PDF Summary:The Fabulous Bouvier Sisters, by Sam Kashner and Nancy Schoenberger

In The Fabulous Bouvier Sisters, Sam Kashner and Nancy Schoenberger chronicle the complex, competitive relationship between Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis and her sister, Lee Radziwill—from their privileged but turbulent upbringing to their divergent paths as adults. The authors illustrate how Jackie embraced wealth and tradition by marrying into the Kennedy clan, while Lee challenged societal norms as an artist and performer striving to escape her sister's shadow.

Through detailed accounts, the book explores the sisters' jealousy, betrayals, and lingering childhood resentments that persisted despite their bond. Their rivalry reached new heights amid Jackie's fame, Lee's quest for recognition, and their connections to the wealthy Aristotle Onassis—culminating in a rift that spanned generations after devastating losses and a contested will.

(continued)...

• Develop a habit of expressing thanks for secondary advantages during your interactions. After spending time with someone, send them a message or tell them in person about a secondary advantage you've gained from them. For instance, if a mentor's advice leads you to a helpful resource, let them know how their guidance has had a ripple effect beyond the immediate advice.
• You can boost your visibility by creating a personal brand narrative that resonates with a global audience. Start by identifying unique aspects of your life and work that are universally relatable or inspiring. Craft a compelling story around these elements and share it through social media, a personal blog, or video content. For example, if you've overcome a significant challenge or achieved something against the odds, frame your narrative to highlight resilience and determination, which can inspire people across different cultures and backgrounds.
• Create a personal achievements document to track and present your skills and intellect. Start by listing all your accomplishments, big or small, and update it regularly. When you need to demonstrate your abilities, you'll have a detailed record to share with others, which can be particularly useful during performance reviews or job interviews.
• Host a themed fashion swap party with friends where everyone brings clothing and accessories that reflect the sophistication and elegance of Jackie's style era. This allows you and your friends to refresh your wardrobes, find unique pieces, and celebrate the impact of historical fashion trends on modern style without spending a fortune.
• Develop empathy through a 'Role Reversal Exercise'. Choose a family member who you have differences with and spend a day or a few hours 'in their shoes'. This means adopting their routines, hobbies, and even engaging in conversations from their perspective. This exercise can provide insights into their experiences and challenges, potentially improving your relationship with them.

Jackie's bond with Lee was shaped by factors that included her fame and marriage, as well as her connection to Aristotle Onassis.

Jackie's marriage to JFK and her role as First Lady had a profound impact on her relationship with Lee, who strove to establish her own identity in the public sphere.

Lee's aspiration to equal her sister's fame played a role in the growing estrangement between them, especially after Jackie married Aristotle Onassis, a man with whom Lee had once had a romantic connection, subsequent to the passing of JFK.

John F. Kennedy's ascension to the presidency in 1960 and the resulting prominence of Jackie as First Lady markedly amplified the complexities within their relationship, as Kashner and Schoenberger have chronicled. While Jackie embraced the responsibilities and opportunities of her new position with ease, Lee struggled to establish her own unique presence alongside her sister's prominent public life. Lee cherished her frequent visits to the White House, where she witnessed Jackie and the president holding lavish events. However, she frequently felt like a secondary figure, akin to a lady-in-waiting, during her sister's grand occasions and official travels. She was often placed at the end of the procession or tucked away in a corner at royal feasts, observing as Jackie received an extraordinary level of admiration throughout the United States.

In 1959, Lee began a love affair with Aristotle Onassis, which underscored this dynamic. The writers observe that Lee was enthralled by the immense wealth, cosmopolitan charm, and significant international presence of the Greek shipping magnate, but it was Jackie who drew Onassis's attention more, leading to his proposal and their marriage five years later. The Kennedy family proposed that Lee accompany the President on his European trips to avert any possibility of a romantic connection developing between Jackie and Onassis. The stratagem failed. After Jack Kennedy's assassination Lee introduced a distraught Jackie to Onassis, urging her to get away from it all on the tycoon's lavish yacht. Jackie's union with Onassis further cemented the perception that Lee was the less noticed sibling.

