Rick Caruso on California’s Collapse: Broken Leadership, LA Wildfire Failures & the Fix
In this episode of All-In, Rick Caruso joins the hosts to discuss leadership challenges in Los Angeles and the city government's response to recent disasters. The conversation examines how remote work policies and bureaucratic processes have affected the city's ability to handle emergencies, with specific focus on the response to wildfires near Pacific Palisades, where private resources had to supplement public firefighting efforts.
The discussion also explores potential solutions to Los Angeles's current problems, including the role of business-oriented leadership in public service and its potential impact on quality of life measures. Caruso and the hosts analyze how voter participation patterns in Los Angeles affect political outcomes, and examine aspects of California's electoral system, including ballot harvesting and voter ID laws.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 30, 2025 episode of the All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Leadership Crisis in Los Angeles
In a discussion between Jason Calacanis and Rick Caruso, they examine the current leadership challenges facing Los Angeles. Calacanis criticizes Mayor Karen Bass for failing to address pressing urban issues, while both speakers point out how city officials prioritize ideology over practical solutions.
City Government's Response to Disasters
Caruso highlights significant operational issues within the city government, noting that many city workers, including essential plan checkers, continue to work remotely post-COVID. This arrangement, combined with excessive bureaucratic red tape, has severely hampered disaster recovery efforts, particularly in areas affected by wildfires.
Wildfire Response Failures
The discussion turns to the city's inadequate response to wildfires near Pacific Palisades. Caruso describes how the city failed to ensure adequate firefighting resources or pre-deployment despite clear warnings. In response to these shortcomings, Caruso's company stepped in with private resources, including firefighters and equipment, to assist the LA Fire Department and protect properties when city resources fell short.
Business-Oriented Leadership Solutions
Caruso emphasizes the potential benefits of bringing business-oriented leadership to public service. Drawing from his success as a developer, he advocates for a results-driven approach focused on concrete quality of life measures. His hands-on response during the Pacific Palisades wildfires serves as an example of the decisive leadership he believes Los Angeles needs.
Civic Engagement and Electoral System
In their discussion, David Sacks and Caruso address the impact of voter apathy in Los Angeles. They suggest that low voter turnout has enabled career politicians to maintain power without delivering results. Sacks raises concerns about California's electoral system, particularly regarding ballot harvesting and voter ID laws, which may create barriers for outsider candidates seeking to challenge incumbents.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Mayor Karen Bass may have inherited complex, long-standing urban issues that require more time and collaboration to address effectively.
- City officials might prioritize ideology with the belief that it will lead to long-term benefits, even if it seems impractical in the short term.
- Remote work for city workers, including essential plan checkers, could be a response to modernizing the workforce and promoting work-life balance, which may have benefits that are not immediately apparent.
- Bureaucratic procedures, often labeled as red tape, can exist to ensure accountability, fairness, and compliance with laws and regulations.
- The city's response to wildfires must be evaluated in the context of available resources, competing emergencies, and the unpredictability of natural disasters.
- The adequacy of firefighting resources is a complex issue that involves budget constraints, resource allocation, and strategic planning, which may not be fully addressed by private interventions.
- Business-oriented leadership brings a different perspective to public service, but public service has different objectives and constraints compared to private business, which may not always align with a profit-driven approach.
- A results-driven approach must be balanced with equitable process and long-term sustainability, which may not always produce immediate quality of life improvements.
- Voter apathy could be symptomatic of larger systemic issues rather than simply the fault of the electorate, such as a perceived lack of meaningful choices or disillusionment with the political process.
- Low voter turnout can be influenced by various factors, including socioeconomic barriers, lack of voter education, and disenfranchisement, not just voter apathy.
- California's electoral system, including practices like ballot harvesting and voter ID laws, may have been implemented with the intention of protecting the integrity of the electoral process and expanding voter access, and criticisms of these practices should consider their intended benefits as well as their potential drawbacks.
Actionables
- You can volunteer with local disaster response teams to better understand and contribute to effective disaster management. By doing so, you'll gain firsthand experience in the challenges and successes of current disaster response efforts, which can inform your perspective on what changes might be necessary at the municipal level.
