fosters a collaborative environment and reminds all parties of the common love for the children, which can serve as a foundation for more empathetic and united interactions.
- Develop a "compliment sandwich" technique for communication where you start with a positive observation, insert your need or boundary, and end with a positive affirmation or gratitude. For example, if you need to address the candy wrapper issue, you might say, "I love how you bring treats for the kids, it's important to keep the house tidy, and I really appreciate your help with that."
- Schedule regular ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Navigating Emotions and Issues From Upbringing
Coping with the emotional baggage that comes from our upbringing is a challenge that affects many aspects of our lives, including how we parent our own children.
Influence of Childhood Experiences and Unmet Needs on Parenting
Kennedy sheds light on the complex influence that our childhood experiences and the emotional needs that were unmet have on our own parenting.
Impact of Emotional Neglect, Criticism, or Lack of Parental Support on Desire for a Different Experience With Child
Kennedy discusses how the body remembers difficult childhood moments and how unmet needs for emotional support and connectedness can influence the way one parents. If one craved emotional support as a child but didn’t receive it, they might strongly desire to provide a different experience for their own child. Kennedy points out that witnessing a parent being an amazing grandparent can often trigger pain, reflecting on the support that one did not receive during their own childhood.
The desire for a different parenting experience can also manifest when a caller feels that her daughter's parenting in her presence suggests a critique of her own past methods, thereby revealing a desire to change the patterns passed down.
Resentment or Grief Toward Parents Reflects Self-Worth and Desire For Connection, Not a Character Flaw
Kennedy recognizes that resentment or grief toward one’s parents relates to self-worth and the yearning for connection. Acknowledging that these feelings are a natural part of the human experience, she notes that they are not indicative of a character flaw. Kennedy underlines that feeling resentful when seeing one's parent provide support to a grandchild, which oneself did not receive in childhood, is natural and reflects an assertion of one's right to emotionally supportive relationships.
Prioritize Self-Reflection and Self-Care to Manage Emotional Burdens
Kennedy emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and addressing our emotional history as part of self-care and healing.
Process and Release Childhood Emotions Through Activities Like Journaling, Therapy, or Mindfulness
Kennedy hints at the process of "re-parenting" oneself, a method that involves adults connecting with their inner ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Navigating Emotions and Issues From Upbringing
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While acknowledging the impact of childhood experiences on parenting is important, it's also crucial to recognize that individuals have the capacity to change and are not solely defined by their past.
- The concept of the body remembering difficult moments is a metaphorical way to describe emotional memory, and some may argue that it's more complex and involves cognitive processes as well.
- The desire for a different parenting experience may not always stem from unmet emotional needs; it could also be influenced by new knowledge, cultural shifts, or personal growth.
- Witnessing a parent being an amazing grandparent might not always trigger pain; for some, it could inspire a sense of healing or provide a model for positive change.
- Feeling critiqued by one's child's parenting methods could also be an opportunity for self-reflection and growth rather than just a desire to change past patterns.
- Resentment or grief towards parents might not always reflect self-worth or desire for connection; in some cases, it could be related to unresolved personal issues or external stressors.
- While resentment is a natural part of the human experience, it's also important to consider the role of forgiveness and letting go as part of emotional healing.
- Self-care and healing are multifaceted, and while addressing emotional history is important, it's also essential to balance this with other aspects of well-being, including physical health and social support.
- " ...
Actionables
- Create a "Parenting Reflections" voice diary to capture and process your feelings about your upbringing and its impact on your parenting. Use your smartphone's voice memo app to record your thoughts and feelings after parenting moments that trigger emotional responses. This can be a spontaneous reflection when you notice a strong emotion or a scheduled daily recap. The act of speaking can sometimes make it easier to articulate emotions than writing, and listening back can provide insights into patterns and triggers.
- Develop a "Parenting Playbook" with alternative responses to challenging situations, based on the parenting you wish you had received. Start by listing common scenarios that cause stress or conflict in your parenting. Next to each, write down how you typically react, and then brainstorm alternative, more nurturing responses that align with the emotional support you desire to provide. Keep this playbook accessible and review it regularly to help internalize these new responses.
- Organize a ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Balancing Grandparent Involvement and Setting Boundaries
Kennedy delves into the delicate task of harmonizing grandparents' contributions to a family while upholding parental sovereignty and establishing clear boundaries.
Discuss Comfortable and Supportive Involvement With Grandparents
Kennedy suggests approaching the issue of grandparent involvement with thoughtful sensitivity and upfront discussions about the types of support that would be most beneficial.
Balance Grandparents' Involvement With Parenting Privacy and Autonomy
Kennedy often addresses queries about the extent of grandparents' participation, indicating a need to strike a balance between accepting their support and maintaining parental privacy and autonomy. She intimates that while it may be tempting to battle out every boundary break with grandparents, sometimes choosing to let go can be a more fruitful strategy. Parents can assert their rules and handle occasional lapses without feeling like they are parenting incorrectly. Importantly, parents do not need their in-laws' approval to feel validated in their choices.
