PDF Summary:Ghosting the News, by Margaret Sullivan

The decline of local journalism threatens the foundations of democracy itself. In Ghosting the News, Margaret Sullivan paints a stark picture of the crisis facing local news outlets—newsrooms shuttering, layoffs decimating reporting staffs, and the vital work of community journalism vanishing. This landscape breeds disengaged citizens, uninformed voters, and unchecked abuses by those in power.

Sullivan examines the economic factors driving this downturn, from digital upheaval to mergers and profit-driven ownership. But she also highlights innovative models aiming to revive local news, from nonprofit initiatives and community-driven projects to creative funding strategies and nascent ideas about government support.

(continued)...

Other Perspectives

• While digital advertising has transformed the revenue model for newspapers, some local outlets have successfully pivoted to digital subscriptions and memberships, indicating that alternative revenue models can be viable.
• The decline in print advertising revenue is significant, but it's also worth noting that some niche and specialty newspapers have maintained or even grown their print advertising by catering to specific audiences or industries.
• Tech giants do dominate the digital advertising market, but there are emerging platforms and advertising cooperatives that aim to redistribute ad revenues more equitably to smaller publishers.
• Media consolidation is often criticized for reducing newsroom expenditure, yet some argue that it can lead to more efficient operations and resource allocation, potentially preserving the viability of some local news outlets.
• While major media corporations have made cuts in their workforce, some have also invested in digital transformation and innovation, which could lead to new forms of journalism and employment opportunities in the industry.
• The focus on profit maximization by investment entities in newspaper acquisitions is a concern, but there are also examples of investor-owned media companies that have managed to maintain journalistic standards and turn around struggling newspapers.
• Regional television broadcasting's reliance on retransmission fees is seen as a financial boon, but it's also possible that this revenue stream could be reinvested into local journalism initiatives, contrary to the skepticism about their commitment to comprehensive reporting.
• The criticism that television news prioritizes sensational content is valid, yet there are also local TV stations that have won awards for investigative journalism and in-depth reporting, suggesting a more nuanced picture of the industry's priorities.

The palpable consequences stemming from the erosion of community-based reporting, along with the inventive measures being implemented to combat this downturn.

The discussion explores the detrimental impacts of areas lacking news coverage and examines fresh efforts to address the challenges facing local journalism.

Without the presence of local journalism, communities are at an increased risk of unchecked wrongdoing by those in government and business sectors.

Sullivan emphasizes instances where the absence of local journalism allows malfeasance to thrive.

Vital information about local issues and the actions of those in government positions often goes unreported, allowing misconduct to continue unchecked.

The author emphasizes numerous cases where the absence of community reporting has led to unchecked abuses of power and deficiencies in government functions. The lack of local journalism in East Palo Alto, California, resulted in a substantial gap in the community's awareness of critical issues, including the school superintendent's inadequate leadership and the heated competition for city council seats. Citizens in East Lansing, Michigan initiated a journalism project that uncovered a series of local disputes, showcasing the vital function that trained reporters serve in uncovering important narratives that could remain hidden.

The lack of reliable local news sources contributes to diminished community engagement and a reduction in the number of people voting.

In her book, Sullivan argues that vigorous local journalism is essential for fostering a community that is engaged and well-informed. The waning of reliable local news sources contributes to a drop in voter participation, diminishes political consciousness, and erodes civic engagement. Citizens have fewer chances to gain insights into community concerns, educate themselves on electoral contenders, and ensure their elected officials are responsible for their actions.

Community-driven initiatives and the creation of nonprofit news organizations are emerging to fill the void in local news coverage.

Sullivan points out a number of encouraging efforts designed to tackle the crisis in local journalism.

Communities have the ability to launch their own local journalism projects, similar to the initiative started in East Lansing.

Sullivan highlights instances where communities have assumed responsibility for their own news reporting. Alice Dreger, a bioethicist, initiated a community journalism project called East Lansing Info in Michigan, which uncovered several local disputes and encouraged greater involvement in local matters. In Texas, a free distribution publication known as "Community Impact" has seen considerable growth by concentrating on highly localized content, which attracts local advertisers and delivers high-quality journalism that prioritizes issues relevant to the community. Communities have demonstrated their capacity to pool resources and expertise to make up for the diminished presence of traditional media in delivering news about local events.

Collaborative efforts between legacy media and nonprofit organizations such as Investigative Post are enhancing local news coverage.

The author emphasizes the growing significance of organizations dedicated to nonprofit journalism in providing crucial coverage of community happenings. The Investigative Post in Buffalo, a modest-sized nonprofit, uncovered corruption and misconduct within the police department, and its impact was significantly magnified by partnering with prominent regional media outlets, including the Buffalo News and several local television networks. The Texas Tribune, recognized for its considerable influence and achievements as a nonprofit newsroom, has demonstrated its ability to generate substantial revenue through organizing events like the well-known Texas Tribune Festival, attracting notable figures and bolstering robust local journalism.