- Start a neighborhood watch group focused on fire prevention and community safety. This initiative can serve as a grassroots effort to complement official resources, providing education on fire safety, organizing local clean-ups to reduce fire hazards, and creating a communication network to keep neighbors informed and prepared.
- Engage with your local community board or council meetings to voice concerns and propose solutions regarding urban issues. Participation in these meetings can help you influence decision-making processes and advocate for a more results-driven approach to city management, as well as encourage others to take an active role in local governance.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Incompetent and Ideological Political Leadership in Los Angeles
Los Angeles Lacks Competent Leadership and Decision-Making
Jason Calacanis and Caruso discuss the crisis of leadership in Los Angeles, criticizing current officials for their lack of competence and ineffective governance.
Karen Bass Criticized For Incompetence, Failure to Address City Issues
Jason Calacanis brings attention to the failure of local leaders like Karen Bass to tackle the pressing urban issues. He raises the proposal from the President about potentially sending in the National Guard as a solution if the situation does not improve under local governance.
Los Angeles Officials Prioritize Ideology Over Results-Oriented Governance
Officials in Los Angeles are criticized for prioritizing ideological approaches rather than adopting a results-oriented governance that could efficaciously address the city’s issues. The critique points to a lack of pragmatic decision-making among the leadership.
City Government's Slow Response To Pressing Problems
City Workers Working Remotely Hamper Disaster Recovery Efforts
Caruso points out that city hall workers, particularly plan checkers in Los Angeles, have yet to return to the office post-COVID. Due to this remote working situation, vital disaster recovery efforts, especially after the loss of homes to fires, have been hampered.
Red Tape Delays Wildfire Rebuilding
The red tape in both the city of Los Angeles and its county is also highlighted as a major issue. Caruso criticizes the bureaucra ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Incompetent and Ideological Political Leadership in Los Angeles
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Competence is subjective, and what may appear as incompetence to some may be the result of complex, systemic issues that a single individual like Karen Bass cannot easily overcome.
- Prioritizing ideology does not necessarily mean neglecting results; it could be that the officials are working within a framework they believe will yield long-term benefits, even if short-term results are not immediately visible.
- Remote work has been widely adopted across various sectors and can lead to increased productivity; the issues with disaster recovery efforts may stem from other systemic problems rather than the remote status of city workers.
- Bureaucratic processes, often referred to as red tape, can be in place to ensure ac ...
Actionables
- You can evaluate the effectiveness of local leadership by creating a scorecard for your city officials. Start by listing the key issues in your community, such as public safety, infrastructure, and education. For each issue, track public statements, policy proposals, and voting records of your local officials to assess their performance. Share your findings with neighbors to foster informed discussions about leadership competence.
- Volunteer to help reduce bureaucratic hurdles in your community by joining or forming a local action group. This group could focus on identifying and addressing specific red tape challenges, such as permit processes for rebuilding after natural disasters. Work with local government offices to streamline these processes, and document your progress to inspire similar actions in other communities.
- Advocate for results-oriented governance by starting a petit ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Failures in the City's Disaster Response
The city's response to wildfires near Pacific Palisades highlights significant gaps in disaster preparedness and response, underscoring the importance of private intervention and the slow recovery process for affected communities.
City Unprepared, Uncoordinated In Wildfire Response Near Pacific Palisades
The discussion focused on what might have been if different leadership, possibly alluding to Rick Caruso, had been in place during the Palisades fires. Caruso criticized the current administration for failing to ensure adequate firefighting resources or pre-deployment, even though there were warnings. He went on to describe an incident where a fire which was not extinguished properly, smoldered and reignited. Due to the lack of preparedness and pre-deployment, the situation worsened.
Inadequate Firefighting Resources; No Pre-deployment Despite Warnings
Caruso pointed out, specifically, that firefighters faced serious challenges due to a lack of water because the largest reservoir had not been filled. This left firefighters scrambling for resources to combat the escalating fire effectively.
Private Aid Supplemented City's Inadequate Disaster Response
In the absence of adequate city resources, Caruso used his company's private resources, firefighters included, to defend properties from the fire.
Caruso's Company Used Private Resources to Save Properties the City Couldn't
His team was not only able to save their property, Palisades Village ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Failures in the City's Disaster Response
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The city's disaster response may have been hampered by unforeseen challenges or rapidly changing conditions that are not accounted for in the criticism.
