PDF Summary:What Doesn't Kill Us, by Scott Carney

Human beings' innate ability to withstand environmental stresses has diminished due to the comforts of modern living. Yet, as Scott Carney reveals in What Doesn't Kill Us, we each harbor an evolutionary capacity to reawaken our physical and mental resilience. This ability lies within reach through methods of controlled exposure to harsh conditions—from withstanding extreme cold temperatures to calculated oxygen deprivation.

Carney's exploration delves into the remarkable strategy of the Wim Hof Method, a practice harnessing breathwork, cold therapy, and meditation to purposefully activate the body's latent potential. By consciously bridging the control of voluntary and involuntary physiological processes, practitioners can kindle dormant capacities for endurance, immune response, and physical fortitude.

(continued)...

• The Wim Hof Method combines specific breathing techniques and exposure to cold to influence the autonomic nervous system. Through controlled breathing and cold exposure, practitioners can consciously regulate their immune system responses. This method aims to enhance physiological alertness and provide practitioners with greater control over their immune responses. Hof's approach suggests that by mastering these techniques, individuals can potentially influence their immune system's functioning consciously.
• Exposure to cold environments triggers physiological responses like the activation of the sympathetic nervous system, leading to the release of norepinephrine and adrenaline. These responses help increase alertness, metabolic rate, and energy expenditure to generate heat. Cold exposure can also stimulate the production of brown adipose tissue, which generates heat by burning fat. Overall, these responses aim to maintain core body temperature and adapt to the cold environment.
• Meditation can enhance mental focus and control by training the mind to redirect thoughts and increase awareness of the present moment. Through regular practice, individuals can improve their ability to concentrate, regulate emotions, and cultivate a sense of clarity and calmness. Techniques such as focusing on the breath or visualizing specific images can help sharpen cognitive functions and promote a more centered state of mind. Overall, meditation serves as a tool to strengthen attention, reduce distractions, and foster a greater sense of mental discipline and well-being.
• The Wim Hof Method involves techniques like controlled breathing, exposure to cold, and meditation to influence the autonomic nervous system. By practicing these methods, individuals can potentially enhance their immune response, cardiovascular health, and overall well-being. The method's focus on breath control and cold exposure is believed to activate physiological responses that may help manage symptoms of chronic illnesses and improve resilience. Personal accounts suggest that individuals have experienced positive outcomes, such as reduced symptoms and improved health, by incorporating the Wim Hof Method into their routines.

Human evolution has resulted in a contemporary divide between people and their environment, simultaneously illuminating the physical and mental responses to the trials presented by the environment.

The evolutionary origins of human physiological adaptability

Our ancestors' encounters with harsh environmental conditions played a pivotal role in the evolution of strong physiological systems.

Carney explores the development of human physical form, highlighting how our biology has been molded by the challenges posed by our surroundings. He proposes that the bodily systems that enabled our ancestors to thrive in diverse and challenging environments became more refined through their struggles with persistent dangers from predators, food shortages, and harsh climatic conditions. Scott Carney argues that this adaptation emerged through a stringent evolutionary process that allowed beneficial traits to be passed down through generations, while traits that were less beneficial did not endure.

Carney highlights the remarkable capabilities demonstrated by our ancestors, as confirmed by anthropological and archaeological evidence. He emphasizes the exceptional skill of ancient mariners like the Tahitian chief Tupaia, who mastered the art of crossing vast stretches of ocean by using only their innate abilities to navigate and their deep understanding of the complex interactions between terrestrial and marine currents. He explores the way a community in Australia navigates by solely referring to the cardinal points, as their language lacks terms for relative spatial concepts such as left, right, forward, and backward. Carney suggests that such occurrences reflect an era where humans were intimately connected to their environment, relying on innate abilities that have been progressively supplanted by technology.

Our innate capacity for adaptation has diminished due to the mismatch between our millennia-evolved biological constitution and the modern environment.

Carney contends that the swift progression of technology, especially in recent times, has led to a discordance between the ancient biological traits we retain and our contemporary surroundings. The adaptive mechanisms within us, designed to thrive, are deprived of crucial growth stimuli because modern conveniences constantly maintain a state of balance. Our ancestors, regularly facing harsh cold temperatures, scarce food resources, and demanding physical tasks, developed complex systems to conserve warmth, maximize energy efficiency, and build robust immune defenses. In contrast, he observes that our era is characterized by the simplicity with which comfort can be acquired and a significant reduction in environmental challenges, signifying an era of contrived plenty.

