The Smurl Family Haunting
In this episode of Conspiracy Theories, the hosts examine the widely discussed Smurl family haunting case from the 1980s. What began as common household issues like malfunctioning appliances and plumbing problems in the Smurl residence evolved into reports of more unusual phenomena, including moving furniture, unexplained sounds, and alleged physical attacks on family members.
The episode covers the family's attempts to address these occurrences through both religious intervention and paranormal investigation, including work with Ed and Lorraine Warren, who claimed to identify multiple spirits in the home. The hosts also explore the public response to the case, examining both supporting accounts from neighbors and alternative explanations proposed by skeptics, including possible medical causes and the notable absence of paranormal activity reported by subsequent homeowners.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 10, 2025 episode of the Conspiracy Theories
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Paranormal Phenomena Experienced by the Smurl Family
The Smurl family's encounter with paranormal activity in their home became one of the most discussed haunting cases of the 1980s. What began as seemingly ordinary house problems soon escalated into something far more sinister.
Disturbing Events in the Smurl Home
The family first experienced common issues like burning appliances and leaking pipes, but these quickly evolved into more unsettling phenomena. They reported autonomous flushing toilets, moving furniture, and unexplained footsteps. The disturbances grew increasingly violent, with Jack and Janet Smurl experiencing physical assaults. Jack reported seeing a scaly-skinned, red-eyed figure, while Janet faced attacks from what paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren would later identify as an incubus.
Spread of Paranormal Activity
The haunting wasn't confined to the Smurl residence. Neighbors reported hearing screams and knocking sounds, even when the Smurls weren't home. Multiple households in the area experienced similar phenomena, including unexplained temperature drops and foul odors.
Attempts to Resolve the Haunting
The Smurls initially sought help from the Catholic Church, with Father Raymond Karciak and Monsignor Francis Cain performing blessings. When these proved ineffective, they turned to Ed and Lorraine Warren. The Warrens identified four spirits in the home, including what they described as a violent demon. Despite multiple exorcisms and the family's eventual decision to go public with their story, the disturbances persisted.
Public and Critical Response
While many neighbors and media outlets supported the Smurls' claims, skeptics emerged. Journalist Paul Kurtz suggested the experiences could be explained by natural causes, pointing to Jack Smurl's previous brain surgery and possible hallucinations. Critics also questioned the lack of documentation and the Warrens' involvement. While the Smurls have consistently maintained their story's authenticity, subsequent homeowners have reported no paranormal activity in the house.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The reported paranormal phenomena could have psychological explanations, such as the power of suggestion or mass hysteria among the family and neighbors.
- The escalation from common household issues to paranormal experiences could be a case of misattribution, where normal but perhaps less common occurrences are interpreted as supernatural due to fear or cultural influences.
- Physical assaults and sightings of figures could be attributed to sleep paralysis, nightmares, or other sleep disorders that can produce vivid and terrifying hallucinations.
- The lack of documentation and objective evidence raises questions about the veracity of the claims.
- The involvement of paranormal investigators like Ed and Lorraine Warren, who have a history of sensationalizing such events, could have influenced the family's interpretation of events or the public's perception of the case.
- The fact that subsequent homeowners reported no paranormal activity could suggest that the experiences were subjective and not related to the house itself.
- Natural causes such as electromagnetic fields, infrasound, or even carbon monoxide leaks could explain some of the experiences, like feelings of dread or seeing apparitions.
- The spread of activity to neighbors could be explained by social contagion, where anxiety and stories spread through a community, leading others to interpret their own experiences through a paranormal lens.
- The effectiveness of religious interventions like blessings and exorcisms is not supported by empirical evidence and could be subject to the placebo effect or confirmation bias.
- The family's decision to go public with their story could be seen as a way to seek attention or financial gain, which casts doubt on the motivations behind their claims.
Actionables
- You can explore the history of your own home or neighborhood to uncover any unusual patterns or events. Start by visiting your local library or historical society to research old newspapers and property records. This can give you a sense of any past incidents that might be similar to the Smurl family's experiences and provide a historical context for your community.
- Create a simple journal to document any odd occurrences in your home, noting the date, time, and details of the event. This can help you identify if there's a pattern or a logical explanation, such as plumbing issues or electrical faults, which might initially seem like paranormal activity.
- Engage with your community by starting a casual conversation about local legends or unexplained stories. This can be as simple as asking neighbors or posting on a community social media group. Sharing and comparing stories can help determine if there's a widespread phenomenon or if experiences are isolated incidents.
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Paranormal Phenomena Experienced by the Smurl Family
The Smurl family endured a series of disturbing paranormal events in their home that eventually spread, impacting their neighborhood.
Smurls Encounter Disturbing Paranormal Events In Their Home
Jack Smurl, Janet Smurl, and their family began to experience strange occurrences that ranged from physical disturbances to terrifying apparitions.
