PDF Summary:When God Was a Woman, by Merlin Stone

In When God Was a Woman, Merlin Stone uncovers a comprehensive history of worship for a divine feminine entity, often called the Great Goddess, across numerous ancient societies and cultures spanning thousands of years. From early Upper Paleolithic Age practices to the widespread reverence during the Neolithic and Chalcolithic eras, Stone examines archaeological discoveries, symbology, myths, and rituals that indicate the entrenched prevalence of the female deity.

Stone tracks how the influx of patriarchal cultures from the north, such as the Indo-Europeans, initiated the gradual erosion of worship for the Goddess and the dismantling of rights for women. She contends that as male deities arose, the status of women declined through new rules and restrictions, leading to long-lasting societal impacts still apparent today.

(continued)...

Militaristic societies overpowered and supplanted the cultures that worshipped the Goddess, instituting male-dominated gods and the rule of kings.

Stone portrays the northern invaders as aggressive and martially adept, utilizing advanced armaments including chariots pulled by horses and weaponry crafted from iron to overpower the societies in the Near East that venerated the Goddess. Merlin Stone suggests that the unearthing of wide-headed (Alpine) skulls in Anatolia, thought to date back to the second millennium BC, signifies that Indo-European conquerors replaced the region's initial settlers. Stone argues that the invasions aimed not only at expanding territory but also at imposing patriarchal religious practices and establishing the invaders' sovereign authority over the subjugated peoples.

Context

• Excavations in regions like Anatolia have uncovered artifacts and burial sites that provide insights into the cultural and religious shifts that occurred during these periods of conquest and assimilation.
• This period saw the decline of many early civilizations, such as the Hittites and the Mycenaeans, partly due to these invasions. The resulting power vacuums allowed new cultures and political entities to emerge, reshaping the ancient world.
• The imposition of new religious and social systems often accompanied military conquest, leading to significant cultural and societal changes in the subjugated regions.
• Various theories exist about the routes and timing of Indo-European migrations, with some suggesting a gradual infiltration and others proposing more abrupt invasions or conquests.
• Maintaining a strong military presence was crucial for invaders to enforce their rule, deter uprisings, and protect against other potential threats, thereby securing their authority over the subjugated populations.

The northern conquerors regarded the subjugated populations as belonging to a race and culture that were less advanced.

Stone suggests that ancient conquerors, emboldened by their military victories, developed an increased sense of ethnic and cultural superiority, leading them to view their societies, characterized by lighter skin and male dominance, as more advanced than those that honored a goddess and were composed of individuals with darker complexions. In their religious narratives, male deities are often portrayed as dominating a paramount deity, often represented by a serpentine or draconic figure, and associated with disorder and obscurity.

Practical Tips

• Volunteer with organizations that support cultural diversity and inclusion. By actively participating in community programs or events that celebrate different cultures, you can immerse yourself in experiences that broaden your understanding and appreciation of the diversity within your own community. This hands-on approach can be a powerful way to break down barriers and challenge the notion of cultural hierarchy.
• Start a conversation club with friends or colleagues where you discuss historical events from multiple viewpoints. This can help you understand the relativity of cultural and ethnic superiority by exposing you to different interpretations of the same events. During these discussions, you might tackle a historical military victory and explore how it's perceived differently by the victors and the defeated, thus broadening your understanding of perspective.
• Engage in role-reversal exercises with friends or family members where you take turns assuming roles that differ from your own societal position. For example, if you are male, take on tasks or roles traditionally associated with females in your community, and vice versa. This can help you empathize with experiences different from your own and recognize the value in roles and contributions across gender lines.
• Engage with art and history from goddess-honoring societies with darker complexions through virtual museum tours or online galleries. This can help you appreciate the sophistication and contributions of these cultures on your own terms, fostering a more nuanced understanding of their advancements and achievements.
• Engage in a writing exercise where you invent a myth or short story featuring a serpentine or draconic deity, focusing on the attributes and lessons that such a figure could impart. This can help you internalize the concept of a paramount deity and explore its relevance to modern-day challenges or personal growth.
• Consider writing a short story or poem that personifies disorder and obscurity, drawing inspiration from the deity's characteristics. Focus on creating a narrative that brings these abstract concepts to life, giving them form, voice, and agency. This exercise can deepen your understanding of how disorder influences human experiences and the ways in which it can be both destructive and creative.

