Podcasts > Bear Brook

Bear Brook • NHPR

Jason Carroll is serving life in prison for a murder he says he didn’t commit. The only evidence against him? His own taped confession. More than 30 years later, is it possible to get to the truth – and who gets to tell it? More at bearbrookpodcast.com

Listen to the original

Bear Brook • NHPR

Episodes

  • Bonus: ‘Crime Story’

    In the latest installment of "Bear Brook," hosts Jason Moon and Kathleen Goldhar delve into the haunting tale of Sharon Johnson's murder. The episode chronicles the subsequent investigations and interrogations, tracing the murky path from initial arrests to questionable confessions and the role emerging DNA evidence plays in a bid for truth. The conversation underscores the importance of forensic evidence as new technologies beckon a reevaluation of the past, instigating fresh hope in what's become a decades-long search for justice.

    Amidst examining the distressing details of Johnson's tragic end, the episode also casts a critical gaze on police methodologies that led to the confessions of Jason Carroll and Tony Puff, two teenagers entwined in a convoluted legal quandary. As Bear Brook scrutinizes the intricacies of their trial and the reliability of confessions won under dubious conditions, the story unfolds against the backdrop of a broader reflection on the American justice system, its potential for error, and the enduring quest to right those wrongs in the face of new evidence.

    Feb 22, 2024

  • Introducing: The 13th Step

    In this piercing episode of "Bear Brook," journalist Lauren Chooljian embarks on a daring exposé, uncovering allegations of sexual misconduct within the ranks of addiction treatment leadership. Delving deep into a world where vulnerable individuals seek help, Chooljian encounters stories of personal boundaries violated and unwanted advances from those entrusted to guide recovery. The episode paints a sobering picture of the systemic challenges that face movements aiming to address such misconduct, particularly within the specialized context of addiction recovery. With sources revealing their struggles and fears, Chooljian herself becomes a target, as retaliation strikes close to home, raising alarm over the protection of those brave enough to come forward.

    The investigation further lays bare the troubling absence of proper regulation within the addiction treatment industry, as explored in Chooljian's podcast alongside co-speaker Jason Moon. "The 13th Step" delves into the allegations against a New Hampshire treatment network leader, highlighting the exploitation hidden behind the facade of support. The term "13th Step" itself suggests a betrayal of trust, serving as a grim metaphor for the predatory behavior witnessed. As the podcast unfolds, the necessity of systemic reform becomes increasingly apparent, urging a call to action against the misuse of power and advocating for the safety and dignity of those seeking a path to recovery.

    Jun 6, 2023

  • Episode 8: The Box

    Delve into the quest for truth as "Bear Brook" presents a captivating account of Jason Carroll's uphill battle for exoneration. Hosts Advertisement, Advertiser, Judge Delker, Fabiana Alceste, Cynthia Mousseau, Melonie Eaton, Jason Moon, Rabia Chaudry, Sarah Cailean, and Jason Caroll navigate through the discovery of new evidence and the pivotal role of true crime podcasts in fighting against a recalcitrant judicial system. The newfound physical traces, which promise a chance at unravelling the truth through DNA testing, stand at the very heart of Jason's petition. This episode examines the complexities and conflicts involved in the endeavor to reexamine evidence and the incessant struggle of an individual against the too-often immovable force of legal finality.

    The narrative extends into the personal realm as well, detailing the repercussions of public intrigue in reawakening difficult emotions for the victim’s family. The story unfolds to reveal the broader implications of media influence in shaping legal cases and challenging the preserved convictions of the criminal legal system in New Hampshire, a state unyielding in its stance on upholding murder convictions. Witness the dynamic interplay between dedicated advocacy through podcasts like "Undisclosed" led by Rabia Chaudry and the stern challenges presented by state authorities. "Bear Brook" offers a window into the enduring spirit of a man set on proving his innocence, and the societal mechanisms that both assist and impede an individual's path to justice.

    Apr 10, 2023

  • Episode 7: This Side of the Line

    Delve into the perplexing world of criminal investigations with the Bear Brook podcast, featuring discussions by Jason Moon, Jason Caroll, and Dr. Fabiana Alceste among others. The latest installment scrutinizes the enigma of false confessions and the interrogation methods that can inadvertently foster them, unraveling the complexity of discerning between truth and deceptive admissions within the confines of the law.

    The episode navigates through a maze of factors that contribute to false confessions: from the psychological nuances explored by Dr. Alceste, to the alarming narrative of Huwe Burton, a man ensnared by the system's flaws. It exposes coercive interrogation techniques that fracture the foundations of trust in justice, and pulls back the curtain on the harsh realities faced by the vulnerable, such as the youth and those with intellectual disabilities. This episode of Bear Brook offers a critical examination of the criminal justice system’s struggle against the shadows of doubt cast by false confessions.

    Apr 3, 2023

  • Episode 6: ‘Don’t Roll the Dice’

    Explore the complex and often controversial world of criminal confessions in the Bear Brook podcast, featuring speakers such as Jason Moon, Jackie Carroll Hughes, and Cliff Kinghorn. This episode delves into the intricacies and developments surrounding the arrest, trials, and confessions of Jason Carroll. With his confessions under scrutiny for potential police coercion and inconsistency with physical evidence, the story unfolds revealing a tangle of legal, ethical, and emotional threads that challenge the listener's understanding of justice.

    Bear Brook presents a narrative that pits the persistence of a sister against the rigidity of the legal system, highlighting Jackie Hughes's unwavering efforts to uncover the truth about her brother's involvement in Sharon Johnson’s murder. With recent scientific insights into false confessions coming to light, the episode hints at a possible reevaluation of Carroll’s case in the future. The journey through Carroll's legal battles and the steadfast advocacy of his sister culminates in a discussion that spans across decades, capturing the shifts in society's grasp of psychological coercion and its impact on the justice system.

    Mar 27, 2023