PDF Summary:Wine and War, by Donald Kladstrup and Petie Kladstrup

In Wine and War, Donald Kladstrup and Petie Kladstrup detail the profound cultural significance of wine in France. The authors reveal wine's deep roots in French identity and explore how the German occupation severely disrupted the revered winemaking traditions during World War II.

The story portrays the resilience of French winemakers who risked persecution to protect their "treasures"—their finest vintages. It captures the covert tactics they employed, from concealing wines in hidden cellars to sabotaging German shipments. The book also examines wine's role in sustaining the French people through deprivation and how the vintners' steadfast spirit mirrored the nation's indomitable character, paving the way for France's revival after the war.

(continued)...

The production of wine faced significant hurdles due to an acute shortage of crucial supplies, including fertilizers and chemicals, as well as a dearth of workforce.

During the conflict, winemakers encountered a critical shortage of essential resources, significantly limiting their ability to produce wines of exceptional caliber. The production of copper sulfate, crucial for combating mildew, encountered challenges as the necessary copper was repurposed for Germany's war efforts, coupled with a shortage of fertilizers and a lack of chemicals to address plant diseases. Jean Miailhe set aside his scholarly endeavors to help his family safeguard their vineyards amid significant shortages. He established a covert production facility at Château Coufran, resorting to the use of unlawfully acquired copper in response to a scarcity of copper sulfate. This hazardous undertaking highlights the lengths to which vintners went to protect their valuable vineyards.

The wine industry suffered further setbacks due to the devastation of vineyards and adverse weather conditions.

The authors depict how, in addition to resource shortages, severe weather events brought on by the conflict had a substantial impact on viticulture. The harsh climatic events, encompassing freezing temperatures, heavy rains, hail, and periods of drought, significantly diminished the output from the vineyards, leading to meager harvests that negatively impacted the quality of the harvested grapes. The story by Kladstrup and Kladstrup recounts the consequences of a severe hailstorm that struck Burgundy in the year 1945. Maurice Drouhin, who had carefully protected his wine reserves throughout the war, saw his hopes for post-war recovery dashed when a severe storm laid waste to his grape-growing fields. He, together with his fellow growers, faced the daunting task of reconstruction with limited means, having only a small portion of their usual yield at their disposal.

In order to meet German demands, French vintners were compelled to take steps that detrimentally affected the caliber of their wines.

During the chaos, vintners felt obliged to take steps that often put at risk the integrity and quality of France's winemaking tradition, as chronicled by Kladstrup and Kladstrup. To meet the demands imposed by the occupying forces, winemakers sometimes compromised their wines' integrity by mixing their finest vintages with inferior ones or using grapes of lower quality, leading to blends that did not match the superior standards they had achieved before the conflict. The story recounts the clever tactics of champagne producers who marked their inferior bottles with "Reserved for the Wehrmacht" to satisfy German orders. Otto Klaebisch, the Weinführer, while loyal to the Third Reich, paradoxically harbored a profound fondness for champagne and often uncovered these ruses, demanding superior wines from vintners he suspected of trying to trick him.

Practical Tips

• You can explore the resilience of wine by tasting vintages from different years, including those known for hardship. By comparing wines from years of conflict or poor weather conditions with those from more stable periods, you'll gain a deeper appreciation for how historical events shape the taste and quality of wine. For example, try a Bordeaux from the early 1940s and compare it with one from a recent, untroubled year.
• Start a wine journal to document the stories behind each bottle you enjoy. When you purchase a bottle of wine, especially from regions with turbulent histories like Champagne or Bordeaux, research its background and note any historical events that may have impacted its production. This practice will enhance your understanding of the wine's character and the resilience of vintners.
• Support wine producers who have overcome adversity by purchasing their products. Look for wineries that have a history of rebuilding after devastation, whether from war or natural disasters. By choosing these wines, you're not only enjoying a product but also contributing to the recovery and sustainability of wine regions with challenging pasts.

The vintners of France employed secretive strategies and demonstrated tenacity in protecting their cherished wines.

The story depicts the resilience of French winemakers who, under the stringent oversight of the Germans, carried out covert resistance, cleverly intertwined with longstanding traditions, to protect their prized wines from being plundered by the German military and their allies in the Vichy regime. Numerous tactics were adopted to resist the occupiers, including the concealment of vintages, engaging in sabotage, and joining the covert Resistance movement.

