PDF Summary:We Who Wrestle with God, by Jordan B. Peterson

How do ancient religious stories connect to modern questions about morality, purpose, and personal growth? In We Who Wrestle with God, Jordan B. Peterson examines biblical narratives to explore how divine order, human conscience, and moral law shape our lives. He argues that these stories reveal patterns about sacrifice, vice, and the balance between stability and change that remain relevant today.

Peterson discusses how concepts like covenant, law, and judgment externalize sacred systems, and how individual choices either uphold or disrupt cosmic harmony. Through analysis of stories like Cain and Abel and the Tower of Babel, he illustrates how sacrifice and truthfulness support growth, while lies and arrogance lead to chaos. This guide shows how these narratives function as archetypes that offer insight into psychological and spiritual development.

(continued)...

Peterson emphasizes that these rules aren't arbitrary or invented. They are discovered by people who strive to conform to the inherent ethical structure suggested by tradition. The laws are the guidelines that make voluntary, responsible, and sacrificial relationships possible. Without such relationships, society devolves into nihilism, the pursuit of pleasure, or seeking dominance.

(Shortform note: Peterson’s argument that moral rules are discovered, not invented, and that they are necessary to prevent society from devolving into nihilism, the pursuit of pleasure, or seeking dominance, echoes the natural-law tradition in philosophy. One of the most influential contemporary proponents of natural law is John Finnis, whose 1980 book Natural Law and Natural Rights revitalized the tradition.)

Dynamic Engagement: Response, Accountability, and Restoration

Upholding Cosmic Harmony Through Action

Peterson argues that sacrifice is essential to preserving the divine order. Sacrifice mirrors the universe's structure, which depends on willingly giving. The amount of sacrifice needed by the divine correlates with the extent of the privilege given.

Peterson uses the biblical tale of Cain and Abel to illustrate the importance of sacrifice. God accepts Abel’s offerings because he labors truthfully and with diligence, fully giving and presenting his first and best. In contrast, Cain's offerings are unacceptable to God because he holds back and doesn't give his utmost. He burns with anger because he hasn't given his best and upset the divine, and he also loses out on what's best in life.

Sacrifice and the Divine Order

Peterson’s argument that sacrifice preserves divine order and mirrors the universe’s structure is abstract, but we can see how it works in practice. In The Gift, Marcel Mauss argues that sacrificial offerings create bonds of obligation between people and the divine. These bonds make the community’s sense of divine order concrete and durable. He explains that sacrificial offerings are public, and the public nature of the offering creates a sense of obligation. This obligation is so strong that to refuse to give or accept an offering is to reject the bond and the community.

Disrupting God's Plan Through Vice and Error

Unlike sacrifice, lies and self-deception disrupt the sacred order and lead to chaos. Peterson explains that these behaviors cause us to prioritize things incorrectly. When we lie, we depart from goodness and the truthful Logos that creates a good cosmos. We also distance ourselves from our own ability to make judgments.

Peterson adds that liars end up living in narratives in which nothing is correctly organized. This twists the world into a space of estrangement from oneself, others, and God. The liar is without hope, aimless, and bound to clash with others who neither comprehend nor share in his lies, as well as with his true self, conscience, and calling.

The Benefits of Positive Self-Deception

Peterson’s claim that lies and self-deception lead to chaos may not always be true. In Positive Illusions, psychologist Shelley E. Taylor argues that mildly distorted yet positive beliefs about oneself and one’s future are characteristic of psychologically healthy people. These positive illusions include slightly overly favorable self-evaluations, an inflated sense of personal control, and unrealistic optimism. Taylor suggests that these illusions help people maintain self-worth, preserve a stable and meaningful understanding of their experiences, regulate distress, and stay motivated and persistent in confronting difficulties. In this way, positive self-deception can help people maintain a coherent and hopeful narrative about themselves and their lives, even in the face of adversity.

Narrative Applications: Archetypes and the Road to Integration

Now, we will explore how stories from the Bible illustrate deeper truths and how they contribute to psychological and spiritual growth.

Recurring Narrative Patterns

Peterson argues that biblical narratives often use particular communities or people to illustrate deeper truths. For example, the Tower of Babel narrative isn't a critique of Babylon or any other empire. The narrative isn't political, or if it has political elements, it serves a higher or deeper meaning. The same applies to many Bible stories that mention particular communities or individuals: they should be seen as types or models, where the specific and recognizable are used solely to illustrate a more profound truth.

Liberation Theology and the Political Interpretation of the Bible

Peterson’s approach to biblical interpretation is in stark contrast to that of Latin American liberation theologians, who argue that the Bible is a call to action against oppression. For example, in A Theology of Liberation, Gustavo Gutiérrez argues that the Exodus narrative reveals God as the liberator of an enslaved people and shows that salvation is a historical, political event that demands the abolition of every form of domination and the creation of a just, fraternal society. Gutiérrez’s approach to biblical interpretation is rooted in the belief that the Bible is a living document that speaks to the concrete realities of the oppressed and marginalized.

Peterson also points out that stories evolve over time, becoming more captivating and meaningful. This evolution happens through collective memory and storytelling. As stories are told and retold, the most notable and attention-grabbing elements are emphasized and refined. Over generations, these stories are distilled into their most essential and impactful forms, often through shared subconscious experience, as described by Jung. This process produces overarching truths that transcend individual facts and convey deeper meanings about humanity and morality.

(Shortform note: In Religion Explained, anthropologist Pascal Boyer offers a different perspective on why certain stories become more compelling and meaningful over time. Boyer argues that the persistence and impact of religious narratives can be explained by how they fit the ordinary architecture of human minds. He explains that stories featuring minimally counterintuitive agents (like gods or spirits) and salient norm violations are more likely to be remembered and transmitted because they exploit stable, cross-cultural biases in human attention and memory.)

Now, we will see how these stories reflect the importance of self-denial and the dangers of vice.

Ascent Through Sacrifice and Redemption

Peterson states that sacrifice is vital to personal growth and community advancement. It involves relinquishing something valuable to form a pact with others and your future self. This selfless act is essential to sustain life at every layer of experience.

Peterson adds that communities must give up their yearning for unlimited gain to the constraints of the natural environment, or else they risk the collapse of sustainable resources. Individuals must sacrifice the urge for immediate gratification to preserve their future selves and their relationships with others.

(Shortform note: Research on self-governed forests and fisheries shows that when individuals accept limits on short-term use, both their communities and the resources they depend on become more stable and prosperous. This supports Peterson’s argument that relinquishing immediate gratification and unlimited gain through sacrifice benefits both individuals and communities.)

Falling Into Vice and Degeneration

Peterson argues that the descent into vice and corruption results from failing to make proper sacrifices and relying on technological prowess. This pattern of degeneration manifests at every level of order, from psyche to nation, and even at the environmental or natural level.

Peterson explains that people don't make the right sacrifices, lie about it for self-serving reasons, and foster their bitterness, which distances them from God. They dismantle their personal principles to erase the harsh adjudicator and retaliate against the essence of the universal structure. Their progeny spread this destructive model across the whole of society, leading to a situation where every person becomes hopelessly corrupt. The root cause is the initial refusal to sincerely and appreciatively work, alongside inappropriately revering technological prowess. Then it all ends in disaster.

The Benefits of Technological Progress

Peterson’s argument that technological prowess leads to universal degeneration is controversial. In Enlightenment Now, psychologist Steven Pinker argues that technological and scientific progress has led to a dramatic reduction in violence, poverty, and other forms of human suffering. Pinker argues that the application of reason, science, and technology has led to unprecedented improvements in human well-being. He points to massive declines in extreme poverty, child mortality, famine, and everyday violence as evidence that human life today is safer, longer, and more humane than at any previous time in history. Pinker acknowledges that problems remain, but he contends that the overall trend is one of progress, not decline. Pinker’s argument challenges Peterson’s view that technological advancement inevitably leads to moral and societal decay. Instead, Pinker suggests that the very tools Peterson criticizes have been instrumental in reducing human suffering and improving quality of life on a global scale.

Mental and Spiritual Dynamics

Peterson emphasizes the importance of balancing steadiness and change for mental and spiritual growth. He explains that stability is symbolized by the center, which holds everything together, while change is symbolized by the margins, where new ideas and experimentation can occur. Without stability, everything crumbles. Without change, you can't have new ideas or experimentation. Peterson adds that this balance is apparent at the most essential layers of biological existence. For example, DNA repairs itself flawlessly when genes crucial to staying alive are damaged, but it allows for variation in nonessential functions. This preservation of the core, alongside edge experimentation, transforms how we understand the random nature of evolution. Advancement isn't random, not even on the mutation level.

(Shortform note: Peterson’s claim that DNA preserves only crucial genes while allowing variation in nonessential ones, suggesting that “advancement isn’t random, not even on the mutation level,” doesn’t align with current evolutionary biology. In Why Evolution Is True, Jerry Coyne explains that mutations occur randomly with respect to an organism’s needs. DNA repair mechanisms work to correct errors and reduce the overall mutation rate, but they don’t selectively channel variation into “nonessential” genes. The creative force in evolution is natural selection acting on this undirected variation, not a guided process of mutation itself.)

Genuine stability is achieved by negotiating the dynamic interaction between the center and the fringe. This kind of stability adapts to change with minimal disruption. It's ensured by honoring the transformative Logos—such as innovative thinking, speech freedom, discovery, and playful activities—and its solidification into the stabilizing paternal tradition, akin to legal codes and prophetic guidance.

The Center and the Fringe as a Feedback Loop

In Complexity, Melanie Mitchell explains that complex adaptive systems—like societies—achieve stability through feedback loops between processes that generate variation and processes that constrain those variations. The center and the fringe can be seen as two parts of such a feedback loop. The Logos (innovative thinking, discovery, play) perturbs the fringe, while paternal tradition (legal codes, prophetic guidance) acts as a filter that amplifies beneficial novelties and damps out destructive ones. This allows the system to adjust to new circumstances without losing its overall organization.

Peterson also warns that arrogance and the desire for power can lead to spiritual downfall. He uses the tale of Babel's Tower to illustrate this point. The tower's constructors wanted to dominate their surroundings for selfish purposes. Their pride led them to disregard the spiritual hierarchy and the limitations set by God. This resulted in disorder and bewilderment, as demonstrated by the tower's collapse and the mix-up of languages.

(Shortform note: Not everyone agrees that the tale of Babel's Tower is about how arrogance and the desire for power can lead to spiritual downfall. In Genesis, Old Testament scholar Walter Brueggemann argues that the story is about the dangers of uniformity and centralization. He explains that the tower represents an attempt to dominate all "surroundings" from a single "tower." The mix-up of languages is a positive act that protects diversity and limits human pretensions to a totalizing spiritual hierarchy.)