Podcasts > 2 Bears, 1 Cave with Tom Segura & Bert Kreischer > Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

By Tom Segura, Bert Kreischer

In this episode of 2 Bears, 1 Cave, Mel Robbins shares her personal experience with financial hardship, depression, and alcohol dependency that led her to make significant life changes at age 41. She describes how an $800,000 debt from a failed business venture in 2007-2008 affected her family relationships and pushed her to develop new strategies for personal transformation.

The discussion covers Robbins' development of the "5-Second Rule," a technique that helps people take action before self-doubt sets in. She explains how sharing this method in a 2011 TEDx talk launched her career as a speaker and author, leading to her book selling 8 million copies and being translated into 63 languages. The conversation also touches on her current work reaching millions through her podcast, where she shares content aimed at helping others change their lives.

Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 10, 2025 episode of the 2 Bears, 1 Cave with Tom Segura & Bert Kreischer

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

1-Page Summary

Mel's Personal Struggles and Self-Improvement Journey

Mel Robbins shares her journey through severe financial hardship, including an $800,000 debt from a failed business venture during 2007-2008. During this crisis, she struggled with depression and alcohol, negatively impacting her role as a parent and spouse. Facing potential bankruptcy and the deterioration of her family relationships, Mel realized she needed to make dramatic changes in her life at age 41.

The Development and Application of the "5-Second Rule"

Robbins developed the "5-Second Rule," a simple but powerful technique involving counting down from five before taking action. She explains that this method works by circumventing the brain's natural tendency to seek comfort over challenge, creating a crucial five-second window for action before doubt sets in. The technique gained widespread attention after Robbins shared it during a TEDx talk in 2011, leading to numerous success stories from people who used it to overcome various challenges, from addiction to anxiety.

Mel's Journey to Speaker and Author Success

Following her viral TEDx talk, Robbins received her first paid speaking opportunity for $10,000, marking a turning point in her career. Through determined effort and strategic preparation, she quickly became the most booked female speaker in the world within three years. Her book "The 5 Second Rule" sold 8 million copies in 11 months and was translated into 63 languages. Robbins maintains a significant global presence through her podcast, which reaches 9-11 million weekly listeners, focusing on delivering accessible, valuable content to help others transform their lives.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Create a personal "5-Second Inspiration Journal" where you jot down one action you've been postponing each morning and then use a 5-second countdown to initiate the task. This journal serves as a commitment device, encouraging you to take small steps towards your goals daily. For example, if you've been delaying starting a fitness routine, write it down and count down from five to begin a simple exercise like a walk or a set of push-ups.
  • Develop a "Turnaround Plan" for your finances by assessing your debts and income, then setting up a weekly review to track expenses and savings. Use this plan to identify unnecessary expenditures and redirect funds to pay off debts more efficiently. For instance, if you notice a recurring subscription service that you rarely use, cancel it and allocate that money towards debt repayment.
  • Establish a "Family and Self-Care Hour" each week where you focus on activities that strengthen family bonds and personal well-being, such as playing board games together or practicing meditation. This dedicated time helps to improve relationships and personal health, acting as a preventive measure against stress and burnout. As an example, you could use this hour to cook a healthy meal with your family, fostering both connection and better eating habits.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

Mel's Personal Struggles and Self-Improvement Journey

Mel Robbins candidly shares the dire setbacks she and her family faced and the personal growth efforts she made to overcome them, including incorporating the "5-Second Rule" to instigate change.

Mel's Mental Health and Coping Mechanisms During Crisis

Mel's Family Faces $800k Debt and Foreclosure After Business Failure

Mel Robbins and her family experienced deep financial turmoil, finding themselves $800,000 in debt with liens on their house after a business venture, a local pizza joint, failed. Ignoring advice, they opened a second location during 2007-2008 that turned out to be too expensive and poorly located, leading to even further debt and the eventual foreclosure threat.