The deliberate suppression and reduction of reverence for the Goddess, as well as the associated structures that upheld women in positions of authority.

Stone suggests that the onset of Indo-European conquests over communities that honored the Goddess signified the start of a systematic campaign aimed at reducing and ultimately eliminating the veneration of the sacred feminine. The ascent of male-dominated ideologies resulted in the sanctified locations being defiled, the killing of worshippers and female priests, and the branding of the reverence for the Goddess as heathen and unethical. The onset of this transformation was cemented through the creation of fresh edicts, religious instructions, and cultural standards, all aimed at thoroughly eradicating any power or control previously held by women.

The temples honoring the Goddess were destroyed, and her worshippers and servants were executed.

Stone emphasizes the use of drastic actions, as evidenced by archaeological discoveries, which were directed at eradicating the veneration of the divine feminine, including the deliberate demolition of holy places that honored the Goddess. She expands on the deliberate destruction of sacred symbols and imagery, highlighting the intentional actions taken to remove representations of the divine feminine. Furthermore, she elaborates on the severe persecution and abuse experienced by the followers and spiritual women devoted to the Goddess, emphasizing documented evidence and religious texts that chronicle the harsh and bloody destruction of this ancient faith.

Practical Tips

• Engage with local history groups to learn about the religious history of your area. Understanding the past can provide insights into how societies have changed and the role of religious persecution. You might discover stories of local martyrs or historical figures that parallel the book's theme.
• Explore the power of storytelling by writing a short story or narrative from the perspective of someone who has faced persecution. This exercise can help you to step into the shoes of others and explore the human side of historical events. By crafting a narrative, you can also discover the power of voice and the importance of preserving stories that might otherwise be forgotten.
• Engage in interfaith dialogues to gain diverse perspectives on how different religions view their history, including periods of destruction. This can broaden your understanding of faith and tolerance, fostering a more inclusive worldview.

Patriarchal belief systems characterized the veneration of the Goddess as heathenish and unethical.

The veneration of the ancient Goddess gradually became demonized, portrayed as pagan and immoral, while its rituals and practices were misrepresented to conform with the new ethical standards established by the rising religions that glorified male gods and cemented their dominance. Stone argues that demonizing these spiritual practices was crucial in justifying the suppression of reverence for the Goddess and establishing male-dominated religious frameworks. The once-revered sexual ceremonies conducted in temples honoring the Goddess were later erroneously termed as "prostitution," fostering adverse perceptions of female sexuality and emphasizing a supposed need for male supremacy.

Practical Tips

• Create a personal journal where you reflect on and question your own biases and preconceptions about different spiritual practices. By actively questioning why you hold certain beliefs and where they come from, you can work towards a more inclusive and respectful understanding of diverse spiritual expressions.
• You can explore alternative spiritual systems by researching and practicing rituals from matrilineal societies or Goddess-centered faiths. Start by finding online communities or local groups that focus on these traditions and participate in their open events or discussions. This allows you to experience firsthand how different religious frameworks operate and to understand the role of feminine divinity in spiritual practices.
• Start a book club focused on historical and cultural texts that challenge modern perceptions. Choose books that explore the role of sexuality in ancient societies and discuss each reading's implications on current views. This encourages a collective reevaluation of historical narratives and promotes a more nuanced understanding of past cultures.

The Levite priests sought to consolidate their power by reducing the veneration of the divine feminine.

Stone suggests that the development of the Hebrew religion might have been shaped by interactions with Indo-European groups. She explores the ways in which the foundational customs and ceremonial practices of the Hebrews were influenced by northern cultures, noting parallels in both language and mythology. Additionally, she investigates the actions taken by the Levite priests to eradicate all forms of reverence for the Goddess in Hebrew society, establishing stringent rules and punishments to ensure the dominance of their male deity, Yahweh.