Balance Needs By Setting Routines, Communication Protocols, and Boundaries For Parenting Decisions
To find common ground, Kennedy presses the necessity of boundary-setting through routines, communication protocols, and non-negotiable guidelines. She encourages parents to express their needs candidly to their in-laws and to approach them as teammates rather than adversaries to prevent defensiveness. Kennedy also suggests inviting grandparents to contribute in tangible ways that free parents to spend more time with their children—such as helping with household tasks. Grandparents are urged to limit their advice and focus on affirming the positive aspects of their children's parenting. This approach respects the parents' role as the primary caretaker and decision-maker, ensuring grandparents are involved but not encroaching on the autonomy of the parents.
Respect Grandparents' Evolving Abilities and Limitations
Acknowledging that grandparents face challenges as their capacities change is vital for adjusting expectations and maintaining their involvement in the family landscape.
Empathize With Challeng ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Balancing Grandparent Involvement and Setting Boundaries
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While upfront discussions are important, they may not always lead to a consensus, and grandparents might feel excluded or marginalized if their ideas of support are not aligned with the parents' expectations.
- The balance between grandparents' involvement and parental autonomy can be subjective and vary greatly between different families; what works for one may not work for another.
- Setting non-negotiable guidelines might sometimes create tension or conflict, especially if grandparents have different cultural or personal beliefs about child-rearing.
- Encouraging grandparents to help with household tasks could inadvertently reinforce certain stereotypes or expectations about the roles of older adults.
- Limiting grandparents' advice could potentially overlook the value of their experience and wisdom, which could be beneficial in certain situations.
- The emphasis on parents as primary decision-makers might not take into account the potential benefits of a more communal or collective approach to child-rea ...
Actionables
- Create a "Grandparent's Guidebook" tailored to your family, outlining how they can best support you while respecting your parenting style. This guidebook could include sections on your child's daily routine, preferred disciplinary methods, and ways grandparents can help without overstepping. For example, it could suggest specific times for grandparents to visit or activities they can do with the grandchildren, like reading stories or playing certain games that align with the parents' educational goals.
- Develop a "Family Contribution Jar" where each family member, including grandparents, can write down tasks they're willing to take on. This can range from household chores to organizing family outings. The idea is to visually represent and distribute responsibilities, making it clear how grandparents can be involved in a helpful and non-intrusive way. For instance, a grandparent might take on the task of grocery shopping for the week or planning a monthly family picnic.
- Initiate a monthly "Family Council" where everyone, including grandparents, ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Addressing Changes in Grandparents' Health and Abilities
Families face the difficult reality of grandparents' health declining, and Kennedy offers compassionate advice on how to navigate these changes with sensitivity, especially when young children are involved.
Discuss Health Decline With Compassion and Sensitivity
The emotional toll that comes with a parent's health decline is significant, and Kennedy emphasizes the necessity to acknowledge the grief and changes in once-stable relationships.
Acknowledge the Family's Grief and Loss From These Changes for the Grandparent
Kennedy acknowledges the challenge of raising young children while dealing with declining parents. It's an overwhelming and taxing situation requiring emotional, physical, psychological, and spiritual energy. Before addressing other concerns, it's crucial to recognize and honor these challenges and the sense of loss that can accompany them.
Involve Children in Discussions, Emphasizing Grandparent's Love, Importance, Reassurance, and Coping Strategies
Kennedy stresses the importance of including children in conversations about a grandparent's health decline, ensuring they feel their observations are valid. When children notice changes, such as a grandparent not participating in activities like mini golf, it's important to confirm these observations honestly rather than dismissing them. Kennedy suggests processing one's own emotions before discussing the grandparent's decline with a child, to approach the conversation without extreme reactions or denials.
She advises being forthright and naming truths with children, such as acknowledging that a grandparent might ask the same question multiple times due to an age-related memory issue.
Adapt and Sustain Grandparents' Meaningful Involvement
To maintain a grandparent's involvement in family life, it is implied that some adaptations may be necessary due to their changing physical abilities.
Solutions: Adjust Visit Frequency/Duration, Modify Activities, Find Alternative Engagement
Conversa ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Addressing Changes in Grandparents' Health and Abilities
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While involving children in discussions is important, there may be age-appropriate considerations to take into account, and some details may be too complex or distressing for younger children.
- The advice to be forthright with children about a grandparent's health issues may not always be the best approach; some families may prefer to shield their children from certain realities to preserve their emotional well-being.
- Adapting activities to accommodate a grandparent's declining abilities is compassionate, but it may also inadvertently reduce the grandparent's sense of independence and self-worth if not done carefully.
- The emphasis on acknowledging grief and loss might overlook the potential for positive outcomes, such as increased family bonding or the development of new traditions that accommodate the grandparent's abilities.
- Prioritizing self-care and seeking support is crucial, but the text does not address the potential financial and logistical barriers that can make accessing support difficult for some families.
- The ...
Actionables
- Create a family memory book to capture and celebrate the grandparent's life stories, which can be a therapeutic activity for both the grandparent and family members. By gathering photos, anecdotes, and family history, you create a tangible way to honor the grandparent's legacy and provide a conversation starter that can help children understand and connect with their grandparent's past.
- Develop a "grandparent's toolkit" with items that can aid in communication and interaction, such as picture cards, simple games, and favorite music playlists. This toolkit can be especially helpful during visits, making it easier to engage with the grandparent in a way that's enjoyable and sensitive to their changing abilities.
- Organize a monthly fami ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
