In this episode of Creating Confidence with Heather Monahan, Justin Roethlingshoefer shares his journey from a life driven by external validation and relentless achievement to finding purpose through spiritual alignment with God. After years of building success in athletics and business, Justin faced a health crisis at 32 that forced him to confront the physical and emotional cost of performance-based living. He discusses how his diagnosis became a turning point, leading him to integrate faith with holistic health practices.
Justin provides practical frameworks for spiritual growth, including the SLOW method for hearing God's voice and breath work practices for calming the nervous system. He outlines "the seven Ds"—a progression of distraction, disconnection, and depletion that leads to spiritual and physical imprisonment. Throughout the conversation, Justin emphasizes that lasting transformation comes not from forced discipline but from understanding one's identity according to God's design, where scripture and scientific health principles work together.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Justin Roethlingshoefer describes moving from a life driven by external validation through relentless achievement to finding deep purpose through spiritual surrender and alignment with God.
Justin recounts how his drive to be impressive—through sports, business, writing, and speaking—became his only source of feeling worthy. He explains, "If I wasn't impressive, I would be nothing. And if I was nothing, my soul would die." This pursuit took a severe toll on his health, culminating in a hospital visit where doctors discovered precancerous polyps and a bleeding ulcer.
He identifies five "trapped hearts" that perpetuate external validation seeking: the pleaser, pessimist, protector, performer, and perfector. These patterns, especially the performer trait, imprisoned him in an endless quest for worthiness from others rather than well-being within.
Justin emphasizes that lasting transformation comes from understanding identity through God's design, not worldly definitions. He asserts that "habits and behaviors are your identity made visible." When actions align with who God says you are, confidence emerges naturally—not from force or discipline, but from living in sync with higher purpose. This alignment brings freedom from performance-based validation.
Justin describes a profound paradox: the path to greatness is through humility—"becoming nothing." Through daily surrender, he heard God say, "If you can be nothing, I will make it something and that will be impressive." He contrasts performative energy with authentic peace, noting that people are far more attracted to genuine alignment than constant performing. Releasing personal agenda has brought him new levels of focus, energy, and health.
Justin speaks to closed doors and rejections as divine redirections, encouraging the view that "rejection is protection." Faith means walking "sight unseen," trusting God's will exceeds his limited view. He practices open-handedness, treating nothing—finances, family, businesses, or calling—as his possession. This enables greater generosity and peace, and Justin credits breakthroughs to surrendering control rather than personal effort. For high-achievers and entrepreneurs, he challenges them to pause, get still, and listen for God's direction, allowing "the pressure comes off, the striving leaves, the continual fatigue starts to pull away."
Justin Roethlingshoefer and Heather Monahan explore practical steps for hearing God's voice through intentional stillness, breath work, and authentic prayer.
Roethlingshoefer warns that wisdom comes in whispers, but modern life's relentless noise—social media, constant stimulation, and busyness—drowns out God's voice. Recognizing God's voice comes from relationship and familiarity, which many lack because religious practices have replaced direct communion. Monahan shares that her Catholic upbringing didn't foster intrinsic spirituality, but opening herself to a relationship with God outside religious structure transformed her experience.
Roethlingshoefer provides the SLOW framework: Stillness, Listen, Obey, Wisdom. Stillness allows the mind to calm, creating receptivity to God's guidance. Patience is crucial—listening deeply lets impressions surface, signaling directions or reaffirming value. Obedience follows understanding God's direction, and wisdom emerges to guide next steps. Practiced consistently, this shifts one's posture from striving to waiting, receiving, and acting from clarity.
Breath work facilitates stillness and spiritual attunement. Roethlingshoefer describes Holy Breath: two inhales through the nose, one exhale through the mouth, repeated for 20 rounds. This calms the nervous system and prepares the heart to hear from God. He links this practice to Genesis, where God breathes life into humanity, connecting scripture with biology.
Roethlingshoefer explains that the "fruits of the spirit"—love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, gentleness, goodness, and self-control—mark God's guidance. If these qualities emerge in moments of decision, one is likely aligned with God's will. Conversely, anger, anxiety, or discouragement signal misalignment. God's voice is always positive and uplifting, while shame, fear, and cynicism are never from God.
Prayer, Roethlingshoefer asserts, is foundational—a conversation with God, not a transaction. Like any relationship, communication must be intentional, frequent, and authentic. He advises praying with gratitude and shares that every significant decision is grounded in prayer. When decisions are made prayerfully, guidance and peace accompany them, re-centering people in the "fruits of the spirit."
Justin Roethlingshoefer outlines "the seven Ds"—a progression through which spiritual and physical freedom erodes, culminating in deep suppression and captivity.
Roethlingshoefer opens with a "letter from Satan," using John 10:10 as foundation. He describes life as a battleground, with the enemy's strategy unfolding in seven stages: distraction, disconnection, division, depletion, discouragement, disqualification, and destruction. Each stage strips away positive qualities, leading to an exhausted, joyless existence.
The progression begins with distraction—not through evil but through "good things rather than God things." Opportunities, money, and achievements divert individuals from God's unique calling. Distraction leads to disconnection from God, community, and mentors, severing support structures. Disconnection creates division between public and private selves, with high-performers presenting polished images while privately enduring exhaustion. Division leads to depletion through overcommitment and excessive yes-saying.
From depletion arises discouragement—achievements lose meaning, mental fog sets in, and self-doubt grows. Discouragement gives way to disqualification, where people internalize self-rejection and abandon dreams. Finally comes destruction: joy, love, patience, and freedom vanish entirely, resulting in physical, emotional, and spiritual devastation.
Justin Roethlingshoefer explores connections between scriptural teachings and scientific understanding, particularly regarding sleep health and holistic well-being.
Roethlingshoefer points to Genesis, where God created light and darkness, describing this as the origin of circadian rhythm. He emphasizes that aligning sleep with the scriptural evening-morning cycle brings the body into harmony with God's intended design. Honoring evening as downregulation time enables entry into deep sleep stages critical for glymphatic detoxification—the brain's cleansing process.
Roethlingshoefer highlights that for optimal brain cleansing, 38–50% of sleep should be in slow-wave and REM stages. This deep sleep is necessary for the glymphatic system to effectively clear the brain, reducing risk of dementia, Alzheimer's, and inflammation. Quality, not just quantity, is essential.
Rather than focusing on behavior modification, Roethlingshoefer urges identity shift as the foundation for health transformation. Like scripture's warning against putting new wine in old wineskins, beneficial habits will fade without underlying identity transformation. When one internalizes a Christ-aligned identity, disciplines become natural expressions of that identity. People often claim to be "night owls," but Roethlingshoefer contends these beliefs conceal false identity.
Roethlingshoefer concludes that scripture offers profound health guidance, consistently validated by scientific discovery. As science proves what scripture has taught—the importance of rest, dietary habits, rhythmic living—it creates a unified model where spirituality and health reinforce each other.
Justin's story begins with childhood rejection as a "fat kid," driving him to transform into a "fit kid." Anxiety over returning to his old self drove him into anorexia. By 16, he experienced organ failure, hospitalization, and feeding tube dependence. In the hospital, he encountered fragmented medical care—specialists treating symptoms rather than addressing underlying causes. This inspired Justin to pursue an integrated approach to health through multiple degrees and doctoral work in cellular biology.
Justin earned a college hockey scholarship, then joined the NHL at 27, applying holistic methods to athlete training. Over eight years, he built businesses and wrote books while coaching elite athletes. However, symptoms persisted: bloating, fatigue, insomnia, forgetfulness. Doctors attributed these to stress or aging, failing to investigate deeper causes.
At 32, a colonoscopy revealed four precancerous polyps and a bleeding ulcer. Physicians warned he wouldn't live to 35 if things continued. Justin reflects on this diagnosis as a divine wake-up call—God's message that healing must begin with oneself. He undertook 14 months of transformation, adjusting his environment and behaviors to align with his body's needs.
After 14 months, Justin received a clean bill of health. He sees this recovery as God calling him to extend his approach beyond elite athletes to everyone. He founded Own It and Holy Health, systems delivering holistic health broadly. Today, his fifty-person team impacts 1,400 people daily, driven by the conviction that holistic health, rooted in both science and faith, is a universal human calling.