Vintners utilized a variety of strategies to prevent their best wines from falling into German possession.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup narrate the clever and occasionally perilous methods that French vintners utilized to safeguard what they frequently referred to as their "treasure," their most valued wines. They safeguarded their valuable vintages by stashing them away in secret locations, constructing misleading partitions in their cellars, and disguising their finest bottles with deliberately mislabeled tags to thwart the confiscation by German troops.

They cleverly safeguarded their valuable vintages by erecting misleading partitions in their cellars and mislabeling inferior bottles as if they were of higher quality.

The writers depict a widespread plan aimed at hiding premium wines. The narrative describes how, under the cover of darkness or by leveraging their extensive knowledge of the local landscape, winemakers hid their wines and casks among the vegetation of their gardens, amidst the crops in their fields, and in the neighboring forests. The book details how wine storage areas were intricately modified to include hidden compartments and misleading obstructions designed to baffle German inspectors. They recount the clever strategies of masking inferior wines as high-quality vintages to deceive and obstruct the enemy forces by altering labels and misrepresenting the products. Kladstrup and Kladstrup narrate several examples of this conduct, one of which involves André Foreau, a Vouvray viticulturist, who ingeniously hid his most exceptional vintages amidst the dense vegetation of his garden, particularly beneath the leaves of beans, tomatoes, and various salad greens. The story also highlights the ingenuity of winemakers from the Champagne area, focusing on how Pol Roger, the favorite of Winston Churchill, cleverly used cement provided by the obliging Weinführer to conceal and safeguard a collection of their most exceptional vintages.

They utilized their familial connections and social circles to initiate conversations aimed at mitigating harm with German envoys.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup emphasize the importance of family connections and individual relationships in navigating the treacherous period of German occupation. The authors detail the pre-war period when vintners, through their established commercial relationships with German wine importers, were able to protect their vineyards and wine reserves, thus mitigating potential harm. For instance, they highlight Maurice Drouhin's ability to sustain a connection with the Weinführer Adolph Segnitz while simultaneously playing a significant role in the Resistance. The relationships they had fostered possibly contributed to his liberation following his capture by the Gestapo.

The French wine producers capitalized on the occupying forces' lack of meticulousness and their superficial grasp of the complexities inherent in France's winemaking procedures

The narrative depicts how French wine producers came to terms with their situation. The French wine connoisseurs capitalized on the German soldiers' limited knowledge and chaotic record-keeping regarding French viticulture. The authors describe the clever strategies of pretending to be puzzled by orders, redirecting consignments, and disguising inferior wines with prestigious labels to deceive the German overseers. Kladstrup and Kladstrup depict the Hugel family's clever deception in convincing the Germans that their available wines were of lesser value. The story also emphasizes the actions of Resistance members in Bordeaux who stopped a train en route to Berlin, which was reportedly carrying top-tier estate wines, only to find out that astute Bordeaux traders had foreseen the intervention and replaced the precious shipment with vintages of inferior quality.

Vintners in France took deliberate actions to obstruct German efforts to confiscate their nation's wines.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup depict the tenacity and resourcefulness of French winegrowers. The French vintners engaged in subterfuge and resistance, successfully thwarting German efforts to take control of the output from their vineyards. They recount stories of deliberately bottling inferior wines, altering their composition, and destroying stockpiles to thwart the military endeavors of Germany.

In response to German requisitions, the French blended their superior wines with lesser-quality ones, altered the bottle contents, and changed the paths of their shipments.

During the conflict, the story reveals the widespread employment of deception among French vintners. Winemakers frequently responded to German requisitions by cleverly disguising their inferior wines with misleading labels or exploiting the Germans' vague standards for acquisition. The book describes how certain wine bottles were deliberately compromised by using inferior corks that would spoil the wine, or by adding substances that made the drink unsuitable for consumption. Kladstrup and Kladstrup offer in-depth examples of deception, showing how producers of champagne deliberately chose inferior corks for the bottles that were to be sent to the German forces, aware that the Germans might overlook the difference in quality. Some vintners intentionally mislabeled the destinations on German orders, which resulted in their wines being dispatched to the wrong places, thus delaying or obstructing their delivery to the intended recipients.