Mel Turned To Alcohol and Avoidance, Neglecting Responsibilities As a Parent and Spouse

During this financial and personal crisis, Mel turned to drinking too much and experienced deep depression. She felt trapped in negative behavior and thought patterns, describing it as a "torture chamber of self-criticism" and struggled with self-hatred. Meanwhile, she found herself constantly apologizing for her anger and frustration, which affected her children and made her husband, Chris, feel like the enemy. She coped by avoiding debt collectors and neglecting responsibilities, like shopping without money and failing to manage her stress appropriately.

Mel Needed Drastic Action to Turn Her Life Around and Save Her Family

Acknowledging the massive pain and fear from her family's financial situation, Mel realized that she needed to take drastic action. She reached a moment of clarity, understanding that she couldn't allow her story to end negatively at age 41. She made a decisive choice to prevent bankruptcy, save her marriage, address her alcohol problem, and change her life's trajectory.

Mel's Use of the "5-Second Rule" to Overcome Inertia and Motivate Action

"5-Second Rule": Act Before Brain Intervenes By Counting Down From 5

Mel credits the "5-Second Rule" for helping her beat inertia and initiate action. This rule involves counting down from five to zero to prompt immediate action before the brain can introduce doubts or excuses. Mel describes the timer as a critical decision-making ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Mel's Personal Struggles and Self-Improvement Journey

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Create a "5-Minute Action Plan" to tackle procrastination by writing down a small, manageable task you can do in five minutes whenever you feel overwhelmed. This can be as simple as organizing your desk, calling to make an appointment, or starting a load of laundry. The idea is to break the cycle of avoidance with a quick win that can lead to tackling bigger tasks.
  • Develop a "Motivation Trigger" by pairing the countdown with a specific, uplifting song or sound that energizes you. Play this tune whenever you need to kickstart an activity. Over time, this auditory cue can become a psychological signal that it's time to take action, similar to how Pavlov's dogs were conditioned to respond to a bell.
  • Start a "5-Second Journal" to document your dai ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

The Development and Application of the "5-Second Rule"

Mel Robbins has introduced a simple yet transformative tool called the "5-Second Rule" which has garnered significant attention for its potential to prompt behavior change.

Neuroscience of the "5-Second Rule" as a Tool For Behavior Change

Robbins proposes that action is crucial for overcoming the moments of hesitation that lead to procrastination and anxiety. She presents the "5-Second Rule" as a direct response to the brain's tendency to seek comfort over challenge.

Brains Prefer Comfort Over Challenge

Our brains are hardwired to prefer comfort and to avoid risk and challenge. When faced with a task that requires us to move out of our comfort zone, the brain might resist.

The Crucial 5-Second Window: Act Before Hesitation Breeds Excuses

According to Robbins, the "5-Second Rule" states that one must act on an instinct within a critical five-second window. If action isn’t taken in that short period, the brain will flood with excuses, and the opportunity to act may be lost.

Countdown to Act Overcomes Task Avoidance

Robbins advocates for a countdown method—counting down from five to one—as a tool to propel oneself into action. She utilizes this rule for tasks she finds less appealing, such as getting out of bed or picking up dog waste, suggesting it aids in overcoming avoidance behaviors.

The Impact of Mel's "5-Second Rule" on Lives

Robbins’ method has influenced many individuals worldwide, leading to major life transformations.

Mel's Viral Tedx Talk on the "5-Second Rule" Spurs Major Life Changes

Robbins experienced an anxiety moment while giving her TEDx talk in 2011 and shared the "5-Second Rule" on stage, explaining the concept spontaneously. The talk went viral, helping to spread the word about her technique. ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Development and Application of the "5-Second Rule"

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The "5-Second Rule" may oversimplify complex psychological issues like depression and addiction, which typically require comprehensive treatment plans, including therapy and sometimes medication.
  • Behavioral change often involves long-term strategies and habits, which may not be addressed by a quick-fix approach like the "5-Second Rule."
  • The effectiveness of the "5-Second Rule" may be subject to individual differences, such as personal motivation, psychological disposition, and the nature of the task or challenge.
  • The rule's reliance on self-initiated countdown may not be as effective in individuals with certain cognitive or neurological conditions that impair executive function or decision-making.
  • The viral nature of R ...

