In this episode of Creating Confidence with Heather Monahan, Wendy Smith and Marianne Lewis explore how "Both-And" thinking can transform our approach to complex challenges. Rather than viewing competing demands as either-or choices, they discuss how recognizing the interdependence of opposing forces can lead to more creative solutions. From navigating work-life balance to addressing contentious societal issues, the guests share examples of how this mindset creates opportunities for innovation and understanding.
Through personal experiences and case studies, Smith and Lewis demonstrate how this approach applies at individual, organizational, and societal levels. They examine the relationship between confidence and vulnerability, explain how reframing questions can move us beyond binary thinking, and show how embracing uncertainty can foster personal growth. The discussion offers practical insights for anyone looking to make better decisions and build stronger relationships in their personal and professional lives.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Wendy Smith introduces her book about embracing creative tensions to solve complex challenges. She explains that while people often view competing demands in their lives as either-or choices, these opposing forces are actually interdependent. By recognizing this interdependence, Smith suggests we can find innovative solutions through "Both-And" thinking.
This approach proves particularly valuable in addressing contentious issues. For example, a pastor successfully applied "Both-And" thinking to the Roe v. Wade controversy, ensuring all congregants felt heard and understood regardless of their stance.
Smith shares her personal experience of balancing motherhood and career, discovering that success in one role reinforced success in the other. Meanwhile, Marianne Lewis discusses the importance of balancing immediate performance with long-term development in careers and organizations.
Lewis also explores Brené Brown's ideas about the relationship between confidence and vulnerability. She explains that embracing discomfort and vulnerability can actually build lasting confidence and courage, demonstrating how seemingly opposing forces can work together for personal growth.
Lewis and Smith emphasize the importance of reframing questions to move away from binary thinking. This involves exploring the complexities of opposing perspectives to foster new insights and creative solutions. They suggest that turning "either-or" dilemmas into synergistic opportunities requires embracing discomfort and uncertainty, which ultimately leads to learning and growth.
The approach proves valuable across various contexts. At a personal level, Smith demonstrates how reframing either-or questions helps integrate different aspects of one's identity. In leadership contexts, this thinking style enables balanced decision-making between short-term and long-term priorities.
When addressing societal challenges, "Both-And" thinking helps transcend polarized debates. Lewis promotes using this approach to foster more nuanced understanding, encouraging conversations that humanize opposing views to build empathy and connection. The earlier example of the pastor addressing the Roe v. Wade controversy illustrates how this thinking can foster collaboration and understanding within diverse groups.
1-Page Summary
In discussing the nature and importance of paradoxes and "Both-And" thinking, Wendy Smith introduces the book "Both and Thinking Embracing Creative Tensions to Solve Your Toughest Problems," which serves as a guide for handling complex challenges by embracing opposing forces.
Smith explains that people often view the competing demands in their lives, such as balancing work and personal life or addressing different aspects of their careers, as choices where they must select one over the other. However, she and her co-author suggest that these forces, which appear to be in opposition, are actually interdependent. They both contradict and complement each other, allowing for a "Both-And" approach to thinking. This approach can lead to innovative and creative solutions by recognizing the synergy between apparent opposites.
The book emphasizes how "Both-And" thinking empowers people to effectively engage with challenges in their personal lives or to assist others, especially leaders, in navigating complex situations within their organizations. It argues that by embracing creative tensions, one can approach problem-solving in a holi ...
Nature and Importance of Paradoxes and "Both-And" Thinking
Experts Wendy Smith and Marianne Lewis discuss how employing "both-and" thinking in various aspects of life can lead to greater fulfillment and success. This approach allows individuals to embrace dualities and paradoxes instead of choosing between conflicting identities or goals.
Wendy Smith provides a personal example of how "both-and" thinking enhanced her life. As a new mom trying to navigate work, she faced tensions regarding time management and her identity. However, Smith found that actively engaging with her work and achieving success allowed her to be more present and confident at home. This, in turn, made her more effective in her work role. By embracing and integrating her work and family roles, Smith experienced reinforcement and fulfillment across both areas of her life.
Marianne Lewis talks about the importance of balancing immediate goals and performance with the development and planning for the next steps in one's career or organizational growth. She argues that focusing on current goals and performance should inform future planning, and vice versa. By considering both present execution and future learning, one ensures that today's activities contribute towards opening up new opportunities down the line.
Lewis also discusses the ideas of Brené Brown, pa ...
Specific Examples and Applications of "Both-And" Thinking
The discussion emphasizes the value and process of transitioning from a binary "Either-Or" mindset to a more integrative "Both-And" thought process.
Marianne Lewis and Wendy Smith underscore the importance of changing the types of questions we ask ourselves and others. Instead of settling into binary thinking that segregates, they advocate for a more integrative approach that considers opposites together.
Lewis highlights the importance of compassion, respect, and reflective questioning to work through defensiveness and promote listening. This involves reframing polarizing issues to consider different perspectives simultaneously.
Diving into the complexities and valid points of opposite perspectives fosters new insights and creative solutions. This method allows us to understand the underlying fears and strengths on each side of a paradox, leading to synergistic combinations and progress.
Smith suggests turning "either-or" dilemmas into synergistic opportunities by including both sides of a challenge. For instance, considering how vulnerability can enable confidence or how acceptance can encourage personal growth, rather than choosing one over the other.
The journey towards "Both-And" thinking involves embracing discomfort and uncertainty ...
Shifting From "Either-Or" To "Both-And" Thinking
"Both-And" thinking is increasingly recognized as a means to handle complexities and dilemmas across various aspects of life, as Smith and other commentators have outlined.
Smith highlights that reframing either-or questions into both-and questions facilitates the appreciation of synergies and interwoven aspects of dilemmas, streamlining personal and professional decision-making. Embracing both-and thinking allowed Wendy Smith to find harmony in her work and family roles, acknowledging their mutual reinforcement and interdependence. This approach fosters personal growth and fulfillment by integrating different aspects of one’s identity.
By applying "both-and" thinking to challenging situations, such as the Roe v. Wade debate, a congregation found a sense of integration and fulfillment despite diverse personal views. Smith stresses the tension between growth and self-acceptance, pointing out that authentic change is built upon valuing ourselves as we currently are.
Smith's discussion about the balance between accepting oneself and seeking growth encapsulates the essence of "both-and" thinking in leadership. A women's leadership initiative showcases this balance by combining new practices with respect for current identities. Heather Monahan illustrates this with a pastor who exhibited leadership by addressing difficult topics, thus demonstrating "both-and" thinking's role in addressing adversary and discomfort. Acknowledging both the immediate state of self and aspirations for future change is how "both-and" thinking balances short-term and long-term goals.
The power of "both-and" thinking to overcome political polarization was discussed, particularly in relation to contentious issues like abortion. By iden ...
"Both-And" Thinking At Individual, Organizational, and Societal Levels
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