They participated in intelligence gathering and disruptive activities to weaken the influence held by the German military.

Winemakers, fueled by patriotism and the need to protect their livelihood, intensified their resistance by joining established movements against the oppressors. They illustrate how these networks leveraged the viticulture sector to secretly move people and arms, while also gathering intelligence on the movements of the German troops stationed along the boundary that separated the controlled and unoccupied areas of France. Jean Monmousseaux, a vintner from Touraine, joined the Combat Resistance group and cleverly hid Resistance leaders and their armaments inside his wine casks, using them to ferry these essential elements across the line that separated occupied France. The writers highlight the joint vigilance of the Resistance and the champagne vintners in carefully tracking the substantial shipments of champagne, recognizing the value of this data for military intelligence. The authors describe an instance in which the Resistance inferred German intentions to move into Egypt after noticing an unusually large acquisition of champagne, an alcoholic drink not typically favored in such warm weather, and quickly communicated this information to British agents.

French vintners organized demonstrations and ceased their work to prevent the confiscation of their wine by German forces.

The narrative describes how French wine producers were deeply resentful of the plundering by German troops and the complicity of the Vichy regime, prompting them to organize protests and work disruptions to obstruct the supply of wine to the Third Reich. Vineyard workers, farmers, and wine producers united in their efforts to obstruct the German appropriation of their winemaking industry. Kladstrup and Kladstrup illustrate the solidarity among Champagne vintners in 1943, which strengthened after the arrest of the leader of the CIVC, Robert-Jean de Vogüé, for obstructing German demands for trade. The writers illustrate how this extraordinary collaborative endeavor highlights the solidarity and preparedness among vintners in France to confront and safeguard their interests and preeminence.

Practical Tips

• You can protect your own "vintages" by creating a personal inventory system for valuable items in your home. Just as vintners hid their wines, you can catalog your valuables and store them in inconspicuous places. Use a spreadsheet to track items, their disguised labels, and their hidden locations, ensuring that only trusted family members know the true contents and locations.
• Develop a network of mutual support with neighbors to safeguard community interests. Taking inspiration from the vintners' use of social circles, establish a neighborhood watch program that focuses on protecting the community's shared resources and interests. Regular meetings can help neighbors to recognize each other's needs and collaborate on strategies to protect local assets, much like the vintners did to preserve their wine heritage.
• Enhance your problem-solving skills by practicing creative deception in a game setting. Inspired by the vintners' blending of wines, you can play strategy board games or online games that require bluffing and strategy, such as poker or strategy-based war games. These games can help you think creatively about resource management and defensive tactics, improving your ability to protect your interests in real-life scenarios.

The wine sector played a crucial role in the revival of the industry after the conflict, providing essential support to the French people throughout the war.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup illuminate the vital part played by the French wine industry in enhancing the spirits and welfare of the French populace, despite the significant trials posed by the occupation of German troops. Wine offered a valuable addition to limited food resources, brought comfort in moments of grief, and fostered a sense of togetherness among the troubled populace. In the aftermath of turmoil, the unwavering commitment to quality within the wine sector stood as an emblem of the nation's robust revival, reflecting its indomitable spirit.

The morale of the French people was significantly boosted by the endeavors of the wine producers.

The authors emphasize the pivotal role that French wine played, serving as a vital economic and symbolic resource that provided necessary solace and support to the French people during the turmoil. The German-imposed rationing turned wine into an essential provider of vitamins, minerals, and calories, making it a crucial dietary supplement for the malnourished population.

Wine provided comfort alongside limited food provisions for the hungry.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup recount how the people of France leaned on their longstanding winegrowing practices to bolster their limited provisions during periods of extreme shortage. Wine frequently acted as a vital source of energy and nutrients, at times more accessible than fundamental staples such as bread. The story underscores the efforts of healthcare experts to enhance access to wine for the sick and elderly, underscoring its significance as a readily assimilable source of essential nutrients. The narrative highlights the troubling situation of elderly individuals in a care home who feigned illness to secure more wine, illustrating the severe conditions of the time and the vital role wine played as nourishment.

Winemaking communities became centers of unity and defiance, bolstering morale while under foreign domination.