1-Page Summary
Justin Roethlingshoefer describes a journey from seeking external validation through relentless achievement to finding deep purpose and peace through spiritual surrender and alignment with God.
Justin recounts how his lifelong drive to be impressive—striving for accomplishments in sports, business, writing, and public speaking—became his sole mode of feeling worthy and validated. Every environment became a new stage to prove his value: “If I wasn’t impressive, I would be nothing. And if I was nothing, my soul would die.” To sustain this cycle, he competed in Ironmans, marathons, reached the NHL, launched businesses, and published books, but each achievement only propelled him to seek the next, never satisfying the underlying need.
This pursuit took a toll on his health. He describes a pivotal moment of realization in a hospital bed after a routine colonoscopy uncovered urgent health issues—precancerous polyps and a bleeding ulcer. Doctors downplayed his symptoms—bloating, fatigue, insomnia, forgetfulness—as normal stress or leadership burdens, but Justin recognized they were signs of a deeper problem: a lifestyle driven by the quest to impress was unsustainable and damaging.
He identifies five “trapped hearts” that perpetuate this cycle of external validation: the pleaser (trying to satisfy everyone), pessimist (expecting the worst after being hurt), protector (building walls after being bruised), performer (seeking validation purely through achievement), and perfector (craving flawlessness). These patterns, especially the performer and pleaser traits, dominated Justin’s identity, imprisoning him in an endless quest for worthiness from others rather than well-being within.
Justin emphasizes that true, lasting transformation comes by understanding identity not through worldly definitions, but as designed by God. “It’s not about who you think you are, but rather who does God say you are?” Without clarity on God-given identity, people simply become what the world expects. Recognizing this Divine identity becomes the foundation for meaningful change.
He asserts that habits and behaviors are “your identity made visible.” If you align your actions with who God says you are, confidence emerges—not from force or discipline, but from evidence of living in sync with a higher purpose. This alignment brings freedom from striving and the end of performance-based validation: you simply walk in the “anointing he’s put on you,” moving from forced discipline to empowered living. “Once you know who God says you are, you just know what to do.”
Justin describes a profound paradox: the path to greatness is not through self-promotion, but humility—“becoming nothing.” Seeking stillness and listening for God’s direction, he recounts hearing: “If you can be nothing, I will make it something and that will be impressive.” Each day, he practices dying to self—letting go of agenda, ambition, and ownership—so that God’s plan, not his own, takes precedence.
He contrasts this with the performative energy often felt when people enter rooms seeking validation, embellishing their stories or striving for perfection. Justin observes that authentic peace and alignment—when someone genuinely stands in their identity, not masking it with competence or humility—commands far more respect and attraction than constant performing. People notice and desire this authenticity.
Justin’s daily surrender—acknowledging that nothing he has is truly his, but God’s—is the source of his new-found peace and clarity. Releasing personal agenda, he reports, brings new levels of focus, energy, and health, freeing him from the perpe ...
Identity Shift to Spiritual Alignment: From Performance to Purpose
Justin Roethlingshoefer and Heather Monahan explore the challenges and practical steps for hearing God's voice amid modern distractions and offer a framework for connecting with divine wisdom through intentional stillness, breath work, and authentic prayer.
Roethlingshoefer warns that in today’s world, wisdom comes in whispers, but the relentless sound and noise of daily life—social media, constant stimulation, and the bustle of community and city life—drown out God’s voice. People are continuously exposed to distractions that prevent their nervous systems from reaching calm and stillness, which is necessary to receive spiritual guidance.
He explains that recognizing God’s voice is much like knowing the voice of a loved one—it comes from relationship and familiarity. Many people don't develop this recognition because they lack a genuine relationship with God, often because religious practices and dogma have replaced direct communion. Monahan shares her own experience, noting that her upbringing in Catholicism did not foster intrinsic celebration of spirituality. Opening herself to a relationship with God, outside religious structure, transformed her spiritual experience.
Roethlingshoefer provides a method he calls the SLOW framework: Stillness, Listen, Obey, Wisdom. Stillness is the first step, allowing the mind and body to calm and creating receptivity to guidance from God. He describes how, in silence, clarity and vision for decisions or events come as thoughts, feelings, or fresh insights—direct downloads, he says, from God. Patience is crucial; listening deeply lets impressions surface, signaling directions or reaffirming one's value. Repeating these practices cultivates familiarity with God's voice, making it easier to recognize and respond.