Family Encounters Strange Noises, Burning Appliances, Temperature Shifts, Moving Objects, Apparitions
Initially regarded as typical issues of an older house, the Smurl family's experiences soon escalated. Jack's TV burst into flames multiple times, and despite the family's efforts, a persistent carpet stain refused to be scrubbed away. They would hear scratching and knocking within the walls, and water pipes installed by John Smurl constantly leaked regardless of repair attempts.
By the late '70s, the disturbances grew more unsettling: toilets flushed autonomously, radios switched on and off emitting static, furniture moved without touch, footsteps were heard when no one was upstairs, and a foul stench akin to rotting flesh moved about the house. The Smurl household also contended with frigid temperatures irrespective of the thermostat settings, additional appliances catching fire, and mysterious claw marks on wooden surfaces.
Intrusive Paranormal Activity Causes Physical and Sexual Assaults On Parents
Physical interactions with unseen forces began to affect Jack and Janet. Jack felt something rubbing his shoulders when no one was there, while Janet heard her name whispered when alone. Their children saw toys move, items disappear, and heard scratching and wing flutters. The eldest daughter, Dawn, would scream about floating apparitions near her bed.
The paranormal presence followed the Smurls beyond their home. During a TV appearance and while staying in a hotel, Janet experienced levitation, and both experienced disturbances in their car.
On one occasion, after such a TV appearance, Mary (who lived on the duplex's other side) experienced a day filled with loud banging, and John felt temperatures drop so drastically they decided to vacate for the night. The holiday season saw no respite either; they were haunted by shaking floors, ominous laughter, and apparitions such as a white oozing mass.
Jack was physically levitated, and Janet dragged across the bedroom floor. Jack once awakened to a scaly-skinned, red-eyed figure beside the bed, an entity the Warrens identified as a succubus. Meanwhile, Janet faced assaults from an incubus, the male counterpart to a succubus, leading to her being levitated and flung.
Both Jack and Janet sighted a black smoke-like humanoid form, Jack's also appearing with other menacing figures including an eight-foot creature with a pig snout. Additionally, a visiting medium confirmed the presence of an elderly woman spirit named Abigail and a malevolent spirit named Patrick, who was fixated on Janet and Jack due to a past gru ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Paranormal Phenomena Experienced by the Smurl Family
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The experiences of the Smurl family could be attributed to psychological phenomena such as mass hysteria, where multiple individuals believe they are experiencing the same thing due to the power of suggestion.
- The strange occurrences like burning appliances and moving objects could have natural explanations such as electrical faults, poor construction, or other mundane issues that were not properly investigated.
- The sounds within the walls and leaking water pipes might be explained by issues with the house's infrastructure, such as rodents or structural damage.
- The experiences of autonomous toilets flushing and radios switching on and off could be due to technical malfunctions or interference rather than paranormal activity.
- The feeling of being touched and hearing names whispered could be symptoms of stress or other psychological conditions.
- The children's reports of moving toys and disappearing items could be influenced by their parents' beliefs or could be the result of their imagination.
- The paranormal presence felt outside the home, such as during a TV appearance, could be the result of heightened anxiety and expectation of paranormal events.
- Neighbors' reports of str ...
Actionables
- You can document unusual occurrences in your home to identify patterns or logical explanations. Keep a detailed journal of events, noting the date, time, and conditions of each incident. This can help you determine if there's a mundane cause, like plumbing issues for water leaks or electrical faults for appliance malfunctions.
- Enhance your home's safety by conducting regular maintenance checks on appliances and infrastructure. Schedule an electrician and a plumber to inspect your home for potential hazards that could explain electrical fires or temperature shifts. This proactive approach ensures your living space is safe and may debunk some seemingly paranormal activities.
- Create a neighborhood watch group focused on unusual ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Smurls' Attempts to Resolve Haunting
The Smurl family's ordeal with something beyond the normal has provoked a wide array of efforts—from religious to the paranormal—to contend with disturbances in their home.
Smurls Seek Rational Explanations For Disturbances and Maintain Privacy
Initially dismissing unusual activity as quirks of their old home, the Smurls attempt renovations to address the issues. However, the escalation of strange events forces them to acknowledge the possibility of a haunting, leading them to discreetly seek help from the local church to avoid public ridicule.
Attribute Early Issues to Quirky Older Home, Avoid Being Labeled Crazy
The Smurl family first attributed the odd occurrences to the quirks of the house they were living in, planning renovations to remedy what they initially thought were issues caused by the home's age or condition.
Escalating Activity Prompts Smurls to Seek Church Aid
Upon realizing these were more than mere quirks, they invited Father Raymond Karciak to their home, who performed blessings in each room. When the activity resumed, with the grandmother feeling her bed lift into the air and falling as a consequence, Janet again turned to the Church, and Monsignor Francis Cain conducted another cleansing. The paranormal activities temporarily ceased, resuming with intensity soon after.
The Smurls then reached out to the local Catholic diocese, but assistance was not forthcoming.