The writers depict how wine contributed to nourishing individuals and fostering a sense of unity and resilience, providing comfort and a brief respite from the difficulties faced during the war. Enjoying fine wine in the dim ambiance of an underground storage space or within the lively atmosphere of a café became an emblematic act of defiance, a way to celebrate their heritage and proclaim their unique identity. Kladstrup and Kladstrup emphasize the tenacity of vintners who continued to partake in traditional celebrations, though in modified forms, in the face of hardship and peril. The story describes the Burgundy vintners' time-honored assembly for the auction of Hospices de Beaune wines, an enduring tradition that continued even during the war, representing their enduring practices and hopes for a brighter tomorrow.

The French wine industry demonstrated exceptional resilience and determination to reconstruct itself in the aftermath of the conflict.

The story emphasizes the remarkable fortitude of France's wine-growing sector in bouncing back from substantial damage sustained during periods of warfare. The determination of the winegrowers to revitalize their fields, adopt contemporary methods, and reclaim their position as leading providers of exquisite wine symbolizes their steadfast determination and is indicative of the nation's revival following the conflict.

Large-scale initiatives were launched to rehabilitate the grape-growing fields, repair the damage, and revive the wine-making industry.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup chronicle the daunting task of reviving the viticulture industry in France after the turmoil. Numerous wine estates needed to be replanted because they had been neglected or damaged during the time of military rule. Damaged infrastructure, including cellars, wineries, and equipment, needed repair. During the conflict, it was crucial to obtain scarce resources, such as substances for soil enrichment and fungicidal compounds. The story highlights the difficulties the Hugel family encountered as they worked to restore their Alsace vineyards that had suffered extensive destruction due to heavy shelling and the placement of mines throughout the war. They recount the tale of the Hugel family, who, facing a shortage of labor because of the war, relied on their own laborious efforts and the power of a solitary horse to cultivate the land, illustrating the substantial toil involved in restoring their vineyards to a state suitable for producing their unique wines.

Government support and investment in modernizing and improving the industry

The authors highlight the essential role that French authorities played in the resurgence of viticulture following the conflict. Jean Monnet, with his family background in the Cognac brandy trade, led government efforts to rejuvenate vineyards, acquire contemporary machinery, and launch programs to elevate the quality of wine production in France. Kladstrup and Kladstrup emphasize the significant improvement in Alsace's viticulture after the government encouraged the replacement of lower-quality hybrid vines with local grape varieties.

The traditions and solidarity within the wine community signaled a revival of the French nation following the war.

Kladstrup and Kladstrup portray the celebrations of French wine aficionados after the war as a symbol of the nation's persistent resilience and dedication to advancement after enduring the difficulties of war. The resurgence of traditional festivities, embraced with enthusiasm after the occupation, nurtured a communal spirit among vineyard workers and those who deeply cherished the art of winemaking. The authors describe the resumption of the Chevaliers du Tastevin's annual banquet in Burgundy in 1946 with a "Chapitre de Résurrection," highlighting the symbolic significance of this event. At the banquet, they recount how Georges Duhamel, a distinguished member of the Académie Française, praised wine for its essential contribution to the development of civilization and its ongoing significance in enhancing the cultural legacy and historical tapestry of France. This event, along with many others throughout the country, epitomized the revival of age-old winemaking practices and simultaneously bolstered the spirits of the French populace.

Other Perspectives

• While the wine industry played a supportive role, it's important to recognize the contributions of other agricultural sectors and industries in France during the war.
• The morale-boosting effect of wine should not overshadow the psychological and physical hardships endured by the French people during the conflict.
• The narrative may romanticize the role of wine as a nutrient provider, whereas it should not be considered a substitute for a balanced diet, especially in times of food scarcity.
• The depiction of winemaking communities as centers of unity and defiance could minimize the complex realities of collaboration and resistance within occupied France.
• The resilience of the wine industry, while notable, may not fully represent the broader economic challenges and slow recovery experienced by other sectors in post-war France.
• The large-scale initiatives to rehabilitate the wine industry may have benefited from a focus on the wine sector that was not equally extended to other agricultural or industrial sectors in need of aid.
• Government support and investment in the wine industry might have been at the expense of other necessary post-war reconstruction efforts.
• The emphasis on traditions and solidarity within the wine community as a symbol of national revival may not fully acknowledge the diverse experiences and contributions of other communities and sectors in post-war France.