The inception of Hebrew religion and beliefs appears to have been influenced by interactions with northern traditions or those stemming from Indo-European roots.

Stone's thorough analysis of biblical stories, genealogies, and societal practices suggests a greater significance in the relationship between the Hebrew religion and the Indo-European invaders than previously acknowledged. Merlin Stone proposes that the cultural links apparent in the customs and stories common to the descendants of Abraham, the Hittites, and Horites, including the custom where a man marries the widow of his late brother seen across various ancient European and Asian societies, as well as the recurring biblical conflicts with snake-like beings reminiscent of the dragon myths from ancient Europe and Asia, might suggest a common ancestry. Stone suggests a careful analysis of the observed similarities, which implies that the Hebrew religion probably assimilated aspects and impacts from adjacent Indo-European cultures.

The connections in language and mythology are evident among Hebrew and Indo-European cultures.

Stone bolsters her case by pointing out a number of parallels in language and mythology that connect the ancient Hebrews with northern invaders. She highlights the possible connection between the Hebrew word 'har,' which translates to a mound, and 'hara,' a term from languages of the Indo-Iranian group, which means a peak, indicating a shared reverence for the sacred significance of mountains in their religious customs. Stone emphasizes the connection of the deity Yahweh with a luminous mountaintop, a common theme in Indo-European mythology where male deities often reside on bright peaks. The story illustrating Yahweh's victory over the sea monster Leviathan also reflects narratives from Indo-European traditions where a storm deity defeats a serpent-like or dragon-like being, suggesting a shared cultural view of these figures as embodiments of light and darkness.

Practical Tips

• Explore the linguistic connections in your environment by researching the etymology of local place names and comparing them to foreign languages with similar roots. This can deepen your appreciation for cultural and linguistic ties. For example, if you live near a mountain with a name that sounds similar to 'har' or 'hara', look into its history and origins to see if there's a connection to ancient languages or cultural reverence.
• Explore the symbolism of mountains in your local area by visiting them and journaling your thoughts and feelings. Mountains often have historical and spiritual significance in many cultures. By visiting them, you can create a personal connection with the concept of sacred spaces and reflect on how these places might have been perceived by ancient peoples.
• Create art that represents your interpretation of the "storm deity vs. serpent-like being" motif, using it as a metaphor for your own life battles. This could be through painting, sculpture, or digital art. For instance, you might paint a scene where a figure representing yourself stands up against a chaotic background, symbolizing your struggle against a personal issue like anxiety or a professional challenge.
• Create a personal journal with two sections, one for 'light' and one for 'darkness', where you record daily experiences that you associate with each.

The Levite priests instituted stringent rules and punishments to eradicate any form of devotion to the goddess entirely.

Stone suggests that the Levite priests, potentially connected to the Indo-European Luvians, played a crucial role in the rigorous imposition of laws and sanctions aimed at eradicating the worship of the Goddess within Hebrew society. She underscores the Levite rules that demanded women's purity before wedlock, loyalty thereafter, and prescribed the death penalty for involvement in ceremonies considered heathen, interpreting these as deliberate attempts to quell the autonomy and freedom in sexual affairs previously associated with Goddess adoration. Stone highlights that such actions were designed to bolster patriarchal dominance and guarantee paternal lineage for inheritance purposes, directly opposing the matrilineal tradition where the Goddess was venerated.

Context

• The Luvians, an ancient Indo-European people, are sometimes linked to cultural and religious influences in the Near East, which may have contributed to shifts in religious practices.
• Archaeological findings, such as inscriptions and artifacts, suggest that goddess worship was prevalent in the region before the rise of monotheism, indicating a deliberate effort to suppress these practices.
• Anthropologists study such transitions to understand how religious and cultural shifts impact social structures, particularly gender roles and family dynamics.
• The death penalty for participating in non-sanctioned religious ceremonies reflects the severity with which religious conformity was enforced. Such measures were intended to unify the community under a single religious and moral code.
• The Levites were a priestly class in ancient Israel, responsible for religious rituals and maintaining the purity of worship practices. Their influence extended to enforcing laws that aligned with monotheistic beliefs.
• Ensuring paternal lineage was crucial for inheritance and property rights, which were central to maintaining wealth and power within male-dominated family lines.
• The imposition of patriarchal norms by groups like the Levites often led to cultural conflicts, as these norms clashed with existing traditions that celebrated female deities and matrilineal heritage.