Actionables

  • You can create a "5-Second Challenge" journal to track daily tasks you've been avoiding. Start by listing tasks you typically hesitate to do, then note the date and time you use the 5-second countdown to initiate action. Reflect on your feelings before and after completing the task to see the rule's impact on your behavior.
  • Develop a "5-Second Buddy" system with a friend or family member where you hold each other accountable. Whenever one of you feels hesitant or is procrastinating, the other can initiate a 5-second countdown to help jumpstart action. This mutual support can reinforce the habit of overcoming avoidance behaviors.
  • Integrate a "5-Second Launch" into your mo ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mel Robbins Calls Out Bert’s People-Pleasing | 2 Bears, 1 Cave

Mel's Journey to Speaker and Author Success

Mel recounts her journey from financial struggle to becoming a sought-after speaker and bestselling author.

Mel's Journey From Struggling Financially To Becoming a Sought-After Speaker

Mel describes the moment that would transition her from financial struggle to the beginning of her career as a speaker. This came in the form of an offer from a man named Darren to speak at a sales conference for $10,000 after Mel's TEDx talk went viral—an opportunity that represented a significant financial turning point for her. Feeling unworthy of the amount, she hired a graphic designer with $5,000 to ensure her presentation matched the value of the opportunity.

Mel Was Offered $10,000, More Than She Had Seen In Years

Feeling the weight of the $10,000, which was more money than she could imagine and equivalent to several months of her mortgage payments, Mel was determined to deliver an impactful performance.

Determined to Deliver Impact, Mel Invested In Professional Materials and Preparation

After delivering an impressive performance, Darren complemented her as one of the best speakers he’d ever seen, leading to a flood of speaking business opportunities.

Mel's Dynamic, Relatable Style Led To a Flood of Engagements

Mel worked hard, recounting how she wore the same outfit all the time to save money, took regional coach flights, arrived late at hotels, and steamed her single outfit in the shower to maintain a carry-on to avoid missing flights. She spoke at regional conferences and various other engagements, totaling 47 bookings within a year while working a full-time job, which rapidly increased to 97 engagements the next year. Within three years, she became the most booked female speaker in the world.

Mel's Transition From Free Speaking To a Successful Speaking and Writing Career

Mel started her public speaking journey for free after her TEDx talk. Following her free speech at the Texas Conference for Women, she was not only invited back as a headliner but also kickstarted her paid professional speaking career.

Mel Became the Top-Booked Female Speaker, Traveling Widely to Share Her Message

Soon, Mel found herself traveling widely to share her message, growing into the most booked female speaker in the world, while maintaining financial prudence and avoiding lifestyle inflation even after regaining financial stability.

Mel's Bestselling Books, Like "the 5 Second Rule," Expanded Her Impact

Not only did ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Mel's Journey to Speaker and Author Success

Additional Materials

Actionables

- You can enhance your public speaking skills by joining a local Toastmasters club, where you'll get regular practice and constructive feedback in a supportive environment, helping you to refine your presentation style and increase your confidence.

  • Toastmasters clubs provide a structured program that allows you to work on various aspects of public speaking, such as body language, vocal variety, and speech organization. By attending meetings and participating in speaking exercises, you'll develop a more dynamic and relatable speaking style, similar to what contributed to Mel's success. Additionally, you can volunteer for leadership roles within the club to gain experience in organizing events and leading teams, which are valuable skills for any professional speaker.
  • You can start a blog or a YouTube channel focused on a topic you're passionate about, sharing insights and tips regularly to build an audience and establish credibility in your field.
  • By consistently creating and sharing valuable content, you can attract a following and demonstrate your expertise. This approach mirrors Mel's strategy of offering free content to help others. As your audience grows, you may find opportunities to monetize your platform through sponsorships, affiliate marketing, or even speaking engagements. Remember to keep your content accessible and concise to cater to people with limited free time, just as Mel crafted her podcast episodes.
  • You can volunteer to speak at local community events or ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA