In this episode of American History Tellers, we learn about Camp Papago Park, a World War II prisoner-of-war camp that faced significant security challenges. The episode explores the camp's operational issues, including unmanned stations and lax security procedures, and introduces Captain Jurgen Vattenburg, a former U-boat commander who became the highest-ranking German officer at the camp.
The summary details how German officers, using their naval expertise, orchestrated an elaborate escape plan that involved digging a 178-foot tunnel. Twenty-five prisoners escaped during a Christmas celebration in 1944, leading to a 17-day manhunt across Arizona. The episode concludes with the capture of all escaped prisoners, including Vattenburg, who had hidden in a cave near Phoenix, and describes the camp's eventual closure following Germany's surrender in 1945.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Colonel Holden arrived at Camp Papago Park to address serious operational and security issues that had led to numerous escapes. Before his arrival, the camp experienced multiple security breaches, including a notable incident where five prisoners escaped using forged documents. Army investigators discovered shocking security lapses, including unmanned stations, unlocked gates, and guards who routinely skipped ID checks and vehicle searches. The camp's reputation was further damaged when Nazi POWs murdered a fellow prisoner who had been cooperating with U.S. intelligence.
Captain Jurgen Vattenburg, the highest-ranking German officer at the camp, proved to be a significant challenge for American authorities. As a dedicated Nazi believer and former U-boat commander, Vattenburg acted as a liaison between German prisoners and American guards, deliberately complicating camp operations. He encouraged other POWs to resist cooperating with authorities and frequently challenged camp conditions using Geneva Convention guidelines.
German officers, led by Vattenburg, discovered a blind spot in Compound 1A's perimeter. Using their naval expertise and trigonometry skills, they calculated the need for a 178-foot tunnel to reach freedom. The officers organized prisoners into digging teams, cleverly concealing their activities behind a "fistball" field. The escape took place on December 23, 1944, during a deliberately noisy celebration in Compound 1B, with 25 men escaping in carefully timed intervals.
The escape went undetected until Christmas Eve afternoon, giving the prisoners a substantial head start. Over the next 17 days, most escapees were captured under various circumstances - some while hitchhiking, others attempting to navigate the desert terrain. Vattenburg and two companions managed to evade capture for weeks by hiding in a cave near the camp, but were eventually caught in Phoenix. Upon their return, Colonel Holden ordered bread and water rations as punishment. The camp's story concluded with Germany's surrender in 1945, and by 1946, all German POWs had been repatriated and the camp was later demolished.
1-Page Summary
Colonel Holden was sent to overhaul Camp Papago Park due to its substantial operational issues and security failures, which had led to numerous escapes and damage to the camp's reputation.
Before Colonel Holden's arrival at Camp Papago Park, the camp experienced several significant escape attempts that exposed its vulnerabilities.
In February 1944, five prisoners escaped the camp by forging documents and sneaking out on the back of an Army truck, intending to cross into Mexico. Two were apprehended in Tucson after police became suspicious due to their German accents. Astonishingly, Camp Papago Park personnel had not noticed any prisoners were missing until they were informed by the Tucson Police Department. This escape laid bare the gaps in the camp's security systems.
That same month, four additional prisoners managed to escape, leading to nine prisoners breaking out within a month. Though eventually recaptured, their successful escapes were widely publicized, marking a pronounced failure for both the camp and the Army.
The Army sent investigators who uncovered shocking security lapses within the camp that facilitated these escapes.
The Army investigator discovered that the camp's guards often neglected to perform ID checks and neglected to search vehicles leaving the compound, even after prior escapes used a vehicle. Additionally, the investigation found unlocked gates and unmanned stations, further highlighting the lack of discipline and oversight.
Despite the camp's remote desert location, which might ordinarily act as a natural deterrent, prisoners were undaunted and still attempted escapes, taking advantage of the lax security protocols.
An inc ...