Carney presents numerous examples of occurrences where evolutionary discrepancies arise. He underscores the connection between the intake of cooked meals and the decrease in jaw dimensions, resulting in a more limited area for the placement of our dental structures. Before the discovery of fire, our ancestors dedicated considerable time to chewing tough plant matter and raw meat, yet the progression of cooking methods resulted in a diet that was easier to consume, diminishing the need for strong jaws and large mouths. As a result, our abundant teeth are squeezed into a jaw that is undersized, leading to oral health problems that our ancestors did not face. Carney suggests that the physiological adaptations of our bodies highlight the potential challenges that may arise from the advantages offered by technological progress.

Scientific insights into environmental adaptation

Research into how brown fat contributes to the body's heat production.

Carney emphasizes the importance of brown fat in producing heat within the body and its role in helping the body adapt to cold environments. He traces the progression of studies on brown fat, beginning with initial findings in rodents and culminating in the acknowledgment of its presence in adult humans. The publication emphasizes the pioneering work of Aaron Cypess at Harvard, uncovering a previously unidentified source of metabolic activity through the study of PET/CT scans. Carney delivers a thorough examination of the research conducted by Cypess, which uncovered that the presumed cancerous growths in the scans were in fact active clusters of brown fat, challenging the longstanding belief that brown fat was only important in newborns. The finding sparked renewed enthusiasm among scientists and drug companies to investigate how brown fat can combat obesity and associated metabolic problems.

Carney explores the unique roles and importance of brown fat in human physiology. Brown adipose tissue actively burns calories to generate heat, setting it apart from white adipose tissue. Mammals possess the capability to maintain their internal body temperature within cold environments by utilizing a process called non-shivering thermogenesis, which is not solely reliant on muscle contractions. Carney delves into the vital functions of brown fat cells, highlighting the importance of mitochondria in these cells for energy production that leads to heat generation. He explains how brown fat, rich in mitochondria, converts stored energy into heat by utilizing white fat.

Studies of indigenous populations have uncovered a variety of physiological strategies for enduring extreme environmental situations.

Carney investigates how humans have evolved to endure frigid conditions by studying communities living in harsh climates. He emphasizes the discoveries of 1930s anthropologists who documented the ways in which various indigenous communities, including the Inuit in the Canadian Arctic, reindeer-herding populations in Lapland, the native inhabitants of Africa's Kalahari, and the Aboriginal peoples of the Australian desert, adjusted to their respective climates. Carney introduces the concept that acclimatization to colder environments elicits a range of bodily reactions that are specifically adapted to the distinct challenges posed by various surroundings.

Carney cites examples of these varied adaptations. Scott Carney describes the way in which the Lapps have adapted to regulate blood flow to their extremities, thereby conserving vital warmth in the core areas of their bodies. In contrast, the Inuit demonstrated a heightened rate of metabolism, signifying a different method for generating body heat. The indigenous people of the Australian desert, wearing minimal attire, displayed an impressive resilience to the chilly nights by way of a unique bodily reaction that involved a considerable constriction of their blood vessels, which in turn reduced the speed at which their bodies lost heat. Carney suggests that our body's biological mechanisms are remarkably adaptable, responding to a range of environmental cues.

Research conducted by the armed forces into the impact of environmental factors on bodily functions.

The US military has carried out studies to comprehend the impact of different environmental factors, such as temperature and exposure to natural elements, on the endurance and performance capabilities of soldiers.

Carney explores the military's long-standing interest in the impact of environmental stressors on the physiological reactions and overall effectiveness of soldiers in the field. He highlights the studies conducted at the military's environmental medicine research facility in Natick, Massachusetts. This facility, equipped with sophisticated simulation rooms that replicate a variety of climatic scenarios, plays a crucial role in developing methods to enhance the resilience of military personnel to diverse meteorological situations and altitude variations.

Carney's work emphasizes the research by military scientist John Castellani focusing on how the body physiologically reacts in ways that can result in hypothermia. Castellani meticulously replicated the conditions that led to the demise of four Army Ranger trainees, submerging volunteers in freezing water to observe changes in their core temperature. An individual's ability to withstand severe cold is greatly affected by their fatigue, muscle makeup, and prior experiences in chilly surroundings. Carney explores the impact of cold environments on the precision of hand movements, highlighting the use of the Purdue Pegboard Test to measure the effects on the dexterity of military members in cold settings. He investigates techniques to mitigate the deterioration of fine motor skills due to cold exposure, emphasizing the military's efforts to develop strategies that go beyond simply providing soldiers with more gear.

Methods have been established to enhance the body's ability to adjust to varying surroundings, such as becoming accustomed to warmer temperatures and increasing resilience to colder conditions.

Carney explores the techniques used by the military to enhance the endurance of soldiers in extreme environments. He underscores the importance of acclimatizing soldiers through deliberate exposure to sweltering temperatures and extreme moisture levels prior to their deployment in dry regions. By subjecting oneself to rigorous exercise in hot environments, the body undergoes adaptations that improve its sweating mechanism, cardiovascular function, and its capacity to withstand higher temperatures. Carney cites studies indicating that acclimatization to increased heat can significantly reduce the risk of heatstroke and improve the effectiveness of soldiers operating in hot climates.

Carney investigates how USARIEM created a software tool that accurately predicts the likelihood of altitude sickness in soldiers ascending Mount Denali quickly, enabling military leaders to anticipate challenges and plan their forces' maneuvers accordingly. He also explores fascinating findings from animal studies, which reveal that mice acclimated to warmer surroundings exhibit improved recovery after suffering traumatic brain injuries. Scott Carney suggests that becoming accustomed to warmer conditions may not only help in tolerating high temperatures but could also enhance an individual's general resilience to a range of physical stressors.

Context

• Non-shivering thermogenesis is a process where heat is produced by specialized fat cells called brown adipose tissue without the need for muscle contractions. This mechanism is crucial for maintaining body temperature in cold environments. Brown fat cells contain a high number of mitochondria, which generate heat by burning calories stored in the fat. This process helps mammals, including humans, stay warm without shivering.
• PET/CT scans combine positron emission tomography (PET) and computed tomography (CT) imaging techniques to provide detailed information about both the structure and function of tissues in the body. PET scans detect the activity of cells, while CT scans provide detailed anatomical images. This fusion allows for a more comprehensive assessment of various conditions, such as cancer, by correlating metabolic activity with precise anatomical locations. The combination of PET and CT scans enhances diagnostic accuracy and aids in treatment planning for patients.
• USARIEM stands for the United States Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine. It is a research institute within the U.S. Army that focuses on studying the impact of environmental factors on human performance and health, particularly in military settings. USARIEM conducts research to understand how the body responds to various environmental stressors like temperature and altitude. The institute develops strategies to enhance the resilience and performance of military personnel in challenging environmental conditions.
• Altitude sickness, also known as acute mountain sickness (AMS), is a condition that occurs at high altitudes due to reduced oxygen levels. Symptoms can include headaches, nausea, fatigue, and dizziness. It can progress to more severe conditions like high-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) or high-altitude cerebral edema (HACE). Preventative measures include gradual acclimatization to higher altitudes to allow the body to adjust to the lower oxygen levels.
• Traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) are brain injuries caused by external forces. They can range from mild (concussions) to severe, with varying symptoms and outcomes. TBIs can result from falls, accidents, or violence, leading to physical, cognitive, and emotional challenges. Imaging techniques like CT scans and MRIs are used to diagnose moderate to severe TBIs.
• Acclimatization to warmer surroundings involves the process of gradually adapting to higher temperatures through exposure and physical activity. This adjustment helps the body improve its ability to regulate temperature, sweat more efficiently, and cope with heat stress. Acclimatization can lead to physiological changes that enhance performance and reduce the risk of heat-related illnesses. It is a beneficial strategy for individuals, including soldiers, preparing to work or engage in activities in hot environments.
• The Purdue Pegboard Test is a manual dexterity and coordination test involving placing pegs into holes on a board. It assesses both gross and fine motor skills, measuring how quickly and accurately a person can perform the task. The test was designed in 1948 by Joseph Tiffin for evaluating dexterity, initially for assembly line workers. Performance on the test can indicate deficits in complex movements controlled by circuits involving the basal ganglia.

Acclimatization to different environmental conditions is a key factor in the training of military personnel and athletes, and it also had a profound impact on the author's transformative journeys and experiences.

Members of the military and extreme sports enthusiasts utilize particular techniques to become accustomed to the demands of various environments.

Competitions that test participants' resilience by exposing them to various demanding physical obstacles.

Obstacle course races have gained popularity as a method for rigorous sports training that includes adapting to various environmental conditions. He narrates the variety of challenges faced in these contests, such as the effort required to navigate muddy ditches and scale tall obstacles, along with the difficulty of squirming under wire as sharp as blades and enduring sudden immersions in ice-cold waters. He contends that OCRs challenge participants to confront the utmost boundaries of their physical and psychological endurance, sparking an innate desire to assess their toughness when confronted with adversity. He observes a growing inclination in the athletic community toward events involving obstacle courses, indicating a shift toward all-encompassing physical training and a quest for experiences that extend beyond the traditional limits of regular gyms.

Carney delves into the history of obstacle course competitions, identifying Tough Guy as the first event of its kind, which originated in England in 1987 and stood alone in its category for over two decades. He narrates the story of Will Dean, a graduate of Harvard with an MBA, who drew inspiration from Tough Guy and launched the Tough Mudder competitions in America. Dean capitalized on the power of social media to rapidly expand Tough Mudder, which in turn catalyzed the development of rival events and established these competitions as a sport with broad recognition. Carney emphasizes the significant influence of this trend, noting that countless individuals have adopted the practice of testing their physical limits in climates that present formidable challenges. He investigates the allure of risky endeavors that awaken our primal survival mechanisms, suggesting that intentionally engaging with these trials can foster a more robust resilience and lead to an intensified sense of accomplishment.