The story of Adam and Eve has frequently been cited to reinforce male supremacy and control over women's sexual independence.

Stone suggests that the story of Adam and Eve may have been intentionally created by Levite priests to assert male supremacy and control over female sexuality. She interprets the forbidden fruit's symbolism in relation to the sacred sycamore fig tree associated with the deity, and sees the serpent's counsel to Eve as reflective of the wisdom and prophetic guidance offered by priestesses in cultures that worship a female deity. Stone argues that the story intentionally depicts Eve as the catalyst for sexual consciousness and portrays her as the seductress who leads Adam astray, thereby framing women as inherently evil and relegating them to a status inferior to that of men.

The traditional story that depicts Eve's wrongdoing has often cast women as inherently defective, requiring the direction of men.

Stone argues that the narrative of Eve's transgression in the Bible was intentionally crafted to burden women with a sense of culpability, portraying them as the imperfect creatures responsible for humanity's fall from grace. This inherent sinfulness, which was believed to originate from the first woman's transgression, was used to justify the subsequent relegation of women to a lesser status, reinforcing the idea that they require the oversight and direction of men.

Other Perspectives

• The narrative of Eve can also be seen as highlighting the capacity for critical thinking and agency, as her actions represent a choice rather than a reflection of inherent defectiveness.
• Some theologians and scholars argue that the story of Eve has been misinterpreted or misused over time, and that a more accurate reading of the text reveals a message of equality and shared responsibility between men and women.
• The concept of requiring oversight and direction is not limited to women; religious narratives often suggest that all humans, regardless of gender, need guidance and moral direction.

The consumption of the fruit, which was off-limits, symbolized the divine feminine, embodying both a holy tree and the core of human sexual nature.

The author explores the symbolic meaning of the forbidden fruit, suggesting that its intentional connection with the highly regarded sycamore fig tree, an important element in the worship of the Goddess Hathor in Egypt and representative of the "Tree of Life" in numerous traditions, was by design. Stone suggests that the sacred tree, symbolizing freedom in sexual contexts, was deliberately portrayed in a negative light to link it with the transgression committed by Eve that led to mankind's expulsion from paradise. Stone contends that such a strategy was intentionally used to undermine the worship of the Goddess by associating its rituals and symbols, particularly those connected to the sexuality of women, with concepts of wickedness and divine punishment.

