PDF Summary:The Divine Dance, by Richard Rohr

Most people think of God as a single, distant entity—but what if God is better understood as a relationship? In The Divine Dance, Richard Rohr presents the Trinity as a model of shared power, mutuality, and constant divine flow. He argues that God is inherently relational, existing as an eternal exchange of love among Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, and that this divine flow connects all of creation.

Rohr explores how the Trinitarian vision transforms our understanding of spirituality, community, and human relationships. He discusses how divine love is unconditional and always available, how the Holy Spirit maintains connection and healing in the world, and how embodied practices like meditation and baptism help us experience spiritual truths. This guide also examines Rohr's reimagining of theology, moving away from individualism toward a relational understanding of God and humanity.

(continued)...

Rohr also notes that humans often resist the natural rhythms of the created world, unlike other creatures. Other creatures go along with the current of creation with a kind of inborn elegance, which people write off as nothing more than instinct. Humans, on the other hand, are dissatisfied with who we are and continually aspire to be someone different. It's difficult for us to embrace "just this" with grace.

(Shortform note: One reason humans resist the natural rhythms of the created world is that we have a unique ability to imagine alternative futures and identities. This capacity for imagination allows us to envision possibilities beyond our current reality, which can be both a source of creativity and a cause of dissatisfaction. Unlike other creatures that live in the present moment, our minds are constantly pulled toward what could be, making it challenging to fully embrace the immediate rhythms of the created world.)

The Practice of Relationality

Rohr explains that the Trinity forms a dynamic relationship based on love and communion, inviting all creation to participate.

(Shortform note: Theologians have long debated how to describe the relationship between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. In the fourth century, the Cappadocian Fathers (Basil the Great, Gregory of Nyssa, and Gregory of Nazianzus) introduced the term “hypostasis” to describe the distinct persons of the Trinity, emphasizing their unique identities while maintaining their unity.)

Implications and Applications of the Trinitarian Vision

Rohr asserts that the Trinitarian vision invites us to recognize divine light in all people. Your ability to perceive light and goodness reflects how Trinitarian you are. Your ability to perceive divinity where you might prefer not to shows the extent to which the divine image is currently active in you.

(Shortform note: While Rohr’s emphasis on recognizing divine light and goodness in all people is a powerful call to compassion, it’s important to balance this perspective with healthy boundaries. Focusing solely on seeing the good in others can sometimes lead to overlooking harmful behaviors or staying in unhealthy relationships.)

According to Rohr, this vision transforms how we perceive God and reality, demonstrating an ideal of freedom within relational dynamics. Everyone lets the other person be who they are while staying perfectly generous toward them. This approach makes it possible to form genuine unity and community, celebrating true freedom. Genuine liberation in the spiritual sense is attained by one who rests inside God’s perfect freedom. Trinitarian love establishes and sustains diversity and liberty, and diversity or liberty doesn't break unity.

(Shortform note: One potential danger of this approach is that it can be interpreted as a call to never set boundaries. If you’re in a toxic or abusive relationship, this can leave you open to ongoing abuse or manipulation. In such cases, it’s important to recognize when to prioritize your own well-being and safety.)

The Trinitarian vision is akin to ocean waves lapping on the shore. All of existence can be visualized as a limitless outward movement that fuels and creates an endless inward movement. The Incarnation of Christ and the Indwelling of the Spirit are historical reflections of this endless current. The inflow always matches the outflow. Both the universe and humankind have become part of this stream. We are intrinsically participants in the sacred movement, not outside observers. Everyone is invited to join the divine dance. Everyone is welcome. Rohr explains that God isn’t simply one being alongside others, but rather Being itself.

(Shortform note: The idea of a “divine dance” is a modern way of describing the ancient Christian understanding of the Trinity. In her book God For Us, theologian Catherine LaCugna explains that the Trinity is not a puzzle to be solved, but a mystery to be lived. She argues that God’s very being is a communion of love, and that this love overflows into creation. This means that God is not a distant, abstract being, but a living reality who invites us into relationship.)

The God whom Jesus talks about, and includes himself in, is presented as unhindered dialogue, a totally positive and inclusive flow in one direction, and a waterwheel of outpouring love that never stops. No human actions can halt the current of divine love. Our most serious transgressions can't unravel this everlasting pattern. God is constantly victorious, and God's love will triumph. Love can't be defeated, and neither can God. The sacred dance is an unstoppable force, pouring out ceaselessly. Viewing retributive justice as a divine attribute is reinterpreted by the abundant Trinity as negated by God's mercy and reframed rightly as restorative justice. The revelation of the Trinity was meant to transform everything, but only a small number of Christians embraced this purifying movement. We're not independently substantive. Our existence is solely relational.

Social Trinitarianism

Rohr’s perspective echoes a 20th-century theological shift known as “social trinitarianism.” This movement, exemplified by theologians like Jürgen Moltmann, reimagined the Trinity as a dynamic community of love, emphasizing God’s relational nature and the call for human participation in this divine fellowship. In The Trinity and the Kingdom, Moltmann argues that “the doctrine of the Trinity must be understood first of all as a social doctrine of God, because the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit exist in eternal reciprocity and their unity consists in their mutually self-giving love; in this way, God’s life is a communion that freely opens itself and calls human beings and the whole creation to participate in this divine fellowship of love.” This approach challenges traditional views of God as a solitary, immutable being, instead presenting the divine as an open, participatory community.

Finally, Rohr asserts that the Trinitarian vision fosters authentic community and freedom. It shows a model of ideal liberty in connections, with everyone letting others be themselves while staying in complete selflessness toward them. Variety and liberty originate and are preserved through Trinitarian love. Diversity and freedom don't destroy union. A person embracing a Trinitarian perspective is one who is breaking free from the shackles of narcissism. A companion in God's dance is a person who chooses to engage in the reciprocal bond of God's nature.

The Dangers of Selflessness

While Rohr’s vision of the Trinity as a model for community and freedom is inspiring, it’s important to recognize that the ideal of “complete selflessness” in relationships can be dangerous in certain contexts. For example, feminist theologians have pointed out that traditional Christian teachings on self-sacrifice and self-denial can be psychologically damaging for women, who are often socialized to prioritize others’ needs over their own. For people who already struggle with asserting their own needs and boundaries, striving for “complete selflessness” in relationships can reinforce unhealthy patterns of self-negation rather than leading to greater freedom and healing.

Next, we’ll explore how Rohr reimagines theology and how embodied practice can help us experience spiritual truths through physical actions.

Reimagined Theology

Rohr reimagines theology by emphasizing the relational aspect of the Trinity over individualism. He rejects the penal substitutionary theory of atonement, which he believes portrays God as transactional and retributive. Instead, he highlights the dynamic interplay among the Trinity's three persons. This relationality is reflected in human beings, who are made in God's likeness and are called to engage in the sacred dance of love and relationship.

Rohr argues that Western Christianity has overemphasized individuality and rationality at the expense of intuition and relationality. He believes that a Trinitarian metaphysic provides a stable and rooted identity for Christians, one that is reflected in the very makeup of the universe, from the tripartite structure of atoms to the three entities of the Trinity.

The Structure of Atoms

Rohr’s claim that the universe’s makeup is reflected in the tripartite structure of atoms is scientifically inaccurate. While atoms were once thought to be composed of three fundamental particles—protons, neutrons, and electrons—modern physics has revealed a more complex picture. Protons and neutrons are themselves made up of quarks, and electrons belong to a different family of particles called leptons. Additionally, there are other subatomic particles like photons, gluons, and bosons that play crucial roles in the structure and behavior of matter. This complexity challenges the notion of a universal tripartite structure in atoms.

Embodied Practice

Rohr asserts that embodied practices help us experience spiritual truths through physical actions. The body is a shrine to the Unknown. For example, baptism is a body-centered symbol of being submerged in the Trinity's current, and crossing yourself is a body prayer that reminds us of our Trinitarian identity. Meditation through walking helps us release accumulated energy and cultivate awareness, connect with people, and revere our surroundings.

(Shortform note: In The Embodied Mind, Francisco J. Varela, Evan Thompson, and Eleanor Rosch argue that our perception, emotions, and thoughts are shaped by the rhythms of our bodies. This means that the way we move and position ourselves can influence how we experience the world. When we engage in specific movements or postures, we can activate certain patterns in our brains that make particular meanings and values feel more real and vivid to us.)

We’ll discuss cultivating inner awareness and manifesting relationality in community.

Cultivating Inner Awareness

Rohr explains that cultivating inner awareness involves participating in how we comprehend existence. This is a unique ability granted to faithful individuals, allowing others to understand our perspective and circumstances. This form of understanding has largely been forgotten due to the Reformation and the Enlightenment's rationalism.

(Shortform note: Some historians argue that the Reformation and Enlightenment shifted the focus of inner awareness from shared contemplation to moral self-examination and scientific self-observation. In A Secular Age, Charles Taylor describes how the Reformation emphasized personal moral scrutiny, while the Enlightenment promoted a detached, objective view of the self.)

Rohr also states that contemplation helps us recognize the unity of everything. It's about discovering how to dwell alongside the inner Witnessing Presence. Contemplation teaches you to perceive the completeness of everything and offers a way to directly experience God's presence through the words themselves.

The Observing Self

Rohr’s language of “dwelling alongside the inner Witnessing Presence” is unusual, but it may be helpful to consider how contemporary contemplative psychology describes the “observing self.” In The Happiness Trap, Russ Harris explains that we can distinguish between the “thinking self” and the “observing self”: the thinking self generates our thoughts, images, memories, and stories, while the observing self is the aspect of awareness that simply notices all these experiences as they come and go, remaining stable and unchanged no matter what we are thinking, feeling, or sensing in any given moment.

Manifesting Relationality in Community

Rohr explains that community reflects the relational character of the Trinity, which is a group of individuals connected to one another. The church organically extends the Trinity. When Christians follow their spiritual makeup, they assemble in a manner that mirrors the triune God's essence. The church's source is the Godhead.

(Shortform note: Rohr’s view of the church as an organic extension of the Trinity reflects a modern theological movement called “communion ecclesiology.” This approach, developed by theologians like John Zizioulas, argues that the church’s communal nature mirrors the triune God’s relational being.)