PDF Summary:What Would the Rockefellers Do, by Garrett Gunderson and Michael Isom

Most people struggle to preserve wealth across generations, but the Rockefeller family has maintained their fortune for over a century. In What Would the Rockefellers Do, Garrett Gunderson and Michael Isom examine the strategies behind this success and explain how you can apply similar principles to protect and grow your own wealth.

The authors describe how permanent life insurance and family trusts form the foundation of the Rockefeller approach, creating centralized wealth structures that protect assets from taxes and legal claims while providing liquidity for family members. You'll learn how to use these financial tools to access tax-free retirement funds, optimize cash flow, and create a family charter that passes down values and financial wisdom to future generations. The guide provides practical strategies for managing wealth that can help you build a lasting legacy for your family.

(continued)...

(Shortform note: The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) explains that a reverse mortgage is a loan for homeowners aged 62 and older, allowing them to convert home equity into cash without selling their home or making monthly payments. The loan is repaid when the homeowner dies, sells the home, or no longer lives there as their primary residence. Typically, the loan is repaid by selling the home, and the homeowner or heirs generally don't owe more than the home's value at repayment. The CFPB doesn't mention using a life insurance policy's death benefit as collateral for a reverse mortgage. Instead, the home itself serves as collateral, and the lender places a lien on the property. However, you can maintain a separate life insurance policy to provide funds for your heirs to repay the reverse mortgage if they wish to keep the home.)

If you hold assets with significant capital gains, like a company, property, or shares, and you're considering selling them to help fund your retirement, numerous strategies exist to delay the tax on capital gains that you'd owe. You might lower taxes entirely and for good, even potentially sidestepping them altogether. Gunderson and Isom suggest that you make donations to a trust that allocates assets to charity to get a tax write-off.

(Shortform note: If your taxable income is so low that you can't use the tax write-off, you won't sidestep the capital gains tax. For example, if you sell your company and donate it to a trust that allocates assets to charity, but you have no other income, you won't be able to use the tax write-off. In this case, you would still have to pay the capital gains tax on the sale of your company.)

When you give to a trust that designates remaining assets to charity, part of your contribution is tax-deductible. You avoid taxation when selling the asset, and you receive a partial deduction, because after your death, the leftover value is given to a nonprofit. If you possess a death benefit, it serves as a way to enable you to donate, reduce taxes, receive a partial tax deduction, and maintain lifelong cash flow. You’re the main beneficiary, with the charity as the secondary one. The objective is to bequeath a minimum of 10% to the charitable organization upon your death.

(Shortform note: In practice, attorneys often use a charitable remainder trust (CRT) to achieve these goals. The IRS requires that at least 10% of the trust’s value be reserved for the charity, and the trust is tax-exempt. The death benefit for your heirs is typically held outside the CRT, often in a separate trust, to avoid complications with the IRS.)

The way you structure your whole life policy ownership and beneficiary designations has significant impacts on estate tax and more. While most policies are owned individually, it might be more beneficial for a trust or an LLC, such as a trust for asset protection, to own them. Each ownership type has its advantages and disadvantages. It's crucial to consult the right legal professionals to ensure that the issues are tailored to your strategy. You need to begin somehow.

Why Ownership Structure Matters

The reason that different ownership structures have different estate tax outcomes is that the IRS and courts look at who has the “incidents of ownership” in the policy. If you own the policy personally, you have the right to change beneficiaries, borrow against the cash value, surrender the policy, and so on. That means the death benefit is included in your taxable estate. But if you transfer all those rights to an independent trust or LLC, and you don’t retain any control, the death benefit is generally excluded from your estate. The same logic applies to creditor protection. If you don’t own the policy, your creditors can’t reach it.

Gunderson and Isom also recommend considering reverse mortgages to access tax-exempt funds for retirement. A reverse home loan lets you establish credit access based on your home's value once you turn 62. As you grow older, you can receive more equity, with an average annual increase of 8%. Mortgage interest from reverse mortgages can be deducted, creating tax-free retirement funds. When you pass away, your trust could apply your life insurance payout to settle the reverse mortgage and retain ownership of the home, or you could allow the bank to take it. You aren't responsible for repaying the money.

Why You Aren't Responsible for Repaying a Reverse Mortgage

Reverse mortgages are non-recourse loans, meaning the lender can only claim the home as collateral if the loan isn't repaid. They can't pursue your other assets or your heirs for any shortfall. This is because most reverse mortgages in the US are insured by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). The FHA insurance protects both you and the lender. If the loan balance exceeds the home's value when it's sold, the FHA insurance covers the difference. This means you or your heirs won't owe more than the home's value, even if the loan balance is higher. The lender can't go after your other assets or your estate to recover any shortfall.