Practical Tips

• Engage in a mindful eating exercise with a piece of fruit, focusing on its taste, texture, and aroma, while contemplating its life-giving properties and its role as a symbol of sexuality. This can connect you more deeply with the natural world and your own senses, fostering a sense of gratitude and reverence for life's dualities.
• Explore the symbolism of fruit in different cultures by researching various mythologies and religious texts online, then create a personal journal documenting how these symbols are used to convey moral or ethical lessons. This can deepen your understanding of how symbolic elements are used to teach values and can inspire you to use symbolism in your own storytelling or moral reasoning.
• You can explore the cultural significance of plants by starting a themed garden with species that have historical or mythological importance. For example, if the sycamore fig tree piqued your interest, research and plant other species that hold a place in different cultures or mythologies. This hands-on approach allows you to connect with history and nature simultaneously, and you might choose plants like the olive tree (significant in Greek mythology) or the bodhi tree (important in Buddhism).
• Start a journaling practice where you write about the interconnectedness of life, drawing inspiration from the symbiotic relationship between the sycamore fig tree and its pollinator, the fig wasp. Use this as a metaphor to explore the relationships in your life and how they contribute to your well-being.
• Use the concept of the sacred tree in a creative project, such as writing a short story, painting, or composing a song, to express your interpretation of sexual freedom. This allows you to engage with the idea on a deeper level and share your perspective with others in a non-confrontational way. It can also serve as a means to connect with like-minded individuals who resonate with your expression.
• You can explore the impact of narrative framing by journaling your reactions to different portrayals of the same subject in various media sources. Write down how articles, documentaries, and social media posts about a specific topic make you feel and why. This will help you understand how narrative framing influences your perception.
• Create a visual art project that reimagines iconic stories or symbols with a positive twist to challenge traditional negative connotations. For instance, if a certain tree is associated with negative events, you could paint or photograph that tree in a way that highlights its beauty and life-giving qualities, thereby offering a new perspective.
• Create a "Paradise Lost and Found" board where you pin images and notes about times when a personal mistake led to a loss and how you recovered or plan to recover from it. This visual representation can serve as a reminder of both the consequences of actions and the resilience you have to bounce back. You might pin a picture of a broken vase if you accidentally broke a family heirloom, alongside a note about how you plan to repair it or make amends.
• Engage in conversations with friends or online communities about the representation of powerful female figures in modern media and literature. Discuss how these representations might be influenced by past portrayals and what impact they have on contemporary society.
• You can explore the historical context of goddess worship by visiting local museums or online archives to understand how perceptions have changed over time. By examining artifacts, texts, and art from different periods, you'll gain insight into the evolution of the goddess's image and how societal views have shifted.

The consequences of transitioning from matriarchal spirituality to male-dominated religious systems on society, governance, and history.

Stone argues that the shift from female-centric worship to patriarchal religions brought about profound and lasting transformations in global social structures, governance, and the realm of spiritual belief. Stone contends that this shift resulted in a diminished state of freedom, social status, and autonomy for women, ultimately laying the groundwork for patriarchal structures that continue to influence modern society. Stone urges us to explore historical contexts to grasp the roots of present-day gender norms and biases, promoting a rekindled appreciation for and devotion to the divine in its ancient feminine form, challenging enduring societal norms.

The erosion of women's autonomy and freedoms occurred simultaneously with the ascent of male-dominated ideologies.

Stone contends that the rise of patriarchal belief systems and the simultaneous decrease in veneration for the divine feminine resulted in a significant reduction of women's autonomy, social status, and legal rights. The author contends that this regression was not an inevitable development but rather the intentional result of patriarchal systems and ideologies being enforced.

Women subjected to severe sexual morality laws, loss of economic/legal independence

As belief systems rooted in patriarchy rose to prominence, they implemented strict rules designed to control women's reproductive rights and personal conduct. Cultures that worshipped a female deity traditionally did not emphasize the importance of virginity before marriage or fidelity within marriage. Stone argues that the shift towards patrilineal inheritance, coupled with these rules, stripped women of their economic independence and legal entitlements, leaving them reliant on men for their social status and financial security.

Other Perspectives

• It's important to consider that the historical record is often incomplete or biased due to the focus on legal texts and elite practices, which may not fully represent the experiences of all women or the complexity of gender relations in past societies.
• The concept of reproductive rights is modern and applying it retrospectively to ancient societies may not accurately reflect the complexities of those societies' views on reproduction and sexuality.
• The idea of control can be nuanced, with some scholars suggesting that women in various societies have found ways to exert agency and influence within the framework of these rules, thereby challenging the notion of absolute control.
• In some cultures, patrilineal inheritance did not necessarily strip women of economic independence, as women could still own property, conduct business, and retain dowries.
• The statement may overlook the role of women's networks and communities that have historically provided support and facilitated women's social status outside of their relationships with men.
• The rise of feminist movements and changes in legislation have increasingly enabled women to achieve financial security independent of men, challenging the idea that women's financial security is inherently tied to men.

The reduced participation of women in matters of spiritual guidance and community engagement.