Obedience naturally follows an understanding of God’s direction. Wisdom then emerges, guiding your next steps grounded in divine insight. This framework, practiced consistently, shifts one’s spiritual posture from striving or guessing to waiting, receiving, and acting out of clarity and alignment with God's will.
Breath work is an essential tool in Roethlingshoefer’s teachings for facilitating stillness and spiritual attunement. He describes a practice called Holy Breath: two inhales through the nose followed by one exhale through the mouth, repeated for about 20 rounds. This technique calms the nervous system and induces peace, preparing the mind and heart to hear from God.
He cites Genesis, where God breathes life into humanity, linking the spiritual discipline of breath work with both scripture and biology. Breath, he asserts, is fundamentally both life-giving and revelatory. Box breathing—inhale for four, hold for four, exhale for four, hold for four—is another method to access stillness and attune the spirit, drawing together science and faith to open channels for divine communication.
Roethlingshoefer acknowledges the common struggle to distinguish God’s voice from internal thoughts or negative influences. He explains that the “fruits of the spirit”—love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, gentleness, goodness, and self-control—are the markers of God’s guidance. In moments of pressure or decision, if these qualities emerge, one is likely in alignment with God's will. Conversely, the presence of anger, anxiety, resentment, o ...
Hearing God's Voice Through Stillness and Prayer
Modern life, according to Justin Roethlingshoefer, can become a prison built from conformity to the world’s patterns and behaviors. This imprisonment, marked by a lack of health, peace, and joy, is the result of choosing self-will over God’s way. Roethlingshoefer outlines a progression—“the seven Ds”—through which spiritual and physical freedom erodes, culminating in a deep sense of suppression and captivity.
Roethlingshoefer opens his work with a “letter from Satan,” using John 10:10—“The enemy comes only to steal, kill and destroy, but God came that we might have life abundantly”—as a scriptural foundation. He describes life as a battleground for our bodies, minds, and hearts, emphasizing the need to recognize enemy tactics. The enemy’s strategy, he asserts, unfolds in seven stages: distraction, disconnection, division, depletion, discouragement, disqualification, and destruction. Each stage slowly strips away the positive qualities of life, leading to an exhausted, joyless, and deeply imprisoned existence.
The first stage is distraction. Roethlingshoefer explains that the enemy doesn’t necessarily distract people with evil but rather with “good things rather than God things.” These can include opportunities, money, jobs, relationships, and achievements—things that are appealing and pleasurable, but not actually what God intends. Such distractions divert individuals from God’s unique calling and the genuine doors He opens. Over time, being distracted by worldly incentives leads people off course, requiring spiritual discernment and the patience to pause before acting.
Distraction paves the way for disconnection. Isolation begins to set in as distractions reduce prayer and spiritual focus, cutting people off from God. There is a disconnection from community, mentors, and the support structures meant to provide guidance and accountability. Heather Monahan reinforces this idea by highlighting how disconnection leads us to “lock ourselves up,” severing ties from both divine guidance and meaningful human relationships.
As disconnection deepens, individuals experience division within themselves. High-performers, in particular, often present a polished public image while privately enduring exhaustion, strained relationships, and emotional collapse. This division between the authentic self and the presented self leads to the effortful maintenance of a false narrative, increasing inner turmoil and stress.
The internal division leads to depletion. To compensate, people try to gain control and prove their worth by saying yes to more things, waking up earlier, staying up later, and overcommitting. This relentless cycle depletes physical, emotional, and spiritual resources, ...
Seven D's: How Modern Life Imprisons Us
Justin Roethlingshoefer explores the deep connections between scriptural teachings and scientific understanding, particularly in the context of sleep health and holistic well-being.
Roethlingshoefer begins by pointing to Genesis, where God created light and darkness, describing this as the origin of the circadian rhythm. Light stimulates cortisol production, waking the body, while darkness triggers melatonin, preparing the body for rest. This sacred rhythm is encoded in the biblical description of creation: "evening came, morning came, first day." This phrasing underlines that days in the scriptural sense begin in the evening, suggesting that preparation for sleep and downregulation in the evening are spiritually significant.