As mentioned earlier, Gunderson and Isom suggest utilizing trusts that donate assets to charity to prevent taxes on capital gains. A charitable remainder trust is an arrangement that donates assets to a charity of your choice. When you donate, you can partially deduct the donation from your taxes. You sidestep taxes from selling it and receive a partial tax deduction, since after your death, the remainder is given to a charitable organization.

(Shortform note: Charitable remainder trusts were created by Congress in 1969. The law was designed to standardize split-interest gifts, which are gifts that benefit both a charity and a non-charitable beneficiary. Before this law, donors could create trusts that provided income to themselves or others while also benefiting charities, but there were no clear rules on how much of the gift had to go to charity. The 1969 law set specific requirements to ensure that a significant portion of the trust's assets would eventually go to charity.)

Demonstrable Outcomes & Historical Comparisons

Gunderson and Isom emphasize financial assurance and handling risks. The Rockefeller Method involves having as many options as possible while minimizing risk by coordinating, planning, and managing risk. It emphasizes understanding what's reliable. A whole life policy’s cash value is available and assured, letting you reliably know annually how much money you'll have. You can leverage this certainty in every part of your life, particularly when deciding on finances in both the short and long term. Whole life insurance helps you establish a strong base, enabling you to aim high while safeguarding your family's standard of living in a Rockefeller-inspired way.

The Boglehead Approach to Financial Security

The authors of The Bogleheads’ Guide to Investing would disagree with the idea that whole life insurance cash value is a reliable base for minimizing risk and planning options. They argue that the best way for most investors to build financial security is to keep insurance and investing separate by purchasing low-cost level term life insurance for income protection and placing their long-term savings in a simple, low-cost, broadly diversified portfolio of index funds. They recommend avoiding expensive cash-value policies such as whole life, universal life, and variable life that mix investing with insurance and usually serve the interests of the insurer and the agent more than the policyholder.

Processes for Generational Wealth Management

Gunderson and Isom recommend forming a family charter to transmit values and philosophies along with financial resources. This document outlines your principles, beliefs, and guidelines for managing wealth. It ensures that those who inherit from you are equipped to make wise decisions and continue your legacy. It safeguards equitable rights rather than offering equal items and can be shared for many generations, regardless of your monetary legacy.

To craft a family charter, write down your premise (your view of the world), your vision (how you see your family impacting the world), your purpose (the significance of the vision), and your strategy (how to achieve the vision).

The Origins of the Family Charter

The concept of a family charter aligns with the idea of a “family constitution,” a formal document that outlines a family’s shared values, vision, and decision-making processes regarding wealth. This concept is rooted in the field of family governance, which emphasizes the importance of clear communication and shared values in managing multi-generational wealth. James E. Hughes Jr., a prominent figure in family wealth management, argues that a family constitution helps prevent conflicts and ensures that wealth serves the family’s long-term goals rather than becoming a source of division.

In the sections that follow, we’ll explore wealth structuring tools and discuss ongoing wealth governance.

Wealth Structuring Tools

Mechanics of Internal Funding & Liquidity

Gunderson and Isom assert that borrowing against a whole life insurance plan can provide liquidity and tax advantages. Instead of withdrawing cash from the policy, you leverage the policy's cash value as collateral. The value of the cash is regarded as a private account, and you can borrow up to 90% of it in the initial year. The value keeps increasing with dividends, and repayment of the loan isn't necessary. If you choose not to, the remaining amount is subtracted from the payout after your death. Taking a loan secured by the policy doesn’t affect your credit, and the interest on a business loan is typically tax-deductible.

The Origins of the Strategy

The idea of borrowing against a whole life insurance plan for liquidity and tax advantages has been discussed in various financial circles for decades. One of the earliest and most influential proponents of this strategy was R. Nelson Nash, who introduced the concept in his 2000 book Becoming Your Own Banker. Nash’s Infinite Banking Concept (IBC) advocates using whole life insurance policies as personal banking systems, allowing policyholders to borrow against their cash value for various financial needs. Nash argues that this approach provides individuals with greater control over their finances, reduces reliance on traditional banks, and offers potential tax benefits.

Strategic Advantages Over Conventional Banks

Gunderson and Isom argue that permanent life insurance offers more stability and control than traditional banking. The insurance sector has survived many economic downturns, including the Great Depression and the 2008 financial crisis. In contrast, banks are volatile and unreliable. They offer low interest rates, require taxation of your earnings, and only protect up to $250,000 of your savings.