- Resource allocation during widespread emergencies can be complex, and the city may have been managing multiple priorities simultaneously.
- The criticism of the city's preparedness may not fully consider the scale of the disaster or the limitations of municipal resources in the face of such events.
- The effectiveness of private intervention is not necessarily indicative of a failure on the part of the city; it could also demonstrate the value of public-private partnerships in crisis situations.
- The city's efforts post-disaster may be more focused on long-term, sustainable solutions for community recovery rather than immediate relief, which might explain the perceived slowness.
- The city may have protocols that prioritize certain actions that are not immediately visible to the public, leading to a percept ...
Actionables
- You can create a personal emergency plan that includes alternative water sources and fire suppression tools. By identifying nearby water sources such as pools, ponds, or water tanks, and investing in portable fire extinguishers or fire blankets, you'll be better prepared for a fire emergency. For example, you might map out the water sources in your neighborhood and purchase a fire extinguisher for each floor of your home.
- You can volunteer with local disaster recovery organizations to help streamline recovery efforts. By offering your time to assist with administrative tasks, you can help reduce bureaucratic delays for affected individuals. For instance, you might assist with paperwork processing or distribution of supplies to ensure quicker aid to those in need.
- You can advocate for improved city planning and resource allocation by p ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Need For Competent, Business-Oriented Leadership and Governance
The discussion around Los Angeles governance highlights the advantages of having leaders like Rick Caruso, whose success as a developer underlines the potential benefits of business-oriented leadership in public service.
Caruso's Success as a Developer Highlights Practical, Results-Driven Leadership
Rick Caruso underscores the importance of making good business decisions, suggesting that these decisions are equally important when running a city. Caruso's approach to business revolves around bringing joy and enriching people's lives, a philosophy which he believes can be effectively translated into public service. This philosophy of enriching lives is presented as a foundation for his potential approach to governance. He further suggests that a results-driven leadership can do what others haven't, setting a new standard that others might follow.
In Harmony with Caruso's philosophy, he stresses the importance of concrete quality of life measures such as adequate housing, low crime rates, and robust opportunities for family and business growth. He makes clear his belief that California, given its economic standing, should lead the nation in these areas.
Caruso is known for being a staunch opponent of street encampments, advocating instead for providing services and proper housing to assist the homeless. Additionally, Caruso proposes the redirection of funds from ineffective homelessness solutions to organizations with proven track records of success.
Problem-Solving Business Leaders Could Govern Los Angeles Effectively
Discussing the current state of leadership in Los Angeles, Caruso laments the lack of attention, responsiveness, and efficiency. He paints a picture of incompetence and stagnation within LA's existing leadership.
Caruso's Hands-On Approach During Wildfires Shows Needed City Leadership
One example of Caruso's ability to take charge comes from his responsive actions during the wildfires in the Pacific Palisades. Caruso mobilized a team that provided private firefighters, water trucks, and retardant to protect properties. This response not only preserved the properties but also did not detract resources from residential areas. It is evidence that hands-on, decisive actions are effective and can be reflective of the kind of leadership Los Angeles needs.
Business Focus on Competence Could Transform City's Governance
Without openly pushing his ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Need For Competent, Business-Oriented Leadership and Governance
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Business-oriented leadership may not always translate well to public service due to differing objectives; profit motives do not always align with the public good.
- Good business decisions may not account for the complexities of running a city, which includes balancing the needs of diverse stakeholders and long-term planning beyond financial considerations.
- Enriching lives through business practices does not automatically equate to effective governance, which requires a broader understanding of policy, law, and civic engagement.
- Results-driven leadership in business may focus on short-term gains rather than the long-term welfare of a city and its residents.
- Quality of life measures are important, but there is debate over the best ways to achieve these goals, and what works in business may not be directly applicable to public policy.
- The assumption that California should lead the nation in quality of life measures may overlook the unique challenges and circumstances of other states.
- The approach to homelessness that focuses on providing services and proper housing, while widely supported, may oversimplify the complexity of the issue and the range of solutions needed.
- Redirecting funds to organizations with proven track records is a sound idea, but determining effectiveness can be complex and may require more nuanced approaches than simple track records of success.