Other Perspectives

• The perception of estrangement might be exaggerated or oversimplified, not taking into account the private support and affection that could have existed between the sisters despite public appearances.
• The assumption that JFK's presidency complicated their relationship overlooks the agency of both women to navigate their personal dynamics independently of their public roles.
• The perception of Lee's struggle could be influenced by societal expectations of women at the time, which often valued their proximity to powerful men over their individual achievements.
• The feeling of being a secondary figure could be common among siblings of highly prominent individuals and may not reflect any intentional marginalization by Jackie or the administration.
• The love affair could be seen as a symptom of the existing dynamics rather than a highlight; it might have brought underlying tensions to the surface but did not necessarily define or significantly alter their relationship.
• The narrative that Lee was merely captivated by Onassis's wealth and charm could be seen as reductive, not accounting for the possibility that her feelings were deeper and more multifaceted.
• The effectiveness of this strategy is questionable, as it assumes that the only way to prevent a romantic connection is through physical separation, which does not account for emotional or intellectual bonds that might form or exist independently of physical proximity.

The marriage to Onassis highlighted the sisters' contrasting attitudes toward wealth, social status, and their appetite for the limelight, further intensifying their inherent rivalry.

Lee played a pivotal part in organizing Jackie's 1968 nuptials with the shipping tycoon, an act which severely strained the relationship between the sisters. Jackie and Onassis were wed on the private island of Skorpios in a ceremony that unexpectedly caught the Kennedy and Auchincloss families off guard. Jackie had indeed been advised by Bobby Kennedy to wait, to avoid such a public scandal so soon after Jack's and Bobby’s assassinations. Onassis offered a haven where she could find respite from the unrelenting scrutiny of the public, which she deemed intolerable, and from the concerns she had regarding the security of her children.

The authors regard the collaboration as a critical juncture marking the beginning of the decline in the relationship between Jackie and Lee. The media's unyielding examination amplified stories that juxtaposed Jackie's descent from her revered status as America's grieving widow with the substantial wealth of Onassis. But more importantly, for Lee, it was a devastating humiliation and a betrayal of trust, particularly after Lee had been warned by both John and Bobby Kennedy against getting involved with Onassis. The sisters' long-standing rivalry was evident, reflecting their differing ambitions, values, and approaches to handling their fame; Jackie embraced her prominent status with poise, while Lee frequently found the relentless attention challenging and resented its control over her existence.

Context

• Aristotle Onassis was one of the wealthiest men in the world, a Greek shipping magnate whose wealth and status made the marriage a significant social event, requiring careful planning and discretion.
• Bobby Kennedy, a prominent political figure and brother to Jackie Kennedy's late husband, President John F. Kennedy, was assassinated in June 1968. His death followed the assassination of John F. Kennedy in 1963, leaving the Kennedy family in a state of mourning and under intense public scrutiny.
• Onassis owned the private Greek island of Skorpios, which offered a secluded retreat away from the prying eyes of the press and the public, allowing Jackie and her children a more private life.
• At the time, Jackie’s decision to remarry, especially to someone like Onassis, was viewed by many as a departure from her previous image as the dignified widow of a beloved president, leading to mixed public reactions.
• She was adept at managing her public image, often using her style and demeanor to influence public perception positively, which contributed to her reputation for poise.
• During the 1960s and 1970s, the media was intensely focused on the lives of high-profile figures like the Bouvier sisters. The press often sensationalized their personal lives, which could be overwhelming and invasive.

Lee perceived her own aspirations and achievements as being overshadowed by Jackie's overwhelming fame and the iconic status she held as the "Queen of Camelot."

Kashner and Schoenberger explore how Jackie's union with Aristotle Onassis after John F. Kennedy passed away profoundly influenced Lee. She presented a brave front to the world, championing their connection, but behind closed doors, she grappled with a sense of treachery and the sensation of being overshadowed. After the Kennedy presidency, which was characterized by considerable public fascination and notable historical events, Lee sought to forge her own identity and connections following the sudden and tragic loss of her brother-in-law, moving beyond Jackie's influence. After leaving the White House and entering into matrimony with Onassis, Jackie's renown appeared to become increasingly robust and invulnerable. Many Americans found it difficult to reconcile with the notion that Jackie Kennedy represented just another wealthy partner.

Lee frequently felt that her efforts to establish herself in acting, interior design, and television were consistently eclipsed by the renown of her sister. The press frequently depicted her achievements as less significant compared to Jackie's, placing Lee at a comparative disadvantage. The relentless pursuit of personal distinction and success, exacerbated by the widespread praise for Jackie, led to growing resentment. The author regards this resentment as a pivotal element that contributed to the ultimate disintegration of their relationship.