Innovative approaches and trials seek to rejuvenate and maintain community-based reporting.

This part explores innovative strategies and models designed to revitalize community-based reporting.

Initiatives are being developed to create a framework for a membership funding support network targeting local news organizations, which includes contributions from affluent benefactors, as well as the creation of nonprofit incubators and the provision of government financial assistance.

Sullivan examines different approaches being contemplated to rejuvenate community-based reporting, acknowledging both their promise and limitations. The purchase of the Los Angeles Times by Patrick Soon-Shiong, who is frequently hailed as a supporter of community journalism, offers a ray of optimism, yet it relies on the generosity and significant wealth of the well-off, a model that is difficult to replicate on a broader scale. Heidi Legg mentions organizations such as the American Journalism Project as catalysts for advancement, and these groups are nurturing optimism for the development of new local journalism initiatives and attracting new talent to newsrooms that are dealing with difficulties.

Joint initiatives among press entities, coupled with innovative revenue creation strategies, may help some regional news outlets to persist.

The author explores a variety of innovative strategies aimed at enhancing the resilience and prosperity of local news outlets. In Pennsylvania, initiatives are underway to expand the scope of journalism with a focus on local matters. Several newspapers are finding success by employing a multifaceted approach that includes maintaining their traditional print editions, offering subscriptions for online content, and generating income through events, with each element tailored to meet the varied interests of diverse reader groups.

Other Perspectives

• While local journalism is crucial for accountability, alternative digital platforms and social media may also expose wrongdoing, albeit with varying levels of verification and journalistic standards.
• The assertion that lack of local news leads to unreported issues assumes that no other forms of media or communication can fill this gap, which may not account for the role of citizen journalism and online forums.
• The correlation between diminished local news sources and reduced community engagement may not account for other factors influencing civic participation, such as general political disaffection or broader social trends.
• Community-launched journalism projects may face sustainability challenges, such as funding and professional training, which could affect the quality and longevity of the reporting.
• Collaborations between legacy media and nonprofit organizations, while beneficial, may not always result in unbiased reporting if the nonprofits have specific agendas or if the legacy media has entrenched interests.
• Funding support networks relying on affluent benefactors or government assistance could potentially lead to conflicts of interest or undue influence on editorial independence.
• Innovative revenue strategies and joint initiatives may not be a one-size-fits-all solution, as they may not be applicable or successful in all regions or for all types of news outlets.

The widespread problem affecting local news outlets.

The conversation broadens here, arguing that the challenges faced by community news outlets are not confined to the United States.

The decline in reporting on community events and stories is not limited to the United States.

The decline of local journalism, highlighted by Margaret Sullivan, has consequences that extend beyond any single area, affecting the world at large.

Local media outlets across the globe, including those in Canada, Brazil, Europe, and Australia, are facing hardships.

The writer provides a global perspective by citing instances from Italy, Brazil, Australia, Portugal, and Canada to demonstrate the challenges faced by community journalism. She emphasizes the detrimental effects that dwindling subscriptions, falling advertising revenue, and the supremacy of digital platforms have on journalism at the community level across the globe.

The convergence of technological advancements, economic challenges, and political pressures is undermining local journalism globally.

Sullivan explores the multitude of reasons behind the global decline in local news reporting, emphasizing how technological progress, economic hurdles, and political forces have played a role. In Brazil, the intricacies of the media environment are intensified by the contentious interactions between journalists and President Jair Bolsonaro, coupled with efforts by his government to destabilize the economic foundations of news organizations.

The waning influence of journalism rooted in local communities has repercussions that resonate worldwide.

The writer argues that the widespread consequences stem from the decline in local news coverage.

The waning presence of local journalism contributes to a decrease in community engagement with local issues, diminished scrutiny of governmental conduct, and a dilution of the ties that bind communities on a global scale.

Sullivan emphasizes the global negative consequences stemming from the lack of robust local journalism. In many areas where local newspapers have declined or vanished, there is a decline in community involvement, a rise in political division, and a heightened risk of corruption in government.

Efforts are underway around the world to strengthen and rejuvenate community-based journalism, though they still face significant challenges.

The situation appears bleak, yet Sullivan highlights numerous global efforts to tackle this crisis. Initiatives are being pursued to investigate community-driven projects and government-funded support strategies aimed at strengthening and revitalizing local journalism, highlighting its acknowledged importance on a global scale.