Military research and protocols are designed to enhance the robustness of soldiers in the face of diverse environmental conditions.

Carney draws attention to how the demanding aspects of obstacle course racing are akin to the rigorous training that the military employs to enhance soldiers' resilience to environmental hardships. He provides a comprehensive examination of the methods developed by John Castellani at USARIEM, which are designed to prepare military personnel for adaptation to extreme heat, chilling conditions, and the challenges presented by elevated terrains. He argues that the structured conditioning practices used by the armed forces offer valuable insights for athletes and others aiming to improve their physiological responses to challenging conditions.

Carney underscores the significance of deliberately and incrementally becoming accustomed to varying environmental circumstances, a tactic employed by military forces. He underscores the significance of gradual adaptation, a process through which people gently condition themselves to respond more effectively and with less distress to changing surroundings. He notes that while extraordinary feats of endurance frequently captivate the public's attention, the basic principle of incrementally challenging our body's boundaries to foster adaptation is relevant to individuals of varying levels of fitness.

The author's journey of transformation was influenced by his ability to adjust to varying environmental circumstances.

Engaging in demanding competitions such as the Spartan Race.

Throughout the book, Carney weaves his personal journey of transformation, showing how overcoming a variety of environmental challenges can strengthen mental resilience and enhance physical vigor. He narrates his participation in a grueling event designed to push the participants' stamina to the extreme. Guided by Wim Hof and other individuals, they achieved the ascent of Poland's Mount Snezka clad only in shorts and footwear, demonstrating their enhanced tolerance to cold temperatures.

Carney recounts his successful climb to the summit of Kilimanjaro in 2016. He provides an in-depth account of the swift ascent, where he, alongside Wim Hof and fellow climbers, defied conventional mountaineering practices by attaining the summit in just 28 hours, foregoing the standard acclimatization time. Carney argues that this accomplishment is a compelling testament to our natural capacity for adapting to severe trials, illustrating that we can greatly enhance our physiological endurance against frigid temperatures and elevated environments, thereby shattering what we once considered to be our boundaries.

The author experienced a significant enhancement in his physical condition and athletic prowess by employing strategies that incorporated the approach developed by Wim Hof.

Carney's investigation culminated in tangible results from his self-devised program designed to acclimate to stressors from the surroundings. Half a year after his initial evaluation, he returned for a subsequent consultation with Rob Pickels, an exercise physiologist connected to the CU Sports Medicine and Performance Center. The author's physiological metrics improved significantly, surprising Pickels, who was initially skeptical about the effectiveness of Wim Hof's techniques. Carney exhibited a significant enhancement in his aerobic capacity, shown by improved oxygen consumption and his sustained endurance during extended periods of exercise. Pickels noted that the improvements in Carney's health were akin to him undertaking an extra seven hours of exercise weekly, even though he did not increase the length of his workouts.

Carney meticulously documents his transformation by systematically tracking his improvements and participating in stringent experiments, offering a vivid and definitive demonstration that when exposed to extreme environments, the human body can unveil previously dormant capabilities. His journey, he argues, demonstrates that through intentional engagement with our environment and dedicated training, we can revive and harness resilience and adaptability, rather than relying solely on traits inherited from our ancestors.

Other Perspectives

• While obstacle course races (OCRs) can indeed challenge and build resilience, they may not be suitable for everyone, and there is a risk of injury that should not be overlooked.
• The popularity of events like Tough Mudder may be seen as a trend that capitalizes on a certain machismo or extreme fitness culture, which might not be sustainable or healthy for all participants.
• Military training methods are designed for soldiers who must face extreme conditions as part of their job; applying these methods to civilian athletes may not always be appropriate or safe.
• The narrative that pushing the body to extreme limits is beneficial could potentially encourage some individuals to ignore important safety signals from their bodies, leading to overtraining or injury.
• The Wim Hof Method, while beneficial for some, is not universally applicable or scientifically proven to be effective for everyone, and individual results may vary.
• The physiological improvements reported by Carney after following the Wim Hof Method could be influenced by a variety of factors, including the placebo effect or concurrent training activities.
• The idea of incremental adaptation is well-founded, but there is a fine line between healthy adaptation and pushing the body too far, which can result in adverse health effects.
• The emphasis on extreme physical challenges may overshadow other important aspects of fitness, such as flexibility, balance, and mental health.
• The focus on individual resilience and adaptability may underplay the role of genetics, access to resources, and other factors that contribute to an individual's ability to perform and adapt to extreme conditions.
• The narrative of conquering environmental challenges can sometimes romanticize dangerous situations, potentially leading to risky behaviors in untrained individuals seeking similar transformative experiences.