Other Perspectives

• Jackie's status as the "Queen of Camelot" was tied to her role as the First Lady, a position that inherently attracts more public and historical attention than individual professional endeavors.
• Jackie's marriage to Aristotle Onassis may have been a source of inspiration for Lee, encouraging her to pursue her own path and independence rather than causing feelings of treachery and overshadowing.
• The idea that Lee sought to forge her own identity might overlook the complexities of sibling relationships and individual psychology, where factors such as personal interests, talents, and the dynamics of family roles play a significant part.
• Success in fields like acting, interior design, and television often requires time, and Lee's accomplishments might have been on a trajectory to gain more recognition irrespective of Jackie's fame.
• The disadvantage might not have been solely due to press portrayal but also because of the inherent challenges in matching the public fascination with a former First Lady and a national figure like Jackie Kennedy.
• Resentment is a complex emotion and could stem from a variety of sources, not just the praise received by Jackie; it might be an oversimplification to attribute it only to the comparison between the two sisters.
• The relationship between the sisters might have remained strong in many ways, with moments of support and affection outweighing the periods of resentment.

The sisters endeavored to create distinct legacies and identities, each independent from the other.

Jackie and Lee each made concerted efforts to forge distinct legacies and personal identities, often setting themselves apart from each other.

Jackie’s work as a White House curator and editor allowed her to cultivate her intellectual and artistic interests, while Lee pursued careers in design, television, and publishing,

Even as she aged and deliberately stepped back from public attention, Jackie continued to be a woman celebrated and esteemed worldwide by numerous individuals. Jackie carefully crafted her unique legacy and persona, ensuring it stood apart from her association with the Kennedy family, with their lives mirroring each other over numerous years. She independently reignited her early enthusiasm for the study of art and literary works. Despite experiencing deep sorrow from the loss of her infant Patrick, the devastating assassination of President Kennedy, and the end of her union with Onassis, Jackie maneuvered through life with grace and resilience, ultimately discovering comfort and a partner in the respected diamond trader Maurice Tempelsman.

She rekindled her long-standing love for equestrian activities, a pastime she had treasured since her younger days, and broadened her circle of acquaintances beyond the Kennedy family circle. She derived significant fulfillment from her profession, first with her role at Viking Press and subsequently by committing almost twenty years to her editorial role at Doubleday. Her passion for the arts and literature, which provided her with a means to articulate her identity beyond her obligations to family and spouse, was nurtured during this period. In acquiring the vast seaside property on Martha's Vineyard, she encapsulated a spirit of tranquility akin to that of Lasata, evoking memories of the joyful summers spent there with Lee and other family members. Lee, too, continued to seek personal and professional fulfillment. She established a successful interior design enterprise, penned pieces for a renowned architecture magazine, and took on the responsibilities of an image consultant and special events director for Giorgio Armani. Her every deed reflected her deep admiration for the aesthetic.

Context

• Her work in publishing included writing and contributing to magazines, where she shared her insights on style and design, leveraging her experience and social connections.
• Jackie was deeply committed to her children, Caroline and John Jr., and prioritized their well-being and privacy, which was a significant aspect of her life after the tragedies she faced.
• Both shared an appreciation for culture and the arts, which likely strengthened their bond and provided a foundation for their relationship beyond romantic involvement.
• The discipline and focus required in equestrian sports may have contributed to Jackie's ability to handle stress and maintain composure in challenging situations.
• Martha's Vineyard is an island located south of Cape Cod in Massachusetts, known for its affluent summer colony. It has been a popular vacation spot for many prominent families, including the Kennedys.
• Her success in interior design was part of her effort to establish an independent identity separate from her famous family ties.
• Architecture magazines often feature articles on design trends, influential architects, and innovative projects, providing a platform for contributors like Lee to express their insights and opinions on these topics.
• As a special events director, Lee would have been responsible for planning and executing high-profile events, such as fashion shows, product launches, and exclusive parties, ensuring they align with the brand's image.