(Shortform note: While permanent life insurance is generally more stable than banks, there are exceptions. If your policy’s death benefit or cash value exceeds the coverage limits of your state’s guaranty association, you could be left unprotected if your insurer fails. In such cases, spreading your funds across multiple banks within FDIC insurance limits might offer more protection.)

This type of insurance also gives you more control over your money. You can withdraw your funds at any time, and you have the option to decide how and when to pay back any loans you take out. You’re even able to deduct business loan interest. If you take a loan from your insurance company, you can continue accruing interest on your funds while borrowing them. Furthermore, you can use your permanent life insurance plan to fund a trust for your heirs. The trust can get a whole life insurance plan for each beneficiary. If a beneficiary withdraws funds from the trust and passes away without repayment, the payout compensates for the amount. This keeps the trust intact for later generations.

How Permanent Life Insurance Loans Work

In The Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning, the authors explain the mechanics of how this type of insurance works. When you take out a loan, the insurance company gives you the money and uses your policy as collateral. This means your cash value and death benefits remain intact, and you continue to earn interest on the full amount. The insurance company charges you interest on the loan, but this is separate from the interest you earn on your policy. If you don’t repay the loan, the insurance company deducts the amount from your death benefit. This setup allows you to use your policy to provide liquidity for your heirs while ensuring the trust can be replenished for future generations.

Ongoing Wealth Governance

Family & Values Alignment

Aligning family values and creating a shared philosophy is essential for an enduring legacy, Gunderson and Isom explain. Legacy encompasses the complete effect of the ideas, values, guidance, modeling, and impact we bequeath to loved ones. It encompasses not only the financial assets we pass on but, more significantly, the guidance and lessons attached to that money. Legacy encompasses our values, deeds, and love that we transmit to subsequent generations.

Legacy Is More Than Money or Values

In Family Therapy in Clinical Practice, psychiatrist Murray Bowen explains that legacy is more than just money or values—it’s the emotional patterns we inherit from our families. He says, “The family is an emotional unit, a natural system in which patterns of emotional functioning are transmitted across generations and in which each person’s level of self-differentiation is shaped by these multigenerational processes.” So, when we talk about shared family values, we’re really talking about tools to reshape those inherited patterns, not just feel-good ideas about money.

Proactive Cash Flow Management

Gunderson and Isom recommend managing finances by adjusting loans and using tax advantages. To boost your liquidity, restructure loans to get reduced interest rates or extended amortization periods. You can also arrange and reorganize your loans to make the interest tax-deductible, like with many mortgages. For example, converting a 15-year home loan into a 30-year fixed-rate loan can boost your cash flow, since you'll pay less today and could potentially save hundreds of thousands on taxes by paying interest over a longer timeframe. Additionally, if your goal is to pay off your house in 15 years, you can draw on the cash value of your whole life insurance plan to do so.

The Risks of Extending Loan Payoff Periods

While restructuring loans to extend the payoff period can provide short-term tax benefits, it can also lead to long-term financial risks. In The White Coat Investor, James M. Dahle warns that the tax tail should never wag the investment dog. He explains that while tax deductions on mortgage interest can be appealing, the additional years of debt and interest payments often outweigh the tax savings. Additionally, using the cash value of a whole life insurance policy to pay off a mortgage can deplete your financial safety net, leaving you vulnerable in emergencies.

Gunderson and Isom also suggest using the CFI to pinpoint loans that aren't efficient. The Cash Flow Index (CFI) is a method for finding the best way to settle inefficient loans and increase cash flow. Settling inefficient debts, particularly revolving ones like credit cards, can potentially boost your credit score, possibly reducing the interest on other loans.

To calculate a loan's CFI, divide the loan balance by its minimum payment. A small index indicates inefficiency in the loan. A higher value indicates greater loan efficiency. Loans that have a CFI between zero and 50 are considered high-risk, and you might want to either restructure or eliminate them quickly. From a cash flow perspective, loans with a CFI above 100 fall in the freedom zone and aren't a payoff priority.

(Shortform note: The CFI is a relatively new metric, but the idea of using ratios to prioritize debt payments has been around for decades. For example, personal finance textbooks from the 1980s and 1990s often included the debt-payment-to-income ratio as a key metric for identifying which debts were most constraining a household’s cash flow. These early approaches laid the groundwork for more sophisticated tools like the CFI, which now incorporate additional factors such as minimum payments and loan balances to provide a more nuanced view of debt efficiency.)