He emphasizes that aligning sleep with this sacred evening-morning cycle, by consistently going to bed when the sun goes down and treating the evening as a time for restful transition, brings the body into harmony with God’s intended design. Honoring the evening as a time for downregulation, rather than continuing stimulating activities like checking emails or planning work, enables entry into the deepest stages of sleep. These deep stages are critical for glymphatic detoxification—a process in which the brain cleanses itself of toxins.
Roethlingshoefer highlights that for optimal brain cleansing, 38–50% of sleep should be spent in slow-wave and REM stages. Achieving this amount of deep and REM sleep is necessary for the glymphatic system to effectively clear the brain, reducing the risk of dementia, Alzheimer’s, toxicity, and inflammation.
The quality of sleep, not just quantity, is essential. Consistent sleep schedules that follow the natural rhythms designed by God aid in reaching these restorative stages. The resulting deep sleep leads to greater cognitive clarity and supports physical health, illustrating the harmony between scriptural principles and modern neuroscience.
Rather than focusing merely on behavior modification or self-discipline, Roethlingshoefer urges a shift in identity as the foundation for lasting health transformation. He explains that just as scripture warns against putting new wine in old wineskins, one cannot implant new habits into an old identity. Even beneficial habits, like better nutrition or improved sleep, will fade unless there is an underlying transformation in self-perception.
He asserts that identity recognition—embracing the truth of being an overcomer, a child of God, and a catalyst for change—precedes sustainable health practice. When one internalizes a new, Christ-aligned identity, disciplines such as sleep routines or healthful behaviors become natural expressions of that identity. Thus, disciplines are not ends in themselves but pathways for becomin ...
Health & Healing Tools: Integrating Scripture With Science
Justin Roethlingshoefer’s story begins with childhood rejection. Teased and made fun of as a "fat kid" for eight years, he was haunted by the fear of ridicule. In response, he transformed himself into a "fit kid." However, anxiety over returning to his old self drove him into anorexia. By 16, his health collapsed: he experienced organ failure, required hospitalization, and relied on a feeding tube, only permitted out to play hockey.
In the hospital, Justin encountered a fragmented medical approach. Specialists—an eating disorder expert, a surgeon, a psychologist—asked him the same questions. They did not communicate or collaborate, treating individual symptoms rather than addressing him as a whole person. Feeling like a "problem to solve" rather than someone to understand, Justin recognized that no one addressed the deeper, underlying causes of his illness.
This experience was pivotal. Inspired by the uncoordinated care he received, Justin committed himself to finding an integrated approach to health, dedicated to understanding why health issues occurred rather than merely treating their symptoms. He pursued this quest through multiple undergraduate degrees, a master's, and doctoral work in cellular biology, ultimately focusing on alternative medicine, root causes, and cellular body function.
Justin’s academic and athletic dedication paid off with a United States college hockey scholarship at 19. He earned multiple degrees, then joined the NHL at 27, where he applied holistic methods to athlete training. Increasingly successful, Justin built businesses, wrote books, and took on more responsibility over eight years, coaching elite athletes and prominent clients.
However, symptoms of declining health lingered: bloating, fatigue, insomnia, forgetfulness. Despite his achievements, these issues persisted over four years. Doctors attributed his symptoms to stress, leadership pressures, or normal aging, failing to investigate deeper or systemic causes. Justin, still focused on performance and helping others, ignored mounting signs that his own health was in crisis.
At 32, after living with symptoms for years, Justin underwent a colonoscopy. The results revealed four precancerous polyps in his colon and a bleeding precancerous ulcer in his stomach. Physicians delivered a dire warning—he would not live to see age 35 if things continued as they were.
Justin reflects on this diagnosis as a clear divine wake-up call. He realized that, while focused on healing others, he had neglected his personal well-being; God's message, he says, was that healing must begin with oneself. The diagnosis inspired a 14-month period of transformation. Justin undertook genetic and cellular testing, adjusted his environment, and made changes to his daily b ...
Crisis as Divine Wake-Up Call: Justin's Health Journey
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