Other Perspectives

• The role of an editor, depending on the nature of the work, might not always allow for personal intellectual and artistic development, as it often involves facilitating the expression of others' ideas rather than exploring one's own.
• The celebration of public figures often wanes as they withdraw from the public eye, and Jackie's case might not have been an exception, with public adulation possibly diminishing over time.
• It could be considered that Jackie's role as a White House curator, which was inherently tied to her association with the Kennedy family, may have continued to influence her artistic and literary pursuits, challenging the notion of her independence in these areas.
• The statement that Jackie broadened her circle of acquaintances beyond the Kennedy family does not account for the depth of these relationships; expanding a social circle can often include more superficial connections rather than meaningful friendships.
• Fulfillment in one's profession is subjective and can fluctuate over time; what may seem like a fulfilling career at one point could have also included periods of stress, dissatisfaction, or routine challenges that are typical in any job.
• Jackie's editorial roles at Viking Press and Doubleday might have been more about leveraging her high-profile persona for the publishing companies' benefit rather than a pure nurturing of her artistic and literary interests.

The sisters competed for attention, and Lee often felt overshadowed by Jackie's fame and status, which she believed impeded her pursuit of recognition.

Throughout their later years, the siblings' rivalry persisted, though it was less fierce than in the periods when they were in the international limelight. Jackie, revered as the nation's cherished widow and a paragon of fashion, maintained a potent influence through a subtle yet steadfast presence, which often eclipsed the accomplishments Lee had in the realms of acting, interior decoration, and literary publishing. Lee discussed the significant burden of such expectations, noting that people often do not grasp the deep significance of being the last one left.

Other Perspectives

• The term "rivalry" could be an oversimplification of a multifaceted relationship, failing to acknowledge the depth and breadth of sibling interactions over a lifetime.
• The perceived decrease in rivalry intensity could be due to a lack of public visibility rather than an actual reduction in competitive feelings between the sisters.
• The idea of a "subtle yet steadfast presence" could be subjective, as perceptions of influence can vary widely among different groups and individuals.
• The perception of being overshadowed might be subjective and not fully reflect the public's view or the industry's recognition of Lee's work.
• The concept of a burden could be re-framed as an opportunity for Lee to differentiate herself and carve out a distinct niche in her professional endeavors.
• Many people have experienced loss and therefore can relate to and understand the significance of being the last one left.

Jacqueline discreetly preserved accounts of history, highlighting a stark contrast to Lee's more pronounced affinity for the arts, thereby emphasizing the fundamental differences between them.

In their later years, Jackie and Lee aimed to create distinct legacies. They each possessed a passionate interest in cultural endeavors, yet their methods for creating distinct legacies varied significantly. During her tenure as a cultural custodian in the White House and her later pursuits in the realm of literature, she discreetly and moderately indulged her intellectual and artistic inclinations, in a manner that aligned with her literary interests and her inherent sophistication. The intellectual capacity and curiosity of Jacqueline Kennedy were often undervalued or misconstrued by many Americans, prompting her to adopt a low profile. Lee tirelessly sought public recognition, endeavoring to showcase her distinctive sense of style, her expertise in interior design, her talent as an author, and her connections with influential figures in the arts and culture scene. Jackie was distinguished by her tranquil grace and composure, which garnered her widespread respect while she maintained a relatively reserved public persona.

Context

• Their efforts in cultural endeavors were part of a broader movement during the 1960s and 1970s that saw a renewed interest in the arts and historical preservation in America.

Other Perspectives

• The term "discreetly" could be subjective; what is considered discreet by some might be seen as quite visible and influential by others.
• The idea of aiming to create a legacy suggests a level of intention that may not accurately reflect the natural evolution of a person's life and influence.
• The emphasis on their differences might overshadow the fact that both women operated within the same social circles and historical contexts, which could have influenced their legacies in more similar ways than the statement acknowledges.
• Indulging in intellectual and artistic inclinations, even discreetly, could still influence public perception and legacy, potentially contradicting the notion of a low-profile approach.
• Some Americans may have indeed valued and understood Jacqueline's intellectual capacity and curiosity, but their voices might have been less prominent in public discourse.
• The very act of preserving history and contributing to literature can be seen as a form of legacy-building that necessitates public acknowledgment and influence, which contrasts with the idea of being reserved.

As the sisters grew older, the weakening of their connection, along with the persistent characteristics of the Bouvier/Radziwill family dynamic, became evident.

As the years passed, the connection between the sisters diminished, marked by increasing estrangement, betrayals, and persistent resentment.

The passing of Anthony and John Jr. deeply intensified the existing strains in the sisters' already fragile relationship, leaving them immensely heartbroken.

The bond between Jackie and Lee, which had grown stronger as they grieved President Kennedy's passing together, completely disintegrated over a decade. Their relationship deepened over time, solidified by mutual love and care for their offspring and subsequent generations, even amidst persistent competition and rivalry. Concerned about the potential impact on her parental rights if she moved to Greece after marrying Onassis, Jackie made certain that she and her children maintained their primary residence in New York, while still upholding the Kennedy family customs, including participating in the annual Thanksgiving celebrations at Hyannis Port and ensuring her children stayed in regular weekly contact with their grandparents. She cherished the belief that, even though her parents had ended their marriage and entered into new unions leading to a mix of half-brothers and sisters, the four children would preserve a solid connection. Lee embarked on the creation of her documentary, "This Side of Paradise," aiming to encapsulate the joyous nature of the sisters' youthful summers at Lasata in the Hamptons. The finished film was not shown to the public until 1999, and when it was, the narrative centered on the offspring instead of the siblings.

Misfortune did not spare either family. In 1999, John Kennedy Jr., his spouse Carolyn Bessette, and her sibling perished in a catastrophic plane crash. Anthony Radziwill, the only child of Lee, lost his battle with cancer and died at the age of forty, mere weeks after ceasing his long struggle with the illness. The bond between Jackie and Lee, already delicate, was unable to endure these substantial losses.

Context

• The Kennedy family's gatherings at Hyannis Port have been widely covered in the media, contributing to the family's iconic status in American culture. These events often symbolized the ideal of a close-knit, influential American family.
• Although the documentary was completed earlier, it was not released to the public until 1999, possibly due to personal reasons or the desire to maintain privacy.
• The crash was partly attributed to poor visibility and pilot error, as John was not fully trained for instrument-only flight conditions.
• Anthony was diagnosed with testicular cancer in 1989. Despite undergoing extensive treatment, including surgery and chemotherapy, the cancer eventually spread.

Other Perspectives

• The passing of Anthony and John Jr. might have been a catalyst for reflection and healing in the sisters' relationship, rather than an intensifying factor of existing strains.
• The term "disintegrated" could be too strong to describe the evolution of Jackie and Lee's relationship, which might have simply transformed or adapted to new circumstances over time rather than completely fallen apart.
• The act of maintaining family customs and ensuring contact with extended family members could be seen as fulfilling obligations rather than evidence of a deepening relationship between the sisters.
• This decision may have also limited the children's opportunity to develop a closer relationship with their stepfather, Aristotle Onassis, and his side of the family in Greece.
• The choice to highlight the offspring in the film could be seen as a way to avoid addressing any unresolved issues or tensions between the sisters, thus presenting a potentially sanitized version of their relationship.
• The statement assumes that the bond was unable to endure without considering the possibility that other factors, not directly related to the losses, could have influenced the state of their relationship.

The will of Jackie, which notably omitted Lee, was seen by many as a final act of retribution, leaving Lee feeling profoundly let down and embarrassed.

The authors cite Jackie’s will as the final insult. She explicitly stated in her will that her stepbrother Yusha, the beneficiary of half of her Hammersmith Farm estate, would not bear the responsibility for any estate tax payments on his inheritance. She persisted in making sure her relatives would keep benefiting from her kindness. Lee perceived her exclusion from the will as an unmistakable slight. Individuals found themselves perplexed. The authors highlight Jackie's profound understanding of history and her recognition of retribution, illustrating her keen awareness of Lee's consistent quest for comparable wealth and security. What motivated this act of retribution? The underlying reasons remain obscure, yet it is evident that the sisters harbor a profound animosity, manifested in the ostracism of one sibling.

Context

• By specifying that Yusha would not be responsible for estate taxes, Jackie ensured that the financial burden did not diminish his inheritance, a strategic move that highlights her attention to financial details and priorities.
• Yusha, or Hugh D. Auchincloss III, was Jackie’s stepbrother from her mother's marriage to Hugh D. Auchincloss Jr. This connection highlights the blended family dynamics and potential favoritism.
• Beyond financial loss, being excluded from a will can feel like a personal rejection, affecting one's self-esteem and sense of belonging within the family.
• During the time, societal norms often dictated that family disputes remain private. The public nature of the will's contents might have intensified feelings of embarrassment or betrayal for Lee.
• Inheritance decisions can often reflect personal relationships and unresolved family dynamics. In high-profile families, these decisions are scrutinized and can be seen as statements of approval or disapproval.

The complex relationships and interactions within the Bouvier/Radziwill family continued beyond their lifetimes, as future generations took on the longstanding grievances and hostilities.

The depiction by Shoenberger and her writing partner highlights the enduring traits and deep-seated complaints that have become embedded within the history of the Bouvier lineage, suggesting that these attributes are transmitted through and inherited by future generations. Jackie maintained a dignified and composed demeanor in the public eye, carefully avoiding being photographed with a cigarette and deliberately not showcasing her intellectual abilities, in contrast to Lee, who led a life with less restraint. Jackie's choice to leave Lee out of her will might have originated from the different manners in which they interacted with the public. The authors emphasize that the trajectories of Jackie and Lee's lives reflect the challenges and opportunities that women faced in the second half of the 20th century, a period characterized by considerable societal transformation driven by the feminist movement, civil rights activism, and the Vietnam War. Lee embodies the modern woman, steering her life with independence, replete with its intrinsic challenges and the highs and lows that accompany them.

Practical Tips

• Create a family interaction map to visualize and understand your own family dynamics. Draw a diagram with each family member as a node and lines connecting them to represent different types of relationships and interactions. Use colors or symbols to denote positive, negative, or complex relationships. This visual tool can help you see patterns and areas that may need attention or healing.
• Start a tradition of annual family meetings dedicated to open dialogue and reconciliation, where each member can express their feelings and grievances in a controlled environment. This can foster understanding and healing. For instance, you could use this time to discuss misunderstandings from the past year and work together to find solutions or compromises.
• Engage in a creative project, like writing a short story or creating a piece of art, that represents the intergenerational traits you've discovered. This can be a personal exploration of how these traits manifest in fictional characters or abstract representations, which can help you process and understand the impact of your heritage on your identity.
• Create a personal development plan that focuses on strengthening inherited positive traits and mitigating negative ones. If you've noticed a trend of strong leadership in your family, for example, you might seek out opportunities to lead in your community or workplace. Conversely, if there's a history of a particular health issue, you could proactively adopt a healthier lifestyle and encourage family members to do the same.
• Develop a personal "press policy" for yourself, deciding in advance what aspects of your life you're willing to share publicly and what you'll keep private. If you're attending an event where you know there will be photos taken, plan your actions and attire accordingly. For instance, if you're a non-smoker who doesn't want to be associated with smoking, you would avoid areas where smokers congregate during breaks at a conference.
• You can embrace spontaneity by setting aside one day each week to do something unplanned. Start by choosing a day where you have no obligations, and when it arrives, make decisions on the fly about how to spend your time. Whether it's trying a new restaurant, taking a different route on your walk, or calling up a friend for an impromptu meet-up, the key is to make choices in the moment without pre-planning.
• Create a personal "values and intentions" journal to clarify your decision-making process. Whenever you're faced with a significant choice, such as who to include in a project or how to distribute responsibilities among team members, write down the values that are guiding your decision. This can help ensure that your choices are aligned with your personal ethics and not unduly influenced by external perceptions.
• Start a journal where you document daily experiences that highlight gender-based challenges or opportunities. This can serve as a personal record to track progress and setbacks in your own life, similar to how historical figures' lives were shaped by their times. You might note instances where you feel your gender played a role in how you were treated at work, in social settings, or in personal relationships.
• Foster a deeper understanding of the era's cultural shift by curating a playlist of music from or inspired by the time of the feminist movement, civil rights activism, and the Vietnam War. As you listen, consider how the lyrics and tone reflect the sentiments and struggles of the era. This can be a way to emotionally connect with the period and appreciate the role of art in societal transformation.
• Set up a challenge that pushes you out of your comfort zone, such as learning a new skill or hobby independently. This could involve online courses, self-teaching, or simply experimenting with new techniques. The goal is to navigate the learning process on your own, dealing with obstacles and enjoying successes without external guidance, which mirrors the journey of self-navigation and personal growth.