Smurls Seek Help From Paranormal Investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren
Desperate for relief, the Smurls contacted renowned paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren in 1986. Lorraine, a claiming medium, walked through the home and identified four spirits, including a potentially violent demon that aimed to destroy the family. Father Robert McKenna was called in by the Warrens to perform an exorcism. The Warrens also performed rituals to provoke the entity, leading to temporary abatement of disturbances. ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Smurls' Attempts to Resolve Haunting
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Skepticism about the existence of paranormal phenomena could question the validity of the Smurl family's experiences and the effectiveness of religious and paranormal interventions.
- The involvement of Ed and Lorraine Warren, who are controversial figures in the paranormal community, might lead some to doubt the credibility of the claims, as they have been accused of sensationalism in the past.
- The idea that the disturbances were caused by spirits or demons is not universally accepted and could be challenged by those who believe in psychological or physical explanations for such events.
- The effectiveness of exorcisms is debated, with some arguing that any relief experienced by the family could be attributed to the placebo effect or psychological factors rather than any supernatural intervention.
- The decision to go public could be criticized as a way to gain attention or financial benefit rather than a genuine attempt to seek help.
- The youngest Smurl daughter's ...
Actionables
- You can document unusual occurrences in your home using a daily log to track patterns and potential causes. Keeping a detailed record with dates, times, and descriptions of events can help you identify if there's a logical explanation or if the activity is truly unexplainable. For example, noting that strange noises occur when the heating system turns on could indicate a mechanical issue rather than a paranormal one.
- Explore local history and previous occupants of your home to gain insight into any unusual activity. Researching property records, speaking with long-term residents in the neighborhood, or visiting a local historical society can provide context that might explain certain phenomena. For instance, discovering that your home was built on a historical site could shed light on the origins of perceived paranormal occurrences.
- Consider ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Public and Critical Response to the Smurl Case
The Smurl haunting is a case that has stirred significant public and critical debate since it first gained widespread attention in the 1980s.
Many Initially Believe the Smurls' Haunting Account
Neighbors and Media Support Family's Claims
Some neighbors of the Smurl family stood by the Smurls' terrifying claims, attesting to the unsettling screams and knocks that they heard emanating from the Smurl home at night. This lent credence to the family's allegations in the eyes of many community members and initially garnered media support for the family's story.
Most Viewers Found the Family Truthful
The Smurl family's account of demonic disturbances in their household was found to be believable by most viewers, particularly when piped into homes via media coverage. Their personal testimonies and apparent sincerity made a compelling narrative that captivated the public imagination.
Skeptics Question the Validity of the Smurls' Story
Journalist Paul Kurtz Claims the Case Relies On Exaggeration and Fabrication, Proposing Natural Causes for the Family's Experiences
Journalist Paul Kurtz took a more critical look at the Smurl case and came to the conclusion that it was constructed on a foundation of exaggeration and fabrication. Kurtz proposed that natural causes, such as Jack Smurl's previous surgery for water on the brain—which can lead to hallucinations—along with stress, family tension, and religious influences, might offer a more rational explanation for the alleged paranormal activities.
Reasons to Doubt the Haunting's Authenticity: Lack of Documentation, Warrens' Reputation, Financial Incentives
Critics viewed the Smurl haunting as a classic moral panic narrative, possibly influenced by the religious beliefs of a Catholic family, and further amplified by paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. The Warrens' reputation for involvement in high-profile ghost stories with scant documentation, coupled with the church's reluctance to validate the occurrences, added to the skepticism. Additionally, the prompt emergence of a book deal and a television movie surrounding the Smurls' account led to suggestions of financial motives behind the story.
Truth of Smurl Case Remains Disputed, Decades Later
Smurls Stand By Story; New Own ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Public and Critical Response to the Smurl Case
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Neighbors' corroboration of the Smurl family's experiences could be influenced by social dynamics or a shared desire for attention, rather than objective validation of paranormal activity.
- Viewer belief in the family's account may be more indicative of the power of media narratives to shape public opinion than of the veracity of the claims.
- Paul Kurtz's skepticism, while valuable, may not account for all aspects of the Smurls' experiences, potentially overlooking phenomena that lack current scientific explanation.
- Critics' focus on lack of documentation and the Warrens' reputation may not definitively disprove the Smurls' experiences but rather highlight the need for more rigorous investigative standards in paranormal research.
- Financial incentives do not necessarily equate to dishonesty; the Smurls could have sought to monetize their story as a means of coping with their experiences or to fund further investigation.
- The absence ...
Actionables
- You can develop critical thinking by creating a "Believability Index" for news stories. Start by rating news articles on a scale from 1 to 10 based on factors like source credibility, evidence presented, and the presence of eyewitness accounts. This exercise will help you assess the reliability of information in a structured way, similar to how the Smurl family's story was scrutinized.
- Enhance your understanding of group dynamics by observing how opinions form in your community. Next time a local event occurs that draws public attention, take note of how neighbors and media react initially and how their views evolve over time. This will give you insight into the influence of community and media on public perception, reflecting the initial support and subsequent skepticism in the Smurl case.
- You can practice ethical discernment by v ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