- The critique of Los Angeles leadership may not fully acknowledge the constraints and challenges inherent in public administration, including legal, budgetary, and political factors.
- The effectiveness of Caruso's hands-on approach during wildfires, while commendable, may not be indicative of how he would perform in the day-to-day operations of city governance.
- The idea that business competence directly translates to city governance may not consider the different skills a ...
Actionables
- You can volunteer with local organizations that focus on quality of life improvements to gain firsthand experience in community-driven change. By participating in activities like neighborhood clean-ups or tree-planting events, you'll contribute to creating a more pleasant environment and learn about the practical aspects of enhancing community spaces.
- Start a small-scale initiative to support residents in your area affected by disasters, such as a tool-lending library or a skills-sharing group. This could involve setting up a social media group where neighbors can offer or request help with home repairs, share resources, or provide advice on disaster preparedness, fostering a supportive community network.
- Engage with your local government by attending town hall meetings or submitti ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Civic Engagement and Accountability of Elected Officials
Civic engagement is recognized as an essential factor in ensuring the accountability of elected officials, particularly in Los Angeles, where voter apathy has been a pressing concern.
Voter Apathy Enabled Ideological Officials' Dominance in Los Angeles
David Sacks and Rick Caruso discuss the issue of voter apathy in California, suggesting it has contributed to a political climate where a single party dominates and officials remain in power for extended periods without delivering satisfactory results. Caruso emphasizes that a higher voter turnout, with citizens exercising their rights to vote regardless of political beliefs, is necessary to challenge the status quo of career politicians and foster a robust, accountable political system.
Need More Voters to Hold Representatives Accountable
Rick Caruso places a spotlight on the crucial role of active participation from the electorate. He implies that without strong civic engagement, officials retain their positions almost indefinitely, which may be contrary to the principles of the nation's founding fathers. Fostering accountability also involves ensuring that law enforcement authorities are supported and able to enforce the law, which is a fundamental aspect Caruso believes elected officials should be held to.
Political System Lets Officials Stay In Power Without Results
Rick Caruso critiques a political system that seemingly entitles officials to hold office for life, advocating for a shift away from ideological governance that has failed to produce beneficial outcomes. The prevalence of ideologue officials, elected by the motivated fringes of the electorate, has led to governance that lacks tangible results, highlighting the need for greater voter engagement across the entire political spectrum.
Concerns: System, Ballot Harvesting, Voter ID Laws Hinder Outsider Challenges
David Sacks raises concerns regarding the electoral system in California, where the legality of ballot harvesting and the illegality of checking voter IDs may create a barrier that prevents outsiders from being elected. These regulatory concerns could be significant in determining the extent to which new candidates can challenge inc ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Civic Engagement and Accountability of Elected Officials
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Voter apathy might reflect a contentment with the status quo rather than just a lack of engagement or dissatisfaction with the political system.
- High voter turnout does not necessarily ensure the accountability of elected officials if the electorate is not well-informed.
- The dominance of a single party can sometimes lead to stability and consistency in governance, which might be preferred by some voters.
- The assumption that career politicians are inherently less effective or accountable than newcomers can be challenged; experience in office can also lead to more effective governance.
- Supporting law enforcement authorities is important, but accountability also requires oversight of those authorities to prevent abuse of power.
- Ideological governance is not inherently unproductive; some would argue that strong ideological convictions are necessary to drive meaningful policy changes.
- The political system allowing officials to stay in power could be seen as a reflection of voter preference rather than a flaw in the system.
- Ballot harvesting and voter ID laws are conten ...
Actionables
- You can start a "Meet Your Candidate" social media group to facilitate discussions about local candidates and their policies. By creating a space on platforms like Facebook or Nextdoor, you encourage your neighbors to share information, ask questions, and become more informed voters. For example, each week, the group could focus on a different candidate or issue, with members contributing research or firsthand experiences related to the topic.
- Develop a "Voter Buddy" system within your circle to ensure everyone votes on election day. Pair up with a friend or family member to remind each other about registration deadlines, research candidates together, and make plans to go to the polls or submit mail-in ballots. This could include setting calendar reminders for each other or having a shared document with key dates and candidate platforms.
- Volunteer for a local election integrity initiative to help a ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