Other Perspectives

• While the decline in local journalism is evident, it's also true that new forms of digital media and citizen journalism are emerging, which can sometimes fill the gap left by traditional news outlets.
• The hardships faced by local media outlets globally might not solely be due to external pressures; some of the challenges could stem from an inability to adapt to the changing media landscape or a lack of innovation within the industry.
• Technological advancements have also provided new tools for journalists and have made it easier to disseminate information, suggesting that the impact of technology on journalism is not entirely negative.
• The influence of local journalism may be waning, but this does not necessarily lead to a decrease in community engagement; in some cases, social media and online forums have increased civic participation and awareness of local issues.
• The assertion that the decline of local journalism leads to diminished scrutiny of governmental conduct assumes that other watchdog entities, such as non-profit organizations or concerned citizens, are not stepping in to hold governments accountable.
• While there are efforts to rejuvenate community-based journalism, it's possible that some of these initiatives may not be sustainable in the long term without significant changes to the business models that underpin journalism.
• The idea that the decline of local journalism dilutes community ties overlooks the role that global connectivity and social media can play in creating new forms of community that are not based on geography.

New models and solutions for supporting local journalism

The final section of the book examines different tactics and approaches designed to support local news outlets that are encountering challenges.

Philanthropic initiatives have led to an increase in the number of nonprofit news organizations.

The inquiry conducted by Sullivan underscores the importance of philanthropic support in sustaining community journalism, particularly as non-profit news entities become more prevalent.

Organizations like the American Journalism Project and Report for America are directing resources toward collaborative projects and the creation of new local journalism ventures.

The author emphasizes the efforts of entities actively strengthening local journalism. Elizabeth Green and John Thornton spearhead the American Journalism Project, which utilizes a venture philanthropy approach to bolster emerging entities dedicated to civic journalism. Report for America, drawing inspiration from the Peace Corps model, is deploying a multitude of up-and-coming reporters to news organizations that are resource-strapped, which markedly improves coverage of local happenings and concerns.

Organizations operating online without profit motives, like the Texas Tribune, are producing crucial local journalism.

Sullivan emphasizes the critical role that existing organizations dedicated to reporting play in preserving local news coverage. The publication known as the Texas Tribune has earned considerable acclaim for its innovative methods of revenue generation and its commitment to impactful journalism, while the Center for Investigative Journalism in Puerto Rico stands as a testament to the crucial function that nonprofit investigative reporting serves in holding powerful figures accountable.

Creative funding strategies and joint efforts hold promise for supporting community-based reporting.

The author explores various strategies that local news outlets could employ to diversify their revenue streams and ensure their financial sustainability.

Local newspapers are achieving sustainability by combining earnings from events with income derived from subscriptions to their digital and print editions.

Sullivan underscores the importance of adapting to the changing landscape in media and embracing innovative approaches to revenue generation. Publications that are flourishing in this challenging era are doing so by leveraging a mix of income from both their physical and digital versions, profiting from event-related revenue, and forging deeper connections with the audiences they serve.

Collaborative news initiatives, such as Spotlight PA in Pennsylvania, can merge their resources to expand the scope of local news reporting.

The author proposes that a practical solution to the challenges faced by community news reporting is to increase collaboration among various news organizations. Joint initiatives like Spotlight PA demonstrate how community reporting is bolstered and in-depth coverage of important issues is facilitated by pooling resources and expertise across various Pennsylvania-based news outlets.

The idea of government support playing a role in the provision of local news coverage is gaining fresh attention.

Sullivan delves into the growing importance and occasional controversy surrounding journalism that is financed by public funds.

Some have concerns about accepting financial assistance from the government, yet such support might be crucial for enacting policy changes and rules that protect local journalism.

The writer acknowledges apprehensions about potential political interference that could occur with financial backing for journalism from government entities. However, she argues for a fundamental reevaluation of entrenched convictions in light of the dire circumstances confronting community-based reporting. To protect the public's welfare, policy changes, regulatory measures, and the contemplation of well-thought-out government funding strategies may be necessary to support and enhance community news reporting.

Debates continue over how to structure public funding for local journalism while maintaining editorial independence

Sullivan acknowledges the continuous discussion regarding the government's proper involvement in backing journalistic endeavors. Ensuring editorial independence is as vital as obtaining financial support from community members. To ensure journalistic integrity and prevent any improper sway from political bodies, it is crucial to establish robust mechanisms such as peer-reviewed grant programs and transparent funding structures.

Other Perspectives

• Philanthropic initiatives may not be a sustainable or scalable long-term solution for all local news organizations.
• The influence of philanthropic donors could potentially bias news coverage, even in nonprofit models.
• The American Journalism Project and Report for America, while beneficial, may not reach all areas in need, potentially leaving some communities underserved.
• Nonprofit news organizations like the Texas Tribune, despite their success, may not be replicable in all markets or regions due to varying economic and demographic factors.
• Creative funding strategies may not be sufficient to counteract the decline in advertising revenue that has traditionally supported local journalism.
• Local newspapers' reliance on event earnings and subscriptions could lead to unequal access to news, with those unable to afford subscriptions being left out.
• Collaborative news initiatives may face challenges in aligning the goals and practices of different organizations, which could affect the quality and consistency of reporting.
• Government support for local news coverage raises legitimate concerns about potential threats to press freedom and the risk of government influence over editorial content.
• Structuring public funding to maintain editorial independence is complex and may not fully alleviate concerns about the influence of political agendas on journalism.