The Challenges and Problems at Camp Papago Park
Captain Jurgen Vattenburg, the most prominent German naval officer at Camp Papago Park, displayed both dedication to his country’s war effort and unyielding loyalty to Nazi beliefs, complicating the lives of his captors.
Vattenburg’s military career was initially stymied by the Treaty of Versailles but saw a resurgence with Hitler’s rise to power. As a result, he climbed the ranks in the expanding German Navy and became a U-boat commander. His capture by the British and subsequent handover to the Americans led him to Camp Papago Park, where his ardent Nazi ideology fueled his role as a thorn in the side of American authorities.
At the camp, Vattenburg acted as a liaison between the German prisoners and their American guards, purposefully complicating the lives of the latter. He was adamant about the observance of Geneva Convention guidelines and leveraged them to demand treatment appropriate to his rank, often voicing complaints about camp conditions.
Concerns were raised by other camp officials regarding Vattenburg's request for gardening tools. Officials feared these could be used in an escape attempt, and his defiant attitude served to disrupt the order among American guards.
Vattenburg’s influence over other POWs was marked by his abili ...
The German Prisoners, Especially the Leader Jurgen Vattenburg
A meticulously organized escape from Papago Park POW camp unfolded due to a blind spot and well-coordinated efforts by German POW officers, including the crafty Jürgen Wattenburg.
Within Compound 1A at Camp Papago Park, German officers discovered a security oversight: a blind spot not visible from guard towers. This vulnerability, located near a wooden shack used as a laundry room and adjacent to a wooden coal bin, was hidden from view by the laundry room and Compound 1B, making it an ideal tunnel entrance point.
The officers, leveraging trigonometry skills honed through naval experience, established that a 178-foot tunnel would bring them to a telephone pole on the camp's edge. Under the leadership of Hans-Werner Krauss, prisoners in Compound 1A were divided into three-man digging teams, rotating in 90-minute shifts at sundown with a garden shovel as their primary tool.
To conceal the dirt from the tunnel excavation and acquire additional digging tools, Vattenburg secured permission to level a section of the camp for fistball—an inventive ruse that integrated seamlessly into the camp’s recreational activities.
In preparation for their escape, the teams stockpiled supplies throughout the fall of 1944, selected for their durability in the desert heat, such as crackers. They also dyed their uniforms to minimize the risk of detection post-escape and pilfered maps from the guards' unlocked trucks.
A trio of ambitious escapees even built a collapsible boat to navigate the Gila River towards Mexico. Vattenburg, exercising discretion, chose 28 men to partake in the escape, organizing their exodus into intervals of 20 minutes between groups.
The Planning and Execution of the Mass Escape
Following a daring escape, the manhunt for German prisoners from Camp Papago Park unfolded over the Christmas holiday of 1944, captivating the nation and leading to varying outcomes for the escapees.
Vattenburg and his cohorts managed to escape without notice until Christmas Eve afternoon, providing them with a substantial head start. It was only at around 4 p.m. on December 24th that guards discovered they were missing. A low-ranking guard was the first to notice when only 39 out of the expected 62 men were present at roll call. Cecil Parcell, the Assistant Provost, took charge as Colonel William Holden, the camp commander, was off duty.
The manhunt that ensued over the next seventeen days saw one team of escapees after another being apprehended. Most were found trying to blend in by hitchhiking or attempting to traverse the terrain but thwarted by the elements or civilians. A driver who became suspicious of one hitchhiker's German accent alerted authorities, leading to capture. Others surrendered, like the pair that gave themselves up after one suffered a cactus infection. Two cowboys and members of the Tohono O'odham tribe stopped more escapees, with some being discovered as they unsuccessfully tried to use a homemade boat on the dry Gila River.
Despite these captures, Vattenburg and his two remaining teammates managed to elude capture for weeks. They had camped out in a cave a few miles from Papago Park and survived for approximately two weeks post-escape. Unfortunately for them, after sending his teammates to downtown Phoenix for a newspaper, their absence was noted, and Vattenburg was arrested by ...
The Aftermath and Manhunt Following the Escape
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser