PDF Summary:Healing Back Pain, by John E. Sarno

If you suffer from chronic back pain, you've likely tried various physical treatments—from massage to exercises to heat therapy—with little lasting relief. In Healing Back Pain, Dr. John E. Sarno presents an alternative explanation: Your pain may not be caused by a structural problem at all, but rather by repressed emotions manifesting as physical symptoms. He introduces Tension Myositis Syndrome (TMS), a condition in which the brain restricts blood flow to muscles and nerves as a way to distract from uncomfortable feelings like anger and anxiety.

Sarno explains how TMS works, why traditional physical treatments often fail, and how understanding the mind-body connection is essential to recovery. You'll learn how to shift your focus from physical symptoms to psychological factors, overcome your fear of physical activity, and ultimately break free from chronic pain by addressing its true emotional roots.

(continued)...

Sarno explains that nerve involvement in TMS can cause discomfort, numbness, tingling, and weakness. Nervous tissue is more sensitive than muscle tissue. Nerves are similar to wires that link the brain to every area of the body. They carry signals from the brain to activate muscles and cause body parts to move, and they also convey details about the body's condition to the brain.

(Shortform note: Discomfort, numbness, tingling, and weakness can occur when a lesion or irritation along a sensory-motor pathway disrupts the input reaching the brain’s body map for that region. This disruption can lead to abnormal sensations (paresthesia) and impaired motor function.)

Nerve pain is caused by oxygen deprivation because low oxygen levels endanger the nerve's integrity. Pain related to nerves and caused by TMS serves as an alert. Someone might feel numb, tingly, prickly, a burning sensation, pressure, or other feelings. These sensations manifest in the regions the nerve serves. If a nerve gets damaged or irritated at any point along its path, you'll feel pain in the body part from which those signals would usually originate. The nerve along the lower spine is situated under the gluteal muscle. The paraspinal muscles of the lumbar region are above the nerves of the lower spine. The upper trapezius (shoulder) muscles cover the cervical spinal nerves and brachial plexus. These nerves are impacted by TMS more often than others.

(Shortform note: Patrick Wall, a pioneer in pain science, explains that when blood flow to a nerve is restricted, it can cause abnormal discharges in the sensory fibers of the nerve. This can lead to unusual sensations, known as paresthesias, such as tingling, numbness, or burning. Wall describes experiments where researchers applied pressure to nerves in animals, which reduced blood flow and caused the nerves to fire abnormally. This suggests that a disturbed oxygen supply alone can be enough to produce nerve-related symptoms.)

The Illusion of Structural Cause & Emotional Timing

Sarno argues that spine deformities seldom result in back pain. The spine is a robust structure that can handle daily activities. The postural muscles are the strongest in the human anatomy. The prevalence of back discomfort is largely a result of a sharp rise in TMS cases over the last three decades. A key factor in the rise is that medicine hasn't identified or diagnosed TMS. The pain has largely been blamed on different structural issues involving the spine, rather than TMS. However, the vast majority of structural issues affecting the spinal column are benign.

Modern Understanding of Back Pain

The field of pain science has evolved significantly since the 1980s, when Sarno first published his work. Today, most experts agree that persistent low back pain is a complex condition involving the nervous system, psychological factors, and social influences, rather than simply a result of spinal deformities. International guidelines now recommend against routine imaging for low back pain unless there are clear signs of serious underlying conditions. This shift reflects a growing recognition that most structural abnormalities seen on scans are common in people without pain and often don't correlate with symptoms. The guidelines also advise against surgery for most cases of persistent low back pain, except in specific situations like severe nerve compression.

Treatment and Underlying Factors in Recovering From TMS

We’ll explore the core treatment strategies for overcoming TMS, then consider the psychological factors that influence recovery.

Core Treatment Strategies for TMS Recovery

To begin, Sarno emphasizes the crucial need to overcome fear about being active. Fear of physical activity contributes significantly to prolonging back pain syndromes. People often anticipate experiencing pain from physical activity, and this fear can actually cause more impairment than the pain itself. It directs focus to the body rather than feelings. Start returning to physical activities once your pain has decreased substantially and you're confident in the diagnosis.

(Shortform note: While overcoming fear is important, it’s crucial to rule out serious causes of back pain before resuming physical activity. Delaying diagnosis of conditions like infections, tumors, or fractures can lead to worse outcomes. For example, spinal infections can cause permanent nerve damage if not treated promptly, and spinal tumors may require urgent intervention to prevent paralysis. If you have symptoms like fever, unexplained weight loss, or severe pain at night, seek medical attention immediately.)

Another core treatment strategy is to stop any physical therapies. Sarno points out that treatments like manipulation, heat, massage, exercise, and acupuncture assume the pain is due to a physical condition that can be addressed through physical approaches. If you continue to believe that your pain is physically caused, your symptoms will continue.

(Shortform note: While Sarno’s advice to stop physical therapies may be helpful for some, it could be harmful for others. In Explain Pain, the authors argue that the best way to overcome pain is to combine a clear understanding of pain biology with a gradual, confident increase in normal, meaningful movement. If you stop using painful body parts, your tissues lose capacity, and your nervous system becomes even more protective. Over time, this reduced movement and deconditioning can actually maintain or increase pain and disability rather than resolve it.)

We’ll discuss the foundational principles of treating TMS, then explore some psychological techniques for TMS.

Foundational Principles of Myoneural Tension Syndrome Therapy

One of the foundational principles of TMS treatment is the emphasis on the mind-body connection. Sarno argues that TMS represents a prime example of this connection, as the pain syndromes result from the mind-body interaction. Chemical and physiological changes in the ligaments, muscles, tendons, and nerves result from a brain process triggered by psychological factors. Concentrating on TMS's physiological and symptomatic aspects is counterproductive and tends to perpetuate rather than alleviate the problem.

(Shortform note: The mind-body connection is a central concept in the biopsychosocial model of pain, which is the dominant framework in contemporary pain science. This model recognizes that pain is a complex experience influenced by biological, psychological, and social factors. In this view, chronic pain is seen as a result of the brain's interpretation of nociceptive (pain) signals, which can be amplified or diminished by psychological processes such as attention, emotion, and expectation.)

Psychological Techniques for Treating TMS

According to Sarno, understanding TMS's psychological roots is crucial for treatment. Awareness of what's happening is the most crucial element for healing. The information given is like penicillin for this disorder. The pain arises from the interaction of mind and body. Alterations in chemistry and physical structure that occur in the nerves, muscles, ligaments, and tendons, causing pain and other symptoms, result from a brain-initiated process with psychological roots.

(Shortform note: A 2021 study by Yoni K. Ashar, Alan Gordon, and Howard Schubiner found that a treatment that helps patients understand their chronic back pain as a reversible brain process, rather than a sign of ongoing tissue damage, led to significant reductions in pain intensity and disability. This treatment also decreased pain-evoked brain activity in regions like the anterior insula and anterior midcingulate cortex.)

Sarno explains that the key (but challenging) task for patients is to start engaging in all kinds of physical activities again, even the most intense. This involves overcoming your fear of engaging in activities like bending, lifting, jogging, and playing sports. It involves unlearning all the myths about how you should bend, pick up objects, sit, stand, lie down, and other medical beliefs. While this is frequently challenging, each patient must overcome their fear and resume regular physical activities. You must do this not just to return to being a normal human being but to free yourself from the fear of physical activity, which often does a better job than pain of keeping your mind focused on the body. TMS diverts the mind away from focusing on emotions.

The Risks of Resuming Physical Activities

While Sarno’s advice to resume all physical activities is well-intentioned, it may not be safe for everyone. If your pain is caused by a serious underlying spinal problem, pushing yourself to engage in all kinds of physical activities again, even the most intense such as bending, lifting, jogging and playing sports, can be unsafe and may delay important medical care. For example, if you have a herniated disc, resuming intense activities like running or weightlifting could worsen the condition and lead to permanent nerve damage. Similarly, if you have spinal stenosis, pushing through the pain might cause further narrowing of the spinal canal, increasing the risk of paralysis. In these cases, ignoring the pain and continuing with all physical activities could delay necessary medical interventions, such as surgery or physical therapy, potentially leading to irreversible damage.

Another psychological technique is to shift focus from bodily pain to psychological issues. Sarno explains that doing this signals to your mind that you're not being fooled by the sensation anymore. When this message reaches your unconscious mind, the pain stops. When you notice pain, consciously shift your focus to an issue in your mind, such as a cause of worry or irritation.

(Shortform note: This technique may not work for people who experience intense pain. For these people, the pain is so threatening that it keeps forcing itself into their awareness, making it difficult to focus on anything else. This can lead to a cycle of increased distress and pain, making it even harder to shift focus away from the pain.)

Sarno also suggests communicating with your brain as an effective strategy to manage pain. This is a way to actively manage your pain rather than feeling like a helpless victim. This might end a bout of discomfort.

(Shortform note: A 2012 review of 42 clinical trials found that cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) can reduce pain and disability in people with chronic pain. CBT is a type of therapy that helps people change their thoughts and behaviors related to pain.)

Mental Aspects Influencing TMS Recovery

Psychological factors, such as stress and tension, are highly influential in the recovery from TMS, according to Sarno. He explains that tension means repressed emotions, while stress is any factor that puts pressure on an individual. TMS is a physical disorder induced by psychological phenomena, and the pain serves as a distraction from undesirable emotions. The brain uses TMS symptoms to imply a physical issue. Pain frequently starts when linked to a physical activity, causing the patient to think something has been injured.

Sarno adds that fear of symptoms coming back and engaging in physical activities, as well as the inability to identify effective treatment, characterize TMS. The combined impact of symptoms, fears, and changes in daily routines is to create someone who's deeply focused on the body. The syndrome serves to shift focus from unwanted feelings.

Pain as a Protective Output of the Nervous System

In Explain Pain, David Butler and Lorimer Moseley offer a different interpretation of the kinds of pain Sarno describes. They argue that pain is a protective output of the nervous system: It’s produced by the brain whenever it judges that body tissue is in danger and that you need to do something to protect yourself. The intensity of pain depends more on the level of perceived threat than on the amount of actual tissue damage. This means that pain can be experienced even in the absence of significant physical injury, and that psychological factors like fear and anxiety can amplify pain. This perspective contrasts with Sarno’s view that pain serves as a distraction from undesirable emotions.