The rise of male deities led to the gradual marginalization of women from positions of spiritual and political power. Women who were once revered as priestesses saw their status decline or vanish entirely as men took over the roles of priests in the emerging religious structures. Stone emphasizes the omission of female participation in the Hebrew priesthood and the diminishing of their functions during Christian assemblies as clear signs of their inferior status.

Other Perspectives

• The idea of replacement implies a direct and intentional act, but the shift in religious roles could have been gradual and influenced by a multitude of factors beyond the control of any single group.
• Women's roles in Christian assemblies have not always been uniform and have varied significantly over time and between different denominations and cultural contexts.
• The focus on the decline of priestesses might ignore the rise of female spiritual figures and leaders in other capacities, such as saints, mystics, and prophets in various religious traditions.

The lasting impact of perspectives and stereotypes shaped by patriarchal dominance continues to shape gender functions in contemporary society.

Stone emphasizes the significant transition toward belief systems dominated by men, which altered the view of women's roles fundamentally and resulted in enduring gender stereotypes that shape modern social norms, extending even outside the sphere of religious practices. The author argues that the portrayal of Eve within the narrative of Genesis, along with the teachings promoted by individuals like Paul, has cultivated a pervasive cultural conviction of an inherent defectiveness, inferiority, and the essential need for women to be subservient to men.

Contemporary views and norms regarding gender still mirror the doctrines that originate from Judeo-Christian religious instruction.

Stone argues that modern perspectives on gender roles and norms have a strong connection to religious doctrines that emerged after the decrease in reverence for a goddess. She emphasizes the enduring societal norms that result in disparate criteria for sexual behavior, an inclination to expect compliance by women in relationships, and a consistent undervaluing of their intellectual and leadership capacities, all of which underscore the persistent influence of these societal dynamics.

Other Perspectives

• The influence of media, technology, and education has significantly shaped contemporary gender norms, often in ways that diverge from traditional religious teachings.
• There is a trend towards legal frameworks that support gender equality and non-discrimination, which can influence societal expectations and challenge traditional views on gendered sexual behavior.
• The expectation for women to comply in relationships is not universal and can vary greatly depending on cultural, social, and individual factors.
• In numerous fields, women have risen to prominent leadership positions, which indicates a shift in societal valuation of women's capabilities.

Understanding the initial reverence for the Goddess is essential when examining modern perspectives on gender roles.

Stone emphasizes the importance of questioning current gender biases and norms by conducting a deep exploration into the historical widespread reverence for the divine feminine. Stone suggests that by recognizing the historical roots of patriarchal viewpoints and the existence of societies where women held significant positions of power and influence, we can begin to deconstruct the deep-seated convictions about the natural framework of gender roles. Merlin Stone suggests that the deep insights and core principles derived from the historical reverence for the Goddess, particularly its emphasis on the interconnectedness of life and the inherent power of women, offer valuable guidance for creating a more equitable and harmonious society.

Practical Tips

• Consider mentoring a young woman or girl in your community. Look for local mentorship programs or reach out to schools and community centers to offer your time. By sharing your knowledge and experience, you're actively contributing to the empowerment of the next generation, fostering an environment where women's historical influence is recognized and continued.
• Engage in a 'nature exchange' to reinforce the concept of interconnectedness. Once a week, spend time in a natural setting, such as a park or garden, and focus on observing the interactions within the ecosystem. Then, do something to contribute positively to that space, like picking up litter or planting a native flower. This hands-on approach allows you to become an active participant in the cycle of life and witness the direct impact of your actions on the environment.
• Consider adopting a symbol of feminine strength as a personal emblem. Choose an artifact, piece of jewelry, or a design that represents the power of the goddess or historical women you admire. Use this emblem as a daily reminder of your own strength and potential, and as a conversation starter to share the stories of powerful women with others, thereby spreading awareness and appreciation.
• Reflect on your daily interactions and consciously practice inclusive language and behavior. This personal audit of your actions helps you become more aware of unconscious biases and promotes a more equitable environment around you. For instance, when in a group setting, make an effort to listen actively to all voices, especially those that might typically be marginalized, and encourage others to do the